Democratic struggle
East Timor
Presidential succession
Political/Economic crisis
Aceh/West Papua
Labour struggle
News & issues
Arms/Armed forces
Students
rally in Jakarta for reform
Agence France Presse - October
4, 1999
Jakarta -- Some 150 Indonesian
students took to the streets of Jakarta Monday, calling on the newly-elected
national assembly, now in its first session, to implement reforms.
The protesters, from the
Network of Indonesian Students, gathered at a busy roundabout in Central
Jakarta in front of a posh hotel were most members of the People's Consultative
Assembly (MPR) are staying.
They chanted anti-military
slogans and brandished signs demanding that former president Suharto be
brought to justice. "The voice of the people is the voice of God, going
against the will of the people is going against the will of God," read
a large banner.
The students' demands for
reform have centered around the scrapping of the much-criticized military
role in politics and the trial of Suharto, who is accused of having amassed
a fortune during his 32 years of authoritarian rule. "We call on Dr. Amien
Rais to implement sweeping reform. Our hope is that he will remain consistent
in pushing for reform," Muhammad Irfan, student at a computer institute
in Jakarta, told AFP.
Rais, a Muslim intellectual
who was in the frontlines of a reform movement that helped topple Suharto
last year, was elected chairman of the MPR in a tight vote against another
Muslim leader, Matori Abdul Jalil. The assembly is scheduled to elect a
new president on October 20.
Student
protests mark Armed Forces Day
Agence France Presse - October
5, 1999
Jakarta -- Thousands of Indonesian
students in the capital and other cities in Java and Sumatra Tuesday marked
the 54th Indonesian Armed Forces Day with mass protests demanding the military
return to barracks, witnesses and reports said.
In Jakarta, at least 400
students of the City Forum marched down a main avenue towards the parliament
where the national assembly was convening, to demand the military get out
of politics.
The protesters, marching
behind a huge banner that included a demand to "reject the socio-political
role of ABRI (the Indonesian armed forces)," were stopped by a strong cordon
of police and soldiers at an underpass some 200 meters from the gate to
the parliament.
Another 150 students massed
at a busy roundabout in front of a posh hotel where most newly-elected
members of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) are staying. "Reject
the military in government," read one banner.
In the university town of
Bandung, in West Java, thousands of students paraded an effigy of Indonesian
Armed Forces Chief General Wiranto at the campus of the state Bandung Institute
of Technology before marching off into downtown Bandung with a brief stop
at the provincial parliament.
The students, from at least
three main universities and several student groups, who also demanded the
scrapping of the military's role in politics, burned the effigy as they
arrived in city square, the Detik.com online news service said.
Some 2,000 students rallied
peacefully in the streets of the city of Padang, the capital of West Sumatra,
chanting slogans and brandishing anti-military posters.
The protestors stopped at
the provicial parliament and held a free speech forum there for almost
three hours before heading to the local military headquarters some five
kilometres away.
In Semarang, some 300 students
from the Indonesian Students Network held a demonstration at the Central
Java military headquarters to demand the scrapping of the military's role
in politics and the disbanding of military command posts from the village
up to the provincial level.
In nearby Salatiga, some
100 students from three local universities held a similar protest at the
local military headquarters.
Some 150 students from several
universities attempted to approach the East Java military headquarters
in Surabaya but were prevented by a thick cordon of mass control troops.
There was not incident and the students dispersed after holding a free
speech forum there for about 40 minutes.
Wiranto,
Habibie sing as students protest
South China Morning Post
-- October 6, 1999
Vaudine England and Agencies,
Jakarta -- Soldiers and riot police lounged in makeshift camps under flyovers
and in central parks across Jakarta as their leaders held festivities to
mark Army Day at the palm tree-lined grounds of Cilangkap military headquarters.
The ceremonies ended with
an exchange of singing skills, in which President Bacharuddin Habibie sang
Strangers in the Night, followed by a heart-rending version of When I Fall
in Love by armed forces chief General Wiranto.
Meanwhile, an Indonesian
student was stabbed to death during a student protest in Palembang, south
Sumatra, as thousands of students in Jakarta and cities in Java and Sumatra
marked the day with mass protests demanding the military return to barracks,
witnesses and reports said.
In Jakarta, at least 400
students of the City Forum marched down a main avenue towards parliament
-- where the National Assembly was convening -- to demand the military
get out of politics. The protesters were stopped by a strong cordon of
police and soldiers at an underpass 200 metres from the gate to parliament.
The President told the military
to avoid security excesses, as international pressure mounts over the role
it played in the East Timor bloodbath.
"An excessive security approach
is no longer relevant. However, that does not mean stability and security
is not important and should be ignored," Mr Habibie told the country's
military as it celebrated its 54th anniversary.
Mr Habibie said the military
could prove itself "through its reforms in a bid to become a defence and
security force that is professional, effective, efficient and modern".
He emphasised the military's
newfound ability to be neutral, as shown in the June general elections,
saying this "has shown the armed forces' commitment to develop democracy,
reforms and human rights".
Mr Habibie's own vulnerability
in the country's forthcoming presidential poll requires him to keep the
armed forces on his side, but public antipathy towards the military has
rarely been higher.
Even the general who promoted
the right of the military to engage in politics, retired General Nasution,
now questions the military's right to its 38 seats in parliament.
The military's game is not
yet over but "it can change every day now", said military analyst Arbi
Sanit. "They are still important in local politics, but as Reformasi [Reform]
continues, they have less and less power," he said.
Military
officers probed Lampung shooting
Indonesian Observer - October
1, 1999
Bandar Lampung -- Lampung
Military Police yesterday began investigating eight military officers allegedly
involved in the shooting that took place during a students protest in front
of the Bandar Lampung University (UBL) campus on Tuesday. One student was
killed during the demonstration.
Military police have confiscated
several guns from the Kedaton military command, located near the UBL campus,
which were allegedly used to shoot protesters during the demonstration
protesting the State Security Law (PKB).
Lampung Military Police Commander
Lieutenant Colonel Bagus Heroe Sucahyo said military police were still
investigating the clash between protesters and security officers. Dozens
of protesters were also injured during the clash.
"In addition to investigating
eight military officers, we are also examining the firearms used," he told
journalists in Bandar Lampung yesterday. He acknowledged that military
police could not determine the time of the shooting, but undertook to probe
the case seriously.
Sucahyo added that the investigation
was now focused on security officers from Kedaton military command. "We
respect the principle of the presumption of innocence, but our findings
in the location indicate we should concentrate our attention on military
personnel," he said.
Meanwhile, Military Commander
of the Garuda Hitam military region, Colonel Mudjiono, accused the Democratic
People's Party (PRD) of using the student protest for its own political
advantage. However the accusation was later denied by PRD activist, Andi
Arif.
"We admit that we gathered
with students during the protest rejecting PKB bill, but there were also
other parties there too. We therefore absolutely deny that the PRD was
there just to use the students," he said.
Three days after the bloody
incident, two students remain in a coma at Bandar Lampung's Advent hospital.
They are Saidatul Fitri from Lampung University and another unidentified
student from Bandar Lampung University.
Yusuf Rizal (23), a student
at Unila, who was killed in the incident was buried on Wednesday in Kedamaian
public cemetery, East Tanjung Karang.
Student
dies from protest injuries
Agence France Presse - October
3, 1999
Jakarta -- A student died
in hospital in the Indonesian city of Bandarlampoung Sunday, a second victim
of clashes between protestors and security personnel, a university employee
said.
"Saidatul Fitria died at
the hospital at 4.30am and she was buried at her village in Gadingrejo,"
an employee of Lampung University said by telephone from Bandarlampung,
capital of the province of Lampung on the island of Sumatra.
Fitria's skull was fractured
in a clash on September 29 as students took to the streets to protest the
passage through parliament of a bill which they said would give the military
sweeping powers. Another Lampung Universtity student, Muhamad Rizal Yusuf,
was shot dead by soldiers on the day of the protest.
The university employee,
who identified himself only as Bambang, said Fitria, a student of the faculty
of teachers' training and education, had died at Abdul Muluk state hospital.
Seven people, including another
student, died in Jakarta in parallel clashes with security troops in running
protests against the security bill last week.
Militias
training to strike Australian soldiers
Agence France Presse - October
10, 1999 (abridged)
Singapore -- Pro-Indonesian
militias are undergoing training in guerilla warfare with the aim of killing
Australian soldiers spearheading a multinational force in East Timor, Singapore's
Sunday Times said.
The three-day visit by the
Sunday Times to militia training camps near border areas between East and
West Timor was the first by foreign or local media, said the report datelined
from Atambua in West Timor. Captain Domingos Pereira, a company commander
of the notorious Aitarak militia told the paper they hoped to step up cross-border
incursions and sporadic attacks against Australian soldiers after a month
or two.
"We don't have a chance in
a conventional war," Pereira told the paper at the camp near a Catholic
cemetery and hidden by trees, where 730 militia men were undergoing physical
fitness training.
"But we can make it very
painful for them in a guerilla war. The Australians must die for what they
have done to my men and their families.
"The Australians are siding
openly with our enemies, the Falintil, and are killing our people in East
Timor," he said, referring to the pro-independence guerillas.
The Aitarak militias in training
are men in their 20s from nearby refugee camps, and carry arms from World
War II and expect to get more M-16 rifles used by the Indonesian Special
Forces, the report said.
"We don't need sophisticated
equipment to rip apart a white man's head. we can do it with our bare hands,"
said one recruit named Roberto Gama.
Militiaman
shot dead in East Timor
Agence France Presse - October
10, 1999 (abridged)
Dili -- An Interfet foot
patrol has shot dead a militia fighter near the East Timor border with
Indonesian West Timor, an Australian army spokesman said Sunday.
Colonel Mark Kelly said a
patrol of about five men from the multinational forces opened fire on 12
to 15 militiamen at about 2.30pm Saturday after they were attacked two
kilometers inside the border at a place called Alto Lebos, to the north
of the port of Suai.
Kelly said the militiamen
clearly posed a threat to the Interfet patrol. "Certainly by the way they
were acting on the ground, they were in an aggressive posture.
They were clearly employing
what appeared to be a sweep and clearance by fire technique. They came
across the Interfet patrol's location," before the Interfet force opened
fire, he said.
"It was at the last safe
moment with the fire coming towards them, [at] their observation post ...
they [the patrol] engaged by fire."
After the clash the militiamen
withdrew towards the border region, but the dead man's body had been recovered,
he said.
The dead man was wearing
typical militia equipment, Kelly said, adding there was no indication he
had anything to do with the Indonesian army. Troops from the International
Force for East Timor (Interfet) suffered no casualties in the encounter,
he said.
Falintil
fighters to keep their arms
Agence France Presse - October
6, 1999
Dili -- Falintil resistance
fighters will be allowed to retain their weapons in their camps pending
further disarmament negotiations, despite a UN mandate to disarm all groups,
an Interfet spokesman said Tuesday.
"They are going to remain
in their cantonments with their weapons out of our area of presence," Colonel
Mark Kelly, spokesman for the International Force for East Timor (Interfet)
said. "We have accepted that they can retain their weapons within their
cantonments at present," he said.
