East Timor
News & issues
Arms/Armed forces
International solidarity
Militia,
troops attack Timor refugees: UN
Agence France Presse - September
12, 1999
Darwin -- Indonesian troops
and pro-Jakarta militiamen were Sunday attacking thousands of refugees
massed in the East Timorese town of Dare, a spokesman for the UN Mission
in East Timor (UNAMET) said here.
"This is once again a major
crime against the East Timorese people," spokesman David Wimhurst told
a press conference, appealing for international action to halt the violence.
"There is an urgent need for armed intervention to prevent these attacks
continuing.
"The international community
have to decide what they will do to prevent these ongoing killings. Action
is needed urgently," added Wimhurst, saying he had spoken directly to two
people in Dare, nine kilometres (six miles) south of the East Timor capital
of Dili, and received other accounts via relatives of witnesses in Australia.
"They are still slaughtering people in East Timor and the international
community has not acted."
One man had called his niece
in Sydney to tell her of the Dare attack, he said. "Right now, he is on
top of the mountain over Dare," Wimhurst added. "What he said is he could
hear shots being fired below him.
"He said there are thousands
of refugees down there. He can hear the people screaming in fear. "And
he said the TNI [Indonesian armed forces] are advancing up the mountain
killing everybody."
Wimhurst said there were
"thousands" of refugees in the town where church workers have been aiding
refugees. UNAMET last week estimated at least 30,000 people had massed
in Dare amid escalating violence by pro-Jakarta militias.
He added UNAMET was also
concerned the refugees in Dare were running short of food, quoting Sister
Anne Forbes of the Sisters of Mercy, as telling him the little food left
was being given only to women and children. "There is an urgent need to
get food in there by the most speedy means possible," the spokesman said.
Will
we let them fall before our eyes?
The Melbourne Age - September
12, 1999
John Pilger -- It had been
a long night of waiting for the Indonesian troop convoy to pass.
Two of us then crossed the
border into East Timor clandestinely, through a forest of petrified trees
which appeared as silhouetted needles around which skeins of fine white
sand drifted, like mist. As the sun rose, there stood the surreal crosses.
They were almost everywhere;
great black crosses etched against the sky, crosses on peaks, crosses in
tiers on the hillsides, crosses beside the road, overlooking white slabs.
I carried hand-drawn maps
of other, unmarked graves where some of those murdered by Indonesian troops
at the 1991 Santa Cruz massacre had been buried; I had no idea that so
much of the country was a vast grave, marked by paths that ended abruptly,
and fields inexplicably bulldozed, and earth inexplicably covered with
tarmac, and villages, which are not so much human entities as memorials.
Kraras is one of them. It
is known as the "village of the widows", because 287 people were slaughtered
by the Indonesians.
In a meticulous hand that
carried on from a faded typewriter ribbon, a priest recorded the name,
age, cause of death and date and place of the killing of every victim.
In the last column, he identified
the Indonesian battalion responsible for each murder. I have the document.
Like the ubiquitous crosses, it records the Calvary of 40 families, among
them, the dos Anjos family.
In 1987, I interviewed Arthur
("Steve") Stevenson, a former Australian commando who had fought the Japanese
in Timor. He told me the story of Celistino dos Anjos, whose ingenuity
and couraged had saved his life behind Japanese lines, the kind of man
who fought like a lion to prevent the Japanese building airstrips from
which they planned to attack Australia -- the kind of man to whom leaflets
dropped by the Royal Australian Air Force were addressed, as the Australians
retreated. "We shall never forget you," the leaflets said.
In 1986, Steve Stevenson
received a letter from Celestino's son, Virgilio, who was the same age
as his own son. He wrote that his father had survived the Indonesian invasion
in 1975, but he went on: "In August 1983, Indonesian forces entered our
village, Kraras.
They looted, burned and massacred,
with fighter aircraft overhead. On 27/9/83 they made my father and my wife
dig their own graves, and they machine gunned them. My wife was pregnant."
The Kraras list is among
my most valued possessions. Not only is it evidence of genocide, it is
an extraordinary political document that shames Indonesia's Faustian partners
in the western democracies, especially Australia.
In my experience, East Timor
is the greatest, most enduring crime of the late 20th century. Not only
do the horrors committed by the Suharto dynasty lay claim to this distinction
-- proportionally, not even Pol Pot put to death as many people -- but
no other recent crime against humanity, from the American devastation of
Indochina to Rwanda, offers such a comprehensive charge sheet.
"Descent into violence" has
become the most worked media cliche of the past few weeks, as if a collective,
almost wilful amnesia prevents us remembering when the descent really began,
and who were Indonesia's partners in its crime. On 7 December, 1975, when
Air Force One, carrying President Ford and his secretary of state, Henry
Kissinger, had climbed out of Indonesian airspace, Indonesian paratroopers
dropped on Dili, East Timor's capital, and the bloodbath began.
"[Ford and Kissinger] came
and gave Suharto the green light," Phillip Liechty, the CIA desk officer
in Jakarta at the time told me. "The invasion was delayed two days so they
could get the hell out. We were ordered to give the Indonesians everything
they wanted, and US arms were shipped straight to East Timor without Congress
knowing. I saw all the hard intelligence; the place was a free fire zone
... and all because we didn't want some little country being neutral or
leftist at the UN."
There were other, more pressing
reasons. "With the region's richest board of natural resources," wrote
Richard Nixon in 1967, "Indonesia is the greatest prize in South-East Asia."
Indonesia is where the British
empire rose again. Britain is Indonesia's largest investor in chemicals,
paper, electricity and weapons.
Name a major British multinational
and you can bet it is "investing" in Indonesia. The list ranges from Shell
and BP, to the BOC Group and Marks and Spencer to Unilever and Glaxo Wellcome,
to the rapacious Rio Tinto, which has a huge holding in the three-billion-dollar
Freeport copper-and-gold mining operation in West Papua.
However, it is the British
war industry that has provided the Jakarta gang with its most vital prop
since 1978 when Labour's Foreign Secretary David Owen dismissed estimates
of East Timorese dead as "exaggerated" and approved the sale of the first
Hawk fighter-bombers to Indonesia.
The Blair Government is Jakarta's
biggest arms supplier. While the Indonesian death squads, "cleanse" Dili,
Mr Blair has pointedly refused to use Britain's considerable economic and
military clout.
In 1994, Labour's spokesman
on foreign affairs, Robin Cook, told Parliament that Hawk aircraft had
been "observed on bombing runs in East Timor in most years since 1984".
He then denied his own words and, once in Government, allowed his underlings
at the Foreign Office to lie that no Hawks were operational in East Timor.
The point is that, between
them, Britain and the United States could stop the Indonesians in their
tracks if they wanted to. (Australia has dissipated any influence it might
have had after years of obsequious dealings with Jakarta.)
Without pressure from their
godfathers in Washington and London, the Indonesians are telling the United
Nations and the world to go to hell; and the UN is scuttling.
Who can the people of East
Timor look to? Public opinion in western countries is a greater phenomenon
for change than many realise. Are we going to let the East Timorese people,
bravest of the brave, who defied the genocidists and came out to vote for
democracy and freedom, fall before our eyes? Are we going to allow those
with the power to act, do nothing, and in our name?
An
audience with Jakarta's Dr Strangelove
The Independent (London)
- September 11, 1999
Richard Lloyd Parry -- It
is a very long drive up the palm- lined, four-lane avenue to the monolithic
headquarters of the Indonesia military just outside Jakarta, and the tension
in our car is rising. It is 9.30 in the morning and the five ambassadors
from New York are finally to meet face to face the man who wields the real
power in this country -- and the power to stop the desperate suffering
in East Timor. He is Chief General Wiranto.
Except that the meeting is
not to be with the general alone. The United Nations delegation -- and
this lone reporter, nervously tagging along incognito -- finds itself ushered
into a third-floor conference room. General Wiranto has brought out all
of his brass -- 20 generals ranged around him. The intent to intimidate
is obvious. We are severely outnumbered, our nametags are egregiously misspelt.
Never mind the cups of cold, sweet tea and pastries.
The ensuing two hours turn
almost comical -- a script, perhaps, from a Sixties war comedy, with Mel
Brooks as General Wiranto. But there is nothing funny here this week. The
chance was given to the people of East Timor to find freedom, after 24
years of brutal oppression, with the self-determination referendum, organised
by the UN, of 30 August. They voted overwhelmingly for independence.
And now that chance is being
sabotaged -- sabotaged, most say, by this man's army. General Wiranto,
an imposing man with an unsettling ability to conceal all feelings, takes
instant charge of the proceedings. His opening remarks are peppered with
bland reassurances: the TNI, the Indonesia army, is committed to respecting
the results of the ballot.
With martial law now imposed,
it is well on the way to restoring order in East Timor. The TNI does not
need the help of outside peace-keeping forces. "Our commitment to handling
the problem should not be doubted," he says.
Then comes a presentation
by his "General for Information", complete with graphs. Do they think the
UN Security Council ambassadors are stupid or blind? Some of the graphs
are surreal in their dishonesty. One depicts the numbers of "attacks, burnings
and destructions" in East Timor over 10 days since 30 August. The worst,
allegedly, was on 2 September. On that day, the graph tells us, there were
five attacks. And the number of burnings on 8 September? Just two.
The leader of the UN group
is Martin Andjaba, a former Swapo freedom fighter from Namibia and now
Namibia's UN ambassador. Finally, he takes the floor. He forsakes diplomacy.
The Indonesian government and military, he begins, have stated repeatedly
that they are doing enough now to protect the East Timorese. "We do not
believe them. The violence has continued, the oppression, the destruction
of property has continued unabated. The killing continues even as we sit
here. In fact, the situation has worsened."
Mr Andjaba does not call
Chief General Wiranto a liar, or not quite. But he does call him a failure
-- in front of his generals. "You are failing the international community,
you are failing the the people of East Timor and you are failing Indonesia,"
he continues. "Perhaps it is a question of lack of political will on your
side."
Therein resides the key question
this week: why has the TNI allowed the carnage to happen, even abetted
it? Does it intend to reduce East Timor to rubble before handing it over
to the UN -- as it is supposed to in November -- as a warning to other
areas of the country? Or does the TNI mean simply to dishonour the UN agreements
and to keep hold of the province for ever?
General Wiranto is not going
to answer that in this room. Instead, he launches into a second monologue.
All will be well. Only the TNI understands the people of East Timor. Only
the TNI can succeed in achieving reconciliation in the divided province.
The TNI, what is more, will repair the physical damage so that it can "hand
over East Timor in good condition". And how long will that take, you might
wonder? Months? Or years?
He will allow foreign humanitarian
workers into East Timor again, but the introduction of foreign peace-keepers
is another issue, "because it is relevant to the dignity of the TNI". And
he tries this: if a foreign force is brought in, bloodshed will follow
because, he argues, it will encourage the pro-independence majority to
begin attacking those opposed to independence.
At about this time General
Wiranto's control of the meeting is punctured by the trill of a mobile
phone on our side of the room. It is from the UN compound in Dili, the
capital of East Timor. Efforts to evacuate non-essential UN staff to Darwin
in Australia have been halted because the compound is under siege again
by militia wielding guns and grenades and trying to force their way in.
The general is challenged by Mr Andjaba. What is going on? Did you not
promise to arrest, even shoot, those carrying arms under martial law?
General Wiranto, however,
has his own phone and says he will get the "real information" from his
"insubordinate commander" in East Timor. (I imagine I have misheard him,
but he repeats "insubordinate" over and again.) "Such kinds of news and
rumours have been heard by me many times," he insists, "but when I check
the news I find that it is contrary to the facts." Sure enough, the "insubordinate"
is confident. General Wiranto reports: "There is no trouble, the situation
is peaceful."
Then our phone rings again
-- more news of trouble in Dili and the general, beginning to sound impatient,
promises to check a second time. Oh, so there may be some trouble, yes.
But it is only some veterans protesting, because of the proposed evacuation
of locally hired UN staff. It is nothing serious. "You must believe me,"
he tells his guests.
So this is how it is. The
UN might not be perfect. But this cameo of the absurd, with two telephones
in a single room telling two different stories, captures exactly what the
UN is up against. These events are happening now, and still General Wiranto
denies that they are happening.
It is in the midst of this
exchange that the general surpasses all with an invitation. Recently, he
has supervised the laying out of a golf course on ground here that was
to have accommodated a new police headquarters. Would the ambassadors come
and play a round with him some time? And by the way, it is called the Cobra
Course, because of all the snakes found on it. "Cobras," a UN delegate
whispers in my ear. "How appropriate."
Death
invades a church
International Herald Tribune
- September 11, 1999
Kupang, West Timor -- The
Reverend Dewanto was the first to die, said Sister Mary Barudero. The militiamen
had lined up outside the old wooden church filled with refugees in the
East Timorese town of Suai on Monday afternoon, and the young Indonesian
priest stepped out dressed in his clerical robes to meet the trouble.
A burst of gunfire cut him
down. The Reverend Francisco followed. The blood soaked his white robes.
The militiamen waited for the senior parish priest, the Reverend Hilario.
When he did not emerge, they kicked down the door to his study and sprayed
him with automatic fire.
One of the nuns watched from
the window of her nearby house at the massacre that followed, said Sister
Barudero. The militiamen entered the church filled with refugees, and began
firing long bursts from their weapons. Then they threw hand grenades into
the huddled victims. One, two, three grenades. As they left, blood flowed
down the doorstep.
Inside, there had been only
young children and women, babies at their mothers' breasts, and pregnant
women, she said. The men had fled days earlier.
"They went to the church
because that's where they felt safe," said the nun, 64, vainly fighting
her tears. "They felt being near the priests was protection."
Her account of the massacre,
which was confirmed Thursday by the Vatican, is one of the first graphic
descriptions of the violence that has wracked East Timor at the hands of
Indonesian military-backed militiamen who oppose independence for the province.
Among the first victims have
been the Roman Catholic clergy, seen by the militia as having supported
independence for East Timor. The nun, a nurse, agreed to talk because,
she said, "I have lived my life. I am not afraid to die."
Other refugees still feel
the militia's reach in the supposed safety of West Timor, and have been
warned not to talk to reporters. Sister Barudero's colleague, who watched
the massacre, has fled to Australia but still is afraid to be identified,
she said.
The fears of those in West
Timor are not exaggerated. The militiamen who have brought destruction
to East Timor have taken up control of the 84,000 refugees now in camps
in West Timor, and move around freely in the West Timor capital of Kupang.
Some are armed; some seem intent on intimidating foreigners and refugees.
Foreigners have not been allowed in the camps.
At a West Timor refugee camp
in Atambua, on the border with East Timor, a man identified as a supporter
of independence was killed Wednesday, apparently by militiamen.
An official of the Catholic
Relief Services, who just returned from Atambua, provided some confirmation
of reports that pro- Independence refugees had been forcibly removed from
East Timor.
"If you ask the refugees
once, they say they left because it was unsafe, and they had to leave their
houses," said William Openg, an Indonesian relief worker for the Catholic
services. "But if you ask again, they will tell you that the soldiers terrorized
them and made them come."
Although many in the refugee
camps are said to be opponents of independence, those who support the outcome
of the ballot may not acknowledge it.
"They are afraid to show
their face," said Agapitus Prasetya, a Unicef worker who has been in the
refugee camps. "It could cost them their lives. The militias are everywhere."
Anti-foreigner passions have
been whipped up by the militias, and even Indonesian staff members distributing
food to the refugees strip the Unicef signs off their cars, he said.
"The militias are killing
people, and the people are threatened here in West Timor," said a Catholic
clergyman who fled from Dili only to find militiamen in control of refugee
camps in West Timor. "Where is the law and order in Indonesia? The militias,
the military and the police are above the law."
He and several other clergy
members described their flight from East Timor on the condition that their
names not be used. They said they feared consequences from the Indonesian
military and Timorese militias. One sister who lived in Dili said the gunfire
began about three hours after the ballot result approving independence
was announced last Saturday.
"It was really frightening.
We couldn't go out of the house," she said. "We could see a lot of fires.
It looked like they would use diesel gas, because the fires would be big
black balls, and then you could see white smoke from houses. That was everywhere."
On Monday, she and other
nuns decided it was too dangerous, and left in an old truck in a convoy
escorted by police. As they passed through Dili, she saw a scene of fires
and lawlessness, she said.
"It was remarkable," she
said. "There was shooting going on, and people were running for their lives.
But others were looting the stores, very calmly, as though they were so
relaxed." She said she saw some looters loading goods into military trucks.
