Democratic
struggle
East
Timor
Aceh/West
Papua
News
& issues
Students
return to parliament to protest
Agence France Presse - September
17, 1999
Jakarta -- Some 2,000 Indonesian
students on Friday converged on the national parliament to protest against
a draft security law and demand a trial of former president Suharto.
Some 1,500 students marched
towards the parliament from the Jayabaya private university in in South
Jakarta about one kilometre southeast of the legislative complex.
But they were held back by
a cordon of fully armed soldiers and riot police units under a flyover
some 200 metres before the parliament.
"Fundamental freedom will
be oppressed with the State security draft bill," one of the posters carried
by the protestors said. Another poster called "Reject the draft bill on
security."
They were shortly after joined
by some 500 students from the Pancasila University and another 200 students
from the City Forum pro-reform student movement.
The students came to protest
the draft bill which many have criticized as being even sterner that an
anti-subversion law which was revoked earlier this year.
Earlier on Friday, a group
of some 50 students from the Alliance for Students and Youths managed to
approach the front gate of the parliament to demand the quick settlement
of the Bank Bali scandal. They were later told to leave by some 30 armed
policemen and they moved to the rear side of the parliamentary complex.
Students
protest against military power
Reuters - September 16, 1999
Surabaya -- Hundreds of Indonesian
students protested in the country's second largest city on Thursday against
a controversial draft security bill which they say would increase the power
of the military.
Some 600 demonstrators gathered
in front of two local government offices in the commercial city of Surabaya,
700 km east of Jakarta.
"For 32 years the military
have been a political power in the new order regime and now they want to
retain their power," said a student identifying himself only as Ucok.
"The enhancement of this
law has to stopped, otherwise we will be the ones rejecting it," he said.
Protesters carried banners calling for a cut in the military's pervasive
presence in Indonesia. "Military out of the economy, society and politics,"
said one sign.
The bill allows the president
to declare a state of emergency in troublespots and delegate authority
to the military which is given enhanced power to handle threats to state
security, including the power to take over all mail and electronic means
of communication.
Opponents of the bill have
said that they are concerned that it would provide a legal framework for
the Indonesian military to clamp down on the press and stifle reform.
Some see the bill as an attempt
by the military to preserve their influence at a time when the once-untouchable
institution is coming under increasing criticism.
The draft bill has caused
an uproar among many pacifists and intellectuals and has provoked a series
of protests over the last month.
Students
wounded in clashes with military
Agence France Presse - September
16, 1999
Jakarta -- Protests erupted
here Wednesday as the UN approved sending troops to East Timor, with security
forces opening fire outside the UN building at students protesting Indonesian
military atrocities.
Across town, however, groups
demonstrating against Australia's involvement in the multinational force
were allowed to picket its embassy and Indonesia's defence ministry without
interference.
At least three were injured
in the protest outside the UN building in downtown Jakarta, and one was
in serious condition with a bullet wound, police and demonstrators said.
Others were injured when
riot police chased them with sticks. Police said only rubber bullets had
been used to fire warning shots.
About 60 protestors had been
trying to march to the defence ministry to protest military "genocide"
in East Timor and the province of Aceh, plagued by separatist unrest. Police
blocked their path and they staged their rally in front of the UN building
instead.
Violence also erupted near
the parliament when the troops ploughed into some 150 student demonstrators
with sticks and their boots after they were pelted with molotov cocktails.
Witnesses said at least three
demonstrators were beaten and kicked by the security forces and seven were
arrested. The rest were chased further away from the parliament building
where they re-grouped.
"One protestor was badly
injured and I took a doctor to the police post where the victim was taken
to," said Gunawan Muhamad, a former chief editor of Indonesia's leading
Tempo weekly magazine. He was later hauled away by police to the Jakarta
police headquarters.
The protesters had marched
from the city's west to within 100 metres of the parliament, where they
were blocked by a human barricade of about 100 police and soldiers.
They were protesting a draft
bill on state security, currently being debated in parliament, which critics
say is no better than the draconian laws brought in under former strongman
Suharto.
Banners reading "Beware of
the military threat" and "The state security bill is intended for a military
coup" were held aloft. But the gathering turned ugly when molotov cocktails
were hurled from the midst of the students, landing near the troops who
ran to extinguish them.
Gunawan said he was unsure
why he was brought to the police post. He said he had addressed the protestors
but only to tell them to disperse. "I do not know whether I am being arrested
or not," he said by telephone from the police headquarters.
Warning shots and teargas
were fired Tuesday as hundreds of students clashed with security forces
at two separate locations in East Jakarta over the same issue, leaving
several injured and at least two cars burned.
Meanwhile, pro-government
demonstrations were staged outside the Australian embassy, the British
embassy and the defence ministry, AFP reporters and television reports
said. At the British embassy some 30 pro-Indonesia East Timorese denounced
Britain for protecting independence leader Xanana Gusmao, who has been
living in the mission since being released from a jail house on September
7.
The protest, during which
they burned the flag of the East Timorese Resistance Council which Gusmao
heads, broke up in chaos when protestors, police and journalists alike
chased provocateurs in the crowd.
A larger group of some 120
pro-Indonesian East Timorese picketed the Australian embassy for several
hours under the watchful eye of police, but there were no major incidents,
an embassy official said. The protestors, who have staged successive rallies
outside the mission, charge Canberra with interference in East Timor.
Television reports said another
group of pro-Indonesian East Timorese, unlike the students, were allowed
to protest outside the defence ministry against Australia's presence in
the peacekeeping force which it will lead.
Ships
sail to East Timor amid new killings
Reuters - September 18, 1999
Lewa Pardomuan, Dili -- Nine
warships of a multinational UN peace force sailed for East Timor on Saturday
and the force commander was expected to hold talks with the Indonesian
military in the shattered territory on Sunday.
The European Commission said
up to 200 people might have been killed on Friday in a continuation of
the blood-letting which has swept the territory since it voted for independence
from Indonesia.
Timorese independence leader
Xanana Gusmao on Saturday left Jakarta and was believed to be heading for
Darwin, northern Australia. The Portuguese news agency Lusa quoted a Timorese
resistance source as saying Gusmao was likely to attend a meeting of Timorese
resistance officials in Darwin.
East Timor's devastated capital
Dili was quiet on Saturday, a source with the International Committee of
the Red Cross said. Gunfire could still be heard overnight and fires seen
in hills around the city, where military sources say 30,000 pro- independence
refugees are sheltering.
UN force commander Australian
Major-General Peter Cosgrove and his 13-member advance team were due to
arrive in Dili at 1pm on Sunday and stay for three hours, the Indonesian
commander in Dili said.
Cosgrove's visit is expected
to be followed by the deployment of the International Force for East Timor
(Interfet) troops, spearheaded by some 2,000 Australians and 250 Gurkhas
of the British army.
The full UN deployment is
expected in about two days. Troops will arrive by air and sea from Darwin.
A total of about 8,000 personnel from around the world are expected to
eventually join the mission.
Ten tonnes of emergency food
rations were dropped to refugees in East Timor on Saturday, Australian
aid agency Ausaid said. Clearance was received for two flights on Monday
to make drops from high altitude, distributing food over a wider area,
a World Food Programme spokeswoman said.
UN Assistance Mission in
East Timor (UNAMET) spokesman David Wimhurst said "massive amounts" of
additional aid were needed for the hundreds of thousands of refugees believed
to have fled violence by pro-Indonesia militias in recent weeks.
The anti-independence militias
have threatened to attack the international force. Across Indonesia, tens
of thousands of Moslems have signed up for a holy war against UN-backed
forces, religious leaders said.
Heads of Indonesia's largest
Moslem mass organisation in East Java province said they were prepared
for such a "jihad". "The call for jihad against foreign intervention in
East Timor should be understood as a spontaneous heroism," said Hasyim
Muzadi, head of the Nadhlatul Ulama in East Java. "The anger of Indonesian
people is not only directed at Australia, but also especially at the United
States." East Timor independence leader Gusmao said in a BBC interview
on Saturday he feared rogue elements of the Indonesian military might attack
peacekeepers.
Refugees
returning to charred homes
South China Morning Post
- September 18, 1999
Joanna Jolly in Darwin and
Irwan Firdaus of Associated Press in Baucau -- As international troops
prepare to go into East Timor, fearful refugees are coming down from the
mountains in the territory and returning to homes still smouldering and
in ruins.
When the peacekeepers arrive
in East Timor they will find a hostile, difficult terrain still largely
in the control of pro- autonomy militia despite a heavy presence of Indonesian
soldiers (TNI).
Witness reports from Dili
yesterday said although the situation was calmer than a few days ago, with
less shooting heard on the streets, militia were still in evidence in the
capital.
But they appeared to be involved
in an organised operation to remove as much looted property as they could
from the territory before the deployment of the international force.
"Militia appear to be moving
out of town with cargo," said a member of the 12-member United Nations
Assistance Mission in East Timor (Unamet) team still operating in Dili.
"There are fewer gangs of
militia. A lot are protecting cargo trucks and coming back to reload."
The Unamet team was able to carry out a patrol through the city yesterday
and check on the situation of refugees sheltering at the dock. They reported
that there were still several fires burning and shots being fired, but
there was a decrease in violent activity.
Unamet reported yesterday
that TNI was patrolling the streets to secure areas of Dili. "They are
working professionally and appear to be doing proper patrol formations,"
the Unamet staff member said.
East Timor's second-largest
town, Bacau, has begun showing signs of life again. Vendors squatted on
the street outside the gutted market to sell vegetables, fruit and cigarettes.
"No one thought it would
happen like this," said Bishop Basilio da Nascimento, still stunned at
the violence that followed East Timor's vote for independence. Hundreds
of Indonesian troops were flown out yesterday in advance of the arrival
of an Australia-led international peacekeeping force.
But enough troops remained
behind to maintain order in Baucau, 200km east of Dili. Knots of soldiers
were posted every few hundred metres along Baucau's main road. New units
replaced soldiers implicated in the unrest, helping restore confidence
among townspeople.
"I have stopped the firing
by everybody, including the police, militia and ordinary people, and now
the situation is calm," said Colonel Irwan Kusnadi, the operations commander
for Baucau.
Soldiers,
militiamen, laying mines in Dili
Agence France Presse - September
17, 1999
Lisbon -- Indonesian soldiers
and militiamen are laying mines in Dili, the capital of East Timor, as
they stream out of the province ahead of the arrival of a multinational
peace force, a resistance leader told Portuguese radio Friday.
Leandro Isaac, a leader of
the Timoran Resistance National Council, warned the Australian-led force
to be careful. He told Lisbon's TSF radio station by telephone from a mountain
hideout close to Dili that the soldiers were laying the mines before leaving.
In a separate interview with
the Portuguese news agency Lusa, Isaac said the soldiers and militiamen
were moving south toward Dare, where tens of thousands of displaced civilians
have taken shelter. "They are firing rifles and submachine-guns continuously,
advancing rapidly towards the displaced persons," he said.
Refugees
dumped in shark-infested waters
Lusa - September 15, 1999
Macau -- A former pro-Jakarta
militiaman has claimed that Indonesian forces eliminated more than 2,000
East Timorese by dumping them in waters off the East Timor coast.
Contacted by the newspaper
"Macau Hoje", Francisco Domingues said he "accompanied Indonesian marines
transporting 120 East Timorese in a front-loading military craft". The
passengers were thrown into shark-infested waters near the coast town of
Batugade, he stated.
Domingues told the Macau
daily that he escaped to Indonesian West Timor because he "couldn't take
another such cargo" of East Timorese. "Six vessels were taking men out
to the sea: two in Batugade, two in Baucau and two in Manatuto", he added.