The statement followed an
incident on Sunday when British Gurkhas escorting an aid convoy to the
eastern city of Baucau allowed a small group of Falintil fighters to keep
their assault rifles after meeting them.
The multinational force for
East Timor is mandated to disarm all parties and groups, including pro-Jakarta
militias blamed for massive destruction, looting and killing after the
territory's August 30 independence vote.
Kelly said that Interfet
officers had discussed the incident in Baucau with Falintil leaders. "Matan
Ruak agreed that it was a mistake. He has instructed Falintil groups not
to bear arms in the presence of Interfet soldiers," he said. Matan Ruak
is the top field commander of the Falintil, the armed wing of the National
Resistance Council for East Timor.
Kelly said that Interfet
was continuing negotiations with Falintil with a goal of reaching full
disarmament.
The multinational force for
East Timor has been criticized by some quarters for seeking to disarm Falintil
fighters in areas which they have yet to fully secure, and in which militias
may still be operating. Kelly said he would ask the senior officers of
the Indonesian army Tuesday to set up a meeting between Interfet and the
leaders of the miltias for negotiations on disarmament.
He gave no further details,
but most of the militia leaders are now in adjacent Indonesian-ruled West
Timor.
US-Trained
Indonesians infiltrate Timor
Associated Press - October
7, 1999
Dili -- Indonesian commandos
are conducting covert operations inside East Timor aimed at sabotaging
the international peacekeeping effort, foreign military officials say.
The commandos, who received
extensive training from the US military despite a 1992 congressional ban,
are actively reconnoitering positions held by the UN-mandated force along
the border with Indonesian-held West Timor, Australian army Capt. Grant
King said.
Several groups of soldiers,
believed to be part of Indonesia's elite Kopassus special forces brigade,
were observed by peacekeepers conducting nighttime patrols around the peacekeepers'
positions near the town of Balibo this week.
"They were definitely soldiers,
not militia," King said. The Australians held their fire and the patrols
eventually slipped back across the border to West Timor, he said. Australian
soldiers on the spot confirmed that the patrols appeared to have been mounted
by Kopassus troops.
Indonesian soldiers are formally
allowed to remain in East Timor until the national parliament ratifies
the province's secession later this month.
But the two remaining infantry
battalions are restricted to the capital Dili, where they are barricaded
inside government buildings. Their commander last week gave a "100 percent
guarantee" that there were no Kopassus left in the province.
However, Wednesday's botched
militia ambush of a convoy of peacekeepers in the southwest of East Timor
bore the "unmistakable imprint" of a special forces operation, said a foreign
officer who spoke on condition of anonymity on Thursday. Two militiamen
were killed and two Australian peacekeepers were slightly wounded.
Assault rifles retrieved
from the dead militiamen were both Indonesian army weapons: the Russian-built
SKS, which has been phased out of service, and the Belgian FNC, which is
the standard infantry weapon today. They are not available to civilians
and can be obtained only from the army.
Indonesian military spokesman
Maj. Gen. Sudrajat denied any Kopassus involvement, claiming the assailants
only were wearing the elite force's uniforms.
Kopassus -- along with the
army's secretive intelligence bureau -- organized, trained and armed the
militia gangs last year to act as a counterweight to the pro-independence
Fretilin rebels who have fought Indonesian rule since the occupation of
East Timor in 1975.
Leaked Indonesian army records
showed a massive special forces buildup in East Timor last year, when the
first militia gangs were set up.
Kopassus has long been portrayed
as a rogue element within Indonesia's military. It's been accused of engineering
civil unrest and violence as the world's fourth-most populous nation grapples
with massive political, social and economic crises.
Human rights groups claim
Kopassus troops conducted a reign of terror in East Timor during 24 years
of Indonesian rule.
Over the years, the unit
participated in numerous joint exercises with the US military, despite
a 1992 ban on the training of Indonesia's armed forces imposed in reaction
to its poor human rights record.
Clinton administration officials
maintained the program was not covered by a law that bars Indonesian troops
from taking part in a US training program for foreign soldiers known as
IMET. State and Defense Department officials claimed the prohibition did
not affect the joint combined exercises carried out by the US Pacific Command.
Kopassus soldiers and officers
received instruction from US special operations advisers in skills like
psychological warfare and reconnaissance missions, media reports said.
Last month, the administration
suspended further military cooperation and arms sales to Indonesia, after
its armed forces allegedly instigated the campaign of violence that followed
a vote for independence on August 30.
Kopassus is organized into
two special forces groups, each consisting of two battalions. Although
military analysts say its capabilities are limited -- particularly when
facing a modern, Western force such as the Australian army -- the 4,000-strong
brigade is the best that Indonesian has.
Indonesian generals have
made extensive use of their crack unit in recent years, particularly in
a campaign to stamp out a separatist rebel movement in Aceh, the country's
westernmost province. But its troops are said to have performed poorly
against the rebels and were implicated in several massacres of unarmed
civilians.
Human rights organizations
also have blamed them for kidnapping dozens of pro-democracy activists
during last year's protests that led to the ouster of Indonesia's longtime
dictator Suharto.
His son-in-law, Lt. Gen.
Probowo Subianto, was a former Kopassus commander. He was dumped as the
unit's chief and now lives in self-imposed exile in Jordan.
Group
has reputation for brutality
South China Morning Post
- October 8, 1999
Agence France Presse, Cassa
-- The armed men involved in a fatal clash with international peacekeepers
in East Timor were from a feared militia that has committed a series of
atrocities, witnesses said yesterday.
Residents of Cassa, a mountain
village, said the attack on Wednesday was carried out by members of the
Mahidi (Live or Die for Integration) militia, whose leader Cancio Carvalho
is based in the village.
Villagers said the militia
had tied one man to a steel-framed chair with wire and burned him alive.
The chair, wire and the charred remains of the man were visible yesterday
outside Carvalho's headquarters.
"They tied him to that and
set him alight after stabbing him in front of the whole town on the soccer
field," said Armandio de Jesus, a former UN employee.
The Mahidi, which has threatened
to wage guerilla war to prevent East Timor severing its ties to Indonesia,
also raided the nearby village of Hatohudo on Sunday, beheading one woman
and killing five others, residents said.
"There was a lot of shooting.
They came in trucks. We all ran," said Aniceto Xavier, 31. "The militia
cut the head off the lady and put her head on an oil drum in the middle
of the road."
Mr Xavier said the militia
had told the people they should go to Atambua, across the border in West
Timor, or they would be killed.
Mahidi has virtually destroyed
Cassa -- about 70km from the border with West Timor -- forcibly removing
many residents.
Two militiamen were killed
on Wednesday when they ambushed an Australian patrol near Suai. Two Australian
soldiers were injured.
Residents of Cassa said about
500 people had been loaded on to a convoy of militia trucks and stolen
United Nations vehicles and driven across the border. Only about 100 people
remained in the town, many of them women and children.
Refugees
pressed to say if they want to go
Sydney Morning Herald - October
8, 1999
Tom Fawthrop and Marianne
Kearney, Kupang -- More than 230,000 East Timorese refugees in West Timor
camps are being pressed to declare whether they want to return home or
stay in Indonesia.
Jakarta's Ministry of Transmigration
has been preparing a resettlement plan to absorb more than 250,000 East
Timorese, with promises of two hectares of land and a house.
International aid agencies
in Kupang, West Timor's capital, are concerned that with intimidation,
disappearances and political killings routine in the camps, now is not
the time to ask the refugees to make such crucial choices.
An officer with the newly
established Kupang office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
(UNHCR) said: "We want [the refugees] to be well informed, to know what
to expect if they return home, to know what kind of guarantees for their
safe return and transportation can be provided. That is clearly not the
case at the moment."
Mr Kenneth McClean, the director
of Catholic Relief Services in Kupang, was concerned that "with armed militias
still in camps, refugees would be afraid of opting to return home, fearing
that they would expose themselves as independence supporters".
The Indonesian Ministry of
Social Affairs has distributed about 50,000 registration cards, one for
each household in the camps. The results for Kupang districts were already
being tabulated on Wednesday.
The head of each refugee
family is required to nominate its preference: to return to East Timor;
to stay in West Timor or neighbouring regions; or to move elsewhere in
Indonesia.
On Saturday refugees held
in a sports stadium in Kupang were among the first to be registered in
a process administered by Indonesian soldiers, who gave red cards to those
who wished to return, and blue cards to those who chose to stay, according
to an Indonesian non-government organisation.
Mr John Campbell, a lecturer
from the Protestant University of Kupang, saw this as a "deeply flawed
process which could be used by pro-integration groups, if the numbers of
refugees opting to stay exceed those who want to return. Whatever this
survey represents, this is in no way a referendum on the referendum."
One priest in Atambua said:
"The only way to make sure you really know who wants to return is to have
UNHCR do private interviews with all the refugees."
Many aid agencies wonder
why the authorities are in such a rush. They have begun a crash building
program to create new settlements, co-ordinated between four ministries
and with land already allocated.
The Indonesian authorities
have authorised the first UN flight taking refugees from Kupang back to
East Timor, and about 180 people are expected to travel today.
Church sources believe the
military has supplied the militia with a hit list of about 300 independence
supporters, many of whom are expected to be on that first flight today.
Disarming
Falintil
Sydney Morning Herald Editorial
- October 6, 1999
The multinational force in
East Timor (Interfet) was wise to avoid a firefight earlier this week with
members of the resistance force, Falintil, by backing away from demands
that the guerillas surrender their weapons. This is a directive that must
be backed by the resistance leader, Mr Xanana Gusmao, if loss of life and
suspicion of Interfet among East Timorese is to be avoided. But Interfet
is right to insist that Falintil must be disarmed. Mr Gusmao argues that
the guerillas were never involved in acts of terrorism and should be treated
as "an army of liberation and not as a band of bandits". He has his constituency
to think of -- fighters who against all odds have stayed loyal to the cause
of East Timor's independence, in some cases for 24 years, and ordinary
East Timorese who fear for their lives if left to the mercy of pro-Indonesian
militias. But the reality is that after an extremely reluctant start, the
international community has accepted responsibility for the protection
of his people. In the overall interests of peace and stability, Interfet
must have a monopoly of force for the foreseeable future.
It shouldn't be hard to thrash
out a compromise on this issue with Mr Gusmao. Falintil rightly points
that about 1,500 armed Indonesian troops remain in East Timor. These are
the remnants of an army of occupation and oppression. While they are there,
Interfet doesn't have a monopoly of force and the resistance has a strong
case - symbolically, emotionally and politically -- for remaining armed
as well. But the disarmament of Falintil can be tied to the Indonesian
withdrawal. When the last Indonesian soldier has left East Timor, the rationale
for the guerillas remaining a fighting force will be gone as well. It is
then that Falintil should hand over its weapons.