In one section, "all the
stores were razed," she said. "I saw a lot of military, and of course,
the militias. Some people were ransacking, and some people were looting.
The whole place was in ruins, except for the government buildings. And
there were a lot of people moving out, because their houses were burning."
Another member of the clergy
said that the gunfire intensified in the days and nights after the referendum
results. "God, it was frightening," he said. "There were motorcycles running
all over, bringing military and militias. You could hear the big guns of
the military going on."
On Tuesday, the water, electricity
and telephone lines were cut in his section of Dili, and he decided to
leave, said the clergyman. He passed many burned houses, he said. "It seemed
the pro-independence houses were targeted. But the referendum was approved
four-to-one, so they didn't have to go very far."
"I never saw any instance
of refugees being forced by gunpoint," said a priest. "Our people did not
want to leave. But they were told if they stayed, the houses would be burned
and they might be killed. They were forced out by fear."
The militias were particularly
strong in the western areas of East Timor, where Sister Barudero and four
other nuns ran a hospital in Suai, and where Roman Catholic priests ran
the church where the massacre occurred. Sister Barudero said she had not
intended to leave, even after the men fled, even after more victims of
the rising violence came to the hospital, even after she and her nuns had
to dig a grave for a victim on the grounds of the hospital. The victim's
family was too afraid to claim him, she said. But after the massacre, "There
was no one left to help. They had all left or been killed.
"And I knew, if we stayed,
we could be killed," she said. "I am old. I'm ready to die. But the young
sisters would not go unless I went. They have many years left to help people.
Finally, I said, pack what you can. We will leave."
Forced
to turn a blind eye to a massacre
International Herald Tribune
- September 12, 1999
A. Lin Neumann, Bangkok --
When machete-wielding thugs set upon journalists in East Timor after the
territory's August 30 vote for independence, it looked like another gruesome
case of the press caught between warring sides. Deplorable, yes, but it
comes with the territory if you choose to cover the front lines in conflict
zones.
Look again. Something far
more cynical is at work this time. The Indonesian government -- or at some
command level, the military - has used armed gangs to rid East Timor of
witnesses to the terror to come.
With few exceptions, the
press corps covering East Timor has now been evacuated. And when you remove
the press from a story, you remove the world's eyes. As atrocities continue,
we are prevented from seeing, learning and judging the scope of the tragedy.
The damage to Indonesia's
credibility and its fragile democracy is incalculable. Since former President
Suharto stepped aside last year, Asians and many others have watched in
amazement as the Indonesian media blossomed with a vibrancy that seemed
to dissipate the dark shadows of Mr. Suharto's New Order regime.
East Timor demonstrates that
the shadows remain. If armed gangs can hound out the international press
in a small, disputed territory, how might such forces behave in a larger
crisis, such as the one now building over the National Parliament's selection
of a president in November?
There were no casualties
among the correspondents covering East Timor. While that is a relief, it
also looks like part of the larger plan. It is evident enough that those
supporting the gangs concluded that a correspondent's death would create
too big a problem.
Dozens of journalists have
testified that the military and police not only watched gun-toting terrorists
pummel correspondents and invade hotels; they also intervened to see that
the beatings stopped short of lethal force. This indicates a high degree
of control over supposedly uncontrollable thugs.
When the BBC's Jonathan Head
suffered a broken arm the day after the vote, other reporters at the scene
saw a man quietly step into the fray with the words, "That's enough."
James Hutchison, a Reuters
Television correspondent, watched about 400 soldiers and police officers
do nothing when a militia member opened fire on the last functioning hotel
in East Timor, the Mahkota. The terrorist aimed at satellite dishes and
microwave uplink facilities on the hotel's roof. "It would seem it was
pure intimidation to get us out of East Timor," Mr. Hutchison said afterward.
"And it worked."
Jakarta's calculation that
the press can be harassed out of the picture speaks volumes about its lack
of commitment to democratic institutions and the democratic process. This
underscores the international community's responsibilities, since the UN
sponsored the East Timor referendum.
Any peacekeepers sent to
the territory now must include media protection among their duties. President
B.J. Habibie must be called to task for attempting to blind the world.
UN
team visits Timor as Jakarta feels heat
Reuters - September 11, 1999
Vorasit Satienlerk, Dili
-- A UN Security Council team toured the ruined capital of East Timor on
Saturday as the world community drew up plans for a security force to restore
peace to the bloodied territory.
The UN Security Council was
due to open debate on East Timor on Saturday after Secretary-General Kofi
Annan told Indonesia it could face responsibility for crimes against humanity
there unless it allowed peacekeepers in.
Jakarta is under huge pressure
to halt the massacres, carried out by anti-independence militia angered
by the territory's recent, overwhelming vote in favour of ending Indonesian
rule.
The UN Mission in East Timor
(UNAMET) on Saturday reported a lull in violence around its compound in
the capital, Dili.
The five-member Security
Council team, in Dili on an inspection mission, travelled with armed forces
chief General Wiranto amid heavy security.
A UNAMET spokesman said the
night had been quiet with only sporadic shooting around the compound in
Dili, scarred by days of murder, burning and looting. Thousands have been
killed and the United Nations has voiced concerns about serious food shortages.
US President Bill Clinton
blamed the Indonesian military for backing the killings by pro-Jakarta
militiamen and also urged Indonesia to accept foreign peacekeepers. Jakarta
said on Saturday an international peacekeeping force was an option. But
it has yet to give any go-ahead.
Dili's houses have been torched
and residents are either dead or have fled. UNAMET now offers symbolic
protection to a dwindling group of pro-independence refugees, many of whom
have fled for the hills behind the UN compound.
Mission official Pat O'Sullivan
said there were about 1,000 refugees still in the compound and there was
enough food.
"There are a lot of children
running about which makes it difficult to make an exact count. Their mood
is good, under the circumstances," he said. A member of the Security Council
mission, British delegate Jeremy Greenstock, said before leaving for East
Timor: "We are not going to go to war with Indonesia on this."
"It needs to be with the
cooperation of Indonesia. I think Indonesia now realises that the burden
of security has to be shared."
Security Council president
Peter van Walsum said the council would await the return of the team to
New York before adopting any resolution or issuing a formal statement.
The mission has been trying
to persuade Indonesia to allow an international force to go to East Timor
to quell the violence in the former Portuguese colony that Indonesia annexed
in 1976. But Indonesia has insisted it can handle the situation alone.
Clinton, in New Zealand for
a summit of Asia-Pacific leaders, said Indonesia must request a UN peacekeeping
force. Asked when this might happen, he said: "I think you'll see a development
in the next couple of days."
"Today we suspended all military
sales and we continue to work to persuade the Indonesians to support a
United Nations operation to go in and secure the safety of the people there
and that's what we have to continue to do," Clinton said.
The United States and other
nations are unwilling to send in peacekeepers without an invitation from
Indonesia, the world's largest Moslem nation.
Australian Prime Minister
John Howard said Australia, New Zealand, Malaysia, Britain, Canada, the
Philippines and Portugal had given firm commitments to participate in a
UN-mandated peacekeeping force if Indonesia consented.
Howard, also at the New Zealand
summit, said the United States, Sweden, Thailand and France had agreed
in principle to support such a force in a way that had yet to be defined.
He had said previously that
up to 8,000 peacekeepers would be needed for such a force, which Australia
would lead. Dramatic television footage brought in to Darwin showed the
storming this week of a Red Cross compound in Dili.
Refugees cowered under fire
from pro-Jakarta militia wearing red and white bandanas -- Indonesia's
national colours. Women and children were herded from the building as Indonesian
police, some drunk and asking the cameraman for beer, sat and watched.
A spokeswoman for East Timor resistance leader Jose Ramos-Horta said Clinton
had agreed to meet him on Monday.
US Treasury Secretary Lawrence
Summers said on Friday the International Monetary Fund and World Bank should
make any lending to Indonesia contingent on how it handles East Timor.
Civilians
'being attacked in the hills'
South China Morning Post
- September 11, 1999
Barry Porter, Auckland --
Resistance leader and Nobel peace laureate Jose Ramos Horta said yesterday
he had received reports that pro-Jakarta forces had begun attacking East
Timor hillsides where unarmed civilians had taken refuge.
He warned that tens of thousands
of women, children and the elderly would die over the next few days. "If
they do not die of slaughter, they will die of starvation," said Mr Ramos
Horta, claiming the hills could not cope with such an influx.
He said he had received witness
accounts of four truckloads of civilians being blown up on the outskirts
of Dili. Bodies were being dumped into the sea and there had been "thousands"
of deaths in the Dili area alone over the past few days, he claimed. "Hundreds
of others are being killed elsewhere," he said.
Mr Ramos Horta described
it as a "preordained, predetermined" campaign of violence by Indonesian
military factions opposed to the East Timorese people's recent overwhelming
vote for independence.
Given that countries such
as the United States, Australia, Britain and Canada had sold the Indonesians
weapons and provided military training, Mr Ramos Horta said they could
shoulder some of the blame.
He also said that if the
UN Security Council, New Zealand, Australia and other countries insisted
an invitation had to come from Jakarta before intervention, "they will
be accomplices in this genocide".
Mr Ramos Horta said he did
not understand why world leaders could intervene to halt mass deportation
and killings in Kosovo without seeking Serbia's consent but needed an invitation
from Jakarta when no UN members other than Australia officially recognised
Indonesia's sovereignty over East Timor.
In particular, Mr Ramos Horta
called on China to fulfil its UN Security Council obligations -- "if not
for the East Timorese, for their own people", he said, referring to the
killing and rape of ethnic Chinese in Indonesia last year.
Victims
'left to die' on streets where they fell
South China Morning Post
- September 11, 1999
Most of the East Timorese
killed in the violence that has swept the capital, Dili, were left to die
where they fell on the street, a French doctor who treated hundreds of
wounded in a city clinic said yesterday.
The Medecins du Monde doctor,
who fled the territory on Wednesday, said he had treated 200 wounded, including
30 children, in the past five weeks.
"It was mainly gunshot wounds,
both homemade guns and automatic weapons. We also had a lot of machete
wounds and stabbings," he said in Darwin.
"I only saw a small amount
of the total number of wounded. It was so dangerous to come to the clinic
that people often didn't even try. "The bodies were left where they were."
The doctor asked not to be
named as he hoped to return to East Timor. "Part of the team is trying
to get back to East Timor. We want to be back in position soon. But I can't
get through to the clinic, nor to the [Carmelite] sisters there. Maybe
the clinic burned down."
Allegations of widespread
killing in East Timor's turmoil are sweeping fast-growing border refugee
camps, where an estimated 50,000 people shelter under the gaze of militiamen
accused of creating the mayhem.
The UN said yesterday it
was investigating reports of executions of East Timorese independence supporters
in Indonesian West Timor.
Commenting on unconfirmed
reports of massacres in the Indonesian territory, UN mission spokesman
David Wimhurst cited sources which claimed to have eyewitness accounts
that independence activists had been summarily executed in front of witnesses
in West Timor. "I don't have any idea of the numbers," he said.
Many frightened refugees
said they were forcibly sent across the border to camps controlled by the
same army and militias spreading terror at home.
An Australian human rights
group yesterday accused Indonesian soldiers of posing as United Nations
Assistance Mission in East Timor (Unamet) staff to encourage East Timorese
to leave the territory.
"The military, posing as
Unamet, is telling East Timorese that Unamet is encouraging them to leave
East Timor," the Melbourne- based East Timor Human Rights Centre said.
It quoted witnesses as saying
some Indonesian soldiers in East Timor were wearing Unamet uniforms, including
the mission's blue berets.
The tens of thousands who
huddled under blue and orange plastic tarpaulins in one camp near Atambua,
20km west of the border, swapped horror stories, but reports of large-scale
killings were impossible to confirm.
"I saw some dead. But I don't
know how many or who killed them. I just tried to get out quickly," said
Jesus da Costa, a taxi driver who fled Dili on Tuesday at the height of
the violence.
The mass military evacuation
of East Timorese to West Timor continued yesterday as the Indonesian Government
announced 21 billion rupiah and 1,500 tonnes of rice had been earmarked
for the refugees in West Timor. But the state Antara news agency said there
was nothing on offer for those left behind.
News
vacuum as reporters go missing
South China Morning Post
- September 11, 1999
Vaudine England, Jakarta
-- Indonesia's Alliance of Independent Journalists has issued an "urgent
action" statement listing several Indonesian journalists missing in East
Timor, as concerns grow about the difficulty of finding out what is happening
in the territory.
Peter Rohe, a journalist
with the Jakarta-based Suara Bangsa daily, last made contact with his editor
on Tuesday morning. Two freelance reporters are also missing in the territory:
Joaquim Rohi and Mindho Rajagoekgoek, who reports for Radio Netherlands.
Tri Agus Siswowohardjo, a
journalist, former political prisoner and member of the local ballot monitoring
group, Kiper, is in hiding somewhere in East Timor.
Reports filtering through
from the handful of foreign journalists left in the besieged United Nations
compound in Dili, and statements from church groups, refugees and independence
activists, suggest a devastating pattern of atrocities committed across
the territory.
East Timorese who have escaped
speak of scores of people being rounded up, the men separated and presumed
killed. No independent witnesses are available.
Experienced journalists in
Jakarta are reminded of the time lag and the stages of disbelief suffered
when they tried to report on the early stages of Cambodia's tragedy from
1975 to 1979, during which time the Khmer Rouge instituted their "Ground
Zero" policy of mass extermination.
"In our case, it was the
volume of evidence from refugees," said John MacBeth, now bureau chief
for the Far Eastern Economic Review in Indonesia. "We were not surprised
when the killing fields were later discovered.
"Lots of the people coming
out had never actually witnessed the killing, they spoke of people who
had disappeared, or the sight of Khmer Rouge returning with blood on their
shoes after taking people away.
"But the most credible reports
were from those who were only hours out. Once people get into refugee camps,
the danger is they're repeating stories from other refugees."
Indonesian military and militias
active in West Timor are severely restricting the ability of journalists
to obtain those first-hand reports.
Journalists remaining in
Dili are subject to the pressures of the lengthy and frightening siege
of the UN compound and a growing anger at the Indonesian military's behaviour
"It now appears that the
forced removal of the press corps from East Timor is part of a deliberate
strategy by the pro- Jakarta militias, and perhaps their allies in the
Indonesian military itself, to deny the world access to the story of East
Timor," said the Bangkok-based Southeast Asian Press Alliance.
Four Indonesian activists
are also missing, said Ging Ginanjar, head of advocacy for the Alliance
of Independent Journalists. His statement named Yeni Rosa Damayanti, Adi
Pratomo, Anthony Listianto and Yakob Rumbiak, all of whom worked for Kiper
and have student activist or political prisoner backgrounds.
Australia's state-run broadcaster
has extended its "Radio Australia" service to East Timor, and plans to
reach parts of central and western Indonesia from today, an official said.but
simply a chaos produced by the actions of the militias and the plots of
some officers, compounded by the cowardice of decision makers, military
and civilian. The Indonesian establishment has to grasp that its foolishness
is profoundly damaging to Indonesia as well as East Timor. It is time to
live up to the responsibilities that the word "Merdeka" implies.
Refugees
may be used as bargaining chips
The Melbourne Age - September
11, 1999
Craig Skehan Kupang and Greg
Roberts Brisbane -- Aid and church groups are concerned that thousands
of East Timorese refugees in camps in West Timor could be used as bargaining
chips in Indonesia's stand-off with the international community.
These concerns have been
heightened by the refusal of authorities to allow independent monitoring
of the camps and reports that thousands of East Timorese are being forcibly
driven across the border by the Indonesian military.
Indonesian soldiers, police
and anti-independence militia are tightly controlling access to refugee
camps and are imposing tough restrictions on the foreign media. Indonesian
authorities argue that the refugees are opponents of independence.
UN officials in the West
Timorese capital Kupang today estimated that at least 68,000 East Timorese
refugees had come across the border while Catholic Church sources in the
West Timorese town of Atambua say up to 100,000 refugees have been crowded
into just four camps.
The Catholic Church is worried
about the safety of the refugees after the reported murder of two pro-independence
East Timorese men in Atambua yesterday by militia members. A church official
said the men were singled out and shot in front of dozens of other refugees.
Church sources in Atambua
and Kupang said militia members had a strong presence in West Timorese
territory along the road between Atambua and the border, an 80-minute drive,
and were stopping vehicles heading west.
Although it is not possible
to confirm the figures, sources in Atambua said more than 40,000 refugees
had arrived by yesterday afternoon. Many are staying in church buildings.