Revealed:
the plot to crush Timor
South China Morning Post
- September 16, 1999
Anne-Marie Evans, Macau --
The political cleansing of East Timor was planned as early as February,
one of the militia leaders present at a meeting which hatched the deadly
plot has revealed. Tomas Goncalves, 54, the former head of the 400-strong
PPPI (Peace Force and Defender of Integration) militia said the killings
had been agreed at a meeting on February 16 in the East Timorese capital,
Dili. He said the talks were organised by the head of the SGI, the secret
intelligence organisation of the military's Kopassus special forces.
The head, Lieutenant-Colonel
Yahyat Sudrajad, called for the killing of pro-independence movement leaders,
their children and even their grandchildren, Mr Goncalves said. Not a single
member of their families was to be left alive, the colonel told the meeting.
Mr Goncalves said that also
present were the heads of other militias covering the 12 regions of East
Timor, including Eurico Guterres, of the Aitarak militia, and Joao Tavares
of Besi Merah Putih.
According to Mr Goncalves,
the colonel said many soldiers had died in East Timor and that it would
be difficult for troops to leave the enclave because if they did, they
would lose face. They were determined not to abandon their supporters in
the territory.
The meeting came after President
Bacharuddin Habibie announced on January 27 that he might consider independence
for East Timor.
On February 11, a day after
resistance leader Xanana Gusmao was moved from jail to house arrest, Mr
Habibie said East Timor's future could be decided by the end of the year.
Mr Goncalves said: "The agenda for the meeting included funding and arming
of the militias, food and other supplies."
His revelations leave no
doubt about the connection between Jakarta and the militias, or about the
direct line of command.
Mr Goncalves said Colonel
Sudrajad had received orders before the meeting from regional military
commander Colonel Tono Suratman, who was answerable to General Adam Daimiri
in command of Bali, East Timor and West Timor. General Daimiri in turn
answered to General Zacky Anwar in Jakarta, himself the former head of
Kabia, Indonesia's national intelligence body.
The meeting set the hour
for the start of the political cleansing as midnight on May 1. However,
on February 17, the following day, the militias began to kill throughout
East Timor, launching attacks in Maliana, Atabai, Kailako and elsewhere.
The survivors fled to churches and priests' houses for protection.
On March 26, Governor of
East Timor Abilio Soares gave orders at a meeting, again attended by Mr
Goncalves, that the priests and nuns should be killed.
Mr Goncalves said: "I could
not stand it. I told them I have no problem fighting the [pro-independence]
guerillas, but as a Catholic I could not kill priests and nuns and attack
the Church." Because of his stand, Mr Goncalves came under suspicion. He
fled Jakarta on April 18 and is now in Macau.
Violence worsened dramatically
in East Timor after the result of the UN-organised ballot was announced
on September 4, showing support for independence. Hundreds, possibly thousands
of people were killed by the militias, encouraged or helped by troops.
Government and military spokesmen were unavailable for comment last night.
Agent
reveals reconciliation 'charade'
South China Morning Post
- September 16, 1999
Anne-Marie Evans, Macau --
Rui Lopes could count former president Suharto's son-in-law, Prabowo Subianto,
and General Gleny in Jakarta among his closest friends.
They have been fighting and
working together since the Indonesian invasion of East Timor. Since 1985,
Mr Lopes, 47, had also been working for Xanana Gusmao's resistance guerillas.
Yesterday he revealed the
extent of the Indonesian military's plans for the political cleansing of
East Timor, and for the arrival of foreign peacekeepers.
While "reconciliation" meetings
were being organised throughout East Timor this spring between pro-Jakarta
militia chiefs and bishops and pro-independence leaders, a massive military
build-up was taking place over the border, the East Timorese agent said
in Macau.
At least 20 battalions --
a total of 15,000 soldiers -- were stationed in West Timor by June. Some
were in Tamrasi and had a secret base in a mountain called Laser, which
the Australian military had also used as a clandestine refuge during World
War II. The Indonesian military brought in a sophisticated radar from Bandung,
West Java, that could track ships in the South Sea.
Marines and tanks were taken
to the Indonesian island of Kisar, off the eastern tip of East Timor. These
had now been driven up through Lospalos in East Timor, Mr Lopes said. "They
prepared all this," he said, "because they knew the Australians would intervene."
A strategic triangle was
set up. There were bases at Balibo on the West Timor border; Kupang, the
West Timor capital, would be used for the refugees coming in after the
cleansing; and military training was carried out in Atambua, just inside
West Timor. Troops would go to the border at night to spy, dressed as civilians.
Mr Lopes was president of
a pro-autonomy campaign based in Suai, East Timor. He was trusted enough
to attend an annual meeting in Austria organised by the United Nations
to bring about reconciliation between the two sides. Mr Lopes arrived in
Macau on Saturday after fleeing Jakarta.
Crimes
against humanity evidence
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
- September 15, 1999
Compere: Which brings us
to the war crimes issue more generally. And fresh evidence is emerging
of the Indonesian military's complicity in the crimes against humanity
in East Timor. The Senate Committee on East Timor heard first-hand accounts
today of TNI links with the militias that rampaged through the country
before and after the referendum. Karon Snowdon reports:
Karon Snowdon: There's an
urgency to collect credible eye witness accounts of the atrocities which
took place in East Timor and to identify who was directly responsible.
The Senate Committee heard today from Garry Wood, a former member of the
Australian Federal Police and now a consultant to UNAMET. His account of
the siege of a Dili hotel confirms what we already know of the blind eye
turned on militia activity by the Indonesian forces.
Garry Wood: I stood on the
roof and I saw at different stages militia come in around four separate
cordons of some hundreds of police and military from four different levels
of command come in and shoot at the building and have people run around
that building with machetes. I can only say that it had to have been orchestrated.
Karon Snowdon: And a report
from BBC correspondent, Humphrey Hawkesley, printed in London's Independent
Newspaper, claims officials in West Timor say they were ordered to set
up camps to handle thousands of people at least four days ahead of East
Timor's referendum. From just how high up the chain of command the orders
came will be up to the proposed International War Crimes Tribunal to prove.
Opposition spokesperson on
Foreign Affairs, Laurie Brereton, says Australia must hand over its military
intelligence which he claims will prove the links to the highest Indonesian
command.
Laurie Brereton: Australia
will have all of -- a great deal of detailed knowledge, just as NATO had
an enormous amount of knowledge of the atrocities committed in the former
republic of Yugoslavia.
Karon Snowdon: When asked
on last night's 7.30 Report whether he supported the UN's determination
to establish a War Crimes Tribunal for East Timor, Prime Minister, John
Howard, was cautious.
John Howard: Well, look,
I support any of the UN processes but, I mean, my main focus at the moment
is the more immediate one of getting people in as quickly as possible,
because as soon as that occurs, you automatically reduce the possibility
of further things being done.
Karon Snowdon: Colonel Bob
Lowry from the Australian Defence Study Centre agrees the timing is the
thing.
Bob Lowry: There are some
risks in the short-term. That's what we've got to be careful of, that it
doesn't impede the process of getting the UN force on the ground and the
co-operation between the Indonesian troops and the UN force in the first
instance, and that it doesn't give ammunition to the hawks in Jakarta to
maybe try and forestall the transition to democracy or indeed to mount
a coup.
Karon Snowdon: But another
view holds that Australia would be reluctant to hand over any intelligence.
Lecturer in International Relations at Deakin University, Scott Burchell,
believes the diplomatic cost to Australia would be considered too high.
I asked him what military intelligence Laurie Brereton was hinting at.
Scott Burchell: I would imagine
it would be phone calls that have been recorded, intercepted and recorded.
Karon Snowdon: Australia
routinely collects or listens to Indonesian phone calls?
Scott Burchell: Absolutely,
particularly as far as foreign and defence intelligence sources is concerned.
Australia keeps a very close ear on all military conversations that are
taking place between Jakarta and its deployment in East Timor.
Karon Snowdon: And you think
that would be the evidence that would be needed?
Scott Burchell: Well, that
would be crucial in providing enough information to indict someone as senior
as General Wiranto.
Karon Snowdon: How much guess
work on your part is involved in assuming that this intelligence would
reveal those links?
Scott Burchell: Not very
much. We've already had leaks from the Defence Intelligence Organisation
earlier this year which clearly stated that Australian intelligence sources
were aware that the militias were being orchestrated from senior levels
of the TNI, right up to and including General Wiranto.
Western
districts off limits to UN
Agence France Presse - September
16, 1999
Jakarta -- The deputy commander
of East Timor's pro-Indonesia militia has warned that the militia will
put eight of the territory's 13 districts off limits to multinational troops,
a report said Thursday.
Deputy Commander Eurico Guterres
said that the militia will offer an agenda to the multinational forces
of the United Nations dictating what it has to do, the Antara news agency
said.
"I will propse an agenda
to the peacekeeping force about what has to be done. If they don't want
to go along [with the agenda], I will demark the boundaryline, which region
can be managed by the UN peacekeeping forces and which regions they cannot,"
Guterres said in Kupang, West Timor.
He claimed that the militias
controlled eight districts in the western part of East Timor and that the
United Nations could manage the remaining five in the east.
The western districts are
the agriculturally-productive regions while the east is mostly arid and
dry land. Guterres had already aired a plan to divide East Timor into two,
saying that the pro- Indonesians would not leave their alleged strongholds.
Antara quoted Guterres as
saying that the militias, as native East Timorese, had more rights over
the territory than the UN peacekieeping forces. He also expressed worries
that the presence of the multinational force would worsen, rather than
improve the situation in East Timor.
Guterres heads the Dili-based
Aitarak militia which has been balmed for the widespread destruction of
the East Timorese capital, the killings and burning as well as the forced
trucking of East Timorese to neighbouring West Timor.
The United Nations Wednesday
approved a multinational force for East Timor, under the leadership of
Australia, with a broad mandate to take every measure to halt the violence
and get vital aid to thousands of starving refugees.
Ministry
gave media training to militia
Agence France Presse - September
15, 1999
Hong Kong -- The Indonesian
foreign ministry organized and paid for leaders of the pro-Indonesian militia
in East Timor to be trained in public relations ahead of the recent election,
the Far Eastern Economic Review said Wednesday.
It cites ministry officials
as saying privately that at least two seminars on public and media relations
were organized by the Indonesian government ahead of the August 30 independence
referendum.
The seminars, held in Bali,
included coaching on how to field awkward questions from the foreign media,
the Review said. "They were said to cost the Indonesian government about
500 million rupiah," the weekly said in a statement.
Speakers at the seminars
included senior government officials, military officers and leaders of
the pro-Indonesia militias that have since been accused by humanitarian
organizations of playing a major role in the violence in East Timor.
"At one seminar, according
to the ministry officials, General Adam Daimiri, the senior military officer
for East Timor at the time, told the militias that Indonesia 'was behind
them 100 percent and would never abandon them,'" the Review said. Asked
by the Review about the seminars, a foreign ministry official said no assistance
was given to the militias by the ministry but that it had close relations
with them.
Refugees
hunted throughout Indonesia
Agence France Presse - September
16, 1999
Sydney -- Pro-Jakarta militia
are harassing East Timorese refugees throughout the eastern islands of
Indonesia, an Australian aid agency said Thursday.
Janet Hunt, executive director
of the Australian Council for Overseas Aid (ACFOA), said the situation
was dangerous in Flores, Lombok and Bali -- a popular holiday spot.