This can be done in a way
that preserves the dignity and honour of the guerillas. The militias have
been involved in cowardly attacks on unarmed civilians. It is right that
they should be treated as thugs and criminals, and unceremoniously stripped
of their weapons. Falintil, by contrast, will be voluntarily disarming
and there is nothing to stop this being an occasion for celebration and
conducted in a fashion conducive to that outcome.
Moreover, disarming doesn't
mean disbanding, and the distinction is an important one that should be
preserved. Falintil is more than likely to form the core of an indigenous
police force when circumstances in East Timor permit. It is sensible to
keep its units intact, even perhaps to think about training them into the
role of civilian law enforcers. And just because Falintil is disarmed doesn't
mean it has no role to play in the interim. Falintil has expertise and
credibility among the East Timorese which Interfet may find useful even
if, in the interests of neutrality, it should avoid a formal association.
Much has been asked of the
East Timorese in the struggle to secure their national rights. Much more
may be asked of them before those rights finally are secured. The same
is true of Mr Gusmao. As the likely first leader of independent East Timor,
what is asked of him now is that he takes decisions in the interests of
all East Timorese.
That doesn't mean turning
a blind eye to the atrocities of the recent past. It does mean, on the
disarmament issue, recognising that the phase of armed struggle against
Indonesian occupation is over and that Interfet's job to restore law and
order in the territory is hard enough without it having to make exceptions
for his fighters. Mr Gusmao says he is willing to discuss the role of Falintil
with Interfet representatives. When he does, he should be prepared to compromise
with them as well.
Ruined
town yields tales of 200 killings
South China Morning Post
- October 7, 1999
Rene Flipo, Maliana -- The
few people who greeted the first international peacekeepers to arrive in
the devastated and deserted town of Maliana yesterday recounted tales of
terror, massacres and forced deportations.
Some of the 15,000 population
were killed on the spot, many others were forced to go to West Timor, where
some were reportedly killed and the remainder fled to the hills, they said.
Every night, they said, soldiers
and pro-Jakarta militias gathered people in the police station, blindfolded
them, then killed them. There were at least 200 killings of the sort, the
residents said.
They started on September
8, after about 500 Indonesian police, soldiers and militia members had
carried out an investigation into which of the town's residents had voted
for independence in the August 30 ballot.
Paulo Maya, 38, said he saw
20 people being killed in the city stadium, some as young as seven.
Many were deported to West
Timor and slaughtered there, said people who emerged from the hills to
greet the Australian peacekeepers on their arrival from Balibo.
Queried about the lack of
bodies in the stadium and the police station, they said the bodies were
taken by truck over the border.
Oliviu Reis Mendoza said
he lost two brothers. Paulo Maya said he lost his father and mother in
the killings. Humberto Alves, 34, said his mother, father, wife and three
children were deported.
Many who turned out to greet
the Australian troops waved banners and flags and gave clenched-fist salutes
as they shouted: "Freedom or death -- viva East Timor."
"We're very, very happy today,"
said Anakleto Moris, 25. "Now that Interfet has come to Maliana, I believe
we'll get [independence]."
But Luciu Americu, 23, said:
"I don't know why it's taken them so long to get here. There haven't been
any militia here since September 22."
The ease with which journalists
reached the town earlier this week has led to criticism that the Australian-led
peace force has been too slow in securing outlying areas. Resistance leader
Xanana Gusmao said yesterday the territory could set up a South African-style
Truth and Reconciliation Commission to deal with the crimes of the militias.
UN
proposes transitional authority
Agence France Presse - October
6, 1999
United Nations -- Secretary-General
Kofi Annan yesterday proposed a United Nations transitional authority for
East Timor that would oversee all aspects of civilian life and include
some 10,000 peacekeepers and police.
In a report to the Security
Council, the Secretary-General details the establishment of a UN Transitional
Administration for East Timor (UNTAET) for the period before independence,
calling it a "major challenge" for the UN whose success will depend on
the "strong and continuing support and cooperation" of the international
community.
Under the 5 May Agreements
that paved the way for the UN-run ballot in August in which an 80 per cent
majority rejected a proposal to remain under Indonesian control with broad
autonomy, the UN would assume authority over the territory after the Indonesian
Parliament took the necessary constitutional steps "to terminate its links
with East Timor." The Parliament is expected to ratify the ballot's results
in late October or early November.
According to the Secretary-General's
plan, UNTAET would be empowered to exercise all legislative and executive
authority, including the administration of justice, in the ruined territory
for two to three years until local elections can take place. UNTAET would
also establish appropriate advisory bodies to ensure East Timorese participation
in the "governance and administration" of the territory.
The Administration would
comprise three parts, including a governance and public administration
component that would oversee the rebuilding of East Timor's judiciary,
civilian police force and public services. This sector would also handle
economic, financial and development affairs, run the electoral operations
and take charge of each of the territory's 13 regencies, or districts.
UNTAET's two other components would provide humanitarian assistance and
emergency rehabilitation as well as military protection.
The Secretary-General recommends
about 9,000 peacekeeping troops to maintain a secure environment, monitor
the "prompt and complete" withdrawal of Indonesian troops and to disarm
and demobilize armed groups. A further contingent of 1,250 civilian police
would be responsible for law enforcement as well as the recruitment and
training of a "credible, professional and impartial" East Timor police
force.
Noting that the current situation
is "critical," Mr. Annan also appeals to UN Member countries to urgently
provide experts to carry out ad hoc measures designed to fill the existing
"vacuum of authority" created by the early departure of Indonesian authorities
from East Timor.
Alatas
`told Downer groups were armed'
Sydney Morning Herald - October
6, 1999
Tom Allard -- The Indonesian
Foreign Minister told his Australian counterpart, Mr Downer, as early as
February that Indonesia was arming pro-integration groups.
According to an article in
the Bulletin magazine, the Indonesian Foreign Minister, Mr Ali Alatas,
told Mr Downer arming of the groups was "legitimate".
Soon after, Mr Downer told
the Portuguese Foreign Minister, Mr Jamie Gama, a peacekeeping force "per
se" was not wise ahead of the ballot. Instead a UN presence along the lines
of the Unamet mission was more appropriate.
Responding to the allegations,
Mr Downer said yesterday Mr Alatas had not referred to militias but "auxiliaries
found right across Indonesia" which supplemented "under-resourced police
and military personnel".
Two weeks after the February
meeting, Mr Downer said publicly that Mr Alatas had told him it "wasn't
happening, that they weren't arming paramilitaries".
The Secretary of the Department
of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Dr Ashton Calvert, and a First Assistant
Secretary of the Department of Prime Minster and Cabinet, Mr Peter Varghese,
had also argued against peacekeepers during meetings with US officials.
Dr Calvert told a senior
US State Department official, Mr Stanley Roth: "Australia had not sensed
any broad international appetite for a large-scale UN intervention." Mr
Roth then warned: "East Timor is about to descend into internecine violence."
Interviewed on the ABC's
The 7.30 Report last night, Mr Downer said Dr Calvert and Mr Varghese did
not rule out peacekeepers "for a worst-case scenario".
"Australian planners were
giving close attention to that, including the possibility of military deployment,"
he said. "And it ended up Roth agreed the Australian approach would keep
a wide number of options open and did not preclude the peacekeeping possibilities."
By June, however, Australia
had sent the Vice-Chief of the Defence Force, Air Marshal Doug Riding,
to Jakarta to complain about Indonesian involvement "at the highest level"
in arming and organising militias.
Refugee
tells of killings in West Timor
Reuters - October 4, 1999
Balibo -- An escapee from
the refugee camps in West Timor said on Sunday that pro- Indonesian militias
were hunting down East Timorese men there and killing them.
In the town of Balibo, near
the border with West Timor and a former stronghold of pro-Jakarta militias,
troops with the multinational force sealed off a bloodstained house in
which they suspected sex crimes had been committed.
"The militia in Atambua are
hunting out the male refugees. They want to kill them all," Domingos dos
Santos told journalists in Balibo where he was being questioned by Australian
troops. Dos Santos fled the camps around Atambua, 10 km from the border
with East Timor, on Saturday afternoon.
The United Nations estimates
there are some 150,000 East Timorese living in appalling conditions in
camps in West Timor.
Many of the refugees were
driven out of East Timor at gunpoint after last months announcement that
the overwhelming majority of East Timorese had voted to end almost 24 years
of often brutal Indonesian rule.
US Defence Secretary William
Cohen said on Sunday it was vital the refugees in West Timor be allowed
home. "We are hoping that this takes place and it is vitally important
that it does take place," he told reporters in Manila at the end of a five-nation
tour. Dos Santos fled his home in Dili after his uncle was killed by militia
on September 4, the day that the result of the independence referendum
was announced by the United Nations.
He said the militias, who
were created and supported by the Indonesian army, were preventing anyone
from returning home. "They told us they want to get everyone out of East
Timor and they arent letting them back in. They are saying there is going
to be a war in East Timor and we cannot go back until later."
He also accused Indonesian
troops of blocking the refugees. "They [the militia and troops] stop the
vehicles going back across the border and threaten to kill the people in
them. Or if they recognise them, they kill them there on the border."
He said that he fooled the
militia into thinking he was one of them in order to escape. "I got to
the border yesterday and the militia were searching cars so I pretended
to search cars too and then slipped across the border." From the town of
Balibo, near the border, thousands of cooking fires can be seen glowing
in the night.
Dos Santos said the refugees
were not getting any assistance. "Nobody is giving us food or water," he
said. The United Nations has visited some of the camps, but say that they
are not being given free access by the Indonesian authorities.
Places like Balibo are ghost
towns, with no remaining population. Many of the corrugated iron rooves
have been stripped off the houses.
In one house in the centre
of Balibo, a militia stronghold before the vote, there are bloodstains
on the walls and floor.
"We are sealing off the area
as a crime scene," said an Australian officer of the international intervention
force which secured the town three days ago. "We suspect it has been the
scene of sexual crimes," he said.
In a bedroom littered with
school books and the clothes of a young girl, lipstick kisses covered the
whitewashed concrete walls and the doors.
'Peacekeepers
too cautious, aid too slow'
South China Morning Post
- October 4, 1999 (abridged)
Associated Press, Waimori
-- The international peacekeeping force is being too cautious in dealing
with the remnants of the militias which ravaged East Timor, the commander
of the pro- independence guerillas said yesterday. The Australian-led force
was also moving too slowly to get vital aid deliveries to people in the
countryside, said Taur Matan Ruak, speaking at his remote base in the hills
of central East Timor.
"This could have been done
much more quickly," Ruak told a United Nations official, Gilbert Greenall.
He offered his own troops as unarmed security escorts for food convoys.
Rauk is the senior commander
of Falintil, the armed wing of the resistance movement that opposed Indonesia's
occupation of East Timor after the Portuguese relinquished its colony in
1975.
Mr Greenall acknowledged
UN agencies "have been slower than we might have been" in getting the aid
to people displaced in the aftermath of the August 30 referendum on independence.
He said there were plans to pick up the pace of aid delivery this week.
The peace force is mandated
to disarm all the militias, including Falintil, except in their own designated
bases.
Ruak said the remaining militia
in East Timor posed little threat. "They are on the run themselves," he
said, and the peace force could be more aggressive in its deployment.