Some have been taken in by West Timorese families. Others are camped in
the open.
In the town of Kepa, 25,000
refugees have arrived. There are about 20,000 in the village of Soa and
another 20,000 in Betun. An unknown number are in Kupang and other West
Timorese centres, with Amnesty International claiming 8000 are in the town
of Kefamenanu.
In Atambua, Catholic workers
have asked the Indonesian Government for medical supplies to cope with
the refugee flow, and water is in short supply in some places.
With most refugees doing
their best to stay away from Government-run camps in West Timor, the province's
two bishops -- Bishop Petrus Turang of Kupang and Bishop Antonius Tain
Ratu of Atambua -- have opened the doors of church property to the East
Timorese.
The leading contender to
become President of Indonesia, Mrs Megawati Sukarnoputri, arrived in Kupang,
where she was enthusiastically greeted by the Governor of East Timor, Abilio
Soares, a strong opponent of independence.
He said the Indonesian Parliament
could refuse to ratify East Timor's vote for independence.
Indonesian journalists were
allowed to film and photograph Mrs Megawati. Mrs Megawati's staff warned
foreign journalists not to follow a convoy to refugee camps on the outskirts
of Kupang because it would be "too dangerous".
Australia,
UN were warned before voting
The Melbourne Age - September
11, 1999
Brendan Nicholson, Canberra
-- The United Nations and Australia encouraged the Timorese to vote even
though intelligence services had warned that the Indonesian military was
orchestrating a violent campaign to hold on to the territory.
The strongest warning was
delivered on 4 March by Australia's Defence Intelligence Organisation,
which warned that the Indonesian military was "clearly protecting and in
some cases operating with" the militia groups.
Although the weight of intelligence
analysis made it clear there was no evidence that the Indonesian military
would soften its approach, the political decision was taken to accept President
B.J. Habibie's assurance that his forces would ensure a peaceful transition.
The same intelligence analysts
were last night trying to work out how many East Timorese died since they
cast their first vote and the real slaughter began. When this warning was
delivered, the official Australian response was that the militias were
being supported by rogue elements within the military.
The DIO's view was that the
lack of any vigorous action by the commander of the Indonesian armed forces,
General Wiranto, to rein in his forces implied he was at least turning
a blind eye.
Australian intelligence was
able to keep track of militia activities by monitoring the mobile phones
used by their leaders and the satellite phones used by Indonesian military
commanders to communicate with Jakarta.
Australian military intelligence
operatives have intercepted "damning" conversations between militia leaders
and commanders in the field.
In July, leaked Indonesian
Government documents predicted a win for independence supporters, and outlined
a scorched-earth plan. The memo, dated 3 July, said Jakarta should put
the army on alert and consider increasing its support for the militia groups.
Early last month an Atlanta-based
watchdog group, the Carter Centre, said the Indonesian armed forces were
continuing to support the militia groups. If anyone had any doubts about
the quality of the warnings, these should have vanished when a militia
gang led an attack on a UN regional office in Maliana, on the border with
West Timor. UN staff there included three Australian Federal Police officers.
A comprehensive report, prepared
by the Department of Foreign Affairs with the help of senior military intelligence
officers, was handed to the UN by the Foreign Minister, Mr Alexander Downer.
The intelligence warnings were not ignored completely.
Australia and the UN accused
the Indonesian military of arming and supporting the militia but the decision
was taken to push on with the ballot and to rely on the Indonesia forces
to prevent violence. In July 1998, Mr Lansell Taudevin, who ran an Australian
Government aid project in East Timor, warned officials at Australia's embassy
in Jakarta that the Indonesian army was arming and training militia.
Mr Taudevin said he was convinced
the worst of the bloodshed could have been avoided if Australia had heeded
such warnings and applied more pressure on Jakarta earlier to rein in those
supporting the militia groups.
A
ride with the militia saves a man
The Melbourne Age - September
11, 1999
John Aglionby, Kupang --
When Ano Loy saw five Indonesian soldiers walking towards his home in Dili
on Monday he was sure they were going to kill him. "They were carrying
guns and cans of petrol. All the houses around mine were already empty,
so they could only have been coming to me."
Mr Loy, a senior member of
East Timor's pro-independence movement, described his extraordinary escape
to safety yesterday as he embarked on the final leg from West Timor --
the adjoining territory to East Timor -- to the Indonesian capital Jakarta.
For the previous two days
-- after the announcement by the United Nations of East Timor's overwhelming
vote for independence from Indonesia -- Mr Loy (not his real name) had
seen the army and the pro-Jakarta militias systematically begin the destruction
of Dili.
"They had already driven
thousands of people from their homes and killed many," he said. "It was
my turn now. My luck had run out."
The soldiers, dressed in
combat uniform, bandannas made of Indonesia's red and white flag and wearing
warpaint on their faces, did not open fire. Instead they gave Mr Loy, 48,
an ultimatum.
"They said I had to leave,
to go to the port or the police station, or else they would kill me and
burn the house. Luckily they did not recognise me or else I am sure they
would have killed me immediately."
To prove they meant business,
the soldiers doused both the neighboring houses in petrol and set them
alight. By the time Mr Loy was ready to leave, his was the only house in
the neighborhood not on fire. He is convinced it is now a smouldering ruin.
Just as he, his wife and
his children were about to leave, a young man ran into the house telling
a terrible story. He had come from the port, where he and some pro-independence
friends had been trying to leave on a ship. The women boarded, but the
men were dragged away. Five were stabbed in front of him and their bodies
dumped in the sea.
Mr Loy decided it would be
a death sentence to take his family either to the already overcrowded port
or to the police station teeming with more than 10,000 refugees.
"They would definitely have
known me at both places and I had heard that families were being separated
and did not want to risk not seeing my wife and children again."
So he took an even bigger
risk. His family and some other friends asked to join people the militia
were forcibly taking in trucks to the border.
"I had no choice. If I wanted
to survive I knew I had to get out. By the time we left there were 124
people in seven vehicles -- five pick-ups, one truck and one Jeep.
We were so squashed in but
I knew it was our only hope. Almost everyone was crying and sobbing. They
had no idea where they were being taken to." The road to the border was
packed with vehicles. "Many were not moving. They were just by the roadside.
Others were destroyed or burnt."
It took seven hours to reach
the border, a journey that normally takes less than three. "The advantage
of driving with the militia was that we had no problems with the roadblocks."
Mr Loy had disguised himself by brushing his hair differently and wearing
a large pair of gold-rimmed glasses.
The scene at the border post
at Batugade was chaos. "Cars, trucks and people were everywhere. But this
helped us as the soldiers were so overwhelmed ... once again we were just
waved through."
After another three hours
the convoy stopped for the night in the town of Keva. "There were people
everywhere, including many, many militiamen. They were all so proud of
what they had done in East Timor, how many houses they had burnt, how many
people they had killed for the sake of Indonesia."
Mr Loy's wife told her husband
he should go on alone. "She said it was more important for me to get to
Jakarta to tell pro- independence leader Jose "Xanana" Gusmao what was
happening."
Police
station piled with dead
The Melbourne Age - September
11, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch Dili and
Craig Skehan Kupang -- Piles of bodies have been seen stacked in cells
at the police headquarters in Dili, while East Timorese forced to flee
into Indonesian West Timor have arrived with accounts of murder and continuing
intimidation by Indonesian militias.
The bodies were seen on Wednesday
by Mrs Ina Bradridge, the Timorese wife of an Australian aid worker, Mr
Isa Bradridge, when the couple were taken to the police compound during
this week's violence.
Mr Bradridge, of Ballina
in New South Wales, said his wife spotted the bodies as she walked the
corridors of the police station looking for a toilet. They were in a building
she said was once used as a torture cell for political prisoners.
"My wife told me she saw
bodies stacked high, thousands of them," Mr Bradridge said. "She smelt
the bodies," he said. "I know it is hard to believe, but it is absolutely
true. My wife saw arms and legs and dripping blood."
Across the border in West
Timor, people forced to flee their homeland have arrived in Kupang with
accounts of murder and Indonesian militia violence, which continued even
when they had left East Timor.
The refugees, some of whom
say they were forcibly expelled, have told aid workers of their ordeal,
amid reports that militia using stolen United Nations vehicles are "hunting"
for independence supporters.
The head of Indonesia's National
Human Rights Commission, Mr Marzuki Darusman, warned today of a "state
of lawlessness" in West Timor.
A spokesman for the Catholic
aid agency Caritas said in Sydney that the treatment of those forced from
East Timor "would have to rank among the crimes of the century". Mr John
Scott-Murphy told a Senate inquiry that those forced across the border
were being held hostage.
"These people should be viewed
as hostages rather than as refugees and it's entirely possible that is
the objective in trucking them across the border," Mr Scott-Murphy said.
An estimated 8000 refugees
have arrived in Kupang on evacuation flights and on ships, but tens of
thousands more have made the dangerous journey into West Timor by road.
Survivors say militia gangs
have intercepted groups of refugees and singled out those believed to be
independence activists. Most refugees now in West Timor have been herded
into camps that are tightly controlled by militia and Indonesian police
and soldiers.
One distraught man told how
militiamen slaughtered defenceless refugees in an East Timor Catholic church
compound.
Another watched terrified
at the West Timor port of Atapupu as militia used machetes to kill men
alleged to be independence supporters. The victims were among people who
arrived by ship from Dili.
"Other men had their hands
tied and they were put on trucks and taken away," said a source who is
collecting accounts for presentation to the international community. "Militia
are checking all the people that are coming in there."
In another incident, four
people accused of being pro- independence activists were stabbed to death
while trying to board a ship.
People arriving in Kupang
who do not have local family or friends are taken to camps on the edge
of the town by Indonesian authorities, the biggest of which is Noelbaki.
Foreign media trying to talk to refugees at the camp have been attacked
by militia.
Members of a United Nations
High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) team left West Timor after they
were assaulted and their vehicle destroyed at the camp.
Underground support groups
are being established to get people in danger to safe houses or to other
parts of Indonesia.
"Many people who are pro-independence
are pretending to be pro-autonomy," one source said. "It is like when Jews
were trying to travel across occupied Europe." Aid officials expect the
number of refugees in West Timor to reach 100,000 in coming days.
One aid worker who is on
the run said there are reports of killings in Balibo, west of Dili. "The
big danger now is to refugees in West Timor because in many areas the militia
are in control," he said. "And the militia are still being being directed
by the Indonesian military."
Humanitarian workers say
large numbers of refugees are emotionally shattered because they believed
the UN team in East Timor would protect them. They talk of the narrow roads
from the east being "badlands" where roadblocks instill renewed terror.
The circumstances of people
being put on trucks and bused to West Timor differ. Aid workers say some
are the families of pro- Indonesia activists and militia members. In other
cases, independence supporters are being expelled for fear they will testify
on the participation of Indonesian police and military in acts of violence.
And aid workers talk of a
third category. "Some people are willing to get on trucks because their
villages are burning around them and many people are dead," one source
said. "It is matter of degrees of bad."
'Stacks
of bodies went up to the roof'
Sydney Morning Herald - September
11, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch who arrived
in Darwin from Dili -- The destruction of the capital is greater than anybody
could imagine. Hundreds of houses are blackened shells. The doors of government
offices are ajar. Banks, cafes, hotels, boarding houses, service stations:
all burnt or trashed.
One building -- the police
station -- hides one of the most shocking of many shocking stories that
have emerged so far from East Timor's killing fields.
Two days ago Ina Bradridge,
wife of Mr Isa Bradridge, 45, of Ballina, walked the corridors of the station
looking for a toilet.
According to Mr Bradridge,
who told her story last night after evacuation to Darwin, she happened
to glance inside a large building that she knew was once used as a torture
cell for political prisoners.
"My wife told me she saw
bodies. Thousands of them. Stacks of bodies went up to the roof. I know
it is hard to believe but it is absolutely true. My wife saw arms and legs
and dripping blood."
Now, from the safety of Australia,
Mr Bradridge plans to do a lot of talking on behalf of his wife, who can't
speak English, in the next few days. "They [the Indonesian military] are
going to obliterate everybody," he said before boarding one of the evacuation
trucks with his family. The East Timorese have a choice ... they either
leave or die."
Leaving Dili to fly out in
the same RAAF shuttles that take out the Bainbridges, we drive in silence
through the mass destruction, past street after street of smouldering ruin.
There are looters and thugs
carrying pistols who walk with the arrogant swagger of the victor. But
Dili is basically empty. In five days 70,000 people have gone.
The bare-footed teenagers
with fresh fish tied to their poles are gone. The clapped-out taxis, the
naked kids playing on the debris-strewn beachfront, the old people hawking
Portuguese-era coins who used to bother us at the hotel, the people who
used to sit in the gutter every morning and read the local newspaper. All
gone.
Dreadful things have happened:
here is a child's bike twisted in the middle of the road; here are pools
of dark liquid on the pavement. It looks like blood.
Our drive from the besieged
United Nations compound starts with a volley of shots from Indonesian soldiers
who are supposed to be guarding us. We all duck for cover, even the 12
soldiers armed with AK-47 rifles who have been ordered to act as human
shields on each truck.
We think it's a pretty good
bet the thugs on the streets, most of whom we suspect are Indonesian police
or soldiers, will not want to hurt their own people. But nobody believes
the word of the Indonesian military any more, not in Dili anyway.
Streets are littered with
burnt-out buses, cars, and motorbikes. Nobody has bothered to move them
out of the way.
Many buildings have BMP or
Aitarak painted on them. BMP stands for Besi Merah Puti or Red and White
Iron, the militia group based in Liquica, 40 kilometres west of Dili. Aitarak
or Thorn is the name of a Dili-based thugs who do the military's dirty
work.
On one building somebody
has scrawled in Bahasa Indonesian: "the result of a wrong choice", a reference
to the August 30 ballot when 78.5 per cent of eligible people voted for
independence. We pass under a blue banner which declares that after East
Timor's ballot the UN will stay.
We all believed that once,
before this evil madness. But here they are departing in fear, almost 500
UN civilian police, international staff and 350 Timorese who were employed
by the UN. Only a small group stay behind to try to ensure there is not
a slaughter of hundreds of refugees who have been living with us for days
in the compound, scared of an attack. We embrace and shed a few tears;
hardship provides strong bonds of friendship.
Only a few hundred metres
from the compound, trucks parked outside a military barracks are loaded
high with furniture. These killers are going, but when? And here is the
clue to how to stay alive in Dili: display a red and white cloth, the colours
of Indonesia's flag. Every truck in the barracks is draped in red and white.
A lone man on the pushbike
wears a red and white headband. Soldiers wear red and white patches. Even
the military truck taking us to the airport has a red and white cloth tied
to the side mirror.
Our drivers choose a route
clear of debris. Past the Catholic cathedral, the one built by the Indonesians,
which is untouched, unlike the waterfront home and chapel of Bishop Carlos
Belo.
There was terrible bloodshed
there when the militia, soldiers and police attacked refugees last Tuesday.
You only had to look at the bloodstains to establish that. The truck we
are in drives slowly past the Portuguese restaurant where we enjoyed fresh
fish most nights and where the militia came one night and made a noose,
indicating they wanted to kill some journalists.
The real business end of
town is now in the western outskirts in a suburb called Comora. We drive
past the two-storey Australian consulate, which was abandoned in great
haste two days ago after the militia had spent two days terrorising the
diplomats.
The high-iron gate is open
and Indonesian soldiers are walking inside. We see the militia in greater
numbers along the road from the consulate, towards the airport. One pushes
an empty trolley, his head down, almost running. But it's hard to imagine
there's anything left to loot.
It is here that for the first
time we see ordinary people. Hundreds of women and children are camped
out in the grounds of Dili's main police station.
We were greatly relieved
to see an RAAF Hercules plane and Australian troops waiting to greet us
at Dili airport.
They were tense and business-like,
searching our bags and checking names off lists. Shortly before we fly
out of the town hidden by thick smoke a Garuda 747 landed and taxied to
the vandalised arrival and departure hall.
Commercial flights had stopped
days ago so I asked a soldier what it was doing here. "There will be three
Garuda flights today to take people to other parts of Indonesia. There
will be nothing left for them here. There will be many flights."
As I walked to the plane,
dozens of refugees being herded off trucks waved. They were the waves of
desperate people.