"There are militias in those
places," she told reporters. "They have [death] lists and they are seeking
these people [refugees]. The people who are in hiding are on the move,
mainly. They are not staying in the same house or hotel two nights."
Hunt urged the UN High Commission
for Refugees (UNHCR) to open an office in Bali. "We are asking the UNHCR
to establish an office in Bali so that those who have already left Kupang
[in West Timor] can have access to help," she said.
She claimed the militia had
lists of particular people that they wanted to see dead. "They are also
targeting some of the religious people, some of the brothers, sisters and
priests, who have come out with the Timorese," she said. "It is getting
increasingly difficult." ACFOA is an umbrella group of Australian aid agencies.
Dita
Sari discusses East Timor
Tapol - September 14, 1999
[Dita Sari, the workers
leader who was released from prison in July this year after serving three
years of a five-year sentence, is now in the UK at the invitation of the
TUC. She gave this interview to Tapol before departing for Brighton yesterday.]
Q. What was the impact in
Indonesia of the result of the referendum in East Timor?
A. The 78.5 percent vote
in favour of independence came as a great shock, something quite unbelievable.
Many people were very angry when the results were announced. They found
it very difficult to accept that the East Timorese want to leave the Republic,
and they directed their anger against Habibie for having given them the
option to decide.
Very few people in Indonesia
support the idea of independence for East Timor. In the first days after
the result was announced, even some NGOs that are members of the solidarity
organisation Solidamor could not bring themselves to support the result
and did not want to take any action. But this is what my party, the PRD,
did.
We went to the UN office
in Jakarta to deliver a statement making three points: we supported the
results of the referendum, we called for the withdrawal of Indonesian troops
from East Timor and we called for intervention by an international peace-keeping
force.
The referendum result provoke
a lot of nationalistic sentiments and there were protest demonstrations
outside the Australian embassy against Australian intervention on the question
of East Timor.
Q. What has been the response
of the political parties?
A. Like many other parties,
Megawati's party, the PDI-P, has used the referendum result to attack Habibie
as part of her efforts to defeat him in the contest for the presidency
later this year. She has accused Habibie of acting unlawfully for allowing
the East Timor people to choose and said this should not have happened
before the meeting of the newly-elected MPR which takes place later this
year.
As for Gus Dur who leads
the Nahdlatul Ulama, his first response was to accuse UNAMET of being unfair
and he said that the results had been rigged. But after a few days, his
position shifted somewhat.
Q. What was it that brought
about this shift?
A. There has been as gradual
shift in public perceptions. The Indonesian press has reported in great
detail on the international reaction to the events of the past ten days.
East Timor has been frontpage news in all the newspapers every day with
many reports about international outrage at what has been happening and
this has helped to bring about a shift in public perceptions about East
Timor.
Press reporting has played
a significant role in breaking up old prejudices about how well Indonesia
has treated East Timor. People are beginning to see the question in a different
light. Statements made by President Clinton condemning the situation in
East Timor have also had a powerful impact on public opinion.
I have to say that the Indonesian
press has played a very good role in informing people. Some Indonesian
journalists put their own lives at risk to follow events in East Timor,
although they were eventually forced to leave the country.
A few days ago, Kompas published
an editorial commenting on the threat of economic sanctions because of
the situation in East Timor. It said that when considering our attitude
towards East Timor, we must also consider its impact on other political
issues such as economic stability. This has also helped to bring about
a shift in attitudes. Kompas is the largest circulation paper in the country
and it is widely read so its views are important in molding public opinion.
Q. Have any of the major
parties seen this as an issue of the right of the people of East Timor
to self-determination?
A. No. Although they say
that they will accept the result, this is only because there was a majority
in favour of independence. It has nothing to do with East Timor's right
to self- determination. East Timor is being used as a political football
in moves by people to get rid of Habibie later this year.
Q. Dont people see any similarity
between East Timor's struggle for independence and Indonesia's struggle
against the Dutch in the 1940s?
A. No, not really. For years,
the Indonesian people have been told that in 1975, East Timor was in danger
of falling into the clutches of the communists. They were also led to believe
that Indonesia was in East Timor because the East Timorese asked to be
integrated into Indonesia. This distortion of history is still very strongly
embedded in the minds of most people.
Q. Has the news from East
Timor helped in any way to strengthen opposition to the armed forces and
its dwi-fungsi ideology?
A. I don't think so. Of course,
there is a great deal of anger towards the armed forces. It is clear to
everyone that they are incapable of handling situations of unrest anywhere
in the country, such as Ambon, Aceh, West Kalimantan or anywhere else.
But in the case of East Timor,
people see this as involving the loss of part of Indonesia's territory
and blame Habibie for suggesting that a referendum should be held. It's
all his fault. They are not blaming the armed forces.
Q. What has been Wiranto's
role in instigating the campaign of violence by the army-backed militias?
A. He has been in charge
all along. He knows all about the arming and training of the militias.
There's no doubt about that. But the problem is that their activities are
now totally out of control. His hopes of imposing some kind of discipline
on the operations have been futile. The main target of these operations
was supposed to be the CNRT but things went beyond that, doing absolutely
crazy things like attacking Bishop Belo.
Then he thought that he could
bring things under control by imposing martial law but that hasn't worked
either.
Q. Habibie has just announced
that Indonesia will allow an international peace-keeping force into East
Timor. How does this reflect on Habibie and Wiranto?
A. I think that this was
an easy decision for Habibie to take, but it is very humiliating for Wiranto
and the armed forces.
Q. And why do you think that
there has been a campaign of such widespread killing and destruction in
East Timor since the result of the referendum became known?
A. The pro-Jakarta militias
and their supporters decided to take revenge on the people of East Timor.
Their logic is: we are going to lose East Timor so we want to make sure
that you won't get anything either.
Euro-MPs
demand recognition of Timor
Agence France Presse - September
16, 1999
Strasbourg -- Deputies at
the European parliament on Thursday passed a resolution demanding that
the European Union (EU) and its member states recognise an independent
East Timor.
The parliament "recognises
the freely and democratically expressed will of the people of East Timor
to be independent and to create their own country," the resolution said
of the restive Indonesian province.
The MEPs also condemned the
"massacres committed by pro- Indonesian militias with the complicity of
the Indonesian police and army" since East Timor residents vote overwhelmingly
for independence in a UN-sponsored referendum August 30. The resolution
called on the United Nations to draw up a full list of atrocities that
have been committed in East Timor, and expressed support for the suggestion
by UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson to set up an ad
hoc international tribunal.
The UN Security Council voted
early Wednesday to send a multinational peacekeeping force to restore security
to East Timor.
Belo's
aide implicates top general
Sydney Morning Herald - September
17, 1999
Philip Cornford -- An assistant
to East Timor's spiritual leader, Bishop Carlos Belo, claimed yesterday
that he saw the Indonesian intelligence official Major-General Syafrie
Syamsuddin direct the separation of boys and men from refugees forced from
Bishop Belo's home 11 days ago.
Mr Francisco Kalbuadi, chairman
of the Bishop Belo Foundation, said he was present when Indonesian soldiers
arrested Bishop Belo 11 days ago and fired on 5,000 refugees who had sought
sanctuary in the grounds of the bishop's home in Dili.
Bishop Belo was eventually
allowed to fly to Darwin, but the women and children who had sheltered
at his home were transported to West Timor, where Mr Kalbuadi said they
were being held as hostages.
Speaking in Sydney yesterday,
Mr Kalbuadi said the operation was commanded by General Syamsuddin, "who
I know personally and who I saw standing in the street outside the compound,
giving orders". He had seen a baby and an old woman killed by bullets.
"Many others were shot."
He escaped when General Syamsuddin
ordered that men and boys of military age be separated from the women and
children. "I knew that meant the men were going to be killed," Mr Kalbuadi
said. Later, when he escaped to West Timor, the women refugees said the
males taken from Bishop Belo's home had disappeared. "General Syamsuddin
is responsible for their fate," he said. "It is certain they were murdered."
Mr Kalbuadi said he escaped
after a militia leader risked his life by handing over his jacket in the
pro-Indonesian colours of red and white.
Dennis Schulz reports from
Darwin: Refugees evacuated from Dili gave further details yesterday of
mass murders by the Indonesian military. Joao Brito, 15, recounted through
an interpreter the murder of perhaps hundreds of people in Ermera on September
4, the day the autonomy ballot results were announced.
An hour after the announcement
two trucks full of Kopassus special forces arrived in Ermera, a stronghold
of the Aitarak militia, dressed in black Aitarak T-shirts. The soldiers,
armed with automatic weapons and cans of petrol, had targeted known pro-independence
supporters.
"They called house to house
and they burnt out the political leaders," Joao said. "When the houses
burn, they let the women and children out, but they push the men back into
the fire, where they die."
Joao said the rampaging group
marched through the town burning and shooting people and slashing them
with machetes. During the slaughter, the killers had openly shown the delight
with their work, he said. "They say, `You dogs. You do not have the right
to independence'."
Joao and nine others were
rescued by nearby pro-independence Falintil guerillas, who were alerted
when smoke began to rise from the town.
[In a September 17 report
in the South China Morning Post, Kalbuadi also named two other officers
as being responsible for the terror, former military intelligence chief
Zacky Anwar and Brigadier-General Glenn Kairupan as being responsible for
the terror - James Balowski.]
Fears
that Darwin refugees infiltrated
The Melbourne Age - September
16, 1999
Bernard Lagan, Darwin --
Two suspected East Timorese militia members and a suspected Indonesian
soldier are being held by Australian authorities after infiltrating the
UN compound in Dili and being flown by the RAAF with 1400 refugees to Darwin.
The men were plucked from
the East Timorese reception centre on the outskirts of Darwin early yesterday
after some refugees told staff the men would be killed in Darwin.
They were taken away by Northern
Territory police to an undisclosed location and were last night still being
interviewed by police and Australian immigration officials. A spokeswoman
for the Northern Territory Police said two of the men had been identified
by refugees in Darwin as members of the notorious Aitarak militia, held
responsible in East Timor for scores of killings and attacks upon pro-Independence
East Timorese.
The UNAMET spokesman, Mr
David Wimhurst, said in Darwin yesterday that the three men were believed
to have infiltrated the UN compound in Dili where about 1400 refugees were
sheltering from militias and the Indonesian army.
When the refugees were transported
to Darwin in Tuesday's dawn RAAF airlift, the suspected militias and the
soldier were included. Their presence was drawn to the attention of East
Timorese social workers working with the refugees after they arrived in
Darwin.
"They have been isolated
and they are being held separately by the authorities in a safe location,"
Mr Wimhurst said. "The allegations that two are militia are being investigated,"
he said. "This is now entirely in the hands of Australian authorities.
If they are indeed members of the militia, it's very possible they infiltrated
the UN compound in Dili and were carried out with the rest of the refugees."
Mr Wimhurst said it would
have been too difficult to conduct screening checks on the refugees before
the airlift to Darwin.
UN officials said later yesterday
that the two men identified as militia were behaving aggressively towards
Australian authorities who were attempting to establish their identities.
The third man, identified
as an Indonesian army soldier, was with a family group of 10 who had been
in the compound. Members of the alleged soldier's family have also been
removed from the main body of refugees because of fears for their safety.
Refugees in the Darwin centre
said last night that one of those suspected as a militia member was a high-ranked
deputy commander in the Aitarak militia, known in Dili as "Elvis".
A refugee spokesman, Mr Sebastico
Guterres, said last night he hoped refugees in Darwin would act with restraint
against the three men if they were freed.