If the peacekeepers needed
reinforcement to escort food convoys, his men were ready to volunteer,
even without their weapons. "The militia are no match for us, even if we
are disarmed," he said. They were effective only as long as they had the
regular Indonesian army behind them, he said.
Residents of Cairu, where
a convoy of trucks made an aid delivery yesterday, said Falintil fighters
drove off militia raiders two weeks ago, killing one of them. Five Falintil
were wounded in the gunbattle. Cairu is one of the few villages seen in
East Timor to have escaped serious damage.
Interfet
wants to disarm Falintil
Associated Press - October
5, 1999
Slobodan Lekic, Dili -- Stung
by criticism of alleged bias, the commander of the international peacekeeping
force in East Timor demanded today that pro-independence rebels hand in
their weapons.
"The policy is that we disarm
any East Timorese who are not in TNI ... we disarm them all," Maj. Gen.
Peter Cosgrove said. TNI is the acronym for the Indonesian army, which
has retained two infantry battalions in East Timor after evacuating most
of its forces from the territory.
Pro-Jakarta militias, along
with Indonesian media and officials, have accused the peacekeepers of a
bias toward independence supporters, including the Falintil rebel group,
which has battled Indonesian rule since 1975.
The militias and their Indonesian
army backers are widely blamed for unleashing an orgy of violence after
East Timorese overwhelmingly endorsed independence in an Aug. 30 UN-sponsored
referendum.
Top commanders of Falintil
have repeatedly stressed their willingness to disarm but have criticized
the peacekeepers for their slow deployment.
In the village of Cairu,
50 miles southeast of Dili, a contingent of Gurkha soldiers from the peacekeeping
force asked the local Falintil leader to order his men to hand over their
weapons.
With journalists watching,
the Falintil leader responded he would do so only if the Gurkhas established
a permanent presence in the village as protection from marauding militiamen.
That ended the discussion, since the peacekeepers, who had been escorting
a convoy of relief aid, planned to spend only a few hours in the area.
The rebels kept their arms.
Cosgrove, however, described
the incident -- which had appeared innocuous -- as verging on violence,
calling it "very tense indeed."
"There could have been bloodshed
right at that time," he said. "For this province to be at peace, we must
take arms out of the hands of those who are untrained and unsanctioned
as a military force."
Cosgrove also said he had
written to Indonesian commanders to demand that four of their officers
be returned to Dili to "assist" in a criminal inquiry into the killing
of a Dutch reporter, Sander Thoenes, slain outside the territory's capital
on Sept. 21 by men reportedly in Indonesian uniform. He declined to say
if the four were suspects.
Meanwhile, Ross Mountain,
a UN relief aid coordinator, said the first of some 250,000 East Timorese
who had fled to the Indonesian territory of West Timor -- many allegedly
at militia gunpoint -- would begin returning Wednesday.
Inside West Timor, pro-Indonesian
militia leader Joao da Silva Tavares claimed his forces now number over
53,000 troops and he intended to take East Timor by force.
He said militiamen would
accompany groups of pro-Indonesian refugees who planned to cross back into
East Timor on foot from camps in the west on Tuesday.
PDI-P
says no plans to mobilize masses
Indonesian Observer - October
8, 1999
Jakarta -- The Indonesian
Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI- P), the party which obtained the largest
votes at the last general elections, says it has no intention to mobilize
the masses no matter what the result of the presidential election on October
20 as non-violence has become its policy.
"Our non-violent policy has
been stated by our Chairperson [Megawati Soekarnoputri] at her recent political
speech that PDI Perjuangan will not allow even a drop of blood to be shed
by the people," Kwik Kian Gie, a PDI-P leader told a press conference yesterday.
Some political analysts have
expressed pessimism that Megawati will be elected as the fourth Indonesian
president although her party collected the largest number of votes (34%)
at the June 7 general election.
This has also been prompted
by the fact that during the first round of the general session of the People's
Consultative Assembly, PDI-P failed to obtain support from other parties.
PDI-P lost in all posts contested
for at the DPR/MPR, as the smaller parties grouped with the Axis Forces,
in electing the speakers for the MPR and the DPR respectiely.
Some analysts have expressed
anxiety that PDI-P supporters may not be able to accept the results of
the presidential election if Megawati fails to become the president.
Kwik stressed Megawati has
expressed the non-violent policy of the party not only to the Indonesian
people, but also when she delivered her speech in front of foreign diplomats
and other members of the international community. "Ibu [Mrs.] Megawati
always tells foreign guests who she meets that she is against violence,"
Kwik stressed.
Kwik also said that all PDI-P
leaders have given an undertaking to their supporters that leaders of the
party would work all out for Megawati's presidential bid. "But it we lose
at the presidential election, [we will explain to them], it is democracy,"
Kwik added.
Supporting Kwik's statement,
the Chairman of the PDI Faction at the MPR, Sutjipto said that mass mobilization
will never become the party's policy. Instead party leaders will attempt
to seek an understanding from members should Megawati fail in her bid for
the presidency.
Recognising that it could
be an emotional issue should Megawati be defeated, Sutjipto, who is chairman
of the East Java PDI Chapter, one of the party's strongholds, added: "We
have never discussed mass mobilization. Our policy is controlling our supporters'
emotions because as stated by Pak Kwik, it is a principle that has been
expressed by our chairperson."
Sutjipto was confident that
PDI-P supporters would understand the explanation of its leaders. "Luckily,
our supporters usually follow what has been expressed by our chairperson,"
he said.
Golkar
co-operation key to presidency
South China Morning Post
- October 8, 1999
Vaudine England, Jakarta
-- The most open secret in Jakarta's murky political world is about the
meeting which presidential frontrunner Megawati Sukarnoputri had with chairman
of the ruling Golkar party, Akbar Tanjung.
Sources say a deal was struck
at the meeting on Tuesday night which would still give the presidency to
Ms Megawati, in co- operation with the wing of Golkar which is aligned
with Mr Akbar.
The deal involved Ms Megawati's
party -- the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle -- giving support
to Mr Akbar in his bid for the Speaker's post in the House of Representatives
(DPR), a commitment which came to pass with his successful election.
"Now the idea is that Akbar
supports Megawati for president so long as he can become vice-president,
but we'll have to see if the deal lasts the next one-and-a-half weeks,"
a political source said.
The spoiler could be the
now-formal presidential nomination of Abdurrahman Wahid, known as Gus Dur,
by his own National Awakening Party (PKB) and by Amien Rais of the National
Mandate Party (PAN) and the Justice Party (PK) -- two members of the Axis
Force, a grouping of Islamist parties.
Time will tell if Gus Dur
as presidential candidate is the dark horse, or a Trojan horse who will
split the PKB and the wider Islamist constituency in his unlikely bid for
power.
The deal is based on the
assumption that there remains a widespread popular expectation that Ms
Megawati should be president because her party won a plurality in the June
general elections.
At the same time, the way
in which Mr Amien and Mr Akbar have swayed votes their way to secure the
Speaker's jobs in the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) and the DPR
respectively heralds a new era in Indonesian politics.
These men and the hardened
politicians behind them appear eager to assert a new dynamism in a parliament
which was but a rubber-stamp under former president Suharto -- with a concomitant
weakening of the office of president.
Ms Megawati's weaknesses
would fit this notion of a more symbolic presidency, leaving the running
of the country to an emboldened parliament.
Alternatively, some sources
suggest that part of Gus Dur's appeal is his physical frailty, which opens
possibilities for more change at the top before the end of his first five-year
term.
Of further interest is the
fact that it is a faction of Golkar which is now a key actor in the post-Suharto
era due to the adept politicking of Mr Akbar and ally Marzuki Darusman.
Similarly, the military's block of votes are not crucial to the numbers
game if Ms Megawati and Golkar can stay good friends.
Wahid
strong contender for president
Agence France Presse - October
7, 1999
Jakarta -- Muslim leader
Abdurrahman "Gus Dur" Wahid Thursday emerged as a strong contender to be
Indonesia's next president in a race with opposition leader Megawati Sukarnoputri
and incumbent B.J. Habibie.
With only two weeks to go
until the election the National Awakening Party (PKB), which finished third
in the June 7 parliamentary elections, said it would "most likely" withdraw
support for Megawati. It would instead back Wahid in the October 20 presidential
election by the 700-member People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).
The PKB has so far been an
ally of Megawati, the daughter of Indonesia's founding president Sukarno
and leader of the Indonesian Democratic Party-Struggle (PDIP), winner of
the June 7 polls.
"We will immediately hold
a meeting. And most likely we will support Gus Dur," Alwi Shihab, deputy
chairman of PKB, was quoted by the Kompas daily as saying. "We have to
be thankful that our leader is nominated as president. PKB can't but support
the nomination," Shihab added.
Wahid was formally nominated
as a presidential candidate of the Reform faction of the new national assembly
on Wednesday.
The Reform faction pairs
the People's Mandate Party (PAN) of reformist politician Amien Rais, now
speaker of the national assembly, and the Muslim Justice Party.
Although Wahid's name had
already been floated by an alliance of seven Muslim parties for president,
his candidacy only became official Wednesday.
Wahid heads the country's
largest Islamic organization, the 30-million-strong Nahdlatul Ulama (NU),
which created the PKB after the fall of former president Suharto last year.
The stock market reacted
cautiously to Wahid's nomination, with the index closingd 0.6 lower as
investors adopted a wait-and-see attitude, dealers said.
"I think the market is still
confused about the signals about who is going to become the next president,"
a dealer with Lippo Securities said.
Khofifah Indar Parawansa
of the PKB had earlier said that once Wahid had been nominated by a faction
in the parliament, the party would throw its support behind him.
"Gus Dur is a prominent figure
in our party, but we cannot support him if none of the factions has nominated
him," she was quoted by the Jakarta Post as saying. She said PKB's formal
support must be decided in an internal meeting between party executives.
But Shihab said the party
wanted to see how serious the reform faction was in nominating Wahid. "Is
it only rhetoric and words, or are they serious in garnering bigger support?"
he said.
Analysts say Megawati's chances
of winning the presidency have weakened following her party defeats in
the elections of chairman of the MPR and speaker of the lower house (DPR).
But Dimyati Hartono, one
of Megawati deputies, said on Wednesday he was optimistic Megawati would
become president. "Up until now, the PDIP is still optimistic," Hartono
said.
"They [speakers' positions]
are not defeats for PDIP because the MPR and the DPR are both not the targets
[of PDIP,]" Hartono said, adding that the main objective of the party was
to ensure Megawati became president.
PDIP's candidate for the
MPR chairmanship, Matori Abdul Jalil, lost by a slight margin of 26 votes
against Muslim reform leader Amien Rais who received the backing of the
ruling Golkar and an alliance of several Muslim parties.
Many fear a violent backlash
by Megawati's supporters, who are mostly urban and rural poor, if she is
not elected president despite her party's victory in the elections.
PDIP executives, and Megawati
herself, have reasoned that the party that won the most votes in the parliamentary
elections holds the right to lead the country.