Herded,
sifted and cut off
The Guardian - September
10, 1999
When Sister Margaret arrived
in Kupang yesterday after a 30- minute flight from East Timor's capital
Dili, she suddenly realised how lucky she was to be a nun. "I was able
to go off with the other sisters and priests to the bishop's house. I was
not herded into a truck like an animal and driven off to a camp. We managed
to retain some dignity."
For most of the tens of thousands
of refugees now in West Timor, dignity is in short supply. Whether they
have arrived from East Timor by land, sea or air, the welcome is the same.
They are whisked off by police and soldiers to camps guarded by pro- Indonesian
militiamen and dumped there for processing.
The first stage is political
identification, according to Manuel, an East Timorese who was able to get
into the Noelbaki camp eight miles outside Kupang. He said when people
arrived their names were checked off against a list of 20,000 known pro-
Jakarta supporters. If they were on it, or could demonstrate support for
Indonesia, they were put to one side.
All the others were taken
to another part of the camp. Here the conditions are much worse, with people
squashed together with little food and water.
"Many of the men are then
'taken away for questioning'," said Manuel. "The women have no idea what
happens to their husbands. Many have not returned."
One woman said a militia
camp guard told her: "You may have got your country but it will be a land
full of widows." The woman had arrived in Noelbaki with her husband and
two children on Monday.
She has not seen her husband
since. Contact with the outside world is all but cut off. People deemed
to be pro-independence are not allowed to leave the camps and no foreigners
are welcome.
Foreign journalists and members
of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees have been stoned, attacked
and harassed whenever they have tried to get near the refugees.
In a highly unusual move,
no international aid agencies have been asked to provide relief, even though
an estimated 100,000 refugees have entered West Timor in the last week.
"Everywhere else in Indonesia
-- the government is desperate for our assistance," said the head of one
European aid organisation's Kupang office. "But here it is as if they have
something to hide."
That something is the forcible
eviction and relocation of tens of thousands of people -- supposedly to
remove them from the violence, but clearly designed to disrupt the move
towards East Timorese independence.
Piet A. Tallo, the provincial
governor in West Timor, denies there is any deliberate relocation of the
population. "We anticipated a crisis like this and we are doing our best
to handle it," he said. "However it is clear that the refugees cannot stay
in the camps forever so we have to move them on."
Resentment against the refugees
is rising among the local population. An Australian aid worker living in
West Timor said the new arrivals would find it very hard to settle. "It
appears the government is trying to make life as hard as possible for them."
UN
compound looted in East Timor
Associated Press - September
10, 1999 (slightly abridged)
Patrick Mcdowell, Jakarta
-- Drunk on stolen beer, pro- Indonesian militiamen looted the UN compound
in East Timor on Friday, smashing equipment and terrifying East Timorese
still inside after most of the UN staff were evacuated.
As Indonesian troops fired
guns to intimidate the 80 remaining UN workers, several journalists and
hundreds of refugees, militia extremists chanted for them to be burned
out. Gunfire sent two elderly women scrambling over the wall into the compound,
shredding their arms on barbed wire. Estimates of the death toll in East
Timor has ranged from 600 to 7,000.
In New York, UN Secretary
General Kofi Annan said martial law has failed to restore order in East
Timor and urged Indonesia to accept foreign military help.
"The time has clearly come
for Indonesia to seek help from the international community to fulfill
its responsibility to bring order and security to the people of East Timor,"
he told a news conference.
Even though Australia, New
Zealand, France and many other countries have offered troops to a peacekeeping
force, Annan said all governments "have made it clear that it's too dangerous
for them to go in without the consent of Indonesia." In Jakarta, the defense
minister, Gen. Wiranto, said: "We do not reject the UN peacekeeping force,
but it is not the appropriate time."
Protesters in Jakarta, Indonesia's
capital, protested the international pressure on their country by urinating
and smearing chicken dung on US and Australian flags before burning them.
President Clinton called
the attacks on the compound "simply unacceptable," and said it was clear
the Indonesian military was "aiding and abetting the militia violence."
Clinton was in Hawaii on his way to a Pacific Rim summit in New Zealand.
Clinton's statement came
a day after he suspended the Pentagon's few formal contacts with the Indonesian
military and threatened to suspend economic assistance to the country.
Comparisons to Kosovo and
Cambodia have increasingly been made as television footage shows men, women
and children, their hands raised, being herded at gunpoint from burning
homes. Indonesia calls the claims of forcible deportation "nonsense," but
UN officials report that an estimated quarter of the 850,000 East Timorese
have fled their homes.
At least four UN staffers
were killed by militiamen in the past week. About 350 staffers were evacuated
Friday from the compound in Dili and flown to Darwin, Australia.
Those who stayed behind were
awaiting a visit Saturday by a team of ambassadors from the UN Security
Council. "Morale is actually pretty high," a UN information officer said
in a telephone interview. "We're all happy we were able to stay." But the
conditions around the compound could not be described as cheerful.
Militiamen drunk on looted
beer entered the parking lot outside the walls and demanded several UN
vehicles, UN officials said. The militiamen were refused, so they smashed
up the vehicles and looted whatever they could.
A UN official said some of
the refugees left the compound and fled into the surrounding hills. As
they were climbing uphill, shots were fired at them. The government has
acknowledged the existence of rogue army elements and claims the problems
can be solved through martial law imposed earlier this week.
However, the thoroughness
of the savagery and depopulation in the past week suggests complicity at
a very high level. Refugees who have been forcibly shipped to neighboring
West Timor remain under the control of the Indonesian military and the
militias. Foreign journalists and aid workers have been threatened and
attacked if they try to enter.
Meanwhile, Bishop Carlos
Belo, the spiritual leader of East Timor, arrived in Lisbon on his way
to Rome for an audience with Pope John Paul II. He called for a war crimes
tribunal. "We can verify that there is a genocide, a cleansing," said Belo,
co- winner of the 1996 Nobel Peace Prize. The crisis has threatened the
stability of this country of 216 million people scattered across 13,000
islands, simmering in turmoil since longtime dictator Suharto was toppled
in street protests last year.
Time
to pray, and run the militia gauntlet
Sydney Morning Herald - September
10, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili --
Pat Burgess wipes away the tears. He doesn't want to make the life-or-death
decision. The Australian political officer working for the United Nations
has just been told that staff and their dependants, including Timorese,
are evacuating from the besieged UN compound in Dili.
But everybody inside knows
that if we leave behind 1,500 refugees who have crammed with us into the
compound the young men among them would be accused of being pro-independence
and probably killed.
Burgess, like many other
UN staff, hates the decision to evacuate that was made on the other side
of the world in New York. But he has no choice. "Tell the young men to
run," he tells his interpreter, wiping away more tears.
Burgess knows very well the
lies that Indonesia's military and police officers have told the UN for
months. Promises that the Indonesian armed forces and police would not
harm the refugees mean nothing. Asked what he thinks will happen to the
women and children, he says: "They will probably rape the women."
Families sit around candles
and pray for a long time. Some weep. They talk in whispers. These are intimate
moments we do not want to disturb. Only the gunshots and distant explosions
break the near silence.
But as the night wears on
we step over babies and children sleeping on concrete and distribute our
remaining food. It is only a few cans of corned beef and some packets of
noodles but we are on our way to Darwin, away from the gunshots, the explosions,
the orchestrated terror. Or so we think.
The men run in the early
hours as smoke continues to rise into the air from dozens of fires across
the largely deserted town. So too do many of the young women, particularly
the pretty ones. For 24 years Indonesian soldiers in East Timor have violated
the women, for their selfish pleasure, with impunity.
As they run, fresh gunfire
erupts. Short, sharp volleys. Soon some of the men return exhausted after
trying to climb the hill that rises almost vertically from the back of
the compound. They report that the Indonesian troops who are supposed to
be protecting us from attack fired over their heads, forcing them to return.
But soon others try other
routes and find ways past the troops. With the fittest leading the way,
others follow, including mothers carrying babies, cooking utensils and
their few possessions.
As they shuffle into the
darkness many of us are deeply concerned, justifying our helplessness by
thinking that the East Timorese have shown remarkable resilience during
decades of immense suffering. We can only hope their instincts will keep
them alive.
When dawn breaks the compound
appears strangely bigger, with spaces free of masses of humanity. I won't
reveal how many of the refugees are left because it is better to keep the
killers and rapists guessing.
We don't know whether to
be relieved because we don't know if the refugees made it to the mountains
outside Dili, where we hope they will not starve until they can return
safely to the town or outside help arrives.
At 1.30am yesterday Ian Martin,
head of the UN mission in East Timor, succumbs to pressure from his staff
to delay our evacuation for 24 hours. This may have saved the life of 70-year-old
Anne Forbes of Ballarat. We were still here when she reached the compound
yesterday.
The Sister of Mercy who came
to East Timor to teach English under the wing of the Catholic relief agency
Caritas trembles as she tells her disturbing story. Since August 1 she
has been staying at an orphanage at Dare, a village in the mountains above
Dili. She has seen Dili ablaze, heard the constant gunshots, and heard
the fears of the hundreds who fled to Dare.
"On Monday or Tuesday morning,
I can't remember exactly, we watched two boats go out from Dili," she says.
"We thought they were heading out to West Timor but they only went out
a distance and then came straight back. We fear they were dropping bodies."
Sister Anne was staying with
the remarkable Sister Lourdes, who runs an orphanage in Dare. A 10-year-old
girl arrived a couple of days ago in the mountains from the town of Liquica,
40 kilometres west of Dili. She told of seeing her brother with a machete
stuck in his chest and bodies piled high. Sister Anne cries as she continues.
"Another little girl, she's only five, recites how she saw three men shot
in her parents' garden."
Sister Anne says she cannot
imagine how many people are dead. "There's a real frenzy out there. A nephew
of one of our Timorese sisters was killed with another man near UNAMET
[the UN compound]. The militia hammered nails into his head and cut off
his flesh. They told other people they were going to eat the flesh but
I doubt they did that."
Sister Anne says it was one
of the toughest decisions of her life to leave the orphanage. But with
food short she felt guilty every time she sat down to eat.
When she drove into Dili's
deserted streets yesterday morning with a German priest, Father Albert
Garim, they stopped their car outside a Jesuit's house, where militia looters
had loaded furniture, two refrigerators and two motorcycles onto their
truck.
"Father Garim told them to
get the hell out of there," Sister Anne says. "But you know the funny thing
is that they were greatly embarrassed and knelt down and kissed his hand
and rosary beads.
"You see these people are
East Timorese and Catholics. Up in the hills the people are spending hours
praying that they end all this and see that they are all Timorese in their
hearts." Police took Father Garim away. His whereabouts are unknown.
Sister Anne's handbag was
rifled as a military officer told her in broken English: "You are probably
doing good work in East Timor. But it is hurting some people." Sister Anne
was near exhaustion when she reached the UN compound. "How can teaching
a little bit of English hurt anybody?" she asks.
She expects to be evacuated
with the rest of us this morning but she will leave East Timor with great
reluctance. As half a dozen dirty but broadly smiling children rush her
in the compound and kiss her hand, she weeps.
"I think about the future
of these children," she says. "What is so special about Indonesia that
nobody will directly call them the liars, thugs and mongrels that they
are? Why can't the world help?"
Marked
for execution
Sydney Morning Herald - September
10, 1999
Louise Williams -- Catholic
Church leaders were hiding in remote East Timor mountains last night after
pro-Jakarta militia gangs went on a rampage of bloody retribution, murdering
at least 14 priests and nuns and stabbing the Bishop of Baucau.
Six nuns were reported killed
in Baucau, four nuns in Dili and three priests in Suai, said a spokeswoman
for Caritas Australia, the Catholic overseas aid agency. The Bishop of
Baucau, the Most Rev Basilio do Nascimento, was stabbed before escaping
into the mountains.
Father Francisco Barreto,
the local director of Caritas, was believed to have been murdered just
outside the capital, Dili.
He had warned the Foreign
Minister, Mr Downer, during a visit to Australia in April that terrible
violence would be orchestrated by the Indonesian military.
One account of the attack
on the six Canossian sisters in Baucau, 115 kilometres east of Dili, said
the militia thugs had forced them into a forest where they were murdered.
Reports of the atrocities
emerged as Indonesia announced last night that a five-member United Nations
Security Council team would travel to East Timor tomorrow, but Jakarta
remained strongly opposed to any UN peacekeeping force.
In the worst slaughter to
date, the UN confirmed that at least 100 people, including three priests,
had died in an attack earlier this week on refugees sheltering in the church
at Suai, on the remote east coast.
The dead priests were Father
Hilario Madeira, who had long been an outspoken critic of military and
militia abuses, Father Francisco Soares and Father Tarcisius Dewanto.
The savage attacks are the
first deliberate violations of the sanctity of the church under Indonesian
rule and have robbed the East Timorese of their last refuge.
The militias appear to be
using a death list of independence sympathisers compiled before the ballot
to systematically hunt down their targets.
Many of the priests and nuns
are sheltering on Mate Bean, the mountain of death, where tens of thousands
were killed by bombing in the first years of the Indonesian occupation.
It is not known whether they have any supplies or access to medical treatment.
A communications blackout
in Dili has made it impossible to confirm the number of dead or injured
in the attacks and Catholic networks in Australia and Indonesia are working
with the Vatican to try to establish the facts.
Some reports have been received
by overseas diocese offices through e-mail from outlying Catholic schools
and churches in East Timor, describing attacks on churches and buildings
where nuns and priests were sheltering with thousands of refugees.
A Caritas Australia spokeswoman,
Ms Jane Woolford, said: "We don't even know where many of our local staff
are. We hold grave fears for their safety as many of them have been on
death militia lists before and have been attacked trying to deliver aid."
Many church leaders were identified as independence supporters and the
Catholic Church became an important symbol of opposition to the Muslim-dominated
Indonesian Government.
The leader of the Catholic
Church in East Timor, Bishop Carlos Belo, was evacuated to Darwin earlier
this week after his offices and home were burnt to the ground, with scores
killed.
Father Jose San Juan, also
recently evacuated to Darwin, said: "I fear many, many priests and sisters
will be killed if they stay. In the past the church was a safe place, even
from the Indonesian military, but if they can attack the bishop then that's
it."
The militia units were stacked
with Indonesian operatives, said Father San Juan, a Filipino from the Salesian
order. "I saw the militias attacking churches before I got out and many
of them were speaking in Indonesian, not the local language, so I do not
believe they are all East Timorese," he said. "They were yelling at people
to get out or be killed, and if they refused they just shot or stabbed
them. The Indonesian police and military were just standing there."
The chairman of Caritas Australia,
Bishop Hilton Deakin, said: "These murderous attacks on the church are
part of a much wider unjust genocide. When Catholic Church members, who
have offered relief and refuge to East Timorese, are struck down, we realise
there is no respect for any life in East Timor."
Ms Ana Noronha, director
of the East Timor Human Rights Commission, said information on the deaths
had been sent to the United Nations. "It is now obvious that the violence
is reaching everyone and that there is a pattern of the Catholic Church
being attacked."
East
Timorese rounded up in Java
Agence France Presse - September
9, 1999
Sydney -- Indonesian military
were rounding up East Timorese on the main Indonesian island of Java, one
of Australia's leading pro-Timor activists said Thursday.
Melbourne Bishop Hilton Deakin,
chairman of the Catholic charity Caritas Australia and the East Timor Human
Rights Centre, said he had been told the Indonesian military was making
a concerted effort to target East Timorese in Java.
"The Indonesian military
has started rounding up East Timorese, especially pro-independence supporters,
on Java," he said.
"They're being taken to camps,
where they can cause less harm. It's exactly the same as what has happened
in East Timor where thousands of people have been forcibly deported," he
added. "You can't call it ethnic-cleansing but it's certainly dreadful,"
he added. "It's concerted and it's obviously planned."
Bishop Deakin said the news
was relayed to him Thursday by the National Council for Timorese Resistance
(CNRT) office in Jakarta. He was unable to make an estimate of how many
people were being rounded up.
Killing
will go on until UN leaves: Dili Mayor
Agence France Presse - September
10, 1999
Kupang -- The mayor of the
East Timorese capital Dili warned Wednesday that the UN Mission in East
Timor (UNAMET) had to leave the territory or the killing and destruction
there would continue.
"If they don't go, it would
be better if we just destroy everything, because they have destroyed everything
of ours," said Mateus Haia during an impromptu press conference in a hotel
lobby in this West Timorese capital.
"We are one island with the
West Timorese. Why on earth should we be separated? We are going to continue
our armed struggle for as long as it takes.
"If foreign troops come in,
we will resist and shoot them. We have 25,000 weapons. The UN are the new
colonialists. First we had the Portuguese, now we have the UN," he said.