Militias
now fear Indonesian troops
Sydney Morning Herald - September
16, 1999
Dennis Schulz and Louise
Williams -- Pro-Indonesian militias are fleeing East Timor ahead of the
arrival of peacekeepers, some saying they fear they will now be killed
by Indonesian troops to wipe out evidence of Jakarta's leading role in
the carnage.
Refugees in Darwin and church
sources working in West Timor, where about 130,000 refugees have been forced
into militia- controlled camps, reported new fears that Indonesian troops
would kill militia members themselves, after using the thugs to kill independence
supporters, priests, nuns and civilians.
"The Indonesian Army wants
to exterminate the militia because they want to take away all trace," said
a refugee from Dili, Mr Alberto Fernandes Belo, who is now in Darwin.
"The militia know about the
Indonesians' plans to kill and burn [following the victory for independence
supporters in the United Nations vote]. That's why they want to finish
the militia."
Mr Belo was one of thousands
who had fled to Dare in the hills outside Dili, before returning to join
evacuees who arrived in Darwin yesterday. He said militia members now feared
for their lives and sought shelter from the refugees.
"The people accept the militia,"
he said. "If they come with guns, they disarm them. Then they console them.
They will face justice in the future."
The reports were backed up
by a UN official still in Dili who said the militia appeared to be preparing
to pull out of Dili. "There are still some militia people on the streets
with weapons, but generally they seem to be preparing to move out," said
Mr Colin Stewart, one of 12 UN staff remaining after Tuesday's evacuation
of the UN headquarters in the city.
From West Timor, church sources
reported militias crossing the border had spoken of fears of being exterminated
as Indonesia came under increasing international pressure over human rights
abuses in East Timor. However, others said the militia would continue to
be used as a frontline force to "take the bullets" in any engagements with
peacekeepers.
"We know that an increasing
number of militias are crossing over from East Timor into West Timor ahead
of the peacekeeping force and now there are anywhere between 8,000 to 14,000
armed militias in West Timor," said the source.
The militia gangs are virtually
in control of the provincial capital, Kupang, where locals say they have
taken over restaurants, demanding free food, and forcing shop owners and
even petrol stations to hand over goods and petrol free. With the clear
failure of the Indonesian military's plan to use the militias to intimidate
the East Timorese into voting against independence, Jakarta faces a serious
problem over what to do with the thugs.
According to one Kupang resident,
resentment was rising to the point that local youths may be used to kill
off the militias in West Timor.
In Darwin, the refugees told
how Indonesian troops used the militias to force the mass relocation of
thousands of East Timorese to Atambua in West Timor, then told the militias
they must also leave or die.
"The militia are finished
now in East Timor. Only the army are left. The army will kill the militia,"
said Mr Carlos Mendoza, 19, of Dili.
Interview
with Alan Narn in Dili
National Public Radio - September
15, 199
One of the few journalists
remaining in East Timor is Allan Nairn, Who writes for The Nation. We caught
up with him in Dili today and asked him about the reaction there to news
of an international peacekeeping mission.
Mr. Allan Nairn (Writer,
The Nation): People's main worry in Dili is that the terrors be brought
to an end. The militias, which are controlled by the Indonesian army, were
still on the streets today. Before sundown, you could see houses burning,
public buildings being set on fire. Bodies are now being left in the streets
of Dili and they're decomposing. I think some hope that maybe peacekeepers
will do it. In my view, General Wiranto, the Indonesian military commander,
can stop the terror in a moment if he gives the command because these militias
are clearly an arm of the Indonesian military. They're under his tight
control.
Siegel: When you say that
there are houses still burning or public buildings still burning, what,
if any, is the pattern to the targets of this sort of violence? Which houses,
which public buildings?
Mr. Nairn: Well, a few days
ago, I was able to go out on the streets as the Aitarak militia was running
wild and I kind ducked from one abandoned house to another. And you could
see that this wasn't a general arson. This was very selective torching.
The houses that are being burned are those of prominent independence activists
and organizers. And the public buildings are stores, warehouses, the mainstays
of daily life and economy. They even went so far as to invade the headquarters
of the ICRC -- International Committee of the Red Cross -- lead some of
the staff members out at gunpoint, take away some of the refugees hiding
there to a fate that's still unknown and burn down the ICRC headquarters.
And then they moved down the road and did the same with the home of Bishop
Belo, the Nobel peace laureate.
Siegel: And there have been
many reports reaching the West of violence targeted against church men
and women. Why is -- apart from the archbishop himself, why are Catholic
clergy a target of violence of these militias?
Mr. Nairn: Well, I think
the military is sending a message to the Timorese that all taboos can now
be broken, that there are no more limits. Now in this final phase, when
it's clear that the Indonesian army is going to eventually have to withdraw
from Timor, as a parting shot they are going after the church. Just yesterday
I was told by a nun about the attack on the Convent of the Canosian Sisters
in which, lined up outside the convent, they saw a uniformed Aitarak militia,
a uniformed bree(ph) mob, which are the US-trained police commandos, and
uniformed army infantry. And they then went in, took away the refugees
and torched the convent. They're just sending the Timorese the message:
You have no place left to hide. Our terror is total.
Siegel: You are speaking
to us from Dili despite a ban -- not just a general ban, but, I gather,
a specific ban on your presence in East Timor. Is that correct?
Mr. Nairn: Yes.
Siegel: And if so, are you
concerned for your safety or for our life right now?
Mr. Nairn: Well, I'm probably
one of the safer people in Timor. Everyone of the Timorese is in a lot
more trouble than I am. I have been banned from Indonesia and occupied
Timor since 1991, since after the Dili massacre. When I was in Indonesia
this time before coming into Timor, apparently military intelligence was
after me. And a foreign diplomat told me last week that the militias were
looking for me. But, you know, they haven't caught me, but they've caught
many East Timorese. They're the ones who have the real fear for their lives
here.
Siegel: But they seem to
have persuaded a lot of Western journalists to get out of Timor, a lot
of Eastern journalists as well.
Mr. Nairn: Well, that's true,
and that's a very important point. This has been a very sophisticated operation,
this army militia operation. It shows a lot of forethought and coordination.
And some of it has just been naked violence against the Timorese, but another
part of this has been what could be called a psychological operation against
foreigners. For example, the Mahkota Hotel, where many of the journalists
were staying during the election period, was -- right after the election
results were announced, the Aitarak went in, they went up on the roof of
the hotel, they were shooting. They and the army surrounded the hotel outside.
They were shooting in the air. They weren't actually shooting at any of
the journalists, but it sure frightened them.
And they did the same thing
around the UN compound. Up until a few nights ago, they were just firing
off thousands and thousands of rounds into the air every night, automatic
rifle, machine guns, they were throwing grenades into the air. I mean,
it was a terrifying non-stop barrage. But, again, you know, the bullets
weren't being fired into the compound by and large and the grenades weren't
coming over the fence. It was just meant to frighten. And I think they
really did succeed in rattling, you know, a lot of the UN people and a
lot of the foreign journalists. But for Timorese, you know, this is daily
life.
Siegel: Mr. Nairn, thank
you very much for talking with us today.
Mr. Nairn: You're welcome.
Siegel: Reporter Allan Nairn
on the line from Dili, East Timor.
Little
hope for the best in plan for the worst
Sydney Morning Herald --
September 15, 1999
The UN forces in East Timor
at first are likely to be involved more in fighting terrorism than keeping
the peace, argues Hugh Smith.
Peacekeeping is a continuation
of politics by other means. And in East Timor the politics do not look
good. Indonesian agreement to a peacekeeping force is no guarantee that
the situation on the ground will be peaceful. Militia elements are liable
to continue their violence, perhaps helped directly or indirectly by the
Indonesian armed forces.
Not only the peacekeeping
force will be under threat, but UN staff, many East Timorese and foreign
citizens, especially those belonging to countries taking part in the mission.
Some in East Timor will obviously find the peacekeeping operation highly
provocative.
The first challenge has been
to persuade governments to contribute to a force of sufficient size. The
target is about 8,000, of which Australia is likely to contribute 2,000,
rising to 4,500.
Malaysia, Thailand, the Philippines,
New Zealand, Canada and the UK also appear convinced that the operation
is worth the costs and the risks. Approval by the UN Security Council and
the logistical backing of the US will have influenced their decision. In
Australia planning has been under way for some months and the ADF is ready
to go. The contingent will be predominantly infantry, with necessary support
elements such as transport, communications, logistics, intelligence and
medical units. Personnel have had injections, briefings and intensive training.
Leave and courses have been cancelled and wills prepared. Equipment has
been checked, supplies and munitions replenished, and detailed plans made.
Not all countries will be as advanced.
Several tasks face the planners.
Getting soldiers and their equipment to East Timor is not easy. Troops
can be conveyed by RAAF Hercules and the Navy's catamaran, but transporting
light armoured vehicles and armoured personnel carriers by sea will be
much slower. Australia has minimal airlift capacity and planners probably
wish they had twice as many Hercules or a few C-5 Galaxies. The Blackhawk
helicopters can fly across without refuelling.
The first priority will be
to secure the means of entry to maintain supplies and personnel. Planes
landing at Dili or ships pulling in to the docks could be attacked, so
a defensive perimeter has to be established. Then Dili and the larger population
centres must be secured, including the UN mission, hospitals, and camps
for displaced people. Communications within the force and back to Canberra
will also be a priority.
If militia violence continues,
infantry patrols -- on foot and in vehicles -- must seek out the sources
and deal with them rapidly and ruthlessly. Armoured personnel carriers,
light armoured vehicles and Blackhawk helicopters will be at a premium.
Peacekeepers will need rules
of engagement covering when they can open fire with lethal force, how to
deal with violent mobs and what riot-control agents can be used. The whole
operation begins to look less like peacekeeping and more like the counter-
insurgency the British Army has been doing in Northern Ireland for decades.
ADF experience in Somalia will be an asset.
The great uncertainty is
the level of violence. A force of 8,000 is too small to control a large
number of widely separated townships if significant hostilities continue.
Poor transport infrastructure and mountainous terrain compound the problems.
Initially, East Timor is
likely to be divided between the peacekeeping force and the Indonesian
Army, with the former controlling the key centres, leaving the hinterland
to Indonesia. There are dangers in this, but there seems to be no alternative,
politically or practically.
But what happens if, for
example, militia elements base themselves in the Indonesian-controlled
areas for attacks on peacekeepers? Do the peacekeepers have to stop at
the boundary or will they be entitled to maintain pursuits that could bring
them into conflict with Indonesian forces? Apart from the difficult question
of where the boundaries are to be drawn, there is also the prospect of
a de facto partition of East Timor.
The legal status of the operation
also needs careful management. Will Indonesia agree to a status-of-forces
agreement authorising peacekeepers to carry arms and use them against Indonesian
citizens? And what is to be done with militia members detained by the peacekeepers?
Can they be tried and punished? Do they have to be handed over to Indonesian
authorities? Who will be responsible for peacekeepers captured by hostile
forces?
Another delicate question
is what the peacekeepers will do with evidence of war crimes which they
will find hard to avoid. Will they record mass graves and photograph buildings
where captives have been killed? The force is unlikely to have a mandate
to arrest suspected war criminals, but if it does not act the UN will be
called impotent.
Humanitarian problems must
also be dealt with. Peacekeepers will be expected to bring in initial supplies
of food, water, shelter and medical support until non-government international
agencies can establish. Police will be needed to bring back law and order.
Civil administration has to resume. The entire country will need to be
rebuilt, almost from scratch. This cannot be done quickly or cheaply.
The peacekeeping operation
will also have to be conducted in co- operation with the governments of
the contributing countries, each of which will have its own concerns and
a domestic constituency to keep happy. Australia may be the lead nation
and provide the force commander, but it will not have total control over
other national forces and their resources.