Megawati's
presidential bid losing steam
South China Morning Post
- October 7, 1999
Agencies in Jakarta -- Opposition
leader Megawati Sukarnoputri's chances of becoming Indonesia's next president
weakened yesterday as a political rival won a key post and her party's
main ally pondered withdrawing support.
Several hundred Megawati
supporters demonstrated in central Jakarta, demanding the country's legislature
select her as the next leader.
Her party scrambled to find
legislators to back her after a vote in the early hours left the post of
Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR) in the hands of its arch-rival.
Political analysts blamed
the hugely popular Ms Megawati for assuming her party's victory in June's
election ensured she would become president.
Akbar Tanjung, chairman of
President Bacharuddin Habibie's Golkar party, became Speaker in a secret
ballot of the 500-member parliament by winning a massive 411 votes.
It was the second such setback
for Ms Megawati's camp this week. On Sunday reformist Amien Rais, backed
by an alliance of Muslim parties, defeated a Megawati-backed candidate
to become Speaker of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR), which will
elect a president on October 20.
Although many members of
Ms Megawati's party voted for Mr Tandjung, he denied any deal had been
struck on the presidency.
Ms Megawati's supporters
have begun sounding uneasy about the October 20 presidential vote. She
has been regarded as the favourite for months.
"We don't feel that we are
going to be defeated but we must never rule out that possibility," said
one official of her Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle. However, party
deputy chairman Dimyati Hartono said the party was "still optimistic" about
her chances.
A senior official of the
Nation Awakening Party (PKB) warned that it might withdraw its support
for Ms Megawati's candidacy in favour of its own founder, Muslim leader
Abdurrahman Wahid. That would virtually kill off Ms Megawati's hopes.
PKB co-chairman Alwi Shihab
said the switch depended on seven other Muslim-oriented parties formalising
their declared support for the frail, nearly blind Mr Wahid, also known
as Gus Dur.
Mr Wahid yesterday accepted
nomination for the presidency by Mr Rais' party and another small Muslim
party, a spokesman for the two parties said. Even with PKB's 51 votes,
Ms Megawati is not assured election.
Analysts said her party,
which won June's parliamentary election, had not lobbied properly. They
accused her of being imperious and assuming that her party's 153 seats
assured her the presidency.
The daughter of founding
president Sukarno, she is adored for her staunch opposition to long-term
ruler Mr Suharto during his chaotic last years in office. But her party
is well short of a majority in the 700-member MPR.
Analysts fear violence in
Indonesia if Ms Megawati fails to win the presidency, especially if the
victor turns out to be the unpopular President Bacharuddin Habibie.
PDI-P's
abysmal lobbying skills
Straits Times - October 6,
1999
Susan Sim, Jakarta -- In
an extraordinary display of the lobbying skills of Golkar leaders, party
chief Akbar Tandjung was set to be elected Speaker of Parliament (DPR)
without a vote being cast last night.
Banking on its earlier deal
with the Central Axis bloc of Muslim parties, Golkar persuaded the Indonesian
Democratic Party-Perjuangan (PDI-P) to come on board and so prevent a damaging
showdown that would make it difficult for both to cooperate later in the
final game -- for the presidency.
If the post were to be contested,
Mr Akbar would probably still squeak in past anyone fielded by the 204-strong
alliance of PDI-P and the Nation Awakening Party (PKB) in the 500-seat
House -- much as the Central Axis' Amien Rais did in a Sunday vote for
control of the 700-member People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).
The double defeat would not
only underscore the potency of the Muslim lobby against Ms Megawati Soekarnoputri,
the PDI-P's chief and presidential candidate, but also expose anew her
party's ineptitude in the cut-and-thrust of coalition-building politics.
Explaining why Golkar worked
hard to get Mr Akbar acclaimed as House Speaker with PDI-P and PKB support
rather than take it to the vote, deputy secretary-general Muchyar Yara
said: "The problem is not that Megawati's people are arrogant, but that
she doesn't think the post is important.
"But it is important, and
if we vote against each other for it, then psychologically, the members
from both sides are going to become more unsympathetic to each other. It
will be difficult to cooperate on the presidential election later."
But sources said some Central
Axis leaders were keen on a vote to drive a wedge between Golkar and the
PDI-P even after reaching a consensus on Mr Akbar as Speaker. At midnight
several legislators were still delaying proceedings as they haggled for
a vote.
In contrast to Golkar, the
PDI-P's lobbying skills have been showing up poorly under the spotlight.
Observers were shocked when
it failed to secure a single regional ticket to the MPR from the Riau parliament
on Monday despite being the second largest vote-getter in the province.
Golkar took three of the
five seats, including one for Home Minister Syarwan Hamid, and the other
two went to Central Axis parties. Each MPR seat is important to the PDI-P
if it hopes to secure the presidency for Ms Megawati come October 20.
But at each turn, PDI-P has
not only been left complaining that other parties "ganged up" against it,
but an erstwhile Megawati ally, Mr Abdurrahman Wahid, has also suggested
he might challenge her for the presidency.
A close aide of Mr Abdurrahman
said he was making a play only to force her to change policies, while at
the same time neutralise President B.J. Habibie's influence with the Muslim
parties.
But signals have been conflicting
even to the PDI-P, who privately dismiss Mr Abdurrahman as "unreliable".
Even if Mr Abdurrahman enters
as a Central Axis candidate -- thereby splitting Ms Megawati's support
in PKB, the party he founded -- he would still need Golkar and military
votes.
But Golkar, locked in an
internal struggle over Dr Habibie's candidacy, is likely to give Mr Abdurrahman
short shrift. Reformers opposed to Dr Habibie are uncomfortable with any
group playing the Muslim card, and individually are more likely to vote
for Ms Megawati and her more inclusive brand of nationalist politics.
The military, now standing
aloof as it contemplates its declining influence as a political player,
will also be concerned not only with the backlash from nationalist hardliners,
but will also have to calculate the risks of mass unrest if the popular
Ms Megawati does not become president, analysts say.
For PDI-P legislators, the
bottom line is this: As the majority party, they can obstruct any government
by withholding support. Warned Mr Subagio Anam: "Any president who's not
Megawati will be short-lived because we control Parliament."
Bets
off for presidential election
South China Morning Post
- October 5, 1999
Vaudine England and agencies,
Jakarta -- All bets are now off for the forthcoming presidential poll in
the wake of several startling, democratic events in the country's highest
political body, the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR).
As deliberation proceeds
on who should be Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR), politicians
and observers were yesterday still trying to understand the 11th-hour success
of reformist politician Amien Rais in securing the Speaker's job in the
MPR.
Meanwhile, the bloc of Muslim
parties which lobbied for Mr Rais was now said to be pressuring the Golkar
party to support Muslim leader Abdurrahman Wahid in the October 20 presidential
poll.
The grouping wants the MPR
to choose Mr Wahid over frontrunner Megawati Sukarnoputri and President
Bacharuddin Habibie, Golkar's candidate, but faces growing opposition on
a number of fronts. Mr Wahid leads Indonesia's largest Muslim organisation,
the 40- million-strong Nahdlatul Ulama.
A significant point about
the election of Mr Rais to MPR Speaker is that a vote was required, and
was conducted by secret ballot.
On a separate front, the
fact that Mr Rais -- former leader of the Muhammadiyah Muslim organisation
-- went to kiss Mr Wahid shows how well these two former rivals are now
getting along politically.
Their ability to work together,
as seen when Mr Wahid lobbied for Mr Rais' victory, poses a direct threat
to Ms Megawati's claim to the presidency. Her own candidate for MPR Speaker
lost to a combination of Muslim groups and Golkar.
Ms Megawati yesterday warned
the MPR not to create a "distortion" by failing to reflect the results
of the June 7 general election.
Speaking after the swearing
in of Mr Rais, Ms Megawati said that, "with all the [Indonesian] people
have done for their sovereignty", failure by the MPR session to reflect
the results of the election would "bring about a distortion" -- alluding
to possible protests by her supporters. She did not elaborate.
"It's a consequence of her
own inaction since the general election," said a political insider, expressing
a widespread view. "She never responded to Amien Rais' gestures, so she
lost him and lost his influence. It seems to make things harder for Mega,
unless there's some very deep Javanese plot going on which we can't imagine,"
a political analyst said.
"It also seems that if this
[Rais' victory] was the result of collusion between Golkar and the Muslims,
then maybe Mr Habibie is not as weak as we thought.
"Also, with Matori Abdul
Djalil [from PKB, National Awakening Party] and Ginandjar Kartasasmita
[from Golkar] now as Vice- Speakers of the MPR, that means they are out
of the presidential race too."
Regardless of what happens
next, which no one is predicting, the message from the new MPR is that
whoever becomes president will face a feisty parliament and a concomitant
lessening of power.
"This is good news from a
democratic perspective," said the insider. "So we'll see if this will also
materialise during the presidential election."
Mr Habibie said yesterday
he was ready to deliver to the MPR his accountability speech outlining
his performance and achievements.
Assembly
picks reformist speaker
Reuters - October 3, 1999
Tomi Soetjipto, Jakarta --
Indonesia's supreme legislative assembly elected a leading reformist as
speaker on Sunday in its first contested vote since the 1950s, a step which
could be crucial in the fight for the presidency.
After a debate which lasted
most of the day the 700-member assembly -- which later this month will
choose the country's next president -- picked Amien Rais, popular reform
leader and head of the minority National Mandate Party. Rais, who polled
305 votes, immediately pledged to reform the constitution and tighten control
over the new government.
Though it is officially one
of the most powerful positions in Indonesia, past autocratic presidents
ensured the chairmanship of the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) went
to figures who toed the government line.
In second place was the head
of the Moslem-backed Nation Awakening Party, Matori Abdul Djalil, with
279 votes. He was backed by the leading Indonesian Democratic Party-Struggle
(PDI- P), headed by presidential frontrunner Megawati Sukarnoputri.
Rais is a key member of the
so-called "central axis" of Moslem and reform politicians which is backing
Moslem leader Abdurrahman Wahid in the October 20 presidential election.
"I will look at the MPR decrees
and take out those which are not necessary, and go on with an effort to
amend the 1945 constitution," Rais told reporters after the vote.
Rais gave no details but
he is widely known to back far greater provincial autonomy in the huge
archipelago and wants to curb the political role of the powerful military.
"I hope that the upcoming
government, whoever the president is, can be checked every year, not every
five years," he added.
Indonesia's first two presidents
were autocrats and the third and current incumbent, the deeply unpopular
B.J. Habibie, has only been in the job just over 16 months. He is widely
expected to lose the October 20 presidential election.
Initially, Abdurrahman Wahid
had been favourite for MPR speaker, which would have kept him out of the
presidential race.
Though almost blind and in
poor health, the 58-year-old Wahid has been viewed as a possible compromise
presidential candidate if former opposition leader Megawati is unable to
win enough support in the newly-formed assembly.
Her party has the most seats
in the assembly but not enough to dictate the result in the presidential
vote. Analysts said if she ran alone against Habibie she would almost certainly
win.