Haia, who like other officials
in East Timor was approved by the Indonesian government, echoed pro-Jakarta
groups which have accused UNAMET of rigging the territory's self-determination
vote.
"We completely reject the
result because UNAMNET was so biased. They didn't want to accept us at
any stage of the voting process," he said.
The result announced by the
United Nations on Saturday showed an overwhelming 78.5 percent of eligible
East Timorese had opted for independence 24 years after their territory
was invaded by Indonesia.
But Haia disputed the figures.
"We counted that in nine districts we had more than 60 percent [of the
vote] and the rest was 50-50," he said.
Asked why he rejected the
results when Indonesian President B.J. Habibie had accepted them, Haia
replied: "He is just the president, he has never been in the field."
Pro-Indonesian militia, in
many cases backed by army soliders and police according to witnesses, have
attacked and driven out all but one of the UNAMET posts in East Timor.
Only the Dili compound is
left, and that is under seige with access to food stores cut off and communications
dead as at least 1,300 refugees crowd inside. The mayor said he had flown
into Kupang to bring his family out and would return to Dili on Thursday.
"No one is left in Dili, everyone is at the police station, at the harbor
or has run to the hills," he said.
But he added that the army
could not be expected to control "a guerrilla war" by the militias in response
to the vote. "It's very hard for the authorities to do anything," he said.
"Everything could return
to normal in one to two weeks if UNAMET accepts responsibility for the
mistakes it has made. As long as they don't take responsibility there will
never be peace. We don't trust the UN any more. They are not neutral."
Eyewitness
hears troops planning killings
ABC The World Today - September
8, 1999
Compere: Rafael Epstein has
also been speaking to Inga Lemp, who was based in Baukau for the past month.
She's been telling Rafael Epstein of conversations that she followed on
a radio scanner. She heard Indonesian elite Kopassus troops and military
intelligence directing and aiding militia activity and giving the militia
thugs directions to kill the unofficial foreign observers.
Inga Lemp: One was, you know,
who would pay for the food of the militia at different campaigning events
that were pro- autonomy where the militia participated? There was another
one of retrieving rifles at a, from a site, a town called Kasar [phonetic]
where the [inaudible] militia and the Mahedian [phonetic] militia from
[inaudible] together, a week prior to that had laid down the arms in a
symbolic laying down of arms ceremony publicly; so the whole conversation
was who was to go, retrieve them, when? Would they do it on the 30th when
UNAMET was too busy with the election, be observing them and watching them
and so on? And the last and probably most clear one was a direct threat
on our lives, as I said, OP observers, where the militia heads of the town's
leading family were told to stop our car, kill us and throw our bodies
in the river.
Rafael Epstein: So the militia
were told to do that by the military?
Inga Lemp: Right. And there
was conversation about how to do it. At one point they said they should
stop the car and let us walk to Dili, which is a likelihood of getting
us to disappear in the woods, but the river was mentioned three times,
our bodies in the river.
Rafael Epstein: What other
orders did the military give specifically about solving [phonetic] the
local population?
Inga Lemp: They were supposed
to keep their radios on air twenty-four hours, that they were supposed
to be on standby is the word they constantly used. That as soon as the
opposition would light a fire, then they would really let it explode, but
they were trying to hold out till the vote and then afterwards all hell
would break loose.
Rafael Epstein: So, there
were orders that after the vote the violence would escalate?
Inga Lemp: Right, but they
kept saying if the other side ignited [phonetic] before it, then they would
go ahead and fight back.
Compere: Inga Lemp has been
based in Bacau for over a month. She's from the International Federation
for East Timor Observer Project. She, like most others, has had to quit
and was speaking with Rafael Epstein in Darwin.
Anti-Australian
sentiments aroused
Jakarta Post - September
9, 1999
Jakarta -- Antiforeigner
sentiments marked a series of demonstrations which took place across the
capital on Wednesday.
A group of some 200 students
from private Sahid University staged a protest in front of the Australian
Embassy on Jl. Rasuna Said in South Jakarta. Several of the protesters
were able to enter the embassy's compound, where they lowered the Australian
flag and raised the Indonesian flag in its place.
Another group of several
hundred protesters from the People's Sovereignty and National Unity Struggle
staged a demonstration in front of the United Nations office on Jl. M.H.
Thamrin in Central Jakarta, where they burned the UN and Australian flags.
Chanting the national anthem,
Indonesia Raya, the protesters in front of the Australian Embassy said
they were retaliating against the recent burning of an Indonesian flag
in Melbourne, Australia.
After entering the embassy's
compound and raising an Indonesian flag, the students returned to their
campus on Jl. Sahardjo in South Jakarta at 3pm.
A security officer at the
embassy, Haryanto, said a few minutes before the protesters dispersed,
an embassy staff member gave him a letter expressing the Australian government's
regret over "recent violent protests within Indonesian consular premises
in Australia".
At 5.30pm, an embassy employee,
assisted by two embassy security guards and a local staff member, lowered
the Indonesian flag and raised the Australian flag.
Meanwhile, the protesters
in front of the UN office denounced the results of the East Timor ballot,
accusing the UN Mission in East Timor (UNAMET) of manipulating the ballot
count to favor the pro-independence camp.
Two other groups, the Nationalist
Youth Unity and the Communication Forum of the Children of Veterans of
East Timor's Seroja Operation, later joined the protest. Separately, some
150 members of the National Mandate for the Struggle of Democracy gathered
on Wednesday on the Taman Ria flyover in Central Jakarta to protest military
violence in East Timor.
They demanded President B.J.
Habibie and the military be held responsible for the ongoing massacres
in East Timor which followed the UN-sponsored ballot on August 30. The
demonstration broke up at 3.40pm.
Earlier in the morning, some
30 East Timorese youths, carrying the flag of the National Resistance Council
for an Independent East Timor, staged a demonstration in front of the defense
ministry to demand the military's withdrawal from the territory.
Unable to meet ministry officials,
the demonstrators moved to the US Embassy, where they called on the US
government to endorse the deployment of a UN peacekeeping force in East
Timor.
Separately, members of the
Democratic People's Party (PRD) staged a protest against the House of Representatives'
deliberation of the national security bill. "The bill, if enacted, will
be used by the military to suppress the democratic movement in the country,"
the protesters said.
The PRD members attempted
to march to the Ministry of Defense, but were blocked by riot police at
the Farmers Monument in Central Jakarta.
Fear
and looting: life on the streets of Dili
Sydney Morning Herald - September
9, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili --
The looting never stops. It's brazen now: soldiers, police and militia
are stealing whatever they can carry.
Dozens of trucks full with
televisions, refrigerators and other household goods are parked on the
road outside Dili's military headquarters, ready to make the seven-hour
dash across East Timor to the Indonesian province of Nusa Tenggara Timur.
United Nations officials
who went under armed escort to Dili's wharf yesterday saw looted goods
still wrapped waiting to be loaded aboard Indonesian ships. There were
bikes, mattresses, coffee tables and countless other items.
"All the good stuff like
televisions apparently went early," said one of six UN officials to venture
outside the besieged UN compound.
UN officials have seen soldiers
on motorbikes, men driving stolen UN vehicles and military trucks loaded
with goods looted from shops, offices, hotels, homes and factories. "They
intend to leave nothing behind," said one UN official.
Indonesia's armed forces
and their proxy militia have embarked on a campaign to steal everything
of value from Dili and destroy all major infrastructure, including electricity
plants, water supplies, the telephone networks and fuel storage supplies.
Power, water and telephones were cut abruptly on Tuesday night.
A senior officer at military
headquarters has been overheard to say that nothing will be left for independent
East Timor. When up to 20,000 Indonesian police and soldiers based in the
territory have fled, the main roads and bridges are expected to be detonated.
"Make no mistake, this is
being directed from Jakarta," said a high-ranking Western official in the
UN compound. "This is not a situation where a few gangs of rag-tag militia
are out of control. As everybody here knows, it has been a military operation
from start to finish."
UN officials estimate the
damage bill will be billions of dollars. They say that it would take decades
to rebuild the territory's basic infrastructure.
For 24 hours a thick pall
of smoke has hung over the almost deserted town. Throughout yesterday a
dozen fires could be seen at any one time. Huge explosions are heard every
hour or so, indicating the Indonesians are using incendiary bombs to set
buildings ablaze.
A UN storage depot less than
one kilometre from the UN's headquarters was alight. UN vehicles were also
burning. All commercial and many government buildings have been either
looted or set alight. An entire block of central Dili is a smouldering
ruin. The bakery where UN staff and journalists got the only fresh bread
in town is gone. So too is the supermarket, the barber's shop, the bookshop
and the clinic.
The waterfront Hotel Turismo,
which had been our home for many months, has been looted and the rooms
and restaurant destroyed. All my belongings have been stolen: new digital
camera, mobile telephone, clothes. Most colleagues in the UN compound are
in the same position.
The colonial home of East
Timor's former governor apparently has been destroyed. It was a prime target
because it was rented two months ago by the Herald. The militia made repeated
threats to kill us.
According to the UN all of
the houses rented by foreigners have been looted and either wrecked or
burnt. Fifty of them had been occupied by UN staff until everybody was
forced to flee.
A house rented by several
Australian Federal Police officers was burnt overnight. "We've lost everything,"
one of them said. "I have no idea what has happened to the wonderful family
that looked after us."
We knew our house was doomed
when the militia came around one night and painted a silver arrow on the
fence, indicating it was marked for attack. The military commander's house
next door is untouched.
For days Dili has remained
deserted except for rampaging militia, police or soldiers. A UN official
described a group of dazed-looking people walking towards Dili's wharf,
where more than 4,000 people waited for ships.
Residents of Becora, an independence
stronghold, said the militia and military went from door to door dragging
people out who were hiding inside. They were loaded onto trucks at gunpoint.
The UN has hundreds of reports
of people being kidnapped and put on planes and ships against their will
with nothing but the clothes they stand in. Some were even put on a ship
departing for Irian Jaya. "The entire town has been cleansed of people,"
an official said.
The doors of most houses
have been left open by looters. Some residents who risked execution to
return to their homes were seen picking through smouldering rubble yesterday.
Militia, police and soldiers
have been seen roaring along streets on motorbikes and in cars, many of
them stolen. An American activist, Mr Allan Nairn, who sneaked past Indonesian
soldiers guarding the UN compound at dawn, returned after three hours to
say nearby houses were deserted.
"One old man hiding out shared
a plate of rice with me," he said. "I was just climbing over back fences
and walking through people's living rooms. The doors were all open."
When the militia eventually
saw Mr Nairn, he wrapped a red and white cloth across his body, the colours
of Indonesia's flag, and walked down the centre of the streets back to
the compound.
When the two-vehicle UN convoy
arrived to check a food warehouse, militia started to gun the motors on
the motorbikes they were riding shouting threats.
A shot was fired at the departing
convoy. A second five- vehicle UN convoy was confronted by a gang of 50
armed militia. A tense stand-off developed. Indonesian soldiers who were
supposed to be providing security did nothing.
The convoy managed to obtain
a small amount of water before one of the militia smashed the rear window
of a UN vehicle with a machete. The convoy dashed backed to the UN compound,
where basic supplies of food and water are quickly running out.
About 100 UN staff and 2,000
refugees sheltering in the compound have only a day or two of basic supplies
left. "The warehouse is probably being looted and burnt at this moment,"
a UN official said.
UN
worker says soldier shot him
Associated Press - September
8, 1999
Darwin -- An American UN
worker recovering in an Australian hospital after being wounded in East
Timor said Wednesday that he was shot by an Indonesian soldier.
Earl Candler was airlifted
to the northern Australian city of Darwin after being shot twice in the
abdomen while driving in an unmarked UN vehicle through the town of Liquica
four days ago.
He said his attacker was
a member of the Indonesian military sent to East Timor to maintain law
and order after pro-Indonesia militias unleashed a campaign of terror in
the aftermath of last week's vote for independence.
"I see him point his weapon,
and me and my driver got down as low as we could go," Candler told Australian
Broadcasting Corp. television. "The impression I got was that there was
an Australian subject who looked a lot like me, and he was their target
and they got me by mistake." Australians might be targeted by the militias
because of their perceived support for Timorese independence.
Candler said he was hit by
several bullets but only two pierced his body armor. "I got hit twice.
One of the rounds passed right through me, and the other one was lodged,
and the doc took it out," Candler said in another television interview.
The bullet removed by doctors
was displayed in a jar next to Candler's bed. Nobody was available at the
United Nations' Darwin base to provide Candler's hometown.
Jakarta's
bloody hands: military back killings
Sydney Morning Herald - September
6, 1999
The Indonesian military --
presented to the world as providing security while East Timor prepares
for independence -- is in fact orchestrating the brutal campaign of killings
and intimidation, according to secret United Nations assessments.
The documents show that in
the past week the 14,000 soldiers serving under officers hand-picked by
the Defence Minister, General Wiranto, have condoned and in some cases
directed attacks by pro-Jakarta militia.
And during many assaults
the military has ordered the 8,000- strong Indonesian police contingent
in East Timor to remain passive -- with open threats to them or their families
if they intervene.
The revelations come as pro-Jakarta
militias stepped up their attacks following Saturday's announcement that
78.5 per cent of voters in last Monday's ballot had chosen independence
over autonomy with Indonesia.
Up to 25 deaths have been
reported in Dili and there are unconfirmed reports of 20 people massacred
in a church in Maliana.
As the situation deteriorated,
the Australian Defence Force increased its readiness for a possible evacuation
with the frigates HMAS Darwin and HMAS Anzac joining the navy's high-speed
catamaran in Darwin at the weekend. There are also two United States warships
in the port from the joint exercise with Australian forces, Operation Crocodile.
At the same time Australia
is pressing for a "coalition of the willing", comprising Australia and
a few other countries, to quickly provide a basic international security
force to protect Australians and other UN personnel in East Timor.
The Prime Minister raised
the proposal with Indonesia's President Habibie on Friday but Mr Howard
said yesterday that foreign troops would not be sent in without Indonesian
and UN Security Council approval.
One of the leaked UN documents
relates to the wounding on Friday of a US policeman working with the UN
team which was condemned yesterday by President Clinton.
The American had been set
upon by militia thugs at the instigation of the military and local police
who tried to intervene were told to stand back, it said. He was recovering
from gunshot wounds in Darwin yesterday.
In another attack, militia
were ordered by a group of Indonesian officers to shoot at trucks carrying
UN staff and journalists.
The leaked documents prepared
by the United Nations mission to East Timor (UNAMET) conclude that there
had been "a deliberate strategy to force UNAMET to withdraw from certain
regions back to Dili".
They found that in some cases
during the past few days there have been "joint operations" including the
burning of houses and attacks on civilians as well as UN personnel, including
UN civilian police (Civpol).
"Civpol strongly believe
this series of incidents was orchestrated by TNI and Polri [Indonesian
police] and that the militias acted with precise instructions as to their
targets and the types of actions to conduct," one report says.
In the western towns of Aileu,
Ainaro, Maliana, Liquica and Same there are specific accounts of abuses,
including a threat to burn down a UN compound by a militia leader who said
he was acting on instructions from the local major.
In Liquica, Indonesian police
and military personnel were not only assisting the militias in an attack
"but also shooting themselves at UN vehicles and their passengers". [By
Craig Skehan, Hamish McDonald, David Jenkins and Mark Dodd]
Former
commander doubts army neutrality
Jakarta Post - September
8, 1999
Jakarta -- Enforcing a state
of emergency in East Timor will not improve the situation because the military
is unlikely to be neutral, said a former military commander in the province.
Former Udayana commander
Maj. Gen. (ret.) Theo Syafei noted on Tuesday the "emotional relationship"
of the military with the prointegration militia, which, he said, "was formed
by the TNI (Indonesian Military) to help us fight the Fretilin."
Fretilin is the former name
of the pro-independence organization and its Falintil militia. "They [the
military] would not hurt the [pro-integration] militia, who are like their
distant brothers," he said after addressing a talk show on East Timor.
"The military's history in
the territory is too emotional and it is unlikely that they can be neutral
if they are take over security command in the territory now," Theo said,
citing the death of some 5,000 soldiers and 100,000 East Timorese during
the military operations.
"The best way to handle the
situation is the arrival of a UN peacekeeping force," said Theo, now an
executive of the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle.
Newly released pro-independence
leader Jose Alexandre Xanana Gusmao said of the decision, "Honestly, I
do not know what for ... there is no population anymore in the villages,
the population has been driven out to Kupang and Ainaro."