We can hope for a peaceful
mission with minimum casualties. But military planners have to prepare
for the worst because the lives of peacekeepers, Australians and others,
will be at stake. Those in charge will also have to be flexible. No military
plans, it is said, survive contact with the enemy. The same is true of
peacekeeping.
[Hugh Smith is an associate
professor in the school of politics at the Australian Defence Force Academy,
Canberra.]
Rape
used as a systematic torture
Sydney Maorning Herald -
September 13, 1999
Indonesian soldiers used
rape as a secret weapon, but their "orphans: bear silent witness. Louise
Williams and Leonie Lamont report.
Sister Maria leaned forward
and quietly confided the truth about the Catholic orphanage which lies
along the lonely northern coastal road of East Timor: "Most of the children
are mixed race, the babies of women raped by Indonesian soldiers."
This is not a truth openly
voiced in East Timorese society. Instead, said Sister Maria in an interview
in Dili earlier this year, the children were raised by the Church. But,
while they are not openly rejected, everyone knows the shame of their parentage.
In the early years following
the Indonesian invasion, orphanages were filled with genuine orphans: so
many adults had been killed in military operations. Now, Sister Maria said,
most are children of rape, a tactic used over and over again in war, usually
to hurt the father or husband of the victim. The woman's own suffering
is an afterthought in a war between men.
"One young woman I knew had
four babies, I kept asking her why this had happened again and she just
said there was nothing she could do," she said. Sister Maria's own whereabouts
remain unknown, following the rampage through Dili and the murder of Catholic
nuns and priests.
Rape, according to a report
released this year by Ms Radhika Coomaraswamy, the United Nations Special
Rapporteur on violence against women, has been systematically used by elements
of the Indonesian military in East Timor, Aceh and Irian Jaya.
"Rape was used by the military
as a method of torture and intimidation against the local population. Relatives
of political opponents were raped by the military as a form of revenge,
or to force the relatives out of hiding," she said.
"Much of the violence against
women in East Timor was perpetrated in the context of these areas being
treated as military zones ... rape by soldiers in these areas is tried
in military tribunals, and not before an ordinary court of law."
Under Indonesian law, for
a rape to be prosecuted it required corroboration -- including the testimony
of two witnesses. Women lived in a "realm of private terror", for any victims
or witnesses who dared to take action were intimidated with death threats,
Ms Coomaraswamy reported.
"Many of the women who were
raped as virgins are single mothers who have suffered stigma in their communities
after giving birth to children of Indonesian soldiers ...
"Some of these children are
the result of rapes, others are the product of a situation that resembles
sexual slavery and some are the result of consensual sex ... the women
are having a very difficult time, not only because of poverty, but because
the sight of these children often reminds them of rape." She said the Indonesian
state should take responsibility for these children.
Senator Marise Payne, one
of the parliamentary members of the Australian observer delegation to East
Timor, said she had been told of soldiers picking attractive girls from
the villages, and making them their "playthings". "This has been happening
for 20 years," she said.
A Catholic nun, Sister Tess
Ward, said: "Many women have said to me they feel dirty, and are too ashamed
to tell people."
"I don't know of anytime
when women were game enough to tell the police. Many of the people said
to me the only people we can talk to is the priest or sisters.
Militia
terror stalks refugees across border
Agence France Presse - September
13, 1999
Kupang -- A terror campaign
by pro-Indonesian militia that started in East Timor has moved across the
border to West Timor, where more than 100,000 refugees have fled, fearful
sources said.
People, who have visited
the border town of Atambua, described it as a lawless place of gunfire,
murder and kidnapping.
There are fears that army-backed
militiamen in Atambua and Kupang are hunting down pro-independence refugees,
say several sources who asked for anonymity.
Two people were shot dead
"by armed people that were not the police" near a market in Atambua last
Thursday, a traveller returning from the area who heard the gunshots told
AFP.
He could not confirm whether
the victims were supporters of an independent East Timor. The territory
voted overwhelmingly for independence in a UN-sponsored vote held August
30.
"People are killed during
the day time," said another traveller who recently returned to Kupang after
several days in Atambua.
One person who also travelled
to the region said he had spoken with a witness, who, late last week, saw
a person kidnapped on the street in Atambua.
"From his point of view it
was militias" who abducted the person, said the source, who recognised
both Aitarak (Thorn) and Besi Merah Putih (Red and White Iron) militia,
groups who were prominent in the East Timor violence, in the town. "Everybody
has a gun -- the army, the police, the militia," he said.
Another source in direct
contact with people in Atambua over the weekend said most shops were closed.
"The tension is escalating," he said. Armed men, believed to be militia,
are demanding free goods from merchants, he said.
"The travel is difficult
and dangerous," the source said. "The militia are hijacking trucks at gunpoint
... because they want to evacuate their relatives from there." He said
Indonesian security forces are "not taking away the weapons" from militiamen.
One traveller said he saw
on the streets of Atambua about 20 Land Rovers stolen from the UN Mission
in East Timor (UNAMET). "Some were driven by IDPs [internally displaced
people or refugees], some were driven by armed people," he said.
Most refugees who have crossed
the land border, fleeing the post-election violence in East Timor, are
staying in the Atambua area where they were sheltering in groups of 800
to 1,000 people, one source said. "You see displaced people behind houses,"
he said. "Each camp has a coordinator -- either military or militia."
Two travellers said young
men are rarely seen in the camps. "What is happening to the young men?
Are they recruited by force?" one asked.
Other sources said many of
the refugees in Atambua were pro- Indonesian and probably families of militiamen
who have been ordered to fight across the border.
A young East Timorese who
fled to Indonesian West Timor called the refugee centers "concentration
camps." He said he had been able to stay elsewhere. "We don't want to register
at the camps, because if we register, we go on a black list and the militias
will force us to follow them," he said.
Knowledgeable sources believe
the largest single refugee camp in West Timor is Kupang's Noelbaki facility
where between 12,000 and 20,000 refugees are staying.
One source with contacts
inside the camp said two people were stabbed to death at Noelbati last
week. The source said militias had been "sweeping" the camps, looking for
supporters of East Timorese independence.
"We definitely know the militias
are going around Kupang," the source said. Even outside the camps, militias
have knocked at peoples' doors asking if East Timorese live there, he said.
"They are going around asking questions. People are in danger."
Troops
fire on women's refugee camp
The Times (London) - September
13, 1999
Max Stahl, Dare -- This once
peaceful hill station overlooking Dili was turned into a death site at
the weekend as Indonesian forces surrounded and fired on terrified refugees
living rough in nearby plantations. Dare, once a popular resort for Portuguese
colonists escaping the heat of the coastal capital six miles away, is today
a scene of misery and terror.
Some 30,000 people, mainly
women, children and the elderly, who were forced from their homes by the
pro-Indonesian militias and the Indonesian Army, have erected shacks and
home-made tents to escape the carnage in the below.
But on Saturday afternoon
the deceptive tranquillity here was broken by the rumble of a column of
military vehicles coming up the road. Normally the military's dirty work
is conducted by the pro-Jakarta militiamen or soldiers dressed as militia.
This time, however, the troops made no effort to conceal their identity.
A detachment of more than
100 Indonesian marines emerged from the lorries and then deployed, fanning
out through the banana and coffee crops. Although there are no armed pro-independence
forces here the marines did not seem to notice. They opened fire without
provocation, killing a woman. Her body slumped over her handicapped husband,
who was pinned beneath her.
Calling out for the people
to "surrender", the marines did not seem surprised when the only people
to emerge with their hands in the air were mothers and children. The incident
served to prove graphically that despite repeated assurances from Jakarta,
troops on the ground are carrying out very different orders.
Yesterday a German Jesuit
priest, Father Karl Albrecht, was the latest victim when he was shot outside
the Jesuit residence in Dili.
There are very real fears
that in the time it takes to negotiate the make-up of a international force,
Jakarta will be able to finish the brutal job of clearing the local population.
Jakarta
backs down
Sydney Morning Herald - September
13, 1999
By Michelle Grattan, Hamish
McDonald, Bernard Lagan and Peter Cole-Adams.
Indonesia buckled last night
and invited a United Nations peacekeeping force "from friendly nations"
to enter East Timor.
President B.J.Habibie, in
a televised address to the nation from the presidential palace in Jakarta,
said the situation was "rapidly deteriorating" and the force would help
"restore peace and protect the populace".
The President said he had
taken the decision after hearing the results of an inspection on Saturday
of East Timor's capital, Dili, by the commander of the armed forces, General
Wiranto.
"Too many people have lost
their lives since the beginning of the unrest, lost their homes and security,"
Dr Habibie said. "We can't wait any longer. We have to stop the suffering
and mourning immediately."
Dr Habibie informed the UN
Secretary-General, Mr Kofi Annan, of the long delayed decision after a
2 1/2-hour meeting of Cabinet and senior military leaders.
No timing was given for the
entry of the international force, to be headed by Australian troops, but
Dr Habibie said Indonesia would welcome the force in East Timor "as soon
as possible".
The Indonesian Foreign Minister,
Mr Ali Alitas, flies to New York today for more detailed talks at the UN.
The US deputy national security
adviser, Mr Sandy Berger, said last night that he expected the force could
be deployed "within the next several days". Dr Habibie said the force would
have to work on the ground with the Indonesian military -- discredited
after two weeks of failing to control the murderous pro- Indonesian militias.
Thousands of East Timorese
have been killed or have disappeared, on reliable accounts, including UN
documentation, as the military stood by and in some cases cases took part.
Dr Habibie praised the efforts
of Indonesian troops but said they faced "very difficult psychological
constraints" -- an apparent reference to emotional links with the pro-Indonesian
militias responsible for the brutality and destruction.
In Darwin, where much of
Australia's troops and Navy and Air Force support is based, lights were
ablaze all along the docks and at Tindall Base, near Katherine, Blackhawk
helicopters were engaged in late night manoeuvres.
Earlier, the Prime Minister
said the United States had joined about a dozen nations in a "coalition
of the willing" ready to help restore peace.
Commitments had come from
New Zealand, Canada, Britain, Portugal, Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore and
the Philippines, with additional support likely from Sweden and France.
In Australia, there were
fears earlier that Indonesia may try to exclude Australians from any ground
involvement -- insisting on an Asia-only force.
President Clinton said it
was anticipated the US would provide extensive airlift support to bring
troops from other countries, primarily Asia, other logistical support,
intelligence and communications. Both Mr Howard and the Americans yesterday
slid around the questions of whether the US would have any ground troops
in the operation.
Mr Howard said that the Australian
military -- the people who needed to be satisfied with the US commitment
-- was happy with what was proposed.
As the peacekeepers prepare
to move in, thousands of frightened refugees -- most without food or shelter
-- threw themselves on ill-equipped hideouts of the pro-independence Falintil
resistance in the rugged hills of East Timor.
Reports reaching the UN in
Darwin said they were being pursued by the army-backed militias -- with
some deaths already reported -- as they took their scorched-earth campaign
to a new level of terror. The reports said there were some attacks on up
to 50,000 refugees who had sought refuge in the hills near Dare, nine kilometres
from Dili. More than 100,000 East Timorese have already been taken to holding
camps in West Timor, some of them under armed guard.
In Darwin, the UN High Commissioner
for Human Rights, Mrs Mary Robinson, said yesterday that she wanted events
elsewhere in Indonesia -- including West Timor -- to be included in her
planned war crimes tribunal on East Timor. She flew into Darwin to talk
to witnesses to the killing and violence and told a press conference that
she had spoken to refugees who had first-hand knowledge of atrocities and
would name those responsible.