If Wahid joins the race,
it could split reformists trying to end the legacy of disgraced autocrat
Suharto, who after more than three decades in power was forced to step
down in May last year, handing the presidency to his acolyte Habibie. The
elections of speaker and president will be the first real contests since
the 1950s in the MPR, which in later decades became a "rubber stamp" assembly.
The body is dominated by
freely elected lawmakers after general elections for the lower House of
Representatives in June, the nation's first free vote since 1955. Megawati's
party won the biggest share of the vote in June, but fell short of a majority.
Political/economic
crisis |
Ten
die in clashes in Maluku
Agence France Presse - October
8, 1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- At least ten people
have been killed and scores injured in renewed clashes between Muslims
and Christians in an island in the riot-torn Indonesian province of Maluku,
reports said Friday.
The battle on Thursday broke
out after groups of people from the Saparua island launched an attack on
residents in the neighbouring island of Haruku, the Media Indonesia newspaper
said.
Meanwhile, four bodies with
gunshot wounds were found on Thursday in the Air Besar area of the strife-torn
Ambon city, the capital of Maluku, a local journalist said.
A man was also killed on
the same day in clashes in the Ahuru area of the city, the journalist said.
"There are indications that the killings were conducted by snipers and
they use standard military weapons," he said.
"The Maluku governor [Saleh
Latuconsina] has urged the military to uncover the mysterious shooters,"
he added.
Earlier this week, two army
soldiers were killed by unidentified gunmen when they were trying to quell
clashes between Muslim and Christian residents in the city.
Indonesia
records 7th month of deflation
Reuters - October 2, 1999
Moris Morissan, Jakarta --
Indonesia on Friday reported its seventh straight month of falling prices
in another sign that the grass roots of its shattered economy were recovering
from crisis. Indonesia's statistics bureau reported month-on-month inflation
of minus 0.68 percent in September, bringing the year-on-year rate -- which
peaked at 82.4 percent in September last year -- down to a mere 1.25 percent.
The figures mainly reflect falling food prices, as staple crops like rice
rebound after widespread drought last year and as the nation's distribution
network recovers from massive upheaval.
When Indonesia collapsed
into political and economic turmoil in mid 1998, some retailers simply
shut down and many Chinese merchants, who had come under popular attack,
fled the country.
But the statistics bureau
said Indonesians were now more hardened to their country's problems and
no longer reacted by stopping production or closing down businesses.
"Unlike last year, right
now people have got used to rumours of unrest and they are not easily prompted
to stop production or close the shops," bureau chief Sugito Suwito said.
Only last week, Jakarta's
streets erupted into riots in which seven people were killed. The unrest
was sparked by mass protests over a new internal security law. "The recent
student protests about the security bill did not affect people significantly,"
Suwito said.
Economists said September's
deflation was widely expected and that it would be difficult to maintain
to the end of the year. "It was already expected in September, but we have
to look till the end of the year because people will buy more ahead of
Christmas and the Eid al Fitr Moslem festivals," said Laksono Widodo, head
of research at ING Baring Securities Indonesia.
September's fall in prices
followed monthly inflation of minus 0.93 percent in August and a yearly
rate of 5.77 percent. The bureau said lower food prices contributed most
to September's result. It has predicted that inflation in calendar 1999
will be under five percent.
Indonesia also reported on
Friday a trade surplus of $2.585 billion in August. Exports totalled $4.599
billion and imports $2.014 billion. The trade surplus in July was $2.007
billion. Non-oil exports in August were $3.585 billion and non-oil imports
in August were $1.635 billion.
Indonesia's trade surplus
has ballooned as it endures its worst economic crisis in three decades
-- not because of a rise in exports but because imports have dived.
Indonesia has been engulfed
by violence since it was swept up in Asia's economic crisis in 1997. Riots
in the capital in May last year killed around 1,200 people and finally
forced long-term president Suharto from power after 32 years.
Students
demand self-determination
Agence France Presse - October
4, 1999
Lhokseumawe -- Some 800 students
in Indonesia's restive province of Aceh rallied Monday to demand an East
Timor-style referendum on self-determination.
The protesters, picketting
the district council building in the city of Lhokseumawe in north Aceh,
called for the prosecution of those guilty of human rights violations in
the province and opposed proposals by the military to establish a regional
command for the province.
Hundreds of housewives meanwhile
protested outside the district police station, demanding the release of
their children and husbands who were arrested during a protest on Friday.
Aceh has suffered years of
violence between soldiers and members and supporters of the Aceh Merdeka
(Free Aceh Movement) which has been fighting for an Islamic state since
the 1970s.
Resentment and discontent
against the central government has spiralled following Jakarta's failure
to punish members of the military for human rights abuses that occurred
during anti-rebel operations over the last decade.
When the operations ended
last year, rights groups unearthed mass graves and brought forward scores
of victims of rape and torture which shocked Indonesia. Military violence
continued even after the operations were officially halted.
The bitterness against the
government has been further fuelled by dissatisfaction over the exploitation
of Aceh's natural resources, including natural gas. Little of the profit
generated has been reinvested in the province.
The discontent has led to
mounting calls for a referendum on self-determination for Aceh, which the
government has staunchly ruled out.
Violence,
tension hurt economy in Aceh
Reuters - October 7, 1999
(slightly abridged)
Lewa Pardomuan, Jakarta --
Violence between Indonesian troops and separatists is hurting the local
economy and scaring off investors in the northern Sumatran province of
Aceh.
One of the hardest hit sectors
in the resource-rich province is coffee growing, traders said on Thursday.
Nearly 40 percent of Indonesia's output of the arabica coffee variety comes
from the staunchly Moslem province.
But many coffee growers have
been forced to abandon their plantations in Aceh, the traders said, for
fear of violence or because migrant plantation workers have been attacked.
Production has fallen and
coffee bean shipments to the central Sumatran commodity city of Medan have
often been disrupted by violence on the main road from Aceh.
"The main issue is security.
Buyers are reluctant to take positions while farmers are worried about
their safety because plantations are located in remote highlands," said
one trader in Medan.
"I think 30 percent of the
arabica plantations in Aceh have been abandoned. You may not hear of fresh
violence lately, but still everyone is cautious," said the trader who has
a plantation in Aceh.
Workers on the plantations,
many of them settlers from the main island of Java, have become targets
of repeated attacks amid escalating violence. They have largely fled.
Road transport firms have
suspended coffee bean shipments to Medan on a series of occasions after
a spate of arson attacks. Coffee is transported by land from Aceh to Medan,
which is also the main export port from Aceh.
"Transport of coffee from
Aceh to Medan is still smooth, but drivers do not dare to bring the commodity
in the evening for security reasons," another trader in Medan said.
"I don't hear new reports
of violence, but the thing is that is everyone is scared in Aceh," he added.
"Harvesting has started in
Aceh, but they [plantation owners] just cannot find workers to harvest
the coffee. Workers used to be the Javanese settlers, but they have gone
because of the violence," a third trader in Medan said.
Indonesia's arabica output
constitutes up to 15 percent of the country's coffee production, which
is expected to stand at 450,000 tonnes in 1999/00 (Oct-Sept) against 380,000
tonnes in 1998/99.
Traders said they had yet
to estimate a decline in output because of the unattended coffee farms.
The official Antara news agency said on Thursday Aceh exported 3,688 tonnes
of arabica in Jan-Sept against 4,011 tonnes in the same period in 1998.
It said the coffee was exported
to the United States, Japan, Taiwan, Singapore, Germany and Denmark. Dry-processed
arabica is currently on sale at 14,000-15,000 rupiah/kg.
Arabica plantations in Aceh
represented 97,886 hectares of land, Antara said.
The Indonesian Coffee Association
said the high costs of growing the aromatic and expensive variety, problems
in finding suitable highlands and violence in Aceh had triggered slow growth
in arabica.
Police
clash with striking workers
Reuters - October 7, 1999
Medan -- Five people were
seriously injured on Thursday in a clash between riot police and workers
demanding a pay rise near the Indonesian city of Medan, witnesses and hospital
sources said.
Police fired blanks at around
100 workers striking near a steel factory just outside the city on Sumatra
island. Dozens of police were assisted by around 300 youths carrying knives
and spears. The clash followed a series of protests near the factory of
steel firm PT Gunung Dahapi.
"Suddenly the youths and
the security forces attacked us," said one worker. Hospital sources said
one of the five injured was in critical condition.
Worker protests have become
common around Medan, an industrial city 1,425 km northwest of Jakarta,
as Indonesia endures its worst economic crisis in three decades. Several
have turned violent.
Australian
soldier's effigy burnt
Agence France Presse - October
9, 1999
Jakarta -- Families of Indonesian
veterans of East Timor protested at the Australian embassy here on Saturday,
burning an effigy representing Australian soldiers.
The some 200 protestors,
mostly children of the veterans, wearing army fatigues, lashed out at Australian
troops in the Australian-led International Force for East Timor (Interfet)
over the latest clashes in the territory that left two pro-Indonesia militia
killed.
They burned a cloth effigy
sporting the name Interfet and slogans such as "Agressors of East Timor",
"Stupid soldiers" and "Australian troops". The effigy stood on two tyres
which caught fire, sending up a column of acrid smoke.
"General Cosgrove, widowmaker,"
said one of the posters carried by the protestors, referring to the Interfet
commander. Another said "Australian Army, have you ordered your body bags?"
Some of the protestors also
attempted to climb the high steel fence of the embassy, but some 100 police
and auxiliary forces guarding the embassy made no attempt at stopping them.
The embassy was closed for business Saturday.
It was the latest anti-Australia
demonstration at the embassy which has almost seen daily protests including
flag burnings in the past weeks.
The embassy was once pelted
with stones and fuel bombs while unidentified gunmen have shot three times
at the mission this month. The Australian International School in Jakarta
was attacked Monday with fuel bombs hurled by unknown men.
Potests have also been held
at Australian consulates in several other towns, forcing the closure of
two of them.
Anti-Australian sentiment
has been on the rise following Canberra's sharply critical stance on Indonesia's
handling of the violence in East Timor and its pressure to push for an
international peacekeeping force there.
UK
keeps lid on role in ousting Sukarno
The Independent (London)
- October 5, 1999
Documents which would reveal
Britain's secret role in Indonesian politics in the Sixties that led to
"one of the worst mass murders of the 20th century" and Jakarta's eventual
annexation of East Timor are being kept under lock and key.
They would uncover the Foreign
Office and MI6's role in helping General Suharto seize power. His regime,
backed by military hardware from Britain and the United States, occupied
East Timor in 1975 and killed up to one-third of the population.
The historian Mark Curtis
believes Britain turned a blind eye to anti-communist massacres of 500,000
people that followed an abortive coup against President Sukarno in 1965,
and may have aided the action that led to Suharto taking over the following
year.
The Cabinet Office, which
is in charge of "open government" policy, refuses to declassify documents
at the Public Record Office at Kew and Churchill College, Cambridge. They
are being held beyond the 30-year period when files are normally released.