"Why are more battalions
are being sent to East Timor? TNI is killing the population, TNI is destroying
and plundering the belongings of the population," he said Tuesday.
Xanana also said that he
"foresees many people will die of starvation and illnesses in the coming
weeks". "I don't know the death toll, but I am quite certain that what
is happening there is horrifying," Xanana said.
"I think the international
community and the government is well aware of the situation in East Timor,
but what we see right now is that the government either does not have the
capacity to control the situation, or it does not want to have the capacity
to control the situation," Xanana said.
Xanana reiterated Tuesday
his appeal to the international community "to help stop the violence and
the killings of the East Timorese".
When Xanana was arrested
in 1992, Theo led the East Timor special military command. Theo said the
TNI should accept the "bitter pill" of rejection of autonomy by East Timorese
as reflected in the ballot results. "It should be considered an expensive
lesson" for the military and the government, he said.
In the beginning, many East
Timorese supported integration, he added. The TNI should "also persuade
the militia to enter certain enclaves in the territory's western parts
(uncontrolled by Falintil), or herd them toward Atambua in West Nusa Tenggara."
The military is responsible
for "rehabilitating the morality of the militia," he said without elaborating.
Presidential military advisor
Sayidiman Suryohadiprojo told The Jakarta Post that while the state of
emergency was now needed because the police could no longer uphold the
law there, "The military has no interest in keeping this status for a long
time. The faster an end to the status, the better ... "
"A good commander will do
his best to ensure that the situation recovers as soon as possible."
Sayidiman added it would
be better for Indonesia if the UN peacekeeping force took over the responsibility
of security and order in East Timor. "All this commotion is partly caused
by the international community, including the UN," he said.
Head of the National Mandate
Party's international relations department, Bara Hasibuan, also called
for the presence of a UN peacekeeping force.
However he suggested that
a rapid emergency force comprising of two or three nations could be assembled
in the interim since a larger UN presence would probably take several weeks
to organize.
"We can no longer trust the
military or the Habibie government to carry out their obligation to ensure
security," he said while adding that the UN Security Council should also
issue a strong ultimatum to press Indonesian military forces out of East
Timor. "If necessary they could use the threat of an economic embargo,"
he told the Post.
Researcher Muhammad A. Hikam
urged the military to review the decision on enforcing martial law in the
province.
He said this was needed to
avoid a prolonged security problem. Hikam added that the TNI should consider
its participation in a UN peacekeeping force "because nobody would trust
its neutrality" if it held sole responsibility for security.
Insisting on martial law
"would give Indonesia a bad image in the international forum." If Indonesia
failed in the agreement, "the UN should implement its contingency plan
to improve the situation," he said.
The Jakarta-based National
Front and the National Reform Movement demanded that President B.J. Habibie
should state he would not seek reelection, or resign.
In a statement signed by
Lt. Gen. (ret.) A. Kemal Idris and Subroto, former minister of mines and
energy, they said "For Mr. Habibie to remain obstinate in his determination
to be reelected president would cause the nation's disintegration."
A leader of the Democratic
People's Party (PRD), Faisol Riza, lambasted the decision of a state of
military emergency as a virtual "coup d'etat" by the military because the
UN-sponsored ballot had clearly voiced the will of most East Timorese.
The PRD said the government
and the TNI "repeated their mistake" when they invaded East Timor before
"forcing it to join Indonesia".
In Yogyakarta, researcher
Lambang Trijono of the Center for Security and Peace Studies said, "The
declaration of martial law would likely only serve to give the TNI space
to provide full support for proautonomy militia," he told the Post.
Military researcher Indria
Samego however hailed the decision, saying it was the last resort to calm
down tension in East Timor, and to save Indonesia's image in the international
forum.
"The world would no longer
have confidence in Indonesia if the it failed to maintain security in the
territory in accordance with the May 5 agreement," he said.
Agus Muhyidin, chairman of
the House of Representatives' Special Committee deliberating the bill on
state security, concurred and said that based on the 1959 law on state
of emergency, Habibie had full authority to make such a decision without
consulting the House.
The United Development Party
had on Monday rejected Habibie's proposal of declaring martial law as one
option to overcome East Timor's situation.
Army
provoked militia attack on Red Cross
Sydney Morning Herald - September
8, 1999
Bernard Lagan, Darwin --
Eyewitnesses have told how the Indonesian military combined with militias
in Dili to storm Catholic Church and Red Cross compounds, forcing out thousands
of East Timorese people sheltering there.
Speaking after his evacuation
to Darwin, the head of the Red Cross in Dili, Mr Jean Luc Metzker, said
that on Monday morning militia men armed with automatic weapons broke into
the Red Cross compound where 2,000 people, including children as young
as two- day-old babies, were sheltering. They were backed by Indonesian
police, who surrounded the compound's perimeter so people could not flee,
and by Indonesian Army units who pulled up in army trucks to help transport
the refugees away.
They fired into the windows
of the Red Cross compound, over the heads of the thousands of terrified
people including another 3,000 sheltering in Catholic Archbishop Carlos
Belo's compound next door.
An Irish freelance journalist,
Mr Sean Steele, watching from a nearby hotel roof, told the Herald that
Indonesian Army officers were directing the militias, yelling: "Go on,
attack them, attack them, they support independence."
Mr Metzker, a Swiss national,
said: "It was an incredible feeling of panic among the 2,000 people. They
were shooting in the air, shooting at the buildings, then they shot over
the heads of the people. "Then they started smashing the windows, making
a lot of noise and creating a feeling of terrible panic."
Before being flown out of
Dili by an RAAF Hercules, he said he had seen 50,000 to 60,000 refugees
being herded along roads and beaches towards a large Indonesian police
compound in Dili. They had been told they would be trucked to West Timor.
He said there was no question that a forced removal of tens of thousand
of East Timorese who supported independence was under way.
Mr David Wimhurst, the spokesman
for the UN mission in East Timor, also relocated from Dili to Darwin, said
the Indonesian military had broken an agreement with the UN to look after
refugees' security.
As
the UN dwindles, Dili burns
Sydney Morning Herald - September
8, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili --
There are not many of us left, here in the United Nations' besieged compound.
It seems the military's operation, to terrify the UN and media out of Dili,
is running right on schedule.
Large parts of Dili were
ablaze last night as about 80 UN officials, including 40 Australian Federal
police, and 10 foreign journalists, desperately resisted pressure from
the military, police and militia to evacuate to Darwin.
The compound had come under
direct fire yesterday and the utter despair was articulated by Ian Martin,
the head of the UN mission in East Timor, as a line of mothers queued at
the door, waiting to see a UN doctor.
The first mother was crying.
Along the line, others were either crying or appeared distressed. Asked
what would happen to them if we all left, Mr Martin could not answer. Asked
what would happen if the killers came over the fence, he hesitated, then
said: "We die."
Mrs Aida Ramos Horta de Assis,
the sister of the exiled 1996 Nobel Peace prize winner, Mr Jose Ramos Horta,
arrived in a distressed state at the compound last night, after being threatened
by an Indonesian military officer who broke into her home. She said the
man demanded to know of her: "You are in Indonesia now. Why do you want
independence?"
When she was leaving the
house, an Indonesian military officer had told her: "Don't go to UNAMET
because we are going to bombard it tonight."
UN sources said East Timor's
military commander, Colonel Noer Muis, had been sacked and a high-ranking
military intelligence officer appointed to replace him. When told of the
sacking, Colonel Muis is believed to have wept.
Last night, UN officials
negotiated with the new military commander to replace the police who were
supposedly guarding the compound with recently arrived Indonesian combat
troops. As the police left, they fired volleys of shots into the air. But
the UN officials have been told the new commander has imposed a 9pm curfew.
Over the next two days, anybody seen on the streets would be warned and
told to go home. After that, curfew breakers would be executed on sight.
Diplomats and analysts believe
months of violence and intimidation directed at the independence movement
has been masterminded by Indonesia's covert military intelligence services.
Mr Martin said he could not rule out a complete evacuation "if the security
situation makes it irresponsible to stay". With gun shots ringing out as
he spoke, Mr Martin said the UN's continued presence in East Timor was
symbolically important to the East Timorese, whose vote on August 30 to
reject Indonesia's rule has triggered the bloodbath in the territory. But
there are now no UN staff outside Dili.
Earlier yesterday, the UN
evacuated about 100 staff from the town of Baucau after militia, Indonesian
soldiers and police opened fire on its compound in the town. Armed militia
repeatedly tried to force their way into the compound but were stoppedby
Indonesian soldiers. UN staff dived for cover as shots slammed into UN
buildings.
About 35 people -- mainly
Australians -- were evacuated from the Australian consulate in Dili yesterday
after the militia terrorised people inside throughout the previous night.
The militia fired repeated volleys of gunfire, some slamming into the building,
and set fire to a building across the road. About five of these people,
including the consul, Mr James Batley, were remaining in Dili last night.
Late yesterday afternoon,
Dili's electricity, telephone and water supplies were abruptly cut. A huge
fireball could be seen about two kilometres from the United Nation's compound,
believed to be the capital's Telcom building. The main Indonesian university
and courthouse also were burnt to the ground.
UN officials believe the
Indonesian military set alight the buildings which house all the capital's
infrastructure.
The officials, who fear the
death toll is in the hundreds, possibly thousands, scoffed when they heard
Indonesia's President, Dr B.J. Habibie, had authorised the imposition of
martial law in an attempt to end the violence. "Martial law will only give
these killers more cover," one official said. "The whole thing would be
a joke if it wasn't so tragic."
Entire suburbs of Dili have
been cleared of people, some of them herded at gun-point on to trucks.
UN officials have been told the Indonesian authorities plan to evacuate
up to 200,000 people to Atambua, at the border with the Indonesian province
of Nusa Tengarra Timur, claiming they want to flee. But Mr Martin confirmed
many had been taken against their will.
Meanwhile, UN staff can only
travel from the UN compound to Dili's airport where Australian RAAF Hercules
are running shuttle evacuation flights. We have a reasonable chance of
making it alive, with an Indonesian police escort along roads controlled
by rampaging killers. It is small comfort that our protectors are the same
police and soldiers who are commanding this cleansing of Dili.
But many East Timorese will
not have even a reasonable chance if the UN evacuates completely.
Anti-Australian
protests hit major cities
Jakarta Post Saturday - September
11, 1999
Jakarta -- The rising wave
of nationalistic fever brought on by a fervor of anti-American and Australian
sentiment continued on Friday as major Indonesian cities became witnesses
to flag burning demonstrations.
Here in Jakarta at least
500 people, mainly members of the People's Sovereignty and National Unity
Struggle (Rver) and the Ansor Youth Movement, burned the Australian and
American flags at the Australian Embassy and on Jl. Sudirman on Friday
afternoon.
The group first burned the
flags on Jl. Jend. Sudirman in South Jakarta. They then boarded two minivans
and went to the Australian Embassy on Jl. Rasuna Said in South Jakarta.
Under the cautious eyes of
hundreds of police officers, they laid the Australian and American flags
on the busy asphalt road and put them in a cage which contained two chickens
which then excreted on the flags. "This should teach Australians not to
burn our flag," the demonstrators screamed.
This is the third straight
day demonstrators have descended on the Australian Embassy. Like previous
days, the protesters were disgruntled over Canberra's alleged intervention
in Indonesia's domestic affairs over the East Timor issue, and also the
burning of Indonesian flags by protesters in Australia. When police tried
to intervene on Friday, the protesters pushed them away.
"They burned our flag in
Australia. We burn theirs here," a protester said. One of the protesters
leader, Zulkifli Tarigan, said that they were also unhappy with the United
Nations Mission in East Timor (UNAMET) over supposed irregularities in
the August 30 ballot.
"If UNAMET does not investigate
and disclose the case, killings in East Timor will continue," said Tarigan,
after meeting with the Australian Embassy's third secretary, Jo Leong.
Tarigan said the embassy official promised to convey the demands to the
Australian government.
Meanwhile in Semarang, Central
Java, a similar scene broke out as more than 100 university students staged
a noisy protest in front of Australian Trade Representative office. They
challenged Australia to prove its threat of sending troops to East Timor.
The students, who identified
themselves as the National Student Movement, also burned the flags of Australia
and the United Nations in front of the trade representative office.
They also deplored the UN
which they described as the mastermind behind all disasters in East Timor.
They decried the world body of failing to maintain neutrality during the
ballot process.
The students warned Australia
and other western countries not to interfere in Indonesia's internal affairs
as East Timor was still part of Indonesia.
They also warned Australia
not to behave like the champion of human rights since their own record
was far from perfect in regard to the mistreatment of native Aborigines.
"If Australia tries to intervene
or to invade East Timor, Australia will have to face the people," said
Warseno, the leader of the protesters.
In Medan, North Sumatra,
a dozen students also burned the Australian flag in front of the North
Sumatra University on Jl. Dr. Mansur.
Student leader Rasum called
Australia arrogant by sending its warships near Indonesian waters. "Australia
is too snobbish," he cried to the enthusiastic protesting students.
Separately, a senior official
at the Ministry of Industry and Trade cautiously reacted against the boycott
threat launched by the Australian Council for Trade Unions (ACTU).
The ministry's director general
for foreign trade, Djoko Moeljono, said the government would consult next
with the National Importers Association (Ginsi) and the Indonesian Exporters
Association (GPEI) before making any decisions. Ginsi has urged the government
to boycott Australian products.
Djoko said not all parties
in Australia agree to the boycott as it would only disrupt current close
trade relations between the two countries.
Citing an example, he said
the Australian airlines, Qantas, had warned Australian airport workers
that the boycott is against the law. "We are still studying the ACTU's
appeals," said Djoko, as quoted by Antara.
IMF
suspends talks on economic program
Agence France Presse - September
10, 1999
Washington -- The International
Monetary Fund has suspended discussions with Indonesia on its economic
program, a fund spokesman said Friday.
"IMF management continues
to keep under close review ongoing developments in Indonesia and discussions
for the next program review are on hold," said the IMF spokesman, who asked
not to be identified.
"Meanwhile, fund staff will
continue to monitor economic developments seeking to preserve as much as
possible all that has been achieved during more than one year of close
cooperation," he said. The fund, whose loans are helping Indonesa.
Indonesia's
future collapses into Timor ruins
The Guardian - September
10, 1999
Martin Woollacott -- When
the Seaforth Highlanders set off for Jakarta docks in November, 1946, after
months of coping with the Indonesian liberation movement on behalf of the
absent Dutch, they passed contingents of troops just in from Holland. With
one accord, the British soldiers raised clenched fists and shouted "Merdeka!"
("Freedom!"). Liberation salute and slogan were more than just a joke at
Dutch expense. They were a recognition by men of what was still an imperial
army that empire was not going to survive long in the Indies -- something
which the young Dutchmen in the lorries going the other way did not yet
understand.
It is an unhappy parallel
with those times that the Indonesians are proving in some ways as obtuse
as the Dutch in dealing today with the problems created by their own quasi-
imperial style of government. While the Indonesians won their freedom from
the Dutch, they did not win freedom from ideas that sustained Dutch power,
notably that the most important instruments of rule were force and guile.
Dutch power at an earlier stage had been based on an array of special agreements
with local rulers. The result was a diverse, proto-federal polity. But,
later, after the conquest of rebellious Aceh, the Dutch used their largely
native troops to impose a uniform political pattern on the archipelago.
They also continued to manipulate local politics by intrigue and by what
today would be called covert action.
It is these traditions which
the Indonesian armed forces inherited and exaggerated, which have caused
much violence and suffering over the years in many parts of Indonesia,
and which have now led to the tragic situation in East Timor. That situation
is full of danger not only for the East Timorese but for Indonesians: if
their elite continues to make the wrong decisions, the chance the country
seemed to have only a few months ago of repudiating the mistakes of the
past may be lost.
It is hard to understand
East Timor unless it is grasped that the Indonesian military regarded it
as a success and not as a failure.
After all, "roads, schools,
and cathedrals" had been built, as one officer told a Guardian reporter.
More important, a significant Indonesian constituency had been built up
over the years since annexation in 1976. Some of the figures recently reported
on the large number of East Timorese in regular army and national police
units in the territory, as well as those in the civil service, illuminate
the nature of the conflict there. This client community was used by men
like General Zacky Anwar Makarim, the intelligence and covert action specialist
who, incredibly, was given a senior command in East Timor during the period
leading up to the referendum.