There had been "gross, blatant,
terrible violations of the human rights of East Timorese", Mrs Robinson
said. "It has been done in the uniform of a government complicit in what
has been done in militia trappings."
Slaughter
linked to militia, soldiers
The Melbourne Age - September
13, 1999
Doug Struck, Kupang -- A
human rights organisation has documented atrocities in East Timor that
implicate the Indonesian military and militias in at least seven mass killings
and dozens of individual slayings.
"Killing, plundering, burning,
terror, intimidation and kidnapping have been carried out by the Indonesian
armed forces, along with the pro-Jakarta militia" since East Timor voted
overwhelmingly for independence on 30 August, concludes the report by the
Foundation for Law, Human Rights and Justice, based in Dili, the East Timor
capital.
Many refugees were interviewed
secretly because of fears of retribution from militiamen in the refugee
camps. Most of the atrocities cited by the group have not been verified
because after shooting erupted in Dili, journalists were confined to the
United Nations compound, and then evacuated.
According to the report,
witnesses identified Indonesian military members, in addition to the militias,
as participants in the atrocities. Indonesia has denied that any mass killings
happened, and has sent more troops to East Timor to impose martial law
and end the turmoil.
The report includes some
incidents that have been verified by the media and other sources and others
not previously known. Among them:
Several hours before results
of East Timor's independence referendum were announced on 4 September,
45 people were killed in Maliana, western East Timor. They included 21
drivers and local employees of the UN observers' operation.
Ten people in Bidau Macaur
Atas, a neighborhood in Dili, were hacked to death on 4 September by militia
and Indonesian armed forces. Some were buried by relatives, but "others
were put into bags and thrown away on the side of the road. Others were
thrown into the ocean". On the same day, militia members killed 50 people
in Bedois, eastern Dili.
The next day, eight people
who went to the Dili harbor to try to leave East Timor by ferry were identified
as pro-independence, and shot dead by Aitarak militia members.
The group said it also documented
the attack on a Dili Roman Catholic centre, which killed at least 25 people,
including a baby; the killing of 15 local employees of the International
Committee of the Red Cross in Dili on 5 September; and an attack by the
army and militia on a Catholic church compound in the Dili neighborhood
of Balide, where unknown numbers were slain.
The human rights group, which
is working in East and western Timor, provided reliable reports in Dili
before chaos engulfed the city last week. Its offices were ransacked and
many of its files destroyed.
Much of the violence in East
Timor has been carried out by pro- Indonesian militias, but there have
been frequent reports of shooting and looting by the military. The Indonesian
armed forces chief, General Wiranto, acknowledged yesterday that the militias
and military were "comrades in arms". He said his forces have not succeeded
in ending the violence, because for his soldiers, "I can understand it
is very hard to shoot their own people".
Horror
worse than UN believes
Agence France Presse - September
13, 1999
Darwin -- An East Timorese
support group claimed here Monday to have received reports that tens of
thousands of people had died in a deliberate genocidal campaign by Indonesia.
The East Timor International
Support Centre also believes 300,000 to 400,000 people face death from
starvation and thirst and another 250,000 people, a third of the population,
have been deported in vast convoys of trucks and ships.
Darwin doctor Andrew McNaughton
said the group has got information from people with access to the only
satellite telephones left in East Timor painting the crisis as being even
worse than the United Nations believes.
McNaughton says the information
his group has been receiving -- from friends and relatives -- is entirely
credible although there is a lack of hard evidence about the numbers involved.
"There's no doubt the Indonesian
army is engaged in an attempted genocide, a final solution against the
people of East Timor," he said. "We don't use these words lightly. The
way in which this has been put together shows that it has been planned
for weeks and months as a major operation.
"The information we have
indicates more than 200,000 people, perhaps by now 250,000 people, have
been forcibly removed to West Timor and elsewhere. We know of vast convoys
of trucks that have gone across the border to Atambua, we know of deportations
in naval ships, we know that people have been flown out in planes."
Young people are alleged
to have been taken out of concentration camps in Atambua and probably killed
while others on ships had been beaten to death and thrown over the side.
"We have reports that ships have left Dili and come back empty within hours
and there's a suspicion that the people on board have been killed."
He said the media focus has
been on the besieged UN compound in Dile and on the Dare refugee enclave
where 31,000 people face starvation, but the situation throughout East
Timor is equally bad or worse.
Satellite cameras had confirmed
that most of the towns of East Timor were ablaze at some stage, he said.
"We think and we know from evidence on the ground that in most of East
Timor a lot of the towns and villages have been sacked and burnt, looted
and destroyed."
There had been a systematic
attack on East Timorese leaders, priests and nuns, with another religious
leader, this time a Protestant moderator murdered at the weekend, McNaughton
said.
"We have reason to believe
that because people fled all over East Timor that there are probably some
hundreds of thousands of people in the mountains, maybe as many as three
or four hundred thousand people. It's not just Dili, it's everywhere.
"Before voting day people
warned us that they would vote and run for the hills because they expected
violent reprisals. We think that there are 300,000 to 400,000 in the mountains
of East Timor.
"They don't have water, they
don't have sufficient water, they don't have food, and we have reports
that people are already dying in Dare and in other locations.
"They have fled to the mountains
to be with the resistance but the resistance don't have the capacity to
look after them and to provide food and water for tens of thousands of
people.
"The situation is horrendous,
tens of thousands dead, 200,000 forcibly deported, of whom many have probably
already been killed in West Timor or elsewhere -- a major orchestrated
forced deporation reminscent maybe of the Nazis. We have people dying in
the mountains because of lack of humanitarian aid."
Military
behind bloodshed: UN official
Straits Times - September
14, 1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- Indonesia's armed
forces (TNI) appears to have organised the mass bloodshed that hit East
Timor, after it voted overwhelmingly for independence, United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson said yesterday.
"My worry is that it appears
to be systemic. All the interlocuters I spoke to.. all of them said TNI
was fully involved . orchestrating it," she told a news conference.
She said that she had received
many harrowing reports, including those of rape and systematic evictions,
when she talked to local and international UN staff who had been evacuated
to Darwin in northern Australia.
She has recommended that
a panel of experts set up an inquiry, as to whether there should be some
sort of international tribunal.
That would help stop "the
well-planned and systematic policy of killings, displacement, destruction
of property and intimidation carried out by militia groups and elements
of the security," said the High Commissioner. "There must be no impunity
from that scale of violation," she said.
Much of the evidence needed
for prosecution of crimes committed in East Timor had already been collected,
she said. "This will allow the international community to put the criminals
responsible away, provided the resolve is there."
Aceh,
Ambon learn cost of resisting Jakarta
The Guardian - September
16, 1999
John Aglionby, Jakarta --
Thousands of people in Aceh province in western Indonesia demonstrated
yesterday to demand a referendum on independence from Jakarta amid reports
of unabated military brutality both there and on the eastern spice island
of Ambon. Human rights activists say that while the world's gaze has been
fixed on East Timor, more than 200 people have been killed since July in
both troubled provinces.
Amien Rais and Abdurrahman
Wahid, two of Indonesia's most influential politicians and both well-known
Islamic intellectuals, joined the 4,000 students and Muslim scholars who
demonstrated at the main mosque in Aceh's provincial capital, Banda Aceh.
Carrying banners emblazoned
with the word "referendum", the protesters were unfazed by military threats
to clamp down on any separatist movements in the wake of the army-inspired
destruction in East Timor after the territory's overwhelming vote to sever
its ties with Jakarta.
"To solve the conflict that
is happening in Aceh there is no other way but with a referendum," Tengku
Nurujjahri Yahia, a local Muslim scholar, told the meeting.
Humam Hamid, a prominent
Acehnese lawyer and human rights activist, said the military's "attempt
to wipe East Timor off the map" would not cow the Acehnese into submission.
"We want peace and justice
and will not rest until we get them. If the army tries to repeat East Timor
here it will only make the situation very much worse," he added.
Information collected by
the Aceh Human Rights Forum indicates that more than 200 people have been
murdered in Aceh in the past six weeks. Witnesses say "unidentified mysterious
gunmen", believed to be members of undercover military units, are responsible
for most of the deaths.
Aceh's problems arise from
Jakarta's repeated refusal to make good a 1958 promise to grant wide-ranging
political, religious and cultural autonomy to the resource-rich province
on the northern tip of Sumatra.
Armed separatist movements
emerged in the late 80s and since 1989 the Indonesian army has waged a
ferocious campaign to crush the Acehnese separatist movement.
President BJ Habibie and
his generals promised to investigate abuses and look into devolution while
intensifying a crackdown on separatists. Last week the Indonesian parliament
discussed the possibility of "special status" for Aceh, but it is not expected
to take a decision.
An army spokesman in Aceh
said yesterday that the situation was still "very tense" but that the majority
of the 140,000 refugees who fled their villages in July had returned.
The chances of lasting peace
on the island of Ambon also appear to be slim, according to local human
rights workers.
"After eight months of violence,
the situation is getting worse not better," said Henky Hatu of Pattimura
university in Ambon. "We now have East Timor style thugs armed with military
weapons operating in many areas."
Researchers in his department
say there have been 202 deaths and 749 serious injuries from ethnic clashes
and military intervention since July 15. Reliable church sources say this
is a conservative estimate.
"Our figures show there were
well over 100 deaths between July 26 and August 15," a priest living in
Ambon said. "We have also heard of very nasty clashes elsewhere in the
area and so the death toll now is probably well over 300."
Independent confirmation
of such figures is almost impossible. Ambon's airport has been closed to
commercial flights since the beginning of August, terror gangs stalk all
the inter-provincial ferries, and many roads are so dangerous they are
no-go zones.
"People have been killed
on every single boat for the last six weeks," said Andi Tamher, a student
about to leave for Jakarta. "The only way to ensure surviving on the ferries
is to rent a cabin and lock oneself in, but few people can afford to do
this."
More than 2,000 military
reinforcements have been deployed on Ambon to quell the eight-month unrest.
At the heart of the violence there appears to be a clash between Christians
and Muslims, but many people believe this is just a cover story for more
sinister goings-on.
"Everything here is top down.
No one is getting the people involved in the peace efforts," Dr Hatu said.
"It seems the government doesn't want to find a solution.
"We're witnessing political
games among the elite and the people are being used as the scapegoat,"
he added. "No one has any idea how long it will go on for."
'Special
autonomy' plan for Aceh
South China Morning Post
- September 15, 1999
Vaudine England, Jakarta
-- On the same day that an independent commission to investigate military
abuses was visiting Aceh for the first time, seven leading political parties
announced proposals for "special autonomy" for the rich, violence-wracked
province.
Both moves yesterday betrayed
Jakarta's deep concern about rising separatist activity in Aceh, a concern
which has only been heightened by the East Timor crisis.
The proposed special autonomy
for Aceh is close to the "comprehensive autonomy" offered by Jakarta to
East Timor, which the East Timorese rejected in their August 30, United
Nations- supervised ballot.
Aceh's deputy chairman of
the National Mandate Party (PAN), Jamaluddin Ahmad, spoke in Aceh's capital,
Banda Aceh, on behalf of the seven political parties which won the most
votes in June's general election, including ruling party Golkar and opposition
frontrunner the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P).
"We hope that at least a
small part of the constitutional framework for the special autonomy for
Aceh can become an input for the Government and the Parliament to strengthen
the law number 22 and 25 of 1999 and the draft law on the special region
of Aceh," Mr Shmad said.