Officials cite "sensitivity" in refusing to release them. Key documents
are those of the British ambassador to Indonesia in the mid-Sixties, the
late Sir Andrew Gilchrist. They include some of his personal papers. Most
are open except those dealing with Indonesia. Gilchrist was a key advocate
of a policy of destabilising President Sukarno.
The Independent requested
the release of the Gilchrist documents in 1997. They have been reviewed
but no more papers have been released.
Gilchrist arrived in Indonesia
in 1962 as it was pursuing a policy of "confrontation" with Britain's former
colony Malaya. By 1963, British, Malaysian, Australian and New Zealand
forces were engaged in a low- level conflict with Indonesia in which British
special forces and MI6 became involved.
As a result of this and the
increasing power of the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI), Britain supported
the anti-communist Indonesian military and Suharto's seizure of power.
British intelligence contacted him in 1965, when he sent messengers to
reassure the British that the army would not step up operations against
them and to explore the possibility of ending the "confrontation".
These channels were put to
good use after the abortive coup in October 1965 that triggered the rise
of Suharto and the massacres.
Mr Curtis found in documents
-- some of which have since been reclassified by the Foreign Office --
that when the Indonesian army set about eliminating the PKI, Gilchrist
ensured that it knew Britain would suspend offensive operations so that
it could concentrate on killing communists.
Carmel Budriardjo, a founder
of the Indonesian Human Rights Organisation, said "the relationship became
very close quickly" between Britain, America and the Indonesian military.
Suharto was offered economic aid and the lifting of the embargo on sales
of military aircraft by Britain.
Mr Curtis said that at the
very least "Britain turned a blind eye to the bloody massacres and at most
actively aided it. And I think there are still some question marks over
the degree of that actively aiding". Among classified papers is a letter
to Gilchrist from the Foreign Office official Norman Reddaway, political
adviser to the commander-in-chief, Far East. Just after the apparent communist
coup attempt he arrived in Singapore. His brief was "to do whatever I could
do to get rid of Sukarno".
Suharto took power in 1966
after the coup attempt linked to the PKI, whose involvement was the pretext
for Suharto's elimination of it and the massacres. Sukarno's alleged involvement
was used by Suharto to discredit and replace him.
The British were not alone
in supporting Suharto's coup. According to open documents, one of Gilchrist's
key contacts was Suharto's foreign minister, Adam Malik, later identified
by the envoy as having given crucial advice to Suharto on how to "eliminate
the PKI" and "undermine Sukarno's remaining power".
Malik's aide received a hit-list
of 5,000 suspected communists from the Central Intelligence Agency. On
6 November 1965 the Americans fulfilled army requests for weapons "to arm
Muslim and nationalist youth in central Java for use against the PKI".
Although President Suharto
resigned in May 1998 after Indonesia's economic collapse and widespread
civil unrest, the army still exerts enormous power in the country.
Keating
is "Suharto accomplice": Horta
Agence France Presse - October
6, 1999
Sydney -- East Timorese resistance
leader Jose Ramos Horta launched a bitter attack on former Australian prime
minister Paul Keating on Tuesday, accusing him of betraying the people
of East Timor.
His attack followed criticism
by Keating of current Prime Minister John Howard, whom he blamed for creating
the East Timorese disaster to gain domestic political advantage and votes.
Keating said Howard had pressed
Indonesian President B.J. Habibie to allow East Timor's self-rule ballot
and the result was 500,000 out of a population of 800,000 were missing
with 60 percent of its buildings destroyed. "This is a complete disaster,"
Keating said.
But in a strong defence of
Howard, Ramos Horta, joint winner of the 1996 Nobel Peace Prize for his
work as international spokesman for the East Timorese, said he found Keating's
words "nauseating."
"He never said a word of
criticism about the brutality during his time," Ramos Horta told ABC radio.
"He has not said a word of condemnation of the killings in East Timor for
the last few months.
"How dare he criticise the
only prime minister in Australia in 23 years who has had the courage to
respond to the appeals to the cries of the people of East Timor."
A succession of Australian
prime ministers, including Keating, have been accused here and overseas
of acquiescing in Indonesia's seizure of East Timor and turning a blind
eye to the deaths of an estimated 200,000 East Timorese people since 1975.
Ramos Horta said the people of East Timor would remember John Howard and
his government as the only government that tried to help them.
"They will remember the likes
of Paul Keating for year after year were an accomplice of the Suharto regime,"
he said. "For 23 years Australia betrayed the people of East Timor, 200,000
died because of Indonesian army's behaviour and the complicity of successive
Australian governments.
"Long before Howard sent
a letter to Habibie, there was pressure from the US Congress, from the
European Union, from people through the region itself to change policy
on East Timor."
Ramos Horta said there was
a cosy relationship between Australia and Indonesia in which they had joint
military exercises, and Australia had provided military and intelligence
training as well as economic aid to the Suharto regime. But while claiming
a special relationship with Indonesia, it was unable to persuade Jakarta
to stop the killings.
He said one single life was
too high a cost for independence, but it would not stop the people of East
Timor fighting or dying for their freedom. "Should the people of East Timor
not vote, renounce all their rights just because the Indonesians might
kill them?.
"Maybe Paul Keating is a
coward, maybe he prefers to surrender to dictators to tyrants, but not
the people of East Timor. I lost three brothers, a sister in this war,
I still do not know where one of my sisters is at the moment. Our house
in Dili was ransacked as well.
"Maybe other families are
like me, but we are still saying we are going to fight, we will fight for
independence, for freedom for our country."
He asked if Australia wanted
a relationship with Indonesia of servility, of subservience to the hardliners,
to Kopassus and to Suharto. "Or do you want a relationship where Australia
can be proud to say: `We stand for human rights'."
Sell-off
to pay for Timor
The Melbourne Age - September
30 1999
Tony Wright, Canberra --
The Federal Government is considering selling billions of dollars worth
of prime defence land throughout Australia to pay for its massively expensive
military commitment to East Timor.
With estimates of Australia's
commitment reaching $2 billion a year, The Age learnt yesterday that Mr
John Fahey's Finance Department is demanding that Mr John Moore's Defence
Department urgently draw up a list of properties that could be put up for
sale.
It is understood the Government
believes up to $16 billion of military properties could be sold outright
or on leaseback arrangements, dramatically reducing the need for the Government
to dig into its Budget surplus to fund the East Timor deployment.
The Prime Minister, Mr John
Howard, admitted yesterday that the East Timor crisis -- and the cost of
helping rebuild the shattered island state -- would have implications for
the Budget, but could not predict how expensive the whole operation could
be.
However, highly reliable
sources said the Government was working frantically behind the scenes to
find revenue that would reduce pressure to make politically damaging reductions
to health, education and welfare spending, or to sacrifice promised tax
cuts. Defence has traditionally resisted pressure to sell large tracts
of its land and buildings, but Finance officials are arguing that it must
accede under present circumstances if it is to receive a funding boost.
Victorian properties being
considered include Victoria Barracks in St Kilda Road, the RAAF's Point
Cook facility, Watsonia Army Barracks at Heidelberg, and military land
at Portsea.
Other training establishments
owned by the Army, Navy and RAAF and disused military land in all states
are in the Finance Department's sights, according to reliable sources.
Prime ocean-front land at
Middle Head in Sydney, in several areas in and around Perth, properties
in Canberra, and sites in Darwin, Queensland and Tasmania are under active
consideration for sale.
The military's move towards
northern Australia has left a wide range of defence properties in the southern
states either under- used or vacant. However, major operational military
bases would be quarantined from sale because of security considerations.
The Defence Housing Authority,
which owns about 20,000 dwellings at 50 different sites around Australia,
is also being targeted for privatisation, although about half its off-base
homes are already in private hands on leaseback terms. The Government wanted
to sell the authority last year, but then Minister for Defence Science
and Personnel, Mrs Bronwyn Bishop, fought successfully against the move.
The authority's market value would be likely to be more than $2 billion.
Both the Finance and Defence
departments were instructed earlier this year to begin a review of defence
property, but Government sources said defence reluctance had meant that
terms of reference had not yet been decided.
However, the East Timor emergency,
coupled with Mr Howard's belief that the defence budget must be increased
from its present $11billion a year, has placed urgent pressure on the process.
About three weeks ago the Government instructed the departments to accelerate
their review, and political pressure has increased substantially since
then.
Mr Howard told Parliament
yesterday that his original estimate of $500 million to send 2000 troops
to East Timor for six months would obviously rise if the deployment continued
longer, and would be higher again if the number of troops rose to the 4500
he has said he would be prepared to commit.
Responding to questions from
the Opposition, he said he had asked the Finance and Defence departments
to provide precise projections on future costs, but the figures were not
yet available. "It is no secret that this troop deployment will cost this
country a lot of money," he said.
Mr Chris Richardson, the
director of the respected economic consulting group Access Economics, predicted
the cost could rise to $2 billion a year. He said the choices for the Government
were to dig into the surplus, risking higher interest rates, cut spending
on health and education, or reduce promised tax cuts.
The Financial Services Minister,
Mr Joe Hockey, told Parliament that, if needed, the Government would dip
into its budget surplus. "And if we have to replenish that surplus spent
on East Timor by budget cuts, expenditure cuts in other areas or other
forms of fiscal change then you will find out about it in due course,"
he said.
Mr Howard told Parliament
that he believed Australia should "contribute a significant amount to East
Timor's future", over and beyond the cost of the military commitment.
"It is hardly reasonable
to support a country's aspiration for freedom and then run away from it
when it has an appalling living standard," he said.
TNI
urges endorsement of Timor vote
Agence France Presse - October
6, 1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- Indonesia's military
on Wednesday urged the country's new national assembly to endorse East
Timor's independence vote and formally free the territory it invaded in
1975.
Police Brigadier General
Taufiequrochman Ruki, reading out the views of the 38-strong parliamentary
faction of military and police MPs said the military favored letting East
Timor go.
"The TNI/Polri (military-police)
faction, herewith proposes that a stand be taken to endorse the result
of the popular consultation," Ruki said.
The general was refering
to the UN-held ballot in East Timor on August 30 which overwhelmingly rejected
an offer of autonomy under Indonesia, opting instead to break away from
the country.
"This decision should of
course, be followed up by handing over the handling of the territory of
East Timor to the United Nations that will lead it to form its own government,"
he said.
The People's Consultative
Assembly (MPR) must take a decision on the ballot because the annexation
of East Timor into Indonesia in 1976 was endorsed by an MPR decree issued
in 1978, he added.
The vote is scheduled to
be taken at a plenary session of the MPR between October 14 and October
20.
Endorsing the result of the
poll would also "release TNI and Polri personnel ... from the dilemma"
of having to accept the ballot result while the territory was still formally
part of Indonesia, Ruki said.
Ruki added the proposal was
made "without any intention to influence the assembly of honorable members
of the MPR on the government policy to hold the popular consultation."
Unpopular
military plays games with blame
Australian Financial Review
- October 6, 1999
Tim Dodd -- General Wiranto
knows who to blame for Indonesia's problems. It's a man in a black dinner
suit with a mobile phone who is secretly directing the host of dark forces
tearing at the unity of the nation.