His brief, self-appointed
or otherwise, can be guessed at: utilise these loyalists to produce a vote
for autonomy or at least so narrow a vote for independence as to induce
second thoughts. What we are now seeing in East Timor, apart from the murky
manoeuvres of the military, are the desperate throes of this client class
after the collapse of that strategy.
The independence leader Xanana
Gusmao sees that reconciliation with this large group, perhaps a quarter
of the population, fearful not only that it will lose its privileges but
that it may be punished, harried, and expelled, is his central political
problem. "They will be forgiven," he says, "and East Timor will also be
theirs."
Men like Gusmao, it may be
hazarded, understand not only that reconciliation is necessary in East
Timor if it is to avoid being burdened by a permanently angry and alienated
minority, but that a broader reconciliation with Indonesia is also vital.
Formal independence is one thing. But there must also be a sense in which
East Timor is recognised as a partly Indonesian society which needs to
find some halfway house in its relationship with the great state that surrounds
it. Such a reconciliation, of course, is hard to imagine now as East Timor
burns.
In retrospect, the decision
to hold an East Timor referendum was taken in an unforgivably light-hearted
way. BJ Habibie, the interim president who succeeded Suharto, tossed it
off in January, seemingly without considering whether he had the authority
to persuade the armed forces to accept it.
The hard work which would
have made it a real policy rather than a tragedy in the making was never
done. Habibie did not prepare the way with the military, with his own party,
or with the other parties. If the policy had been seriously weighed, it
would have been immediately grasped that what was needed was not just a
vote but a negotiation between East Timorese. The vote would inevitably
be for independence, the negotiation should have been about guarantees
for the pro-Indonesian element. It would also have been about Indonesia's
own future influence in an independent East Timor, an influence based in
part on that protected client class and in part on the gratitude of the
independence movement for a clean break with the past.
Instead, some in the armed
forces used the very assets that could have assured a trouble-free transition
to ensure the exact opposite. It is not so much that the Habibie government
is not in control of the military but rather that nobody in today's Indonesia
is fully in control of anything. The old ruling party is split, the new
parties are inexperienced and not in government and the officer corps is
racked by its own internal politics.
This is hard to read, but
senior figures can be presumed to be desperate not to be the ones who gave
up East Timor. The only way to have avoided this situation, in which even
the sensible men want to be on the sidelines, would have been to involve
everybody in the decision to get out. The painful creation of such a consensus
was beyond either Habibie or Wiranto, the armed forces chief, with the
results we now see. Without it, the way was open for mischief of the worst
kind.
To ask what is the policy
now being pursued in East Timor is thus probably the wrong question. Is
the policy to somehow retain the territory? Is it to accept its independence,
but only after destroying its assets and dispersing its people, both as
revenge and as a warning to other separatists? Is it partition? Is it to
seek leverage in an independent state by entrenching the integration forces?
The likelihood is that there is no one policy, however malign, but simply
a chaos produced by the actions of the militias and the plots of some officers,
compounded by the cowardice of decision makers, military and civilian.
The Indonesian establishment has to grasp that its foolishness is profoundly
damaging to Indonesia as well as East Timor. It is time to live up to the
responsibilities that the word "Merdeka" implies.
A
general squeeze and Habibie succumbs
Sydney Morning Herald - September
10. 1999
The men in uniform usually
get their own way, David Jenkins writes from Jakarta. Indonesia's military
leaders are accustomed to getting their own way. And when it looked yesterday
as if President Habibie might be tempted to give the green light to the
early arrival of foreign peacekeepers in East Timor the generals decided
enough was enough.
After a day-long meeting
with his senior commanders, the defence minister, General Wiranto, called
on Dr Habibie to make it clear that the army (TNI) would not accept that
outcome under any circumstances.
The TNI, he said, was to
remain the sole military force in East Timor until the People's Consultative
Congress (MPR) met in October-November to consider the outcome of the August
30 referendum.
This was an unmistakable
flexing of military muscles, an almost off-hand reminder that Dr Habibie
has no power to rein in Indonesia's runaway army. The unstated message
was: "If you care to oppose us on this, other scenarios may unfold."
The next day's headline in
Kompas said all that needed to be said. "The Generals Meet Habibie. General
Wiranto: 'It is not true there has been a coup d'etat'."
That was true enough. But
in the opinion of one senior Indonesian source: "It was a quarter coup.
There was a sort of confrontation last night between Wiranto and Habibie.
Wiranto said, 'Don't let foreign peacekeepers come in.' It means the military
have the upper hand." Asked if there was any implicit threat from Wiranto,
the source said: "Well, actually not a threat. Just a squeeze!"
The confrontation between
Dr Habibie and his generals came with the arrival in Jakarta of five UN
ambassadors, who were thought to be pushing for the early arrival of an
international peacekeeping force.
Indonesia's military commanders,
who have never accepted what they see as Dr Habibie's rash decision to
approve an independence referendum in East Timor, were concerned that the
president might give way.
In their view, Dr Habibie
takes more notice of his inner "kitchen Cabinet", a group of Muslim intellectuals
who have long argued that there is no point in hanging on to this largely
Catholic problem province, than he does of his Cabinet and his defence
chiefs.
They aren't even sure that
he should be listening to some members of Cabinet. The Information Minister,
Lieutenant-General Mohammad Yunus, who served numerous tours in East Timor,
is seen as altogether too liberal these days.
In these circumstances, there
is no need for the military to think, at least for the time being, about
pushing Dr Habibie off stage. The TNI is able to act as it pleases in places
like East Timor and can afford to wait until the MPR chooses a new president
in two months' time.
No-one believes any longer
that Dr Habibie will remain in office after that. He is widely seen as
a lame duck, crippled by the charge that he "gave away" East Timor.
At their meeting yesterday,
sources in Jakarta say, Indonesia's leading generals, admirals and air
marshals talked at length about the "threat" posed by foreign forces, including
what one well-connected source called "the threat from the Australian armed
forces".
In the next day's papers,
the air force commander was even quoted as saying "We are ready to face
any intruders from Australia". This may sound bizarre. But some Indonesian
officers have no trouble these days locating possible threats.
"Australia keeps talking
about sending troops," said Dr Salim Said, a political scientist who has
close ties with a number of prominent generals.
"Australia is saying Indonesia
is not able to take care of the situation. We see pictures of Australian
panzer wagons in the morning newspapers and we read that they are ready
to be sent to East Timor. "Unfortunately, the domestic pressure in Australia
for something to be done in East Timor spills over to Jakarta and galvanises
Indonesian nationalism. And that is felt very strongly in the armed forces."
According to a source in
Jakarta, one prominent Indonesian general was saying last night: "We are
ready to go to war with Australia if [they send troops without our permission]."
Indonesia's army may have
some reason to believe that Dr Habibie and his advisers rushed into the
East Timor referendum without proper consultation with key ministers. But
the army's attempt to subvert that policy has been nothing short of disastrous.
No wonder Indonesian Foreign Minister Ali Alatas is such an exhausted and
demoralised man.
[The following note was
posted by Joyo (accompanying a different article) on the Van Zorge Report
web page on September 10, 1999 - James Balowski.]
Rumor has it that Prabowo,
Suharto's "disgraced" son-in-law and former "golden boy" (about whom US
Sec. of Defense Cohen made glowing remarks during a visit to Jakarta in
Jan. 1998), has recently slipped back into the country after staying abroad
in Jordan and elsewhere since August 1998.
Prior to becoming head of
the dreaded Kopassus special forces, Prabowo cut his teeth so to speak
as the mastermind behind the "black ninja" death squad terror campaign
in East Timor. From 1985-98, every significant Jakarta operative in East
Timor from the governor down to the village level has been a member of
the Prabowo network.
It is believed by some well-informed
sources that Prabowo and his operatives have used the East Timor situation
to re-assert their power after coming out on the losing end of Prabowo's
failed power grab in May 1998 -- when Kopassus gunned down students at
Trisakti university and instigated massive devastation, mayhem, rapes of
Chinese women, and killings as a smoke screen to seize power.
With Wiranto's so-called
credibility on the line after the imposition of martial law, it is not
Wiranto but Prabowo himself who can decide when the terror in Timor stops,
and this is the bargaining chip Prabowo is using to re-assert his power
in TNI. In other words, Prabowo has Wiranto by the balls and is using the
unspeakable horrors in East Timor as his bargaining chip.
Prabowo, moreover, controls
a war chest of hundreds of millions, if not billions of dollars, much of
it coming from the business empires of his wife Titiek Suharto and his
brother Hashim. Recently, it was revealed that US$250 million was missing
from Cement Cibinong, the crown jewel in the Titiek-Hashim empire, which
may have been used to bankroll Prabowo's black operations intended to undermine
Wiranto and buy significant numbers DPR and MPR members to shore up Prabowo's
political base.
It is also believed that
the "black ninja" terror campaign in Java last year was the first stage
in Prabowo's masterplan to reassert his power and undermine Wiranto. In
order to turn off that campaign, it is alleged that Wiranto made certain
concessions such as not pressing to court martial Prabowo or his operatives
for the Trisakti killings and abductions and torture of government critics
-- and not to purge members of Prabowo's extensive network from the ranks
of TNI and its intelligence apparatus.
US
priority is to maintain good ties
The New York Times - September
9, 1999
Elizabeth Becker and Philip
Shenon, Washington -- The United States is resisting direct threats of
economic or military sanctions against Indonesia over the chaos in East
Timor in hopes of preserving its relationship with that vast archipelago
nation, even as the Clinton administration protests the chaos that has
left hundreds of Timorese dead, senior officials said.
The administration, these
officials said, has made the calculation that the United States must put
its relationship with Indonesia, a mineral-rich nation of more than 200
million people, ahead of its concern over the political fate of East Timor,
a tiny, impoverished territory of 800,000 people that is seeking independence.
The Defense Department is
taking the lead in dealing with the crisis. Hoping to make use of longstanding
ties between the Pentagon and the Indonesian military -- a relationship
that dates back to the early days of the Cold War, when Indonesia was seen
as a bulwark against communism -- the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff,
Gen. Henry Shelton, has telephoned Indonesia's military commander, Gen.
Wiranto, several times this week to discuss East Timor.
Officials say the two military
leaders have discussed details of Wiranto's plan to remove troops from
East Timor who have allied themselves with anti-independence militias and
replace them with soldiers clearly loyal to the central government in Jakarta.
The Indonesian military leader
is respected by Pentagon officials for his military professionalism and
is seen as the key figure in the crisis, overshadowing President B.J. Habibie,
who appears to have little control over the situation and is distrusted
by many in the military.
"It is not unreasonable to
give him at least 24 hours to get folks there, and then you've got to give
him a little time to bring them under control," said a senior administration
official. "Wiranto knows that everybody expects to see real traction on
this very fast -- and very fast doesn't mean weeks."
While senior administration
officials did not rule out the use of sanctions, they acknowledged that
the United States had no firm plans to punish the Jakarta government if
the violence continued. The administration, they said, is willing to support
an Australian-led UN peacekeeping force in East Timor, but only if it is
invited by the Indonesian government.
"Because we bombed in Kosovo
doesn't mean we should bomb Dili," said Samuel Berger, Clinton's national
security adviser, referring to the Timorese capital.
"Indonesia is the fourth-largest
country in the world," he said. "It is undergoing a fragile but tremendously
important political and economic transformation, which the United States
strongly supports. The resolution of this crisis matters not just for East
Timor but for Indonesia as a whole."
He suggested that US threats
of a cutoff of economic or military aid to Indonesia were not necessary.
"It's not a question of making threats," he said. "It's a question of stating
what is simply a practical fact of life, which is that it would be very
hard for the international community to continue to be of economic assistance
if there is a chaotic situation in Timor."
The United States has little
direct leverage over the Indonesian military. As a result of human rights
abuses attributed to the military, Congress has sharply limited military
aid and training to Indonesia, and the total military aid package this
year totaled only $476,000. "It's not as if we have a military assistance
program that could be cut off," said State Department spokesman James Rubin.
The United States has a more
potent means of punishing Indonesia through what amounts to its veto power
in the International Monetary Fund, which has committed tens of billions
of dollars in emergency financial support to Indonesia as a result of the
Asian economic crisis.
But Washington has been reluctant
to threaten a cutoff of the aid for fear that the result would be a new
economic collapse in Indonesia, further undermining its transition to democracy
after three decades of authoritarian rule under President Suharto, who
was forced from office last year. It could also harm US corporations that
have large investments in Indonesia.
The Clinton administration
has focused its attention on persuading Wiranto that he must step in personally
to insure that his troops stop the violence.
US officials said they are
convinced that Wiranto is not directing the violence in East Timor, but
they said he has made few efforts to reign in junior military commanders
who may be encouraging the violence as a means of blocking independence
for the territory.
The United States is trying
to convince Wiranto that with order restored, a UN peacekeeping force could
be deployed to East Timor and relieve him of the responsibility of controlling
the militias until there is a final decision on East Timor's political
future.
In a referendum last week
that ignited the violence, an overwhelming majority of Timorese voted for
independence from Indonesia, which invaded and annexed the former Portuguese
colony in 1975.
A senior Pentagon official
said Wednesday that the commander of US military forces in the Pacific,
Adm. Dennis Blair, arrived in Jakarta on Wednesday to carry the message
to Wiranto "that he has the responsibility to bring this under control
and he had better belly up to that responsibility."
Administration officials
are also concerned that the crisis in East Timor could disrupt the difficult
relationship between the Indonesian military and its civilian leaders,
and could bring down Habibie, who has been praised by the United States
for pushing ahead with democratic reforms.
Administration officials
said that if the United Nations sponsors an armed peacekeeping mission
in East Timor, it will almost certainly receive military support from the
United States, although not ground troops.
"The United States is not
planning an insertion of any peacekeeping troops," said Defense Secretary
William Cohen. He called upon the Indonesian government to act "swiftly
and effectively" to stop the militias. "The government of Indonesia is
responsible for bringing order and peace to East Timor," he said. At a
White House news conference, Berger said that any peacekeeping force would
be "overwhelmingly Asian in character."
"We have to recognize that
Indonesia is in Asia, and that the Indonesians will respond much better
to a solution here that is dominated by the Asians and not dominated by
the United States." he said.
The government of Australia
has volunteered to lead an international peacekeeping force and provide
2,000 troops, but has said that it will not go in alone.
US officials say they have
been in close contact with the Australian government and that if the United
States participated in the mission, it would be likely provide communications,
logistics and intelligence support.
"We will look at what is
the appropriate level of assistance we can give, whether it be logistical
or technical support or other," said White House press secretary Joe Lockhart.
"But I can tell you that there's been no decision made on that."
Habibie
feels the heat
Far Eastern Economic Review
- September 9, 1999
John McBeth and Margot Cohen,
Jakarta -- On a late-August evening, senior officials of Golkar, Indonesia's
ruling party, filed out into the dark after a five-hour conclave at the
home of President B.J. Habibie. The official word was that the beleaguered
and embattled party now stood united. In truth, its members were deeply
split.
The discussions were punctuated,
according to people present, by rancorous exchanges over an issue that
now fixates Indonesian -- money politics. At one point, according to party
Vice-Chairman Marzuki Darusman, President Habibie flew into a rage in response
to warnings from Marzuki that his election bid was doomed if people close
to him were seen as buying the presidency.
"He said I should disqualify
myself if I even thought we could lose the election," recalls Marzuki,
who opposed Habibie's selection as the party candidate earlier this year.
"He was in such a fit of rage I had no reason to respond; everyone was
just looking at him."
The incident, confirmed by
senior party official Eki Syachrudin, shows how deep are the divisions
within Golkar as it approaches the event that will determine its future
role after three decades in power during the Suharto era. Those splits
are now being widened by the Bank Bali scandal, which involved the transfer
of 546 billion rupiah ($70 million) in public funds to a company controlled
by Golkar's deputy treasurer, Setya Novanto. Although the evidence remains
sketchy, many Indonesians believe a sizable chunk went to a war chest held
by backers of Habibie's election bid. The aim of these supporters, many
fear, is to buy up votes when the members of Indonesia's People's Consultative
Assembly meet to elect the president in two months' time. Marzuki himself
believes as much as 200 billion rupiah went into the Habibie war chest.
Local media reports say it now contains more than 1.3 trillion rupiah.
The identity of the president's
backers is almost as controversial. They are known as Tim Sukses ("Team
Success"), an informal group of political allies and Habibie family members
whose activities on the president's behalf have become a topic of national
speculation. A recent opinion poll in Tempo magazine showed that half the
respondents believed Tim Sukses was responsible for the Bank Bali case.