He was referring to two recently
passed laws on the sharing of provincial revenues between the province
and the central Government in Jakarta, and a draft law recognising Aceh's
specific customs, laws and education.
He said the general outline
of the proposed autonomy would leave foreign affairs, external security,
fiscal and monetary matters and the judiciary in Jakarta's hands, with
Aceh able to accept aid from abroad and from Jakarta.
The proposal is for Aceh
to get authority over 70 percent of the revenues from local oil and gas
resources and over 60 percent of other natural resources. These proportions
are significantly larger than the respective 20 and 15 per cent allowed
for under the recently passed law.
The proposal represents an
effort to buy off growing anger in Aceh at the continued presence of extra
troops and riot police in the province following the past decade of special
military status for the province which has been marked by army-led massacres.
The Independent Commission
on Aceh, formed by President Bacharuddin Habibie more than a month ago,
is to investigate such military abuses, starting with the most recent,
on July 23 in the Betung Ateuh area of West Aceh.
The team of independent investigators,
which will visit Betung Ateuh first, includes people involved in last year's
fact-finding team on the rapes of Chinese Indonesian women during the power
struggle in Jakarta of May last year.
Members of the team have
been appalled by preliminary evidence gathering, which in the words of
one member, spelled "Kopassus, Kopassus, Kopassus", the army's special
forces now renowned for manipulating much of the recent violence in East
Timor.
Many Indonesians feel much
more strongly about the potential lose of Aceh than they do about East
Timor -- hence broad-based efforts by politicians and academics outside
government to find ways to avert a second national tragedy. Aceh, which
played an important role in the nationalist struggle that led to the birth
of Indonesia in 1945, is largely Muslim and rich in oil and gas.
But a growing number of Acehnese
are likely to reject any offers from Jakarta as being too little, too late.
Jakarta
cave-in sparks anger
Straits Times - September
14, 1999
Derwin Pereira, Jakarta --
President B.J. Habibie's decision to allow foreign troops into trouble-torn
East Timor sparked an upsurge of nationalist sentiments especially in the
government and local media, with many resentful of international pressure
on Indonesia.
While diplomats and analysts
saw some light at the end of the tunnel over the issue -- with the possible
deployment of a multi-national UN peacekeeping force in a matter of weeks
-- newspapers yesterday expressed anger after Jakarta buckled under the
weight of criticism.
There were also demonstrations
at Australia's embassy in Jakarta and at the representative office of the
state of Western Australia in Surabaya. Police managed to head off protesters
intending to march to the American consulate in Surabaya.
But sentiment on Indonesia's
stock market rose in the wake of Jakarta's decision, closing up 1.22 per
cent at 569.6 points yesterday. The rupiah was quoted at 7385/7885 to the
US dollar in late trading, against 8250/8300 on Friday.
While reports out of Dili
said the capital was decidedly calmer yesterday, the news for Indonesia's
Defence Forces (TNI) out of Jakarta was anything but.
UN High Commissioner for
Human Rights Mary Robinson said there was mounting evidence the military
was fully involved in the violence against East Timorese -- and spoke of
the possibility of having a tribunal to examine human rights abuses by
the TNI.
The sentiment in leading
Indonesian dailies, however, was decidedly one of anger. The Indonesian-language
Kompas daily, accusing the West of double standards, said in a strident
editorial: "The presence of a UN peacekeeping force in East Timor is the
result of continuous pressure against us.
"The international reaction
to East Timor's problems has removed the mask of Western governments. Previously
they supported invasion, now they threaten us. In the past, they sent war
arms to fight the Timorese.
"Now they have stopped. But
we don't have to be disappointed. There are still many countries which
sell sophisticated weapons, like China, Russia, Argentina or even India."
The criticism appeared directed
at countries like the US, which backed quietly Indonesia's 1975 invasion
of East Timor and gave arms to the military, as it saw Jakarta as a staunch
regional ally against communism. Australia was also one of the few countries
to recognise Indonesian rule in East Timor.
Several other papers reflected
in varying degrees the sentiments aired by Kompas. But the English-language
Jakarta Post, hailed Dr Habibie's move, saying it would rebuild foreign
confidence in the country. "It provides Indonesia with a face-saving exit,"
the paper said.
But with national pride hit
badly by Jakarta having to accept the idea of foreign troops in the territory,
obstacles could still crop up and affect the composition and the type of
peacekeeping force that could be sent in. Some parliamentary leaders here
have expressed opposition to countries like the US and Australia being
involved.
Australia, which has positioned
itself as the leader of any international force, has put 2,000 troops on
48-hour standby.
Western diplomats said that
while Jakarta accepted participation by Australia and the US publicly,
there were private reservations.
"Deep down in their hearts,
the Indonesians don't want anyone," said a senior diplomat. "But given
a choice between Westerners and Asians, the government prefers Asians to
lead the way."
Indonesian generals and politicians
mention the involvement of Asean nations -- in particular Malaysia, Philippines,
Thailand and Singapore -- which could work side by side with TNI.
They said bilateral military
exercises have fostered strong ties and would thus make it easier to coordinate
operations on the ground.
A Western diplomat said there
was likely to be "a great deal of foot-dragging and negotiations" in Jakarta
and New York over the next few days to "save the face of a few individuals".
"But there is light at the
end of the tunnel," he added. "The Indonesians have conceded the fundamental
principle of allowing foreign troops in. There will be some resistance
along the way, but things can only improve for East Timor."
PAN
and PKB reject state security bill
Jakarta Post - September
17, 1999
Jakarta -- Opposition to
the state security bill continued on Thursday, with the National Mandate
Party (PAN) and National Awakening Party (PKB) demanding the House of Representatives
drop the government-sponsored draft law.
PKB secretary-general Muhaimin
Iskandar said his party would reject the bill because the current House
did not have the legitimacy to deliberate its terms.
"If the House heeds the people's
aspirations and increasing protests, it should stop the deliberation of
the bill and leave the job to the next House instead," he said in a seminar
on the bill held by the Mass Communications Forum.
Separately, PAN secretary-general
Faisal Basri said his party was opposed to the bill because it feared that
it would be misused by the government during the General Session of the
People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) in November.
"Regardless of all significant
changes made into the bill, we are worried that the bill will only justify
the government in preventing the people from holding demonstrations and
protests before and during the MPR General Session," he told the House
committee in charge of deliberating the bill on Thursday.
He said student and mass
demonstrations were expected to color the Session because of anger over
President B.J. Habibie's handling of East Timor and the failure to resolve
allegations of corruption against his predecessor, Soeharto. Habibie will
deliver his accountability speech before the MPR in the Session, scheduled
to take place between November 1 and 10.
Another speaker in the seminar,
Faisal Razi from the Democratic People's Party (PRD), called on all political
parties and mass organizations to reject the bill, which gives authority
to the military to use force and take wide-ranging measures in a state
of emergency.
"PRD is against the bill
because it gives new authority to the military, which has lost the people's
confidence because of its tarnished past image," he said.
PAN and PRD also urged the
House to annul the restrictive 1959 law concerning a state of emergency,
which is now in effect in East Timor.
Agus Muhyidin, the House
committee chairman who also spoke in the seminar, said it would depend
on the House as a whole whether to halt deliberation of the bill. The House
is expected to endorse the draft law on September 23.
Spokesman for the Indonesian
Military (TNI) Maj. Gen. Sudrajat appealed to all quarters opposed to the
bill to recognize TNI's "goodwill" in accepting amendments.
"TNI has been open to gradual
reform to repair its image. Many substantial changes have been made in
the bill and the military agrees with the changes in order to accommodate
the people's demands," he said in the seminar.
Syamsuddin, a member of the
National Commission of Human Rights and a retired Army general, hailed
the changes made by legislators, saying the present version was far more
democratic than the original draft.
"All sides opposing the bill
should reconsider their rejection of the bill," he said, citing the bill
guarantee of law supremacy, human rights and democracy in a state of emergency.
Student rallies protesting
the bill continued in Surabaya and Yogyakarta on Thursday. In Surabaya,
hundreds of students took to the streets in separate demonstrations. A
student group identified as the Arek Surabaya Association protested outside
the local council to demand counselors reject the bill.
Another 400 students claiming
to represent the Communication Forum of Surabaya Students (Formasa) held
a free-speech forum in front of the provincial legislative body on Jl.
Indrapura. They said the bill would pave the way for the military to strengthen
its grip on power.
In Yogyakarta, more than
200 students representing the Indonesian Front for Youth Struggle (FPPI)
marched through the town. The march caused traffic congestion on major
streets. The students also burned tire stashes and carried a coffin covered
by a red cloth contained with signatures of students who rejected the bill.
Jakarta
severs security ties with Canberra
The Australian - September
17, 1999
Don Greenlees and Robert
Garran -- Australia's battered relations with Indonesia suffered a new
blow yesterday when Jakarta terminated the bilateral security treaty.
Prime Minister John Howard
played down the move, which he said was expected. "We never saw it as being
the solution to all the problems in the relationship, as the former government
did, so I don't pay too much regard and I'm not particularly surprised
or concerned about this decision," Mr Howard said.
But former prime minister
Paul Keating, who secretly negotiated the pact for 18 months until it was
revealed in December 1995, said Jakarta's action was a symbol of the "all-time
low" in relations between the two countries.
The cancellation of the agreement
came as the UN announced Thailand would appoint the deputy commander for
Interfet, which is to be led by Australian Major-General Peter Cosgrove.
In Jakarta, Political and
Security Affairs Minister Feisal Tanjung cited Australia's decision to
review or cancel a number of bilateral military activities as among reasons
for Indonesia deciding to "abrogate" the agreement. He said the attitude
and actions of Australia were "no longer consistent with the spirit and
letter of the agreement".
Senior Indonesian military
sources said there was widespread resentment in the armed forces at what
was seen as Australia's aggressive support for the August 30 ballot in
East Timor and its leading role in forming a peace force to the territory.
They predicted the peace-enforcers would run into opposition from pro-Indonesia
forces in East Timor.
It is understood the decision
to scrap the 1995 agreement was left largely to armed forces commander
General Wiranto and other senior officers, but endorsed by President B.J.
Habibie.
Defence Minister John Moore
said the treaty decision suggested the TNI "will probably not be very co-operative"
in East Timor, although this did not mean they would be aggressive.
Meanwhile, the latest intelligence
reports showed the TNI were leaving eastern parts of East Timor, sources
said. But there are fears elements of the military in the western parts
of the territory intend to try to partition East Timor, raising the prospect
of confrontations with the Interfet force.
Eurico Guterres, deputy commander
of East Timor's pro-Indonesia militia, yesterday warned his forces would
put eight of the territory's 13 districts off limits to multinational troops,
the Antara news agency said.
Meanwhile in Darwin, RAAF
plans to airdrop food to refugees in East Timor late yesterday were frustrated
when detailed talks with Indonesia about the locations and other technical
details failed to conclude in time for the operation. It is expected more
efforts will be made to airdrop today.
Tension
in Jakarta
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
- September 16, 1999
Compere: East Timor's anti-independence
militia have now been seen on the streets of Jakarta, threatening pro-independence
East Timorese and foreign journalists. There were scenes which seemed quite
out of place in the Indonesian capital, as Geoff Thompson reports from
Jakarta.
Geoff Thompson: An angry
young man in a pro-autonomy T-shirt denounces Xanana Gusmao. Nearby, another
man stands wearing a T- shirt bearing the name of Mahidi, one of East Timor's
notorious anti-independence militias -- red berets and army fatigues. And
foreign journalists are warned to leave. These pro-autonomy protesters
then break into a run to chase what they claim are pro-independence provocateurs.
