Democratic
struggle
East
Timor
Political/Economic
crisis
Aceh/West
Papua
News
& issues
Environment/Health
Police
arrest students protesting at palace
Agence France Presse - August
23, 1999
Jakarta -- Indonesian security
personnel in the capital on Monday arrested at least nine students who
had attempted to protest at the palace against clinging Suharto-era politicians
and political and economic practices.
The students, from the Mercu
Buana private university in West Jakarta, stepped down from public buses
with a flaming flag of the ruling Golkar party and marched towards the
front of the Merdeka Palace but were intercepted by police and soliders
guarding the area, an AFP photographer said.
A leaflet distributed by
the students called for an end to all corrupt political and economic practices
prevalent under the 32 years of former president Suharto and the eradication
of "criminals" of Suharto's New Order era who still clung to power.
The students were brought
to nearby police vehicles where they were questioned, the photographer
said.
The state palace is one of
the "strategic locations" where public demonstrations are off limits, according
to a law governing public protests.
The ruling Golkar is currently
under criticism following allegations that it had benefited from an 80
million dollar commission taken by a party deputy treasurer in the Bank
Bali interbank debt scandal.
The Bank Bali case has already
led to split within the party's ranks opposing those wanting a transparency
in the case and those saying that the Bank Bali case did not involve the
party.
Gunmen
aim to intimidate press
South China Morning Post
- August 27, 1999
Joanna Jolly, Dili -- It
was after the thousands opposed to independence had paraded through Dili
that a hard-core of several hundred militiamen showed the true colours
of the pro-integration campaign.
With the main convoy of trucks
and buses crammed with Indonesian flag-wavers out of town and on the road
to Liquica, the gunmen, in their black shirts bearing the Aitarak militia
insignia, marched through the streets shooting wildly in the air.
Streets in the town centre
emptied before them as they descended on the main resistance headquarters.
In a road beside the office, a South Korean cameraman filmed the militia
members shooting their home-made guns.
The militia turned on him,
but police intervened and he was unharmed. So, too, was a female colleague
who got out of a car to help him. She had a gun forced into her back before
police also hurried her away. Both were ordered to shelter behind a truck.
I was among three other journalists
told to join them. After a moment of calm, about 150 militiamen marched
towards the truck shouting.
Most were armed, some with
Kalashnikov AK-47 automatic rifles, Portuguese pistols and sawn-off shotguns
while others had knives. Some wore army fatigues, others the red beret
of the Indonesian Kopassus special forces. Among them was Aitarak leader
Eurico Gutierres, in army fatigues and a beret, brandishing an AK-47. Shouting
"kill them all" they came for the truck. Three of us sheltered inside the
cabin.
One of the two outside had
a knife pulled on him. A policeman yanked back his attacker. The militiamen
now shouted "kill all Australian journalists" and tried to kick the two
journalists. Police pushed the two into the cabin and told us all to keep
our heads down as the fighters rocked the vehicle.
When, after about 10 minutes,
they moved away, guns blazing in the air, police radioed for a car but,
after a few minutes, escorted us instead to the Hotel Dili.
Other journalists there had
been shot at and chased by machete- wielding militiamen across the hotel
compound into the main building. The firing lasted more than an hour, they
said, until police formed a cordon to keep the gunmen at a distance. In
the hills behind, smoke rose from several large fires.
The militias' action could
only have been deliberate -- and intended, perhaps, to intimidate foreign
reporters into getting out of town before Monday's vote.
Australia
ready to rescue foreigners
Sydney Morning Herald - August
27, 1999
Peter Cole-Adams -- Australia
put military units on standby yesterday to evacuate about 200 Australians,
and other foreign nationals, from East Timor after Monday's vote on the
future of the province.
The Defence Minister, Mr
Moore, and the Foreign Minister, Mr Downer, told their Indonesian counterparts,
General Wiranto and Mr Ali Alatas, about the decision in advance.
Mr Moore described it as
a "necessary and prudent step" in view of heightened tensions, violence
and intimidation in the lead-up to Monday's ballot.
Neither Mr Moore nor the
Chief of the Defence Force, Admiral Christopher Barrie, would go into detail,
but they confirmed that military elements in Darwin, Townsville and elsewhere
were involved in the planning for a possible evacuation and had been put
on increased readiness for possible deployment.
Military analysts suggest
the fast catamaran, HMAS Jervis Bay, or Australia's fleet of Hercules aircraft
would be required, and that the parachute regiment or the Perth-based Special
Air Service might be needed -- in addition to combat-ready troops based
in Darwin and Townsville -- to secure embarkation points.
But Mr Moore said last night
that Australia would send troops only in conjunction with the United Nations
and with the approval of Indonesia. "But we stand ready, and [are] making
plans, to evacuate Australians if the position deteriorates," he added.
The Australians include observers,
civilian police and military liaison officers attached to the UN mission,
as well as aid workers and journalists.