Wiranto, together with President
B.J. Habibie, presided over the Armed Forces Day ceremonies at the General's
Jakarta headquarters yesterday and, after the formations of troops had
marched and wheeled, this message was delivered to the nation on live television
in a piece of none-to-subtle political theatre.
First came groups of dancers
in spectacular traditional costumes, one group from each of the country's
main ethnic divisions, who performed under the red-and-white national flag.
But this happy reverie was
spoilt by the guy in the dinner suit, a James Bond-style villain, who brought
with him a horde of masked followers dressed in black. To ensure the meaning
was clear, most of them had provokator or gadungan (impostor) written prominently
on their tops.
After receiving orders via
the mobile, they proceeded to accost each ethnic group the Irian Jayans,
the Dayaks, the Bataks, the Balinese and so on tempting them to betray
the national ideals. But, happily, they failed and the performance ended
with patriotic songs as the whole cast, backed by a thousand or so troops,
swayed to the music in a sea of red-and- white.
The military has an interest
in blaming others for what is going wrong in Indonesia, because a large
number of Indonesians are blaming them. The reputation of the military,
the much vaunted people's army which fought the independence war against
the Dutch with high popular support, is at an all-time low.
This week the Indonesian
news magazine Tempo published a poll, which sampled opinion from a diverse
and representative section of the population, on the army's standing. The
results are devastating for Wiranto.
They reveal that Indonesians
want major reform to the army's current pervasive role in the community,
business and government. And far from buying the line that the army is
important to the stability of the nation, many respondents think it is
part of the problem. Since the earliest days of the republic the army has
played a role in politics and business, at first from necessity, but later
because it gave the military a strong power base. And the business role
gave ready access to funds which enhanced both the army budget and the
personal fortunes of its officers.
But the Tempo poll found
that 70 per cent of people are opposed to the army's dwifungsi, or dual
function, in political affairs as well as its core function of maintaining
security. It also found that 66 per cent oppose the system which automatically
awards the army seats in the national and provincial parliaments.
And 61 per cent of people
say they want the army to "return to the barracks", while 80 per cent say
they are worried by the army's close "you scratch my back and I'll scratch
yours" relations with businesses.
The army is also not convincing
people that it is successful at its primary role of guarding the security
and stability of the nation. The poll asked respondents whether the army
is the solution or part of the problem in three of Indonesia's current
trouble spots. In each case, more think it is part of the problem: in Aceh
(where independence sentiment runs high) by a 57 per cent to 9 per cent
margin; in East Timor by a 42 per cent to 18 per cent margin; and in violence-wracked
Ambon by a 34 per cent to 20 per cent margin.
The poll does not test the
popularity of Wiranto himself. But his move to force through a security
law in the dying days of the old Parliament, which updated his emergency
powers, caused huge protests last month. Yesterday students burned him
in effigy in the Javanese city of Bandung.
At the moment, with Indonesia's
highest Parliament about to choose a new president, Wiranto has huge political
influence; his block of votes may be decisive in the October 20 presidential
vote.
This week he has proved that
his parliamentary members are cohesive and opposition contender Megawati
Soekarnoputri, who badly needs support, may be forced to turn to him and
even offer him the vice-presidency in order to win. If he gets the job,
it is likely to spark major demonstrations in many Indonesian cities.
But Wiranto faces numerous
other problems. The United Nations will inquire into the army's human rights
abuses in East Timor and, if it eventually establishes an investigative
tribunal, then army officers, and potentially even Wiranto himself, face
being branded criminals and liable to arrest of they leave the country.
A long-time army foe, Amien
Rais, was this week elected chairman of the highest national Parliament,
the People's Consultative Assembly, which will be amending the constitution
during the coming year. He may not be sympathetic to preserving army privileges.
In a speech on Monday, Wiranto
said that the army had already recognised problems with its dual function
which had "already been corrected at a fundamental level".
But millions of Indonesians
don't agree and they are unlikely to blame the man in the black dinner
suit. More likely they will blame the General.
Subdued
birthday for tainted military
South China Morning Post
- October 5, 1999
Vaudine England -- Indonesia's
military plans a simple celebration of its 54th birthday today, but is
paying little heed to growing unpopularity at home and abroad.
Last year's Army Day involved
intricate performances by a dazzling array of marching bands, including
one group of drummers dressed as frogmen complete with flippers.
This year, several Western
ambassadors, after checking back with their home offices, have chosen not
to attend the events laid on by a military now under investigation by the
United Nations for alleged crimes against humanity.
Today's ceremonies, to be
held at the imposing Cilangkap military headquarters, include an evening
of karaoke where the fabled singing voice of armed forces commander General
Wiranto may once more feature.
"It's important to the army,"
said military analyst Arbi Sanit of Army Day. "But it's not important to
the people of Indonesia at all."
This point may be one which
the military has missed, as recent events have shown how far removed the
military has become from the people it is pledged to protect.
Less than two weeks ago,
a combination of students, local residents, office workers and unemployed
youths engaged in fierce battles against troops on the city's main thoroughfares,
risking their lives in order to vent their contempt and loathing for the
men in uniform.
Less than two days ago, in
the country's highest constitutional body, the Peoples' Consultative Assembly,
the military establishment's candidate for speaker won just 41 votes from
the 700-seat body.
"Considering they were given
38 seats anyway, that's a bad performance," said a political analyst. "It
means they only gathered three seats from the claimed extra dozens they
were supposed to be able to influence."
US
still training Kopassus killers
Boston Globe - October 5,
1999
Terry J. Allen, Vermont --
Quietly tucked away in the hills of Vermont, Norwich University, the only
private military college in the country, has continued to educate and train
future members of the Indonesian army, even as President Clinton has effectively
frozen all relations with that country's military in the wake of the violence
in East Timor.
According to Norwich records,
11 of the school's current crop of 13 Indonesian undergraduates list their
billing address as the Jakarta headquarters of Kopassus, the Army's elite
special forces.
"Kopassus played an especially
brutal role in East Timor," Sidney Jones of Human Rights Watch said. "They
were unquestionably the most feared, most hated, and most abusive of all
Indonesian units in East Timor."
The US government blocked
Indonesians from programs at federally funded military institutions such
as West Point, citing human rights concerns. But Norwich, a private institution,
has continued with its cooperative program, which brings in about $20,000
annually in tuition and fees for each student.
According to Norwich spokesman
Richard Greene, the Indonesian students in the two-year-old cooperative
program were chosen and paid for by the Indonesian Embassy in Washington
with funds wired "by order of the military attache." The undergrads, ostensibly
civilians, are obligated to serve 10 years in the Indonesian army after
graduation.
Thirteen of them are enrolled
in Norwich's Army ROTC program, where they take the standard course that
includes weapons training, intelligence gathering, field training, and
tactics, as well as military ethics.
"The curriculum is dictated
from US Army Cadet Command," said Captain Mike Lefebvre, who teaches ROTC
at Norwich. ROTC instructors are active duty Army officers chosen by the
Pentagon. "The training of these foreign students [at Norwich] came about
from an agreement made between university and the US Army," Lefebvre said.
Ten graduate students, who
returned to service in Indonesia in 1999 after completing master's degrees
in military science and diplomacy, have served as active duty officers.
The worst violence in East
Timor erupted after the island voted for independence from Indonesia on
August 30. Pro-Jakarta militia backed by, and often part of, the Indonesian
army killed hundreds, if not thousands, of civilians. Another 300,000 either
fled the violence or were forcibly repopulated to various islands in the
Indonesian archipelago.
At least four of the Norwich
graduate students served in East Timor around the time of the referendum.
According to an August report from Norwich President Thomas W. Schneider,
the four were "in East Timor serving under the United Nations flag." The
Indonesians, however, could not have been a part of a UN mission, according
to the United Nations. "There is no room for confusion," said Manuel de
Almeida e Silva, deputy spokesman for secretary-general of the UN.
Some Norwich faculty oppose
the university program, including one member who quit in protest in late
1997. "When I resigned my teaching position at Norwich, I believed they
were profoundly misguided. I am very sorry my predictions were true," said
James Chapados, referring to the service of the four Norwich graduates
in East Timor.
Schneider said he has no
plans to end the program and thinks that it performs a valuable service.
The curriculum, he said, includes a heavy dose of military ethics.
"We are not claiming that
[Norwich graduates] will behave humanely when they go back, but what we
do is talk about human rights, civil rights, and give them a new way of
thinking," he said. "We would take Communist students from Red China. What
better way to teach them that their system is screwed up?"
The Indonesian students now
at Norwich did not want to speak with the media, according to Greene.
The Norwich-Indonesia program
was set up after a visit to Jakarta by Norwich officials who met with Major
General Zacky Anwar Makarim and General A.M. Hendropriyono. The generals,
who have been implicated in serious human rights abuses by Human Rights
Watch and have been members of Kopassus, visited the Norwich campus in
fall and winter 1997.
Zacky, as the general is
more commonly known, had been head of BIA Indonesia's national intelligence
body until January and spent a large part of his career in Kopassus, according
to Jane's Intelligence Review, a British military journal. One of the country's
most experienced covert operatives, he is generally believed to have helped
set up and organize the militias in each of East Timor's 13 districts.
Zacky was in charge of Indonesian
army operations in East Timor. After meeting with him in Dili in September,
Senator Tom Harkin, Democrat of Iowa, called for the general's resignation.
"He was very hostile toward the referendum," said an aide to Harkin. "His
troops intimidated people and tried to stop them from going to vote; he
was working with the militias."
The other officer, Hendropriyono,
is nicknamed "The Butcher of Lampung," according to Human Rights Watch.
In 1989, he commanded troops that opened fire on a Muslim school in Lampung
province and massacred an estimated 100 people.
Formerly an officer in Kopassus
and chief of the Jakarta Military Command, Hendropriyono was minister for
transmigration and resettlement until Sept. 27.
In that capacity, he oversaw
the establishment of camps and proposed resettlement of some 200,000 East
Timorese refugees to various Indonesian islands.
Schneider said he did not
know the generals' backgrounds or that the students' billing address was
Kopassus. But, he said, that information would not have deterred him from
accepting the young men. Others might find the links more troubling.
Vermont's Democratic Senator
Patrick Leahy, who has been particularly vociferous in condemning Indonesian
repression, sponsored legislation passed in 1998 that prohibits assistance
or military training to units implicated in human rights abuses. The ban
includes some Kopassus units, Leahy aide Tim Rieser said.
After the postreferendum
violence, the United States also stopped all military cooperation, training,
assistance, and commercial arms sales and pushed the International Monetary
Fund and the World Bank to suspend loans to Indonesia.
With Norwich receiving federal
funds in the form of financial aid and the Indonesian students receiving
military training from US Army officers through ROTC, the program could
be in conflict with US government policy. "One could argue," Rieser said,
"that the US government is subsidizing the training of future Indonesian
soldiers." The Norwich program, "if not strictly illegal," he said, "may
be inconsistent with President Clinton's order ending cooperation with
the Indonesian military."