It looks and sounds like
Dili, but it's in the heart of Jakarta, a city in which small, angry protests
with different angry agendas are becoming frequent if not well attended.
The Indonesian media is discussing
nationalism, jingoism and anti-Australian sentiment. In its latest bulletin
to Australian citizens in Indonesia, the Australian Embassy in Jakarta
says that it, the consulate in Bali, and a number of Australian businesses
have received threatening telephone calls, including bomb threats.
But is anti-foreigner sentiment,
and in particular anti- Australian sentiment, representative of Indonesian
public opinion at this sensitive time? That is the question that cannot
yet be answered.
What we do know is that this
question is about to be sorely tested when thousands of Australian troops
lead the UN's peacekeeping force into East Timor to tackle the violence
by militia who have the support of the Indonesian military which still
remains in the territory.
Indeed the UN already knows
very well that several militia commanders are serving officers in the Indonesian
military, and so it's hard to imagine just how the peace-enforcers will
avoid some sort of conflict with the Indonesian military.
Political analyst Soedjati
Djiwandono thinks that the complete withdrawal of the Indonesian military
is the only real answer.
Soedjati Djiwandono: Well,
I hope that the first thing the UN peacekeeping forces -- what they would
do first is to disarm these people -- would disarm the people of both groups,
both the pro-integration and pro-independence East Timorese. Without disarming
them, yes the possibility is real that somebody might shoot at you, and
you would retaliate, and there will be a conflict, and you have to deal
with the Indonesian military.
Geoff Thompson: I think the
world wants peacekeeping troops in East Timor. But now that that is a reality,
the questions have to be in turn to how it will work in practice while
the Indonesian military remains in East Timor.
Soedjati Djiwandono: That's
why in the first place I would like to see the Indonesian military withdrawn
totally from East Timor.
Compere: Political analyst
Soedjati Djiwandono.
Wiranto
may quit to run for president
Straits Times - September
15 1999
Susan Sim, Jakarta -- Indonesia's
powerful defence forces (TNI) chief General Wiranto will likely step down
next month to prepare for his presidential campaign as a parliamentary
investigation into a banking scandal looks certain to implicate close friends
of Dr B.J. Habibie and kill off his chances.
Sources close to Gen Wiranto
told The Straits Times yesterday that he was "definitely stepping down"
sometime after October 5 -- Defence Forces Day.
He would retain his portfolio
as Defence Minister, but would relinquish operational command of the military
to current deputy chief Admiral Widodo, who would hold the post in an acting
capacity.
His resignation as the TNI
commander-in-chief would pave the way for the ruling Golkar party to name
him as its new presidential candidate in a national leadership congress
due to convene around Oct 14 or Oct 15.
And to prod political parties
into some deal-making soon, Adm Widodo on Monday raised the prospect of
a delay in the convening of the 700-member People's Consultative Assembly
(MPR), which was scheduled to pick a president by November 10.
"It seems to me that certain
people, especially the political elite, have yet to prepare mentally and
politically to face the upcoming MPR general meeting," he told a nationwide
meeting of military commanders.
Urging politicians to reach
a consensus, he added: "There has been a high potential for conflict in
our society so that a riot can easily surface in the capital and other
regions. Such a condition is of course not conducive to the safe, orderly
and democratic holding of the general assembly of the MPR."
His warning spooked the stock
market, whose key composite price index shed 6.653 points to 562.999 in
the first hour of trading. The rupiah also weakened to 8100/8200 to the
US dollar in early morning trade, down from the euphoric 7840/7880 on Monday
after the peacekeeping announcement.
Golkar deputy chairman Marzuki
Darusman said Adm Widodo's comments indicated that the military hoped to
sideline Dr Habibie by encouraging parties to reach a consensus rather
than risk a vote in the MPR with its unpredictable outcome.
Golkar itself had not yet
decided to dump the President as its candidate, but it was clear that it
would soon "have to outline the picture to Habibie that there was still
no clear support for him despite continued lobbying".
He said that no deals had
yet been cut with the TNI to support Gen Wiranto's candidacy, but added:
"If we do make a decision to nominate him, it would be best if he's nominated
when he's not in office anymore."
But confidants of Gen Wiranto
appeared assured that at least one major party would support his candidacy.
The major Muslim parties, which together control the largest bloc of MPR
seats, are also likely to support the general, he said, giving him enough
votes to beat Ms Megawati Sukarnoputri.
Opponents of Dr Habibie have
been given ammunition by testimony before parliament that his main campaign
manager, Mr A.A. Baramuli, tried to exert undue influence over Finance
Minister Bambang Subianto and allegedly organised a cover up of a scam
involving Bank Bali.
In what has become known
as Baligate, more than 546 billion rupiah was siphoned out of central bank
payments to the nationalised Bank Bali to a company linked to a now-sacked
Golkar treasurer.
Domestic outcry over the
loss of East Timor and the humiliation of allowing foreign soldiers in
have also eroded Dr Habibie's credibility.
For Gen Wiranto too, the
question remains whether international outcry over his possible complicity
in East Timor might derail his presidential bid or boost his nationalist
credentials.
Investigators
uncover indications of fraud
Wall Street Journal - September
14, 1999
Jay Solomon, Jakarta -- An
investigation into a politically charged banking scandal here has uncovered
"numerous" indications of fraud, as well as the transfer of millions of
dollars to senior Indonesian officials and politically connected individuals,
an audit by the US accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers says.
The report also says Bank
Indonesia, the country's central bank, failed to cooperate sufficiently
with the investigation. The International Monetary Fund and World Bank,
which are leading a $43 billion bailout package for Indonesia, have stated
they won't release new funds to the country until the financial scandal
is satisfactorily resolved.
Indonesia's financial markets
were roiled last month by banking regulators' reports that 546 billion
rupiah ($66.6 million) was siphoned out of the recently nationalized Bank
Bali to a company linked to President B.J. Habibie's ruling Golkar party.
The company, PT Era Giat Prima, is headed by Golkar's vice treasurer, who
contends the funds were earned through a legal "debt collection" service.
Golkar Chairman Akbar Tanjung, meanwhile, said none of the money was transferred
into the party's coffers.
Indicators of fraud
The Pricewaterhouse audit,
which was commissioned by the Indonesian government and the IMF, however,
stated the two-week investigation "uncovered numerous indicators of fraud,
noncompliance, irregularity, misappropriation, undue preferential treatment,
concealment, bribery, and corruption" in the transaction, despite being
granted only "limited access to information." In particular, the report
highlights how rules governing Indonesia's loan-guarantee program had been
breached by government officials in the Bank Bali case. Under the program,
the government is obligated to repay all loans owed by shuttered Indonesian
banks to third parties, in this case Bank Bali. But the report highlights
that senior members of the Indonesian government assisted in channeling
the funds to the Golkar-linked party.
Pricewaterhouse says Indonesia's
loan-guarantee program, because of the government's lack of resources,
offers "a high fraud risk scenario."
Pricewaterhouse also says
it made every attempt to trace the 546 billion rupiah, as required by the
IMF and Indonesian government, in its audit. Opposition parties have charged
that senior members of Golkar were attempting to use the funds to boost
Mr. Habibie's hopes of re-election in November -- an accusation that party
denies. Golkar also says officials involved returned the 546 billion rupiah
they received to Bank Bali.
Funds to more than 100
accounts
Pricewaterhouse states, however,
that its audit uncovered that the Golkar-linked company transferred the
funds to more than 100 accounts. Among these included "senior public officials
and senior political party members." It also said the sources who returned
the entire 546 billion rupiah were "not identical" to those who received
them.
Umar Juoro, a senior economic
adviser to Mr. Habibie, who has yet to see the audit, says the government
will continue to push through the probe regardless of how sensitive it
is.
In an interview in Auckland,
New Zealand, Indonesia's top economic minister, Ginandjar Kartasasmita,
voiced the same view. "We will go down to the bottom of it, and take necessary
action to rectify the problem" at Bank Bali, he said.
A vice chairman of Golkar,
Marzuki Darusman, said his party couldn't yet comment on the audit. He
and other members of Golkar have threatened to dump Mr. Habibie as the
party's presidential candidate in November if the Bank Bali affair wasn't
resolved.
UK
ministers under fire over deals
Agence France Presse - September
15, 1999
London -- British ministers
were under fire Wednesday after it emerged that millions of pounds of public
money had been used to help Indonesia buy jets and secure industrial contracts,
newspapers reported.
The Times newspaper said
130 million pounds (195 million dollars) of public funds was used to help
the Indonesian military -- accused of orchestrating a campaign of violence
against supporters of independence in East Timor -- buy Hawk fighter planes
from Britain.
The revelation will further
embarrass Foreign Secretary Robin Cook whose "ethical" foreign policy was
challenged by human rights activists after a British-made plane was used
to intimidate East Timorese ahead of a referendum on the future of the
territory.
Britain's Export Credit Guarantee
Department (ECGD) underwrote payments to British Aerospace after the Indonesian
economy ran into trouble last year. The money was used to help Jakarta
reschedule payments on contracts for Hawks, The Times said.
Britain suspended export
licences for the sale of arms, including nine Hawk jets, to Indonesia at
the weekend, in the wake of the bloodshed in East Timor.
Meanwhile, the Guardian daily
said Britain's National Audit Office was considering an investigation after
it emerged that Trade Secretary Stephen Byers had overruled civil servants
and given the go ahead for financial help to Indonesia.
The daily said according
to official documents, Byers ignored warnings from senior civil servants
who refused to back the help because they deemed Indonesia too risky for
the investment of taxpayers' money.
Byers authorised the payment,
however, "in view of the importance we attach to our relations with Indonesia,"
the Guardian reported.
Byers ordered the ECGD to
underwrite a 1.1-million-dollar loan for a British engineering company,
Va Tech Reyrolle Projects, to help the company win business building new
power transmission lines in Indonesia.
The Guardian said Byers'
decision was taken on July 19 against a background of a virtual moratorium
on financial support for Indonesia amid alarm that Britain was already
exposed should the country default on heavy loans.
Britain's dealings with Indonesia
have been the subject of scrutiny since early September when pro-Jakarta
militia went on the rampage, killing and driving out supporters of independence
for the territory. The violence follows a UN-organised ballot on the future
of East Timor, a former Portuguese colony invaded by Indonesia in 1975,
in which East Timorese voted overwhelmingly in favour of independence.
Indonesian
leader voices 'feelings'
Associated Press - September
12, 1999
Jakarta -- After a week of
chaos and terror in East Timor, Indonesia's powerful military boss sang
"Feelings" on Sunday to show why he can't walk away from the independence-minded
province.
To cheers from retired military
officers at a party, Defense Minister Gen. Wiranto dedicated the song to
foreign journalists: "I hope you have the same feelings, like me, for East
Timor." His eyebrows arched in restrained emotion, Wiranto held the microphone
in both hands and stood stiffly in a yellow batik shirt and crooned as
a band played the 1975 hit popularized by Paul Williams:
"Feelings, nothing more than
feelings, trying to forget my feelings of love." "Teardrops, rolling down
on my face, trying to forget my feelings of love. Feelings, for all my
life I'll feel it ... I wish I've never met you, girl; you'll never come
again." He hit all the high notes.
Wiranto earlier said Indonesia's
army, which invaded East Timor in 1975, is profoundly attached to the former
Portuguese colony and those residents who backed Indonesian rule.
The international community
has condemned the military for aiding and directing anti-independence militias
in a murderous rampage against East Timorese who voted in a UN-backed referendum
to break away from Indonesia.