In an indicator of the damage the bank scandal could do to both Habibie
and Golkar, another poll in the magazine showed that just 9% viewed Habibie
as a "fit and proper" person to serve as president. Before the scandal
broke on July 20, the figure had been 39%.
For Marzuki, the question
of whether the Bank Bali money made its way to Tim Sukses is "the whole
issue now," and could determine whether the party is prepared to unite
behind Habibie when it holds its final leadership meeting on October 20.
Other Golkar opponents of his bid to keep the presidency have already made
up their minds. "By staying there, Habibie will only distort the reform
process and jeopardize the fabric of the nation," says former Golkar Secretary-General
Sarwono Kusumaadmadja, pointing to the twin problems of corruption and
fraying national unity -- the crises in Aceh in East Timor.
Habibie's supporters, however,
remain determined. They argue that the general election that took place
in June and the presidential election due on November 10 are two different
processes. One was decided by the masses while the other will be settled
by the new national assembly composed of the 500 members of the House of
Representatives elected in June and a number of appointed members. The
fact that voters backed opposition leader Megawati Sukarnoputri in the
June election doesn't mean the assembly must follow suit, the president's
supporters say.
Could Habibie's supporters
buy the presidency despite the opposition's triumph in the general election?
"I think so," says Rachmat Witoelar, another former Golkar secretary-general.
"There's a widespread belief it can be done because the appointed members
of the assembly are vulnerable people."
Little is known for sure
about the low-profile Tim Sukses, mentions of which first began appearing
in Indonesian media about five months ago. It's believed to be built around
a close-knit core of associates from Sulawesi, Habibie's birthplace. "The
major players might not be saying that it exists," says James Van Zorge,
a political analyst and publisher of the Van Zorge Report, a twice-weekly
publication on Indonesian politics, "but no one is denying it either. Of
course it exists."
Eki, the senior Golkar official
who confirmed Marzuki's account of the August meeting, and who led the
party's election committee in the June poll, also confirms the group's
existence. He says it was formed about six months ago after Habibie narrowly
got his nomination accepted in the plenary session held to choose Golkar's
presidential candidate. "Habibie was not sure he had the trust of Golkar,"
says Eki, "so he created his own team."
Eki says the group includes
Habibie's two brothers, Effendy ("Fanny") and Suyatim ("Timmy"); State
Advisory Council Chairman Arnold Baramuli, who is also a member of Golkar's
board of advisers; and Hariman Siregar, a former student activist who was
jailed for his role in 1974 riots in Jakarta. Media reports and another
party source say other members include Setya, the Golkar deputy treasurer
whose company received the Bank Bali cash, and State Enterprise Minister
Tanri Abeng. Tanri has been tagged by local media as one of Habibie's main
fundraisers -- a description he rejected in a faxed response to the Review.
Another Tim Sukses member,
according to a party source, is Nurdin Halid, former head of a clove monopoly
run by Tommy Suharto, a son of former President Suharto. Nurdin said in
a recent media interview that Tim Sukses has been campaigning throughout
the country's 27 provinces. He said part of its strategy was to target
opposition-party officials in remote provinces in a bid to secure votes
among the 135 assembly members nominated by regional parties.
But Tim Sukses may be prepared
to do more than just campaign. One of its key figures, asked by the Review
in early June if he thought the assembly could be bought, responded: "Pastilah
[Certainly]." This man, who insisted on anonymity, also said the parliamentary
elections shouldn't be taken seriously. "For me, this election is only
an International Monetary Fund package. They need a legitimate government
to protect their money."
Marzuki has no doubts that
Tim Sukses is prepared to buy votes: "Their job is to secure the numbers,"
he says. "I have no doubt money politics is involved and that people around
Habibie are using money politics to win his presidency. There's a general
sense and belief these are real happenings. It's not easy to corroborate
in terms of real evidence, but transactions are happening, there is no
doubt."
Elements of the military
are also worried. Lt.-Gen. Agum Gumelar, governor of the National Defence
Institute, told a closed-door gathering in Singapore in early August that
anyone who uses money to win the presidency "won't last long," according
to someone who was present. Speaking to officers attending summer school
at the Institute for Defence and Strategic Studies, Agum said the army
is only obliged to support a president who comes to power through "just
and fair means."
The old-style politics of
Tim Sukses also faces resistance from Indonesia's middle classes, chastened
by cronyism's contribution to the Asian Crisis.
Sarwono, a former senior
figure in Golkar, believes an amalgam of honest bureaucrats, journalists,
lawyers and others disgusted by corruption are in the vanguard of opposition.
"There is this white-collar conspiracy with state funds being embezzled
and diverted for personal or political purposes, and what we're seeing
is a white-collar network fighting it," Sarwono says. Political sources
say Indonesian Corruption Watch, a private watchdog, has recorded 40 corruption
cases involving figures in the Habibie administration. For Habibie the
risk is that the perceptions of wrongdoing surrounding Tim Sukses will
lose him the support of even more members of Golkar and deepen its divisions.
Even presidential adviser Dewi Fortuna Anwar lamely admitted recently that
"the president can't do much, even when he is so clean and honest, because
so many people around him aren't clean."
Timor
crisis drags down Rupiah, stocks
Jakarta Post - September
8, 1999
Jakarta -- The rupiah breached
on Monday the 8,000 level against the US dollar as international pressure
increased over Indonesia's handling of the East Timor issue.
Currency dealers said investors
dumped their Indonesian currency over concerns that the growing pressure
would prompt donors to suspend loans to Indonesia.
The rupiah lost nearly 2.5
percent to end the day at Rp 8,010 against the American dollar -- its lowest
level since early June -- from 7,815 at the close of Friday trading.
The East Timor issue also
dragged down share prices, with the Jakarta Stock Exchange (JSX) Composite
Index falling almost 4.5 percent to close at 549.42 in thin trading.
Major countries and international
institutions warned Indonesia on Monday to ensure stability in the violence-wracked
province.
The International Monetary
Fund, which is leading a US$43 billion economic bailout for Indonesia,
issued on Monday a veiled threat, saying the Indonesian government had
"every interest in seeing the process in East Timor unfold smoothly and
without violence, in accordance with internationally recognized norms".
Bank Indonesia (BI) Governor
Sjahril Sabirin also acknowledged that the weakening of the rupiah against
the US dollar was directly related to the situation in East Timor.
He acknowledged that the
central bank had intervened in the market to prevent the market rate from
moving unrealistically out of proportion due to the political instability.
He said BI sold $5 million on the day to arrest a further drop in the Indonesian
currency.
Sabirin said the current
ideal level for the rupiah exchange rate against the greenback was between
Rp 6,000 and Rp 7,000 per dollar.
Mirroring the rupiah, stock
prices on the Jakarta Stock Exchange fell 24.76 points, or 4.38 percent,
to close at 540.42 in thin trading with a total value of only about Rp
300 billion.
Vonny Juwono, a broker at
PT Trimegah Securindolestari, said that foreign investors, the main market
players in the local stock market, mostly sold their blue chip stocks.
She said the instability
in East Timor was affecting the market. "There is certainly the East Timor
factor, which led to the drop in share prices."
Vonny said trading on the
JSX in coming days would continue to remain thin and bearish. She said
that the trading value was below Rp 400 billion.
Vonny said the East Timor
issue had overshadowed the potential market effects of the companies' good
results in the first half in financial reports recently released to the
public.
At the close of trading,
shares of state-owned telecommunication companies were down. PT Telkom
lost 6.2 percent, or Rp 175 to Rp 2,650, and PT Indosat fell 1.7 percent,
or Rp 200 to Rp 2,650.
Cigarette manufacturer PT
Gudang Garam lost 9.1 percent, or Rp 1,700 to Rp 17,000, and its competitor
HM Sampoerna fell by 4.2 percent, or Rp 650 to Rp 15,000.
The most actively traded
Bank Lippo shares fell 13 percent, or Rp 25 to Rp 175.
Military
exercises called off
Sydney Morning Herald - September
11, 1999
Peter Cole-Adams and Mark
Metherell -- The Federal Government yesterday cancelled three joint Australia-Indonesia
training exercises and announced a review of all aspects of the defence
relationship.
Only hours before the announcement,
the Prime Minister, Mr Howard, had dismissed the defence links between
the two countries, on which Australia had planned to spend nearly $8 million
this year, as "neither here nor there".
Mr Howard, the Defence Minister,
Mr Moore, and the Chief of the Defence Force, Admiral Barrie, all rejected
calls for a complete break in defence ties. They said it was critically
important to retain the links that had made it possible for Australia to
evacuate United Nations staff from Dili and support those still in the
UN compound.
Mr Howard also announced
an initial $3 million in humanitarian aid through UN agencies for East
Timorese victims of the killing and violence of recent days. It would be
used to buy, stockpile and transport blankets, plastic sheeting, health
and kitchen kits and other emergency supplies.
He said Australia was ready
to provide more aid as soon as the security position improved and there
was a clearer picture of what was needed.
But Mr Howard described calls
to withdraw Australian recognition of Indonesian sovereignty over East
Timor as "empty" and "futile".
"It's a bit late for that,"
he said, because, according to the May 5 agreement signed by Indonesia,
East Timor would soon be independent. On economic ties, Mr Howard said
these were "on the table", but ruled out a trade boycott. The Treasurer,
Mr Costello, when asked if the $1 billion Australia had pledged to Indonesia
would be withheld, said: "Well I can't see that we will be [doing that]
in the current situation. No."
Labor's spokesmen on foreign
affairs and defence, Mr Brereton and Mr Martin, said the part-cancellation
of defence exercises and the review of other aspects of the defence relationship
fell hopelessly short of what was needed to send an unambiguous message
to Jakarta. They demanded full suspension of bilateral defence ties.
Mr Brereton said continued
recognition of Indonesian sovereignty was unsustainable and warned the
assumption that Indonesia would honour its undertaking to let Timor become
independent showed "tragic naivety".
Admiral Barrie listed three
joint training programs to be cancelled: a paratroop exercise planned for
Brisbane in November, an instructor-training mission to Indonesia by junior
officers this month, and a planned capability development seminar. But
this was not the full list, he said. A "fair slice" of the $7.8 million
defence co-operation program would now be under review.
A leading defence analyst,
Dr Des Ball, said the events in East Timor had shown Australia's defence
strategy with Indonesia to have been "a massive policy failure" in its
bid to influence the Jakarta military chiefs.
Thousands
take to the streets over Timor
Australian Associated Press
- September 12, 1999
Ordinary Australians took
to the streets in their thousands today demanding urgent government action
over the slaughter in East Timor.
Protesters stormed Prime
Minister John Howard's Sydney office, blockaded airline terminals and maintained
vigils as nation-wide anger continued to mount over the genocide in the
violence- wracked region.
The anti-Indonesia demonstrations
called on the Australian government to withdraw recognition of Indonesia's
sovereignity of East Timor and to immediately send in armed peacekeeping
forces.
About 20,000 protesters took
over Sydney streets to broadcast their condemnation of Australia's refusal
to act on peacekeeping forces without Indonesian permission and a UN mandate.
"Make the Australian government
do what the Australian people want -- send troops in," these protesters
chanted. Wielding banners emblazoned with slogans such as "Howard You Coward"
and "East Timor -- Blood on Howard's hands" a breakaway group of protesters
battered their way into the building containing Prime Minister John Howard's
office.
To screams of "UN in, Indonesia
out" the group of about 30 protesters rammed their way into the building,
buckling the front door and occupying the lifts for a short time.
The break-in was a mere 15
minute episode during a five hour rally which featured demands for the
federal government to cut all ties with Indonesia. It followed a CFMEU
push for a national consumer boycott of Indonesian products and services.
Spokesman Andrew Ferguson
also threatened Australian retailers they would be picketed if they did
not take Indonesian goods off their shelves.
Meanwhile, dozens of building
workers and East Timorese blocked Garuda's passenger check-in area at Melbourne
Airport today, preventing many passengers from boarding a flight to Bali.
Channel Ten said the Construction,
Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (CFMEU), checked boarding passes at the
departure gates, preventing those Bali-bound passenger from going through
and cheering through those off to other destinations.
The flight took off, but
many angry passengers were not aboard. Union spokesman Martin Kingham said:
"We had a payload of 170 and of those 170 only four got on the plane".
And about 30 people maintained
the continuing vigil outside the Indonesian Consulate in Melbourne's inner
city Queens Road, following today's 150-strong free Timor rally.
In Brisbane, unionists, children
and nuns were among well over 1,000 protesters who packed City Hall for
a rally in support of East Timor.
Jose Teixiera, a spokesman
for the Brisbane-based Timorese community group East Timor National Resistance
Council, said one way of showing Indonesia how Australians felt about the
atrocities in the troubled province was to call for the boycott of Indonesia
at next year's Sydney Olympics.
He said that the International
Olympic Committee (IOC) should be asked to examine whether it was "proper"
for Indonesian athletes to compete against those from countries seeking
Indonesia's withdrawal from East Timor.
And in Adelaide more than
500 people marched to Foreign Minister Alexander Downer's office, the Indonesian
consulate and Parliament House, where a vigil began yesterday.
Action in Solidarity with
Indonesia and East Timor group activist Emma Webb said the vigil would
continue for as long as it took for peace to return to East Timor. Meanwhile,
federal parliament is expected to consider a motion to recognise the sovereignty
of East Timor.
Democrats senator Vicky Bourne
told a Sydney protest she would ask Independent Peter Andren to put forward
the motion at the next sitting of parliament.
Australia is at the forefront
of international calls for a multinational peacekeeping force for East
Timor and has offered to send up to 4,500 troops, but Mr Howard refuses
to act without Indonesian permission and a UN mandate.
The
tide of protest swells
The Australian - September
11, 199
In another day of nationwide
demonstrations more than 25,000 protesters packed the centre of Melbourne
yesterday to hear East Timor independence leader Xanana Gusmao appeal to
his Australian "brothers and sisters" to pressure the Howard Government
to send peace enforcers into East Timor.
"I thank our friends, the
people of Australia, my brothers and sisters, Australian workers and Australian
students. Please help us, please help me to save my people," Mr Gusmao
said.
East Timorese guerilla leader
and Falintil chief of staff Taur Matan Ruak earlier spoke to the rally
by satellite phone and appealed for a food airlift from Australia directly
into the hills of Timor to aid starving refugees.
Postal, tele-communications
and freight bans were imposed on Indonesian embassies by Victorian unions
yesterday, while union pickets at Melbourne airport continued to severely
disrupt the plans of holiday-makers flying to Indonesia.
About 60 unionists blockaded
check-in counters for the 8.55am flight to Bali, leading to two arrests.
In Sydney, scuffles broke
out as more than 500 protesters blockaded Garuda's check-in counters at
8am and then tried to blockade the departure gate.
Elsewhere in Sydney, almost
1000 high school and university students stopped lunchtime traffic as they
marched through the CBD before joining East Timorese for a sit-in at the
Garuda office.
In Canberra, Parliament House
faced another embarrassing security breach yesterday when East Timorese
activists dodged patrolling guards and spray-painted "shame Australia shame"
over the building's entrance.
Four men perched dangerously
over the entrance on a glass roof and held police at bay for about an hour.
One of the four protesters
arrested after the incident, Gareth Smith, who worked as part of the UN
mission, later told Canberra Magistrates Court he had faced a "crisis of
conscience", with many of his East Timorese friends being jailed or killed.
Elsewhere in Canberra, people
tooting their horns in support of protesters outside the Indonesian embassy
were yesterday hit with $90 fines by Australian Federal Police.
Meanwhile, travel retailer
Flight Centre has become the first tourism operator to react to the Indonesian
tragedy, threatening to pull the plug on millions of dollars of business
to Bali.
Flight Centre -- which sends
around 100,000 travellers to Indonesia each year -- has written to Indonesian
embassies around the world warning that it will encourage its clients to
holiday elsewhere, chief executive officer, Graham Turner, said yesterday.
"We will also be advising
people not to fly with Garuda, the [Indonesian] national carrier," Mr Turner
said. Flight Centre's business to Indonesia amounts to between $130 million
and $150 million a year, or 10 percent of their business out of Australia.
Solicitors in NSW are being
encouraged to volunteer to help prepare evidence briefs and prosecution
cases arising from alleged human rights atrocities in East Timor.
The chairman of the society's
Human Rights Taskforce, Michael Antrum, said solicitors would perform a
range of duties, including viewing atrocity sites, taking statements and
researching where laws had been breached and human rights abuses had occurred.