Meanwhile, Australia and
the United States intensified diplomatic pressure on Jakarta to bring the
pro-autonomy militias under control.
The US Assistant Secretary
of State for East Asia and the Pacific, Mr Stanley Roth, said in Canberra
that a successful resolution of the East Timor problem could give Indonesia
a special claim for international help to restructure its economy.
But he warned there would
be negative consequences if the independence-or-autonomy ballot and its
aftermath were marred by a security breakdown. "It won't be business as
usual ...," he told the National Press Club. "They [the Indonesians] will
pay a price if this is not managed well."
Mr Downer said he had told
Mr Alatas that it was "absolutely critical" to stop militia violence, that
any threat of death or injury against Australians in East Timor was completely
unacceptable, and that the consequences of harm to any Australian would
be "very serious indeed".
Labor's foreign affairs spokesman,
Mr Brereton was on his way to Dili yesterday as a member of Australia's
10-member observer mission for Monday's ballot.
He said more than 438,000
people had shown courage in registering to vote but would be going to the
polls against the backdrop of months of violence and intimidation.
Thousands
go hungry as mayor blocks aid
Sydney Morning Herald - August
27, 1999
Mark Dodd -- Something is
rotten in the regency of Suai. About 3,000 East Timorese refugees are living
in unsanitary conditions, without adequate food, water or medicine, crammed
into the grounds of an unfinished church under grass roof humpies and plastic
sheeting.
They are in fear of their
lives because outside the grounds are the Laksaur militia who, helped by
local army personnel, drove the refugees from their homes in a deadly pogrom
of house burnings, murder and intimidation earlier this year.
The local bupati (mayor)
says the refugees, many of whom are women with infants, support independence
and are undeserving of humanitarian aid. He cut off their water supply
last week and refused access for a relief convoy from Dili.
There is no food shortage
in Suai. On Wednesday morning, a crowd of about 2,000 people showed up
for a rally in town although their motivation had less to do with singing
patriotic Indonesian jingles than it did with a promise of five kilograms
of free rice, T-shirts and baseball caps.
Outside the church surly
faced militiamen walk down the street carrying machetes. Police stand by,
watching. Machetes are a traditional weapon, not illegal they say.
Shortly after 8am, two yellow
dump trucks arrive at the rally and start unloading sacks of rice. Among
the militia helpers, is a uniformed Indonesian police officer standing
atop one of the trucks, heaving bags of rice into a sea of outstretched
hands. The local priest in Suai, Father Hilario, has taken responsibility
for the plight of the refugees, a thankless task which has incurred the
militia's wrath, and a death threat.
"The situation now is bad,"
he said. "There is no food and no medicine. They have come here because
of the militias who have been terrorising the local people." He described
the refugees' health as "very bad". They had access to only one water point
once the mains supply was restored late on Saturday following United States
diplomatic pressure, he said.
"I think the reason they
[local authorities] cut off the water was the bupati," Father Hilario said.
"He said it was an accident, but he is angry at the people. The refugees
don't want to go outside because the militia are still there. The majority
of the people are pro-independence." The priest estimated more than 400
people had been murdered by the militia and their army allies in and around
Suai since January -- a figure not disputed by the United Nations Assistance
Mission in East Timor (UNAMET). Most of the refugees were registered to
vote in Monday's referendum but he was extremely worried about their safety
after
polling day.
Continuing militia violence
and intimidation remains a serious threat to the success of Monday's vote.
But 8,000 Indonesian police
charged with maintaining law and order over the ballot period are reluctant
to put themselves on a collision course with their army colleagues, although
there have been some exceptions.
Suai, in the south-west corner
of East Timor, and neighbouring Maliana are two recurring sites of militia
violence.
UN officials and aid workersclaim
militiamen were responsible for a grenade attack last Thursday. A fragmentation
grenade was tossed into the church grounds but did not explode among the
refugees camped there.
The office of the National
Council for Timorese Resistance (CNRT) has closed in Suai due to fears
of violence, its staff moving in with the refugees. "Now we are afraid
and pray to God to help us. There are many rumours that after the vote
they [militia] will do something," Father Hilario said.
One 25-year-old man, called
Bento, said he and his family fled from Zumulai to escape militia violence
a month ago. He now lives in the church grounds with his parents, a brother
and two sisters after fleeing the family home. "We were intimidated by
[militia groups] Laksaur and Mahidi. That is why we fled into the forest.
We were beaten, our houses
were burnt, many of us were tortured. I saw one of my friends tortured.
They [militia] tore out his fingernails and stubbed cigarette butts on
his hands," he said.
Asked why the militia did
this, he replied: "Because we will not accept autonomy." Two other refugees,
Elizabeth dos Reido, 22 and Paulo Augustin, 30 recounted similar stories.
"One day the Laksaur captured
two people in our village, Fatulaura," Ms dos Reido said. "One was killed.
Most of the people left the village after that incident."
Dili
violence threatens independence vote
Australian Financial Review
- August 27, 1999
Tim Dodd, Dili -- United
Nation officials are considering whether Monday's referendum for independence
on East Timor can go ahead after pro-Indonesia militia groups fought pitched
battles with independence supporters in Dili's streets yesterday afternoon,
leaving at least three people dead.
Shots echoed around Dili
for 30 minutes as militiamen smashed the offices of the main independence
organisation, the National Council of Timorese Resistance and sent truckloads
of armed men into Becoro, a suburb of Dili which strongly supports independence.
The worst of the violence
erupted after a pro-Indonesian rally attended by several thousand people,
where Mr Eurico Guterres, the leader of the local militia group, Aitarak,
urged his followers, who included armed militiamen, to go to Becoro, an
independence neighbourhood.
Mr Guterres had earlier threatened
to push for East Timor to be partitioned if the independence side wins
Monday's ballot. Pro- Indonesian feeling is much stronger in the western
section of East Timor.
Last night, UN officials
were conferring with the Indonesian authorities and diplomats on whether
the referendum can proceed, given the poor security.
After talks with both sides,
the UN mission, which is running the referendum, has decided to cancel
today's campaigning by the independence side in case it sparks more violence.
Indonesian police, who have
been heavily criticised for not acting to stop trouble, did intervene yesterday
by firing shots into the air. They also protected at least one group of
foreigners who were caught in the middle of the violence. However, the
police are likely to be criticised for shooting dead one man, claimed to
be a provocateur, as he ran.
The fighting in Dili yesterday
contrasted with Wednesday's huge, peaceful rally by 10,000 or more independence
supporters, when whole families came out to support separation from Indonesia.
Yesterday's rally by pro-Indonesia
campaigners, who support remaining part of Indonesia under the autonomy
package offered by President B.J. Habibie, was less than half as large
and was dominated by young men rather than families.
They cruised the streets
packed into more than 100 trucks and buses decorated with the red and white
Indonesian national colours, then rallied at a soccer field.
Yesterday's fighting began
in Becora when militia entered the area and, according to locals, threw
rocks at a picture of the independence leader, Mr Xanana Gusmao.
Away from Timor, Indonesian
marines shot dead five people and wounded scores of others yesterday when
they confronted a Muslim mob in a fresh wave of sectarian violence in Maluku
province, a military officer and witnesses said.
Lieutenant-Colonel Ivsan
Art, commander of a marine battalion sent to reinforce the local police,
said his men opened fire to prevent the mob from breaking into a Christian
neighbourhood in the provincial capital Ambon, 2,300 kilometres east of
Jakarta.
Transcript
of live report from Dili
Australian Broadcasting Corporation
- August 27, 1999
Mark Colvin: We begin the
programme tonight in Dili, capital of East Timor, where there's been a
major and ominous development involving a shoot-out involving pro-autonomy
militias and pro- independence supporters. Our correspondent, Mark Bowling,
was in the middle of it and he's just endured a fairly dangerous situation
getting out of it. Mark joins me on the satellite phone now. Mark where
exactly are you and how did you get to safety, to start off with?
Mark Bowling: Mark, we are
down near the Dili waterfront after running the gauntlet of a militia gang.
They fired at our driver. He drove very courageously through the militia
gang as they aimed pipe guns at him.
They threw rocks at the car,
they smashed the windows in the car. My radio Australia colleague was hit
in the elbow. He has now tourniqued his elbow up. It's not bleeding extensively
but we are ... we are now safe and out of that situation.
But I think it's suffice
to say that the streets of Dili now are a battlefield between the pro-Jakarta
militias and youths who are mainly pro-independence youths.
Mark Colvin: Do you mean
your colleague was hit by a bullet or a rock?
Mark Bowling: He was hit
by a flying rock as they tried to stop our vehicle. One of the rocks smashed
the window, came through and hit him on the elbow.
Mark Colvin: So tell us what
built up to this incident?
Mark Bowling: Well there
was a stand-off between pro-Jakarta militias and the pro-independence youths.
They were separated by about
a hundred metres with a motorbike which had been set on light. The only
thing separating them the pro-Jakarta militias opened fire, first with
pipe guns, later with automatic weapons, and rather than run away the pro-
independence youths ran forward with sticks and stones and tried to fight
back.
So it became a very explosive
situation. We understand that that whole fight between the two groups started
with the burning of a house which belonged to a pro-independence supporter.
Mark Colvin: You were an
eye-witness right in the middle of this, and you're telling me that the
ones who were armed with guns, pipe guns, automatic weapons -- they were
the pro-autonomy militias. The pro-Jakarta forces. And are you saying that
the pro-independence forces were not armed in that way at all?
Mark Bowling: That's correct.
It was the pro-Jakarta militias who had both crude weapons made out of
pipes and cobbled together pieces of wood, but also we heard ... we heard
automatic firing outcoming from their direction as well. Facing off with
them were the pro-independence youths who were simply -- and I can say
that because we were amongst them -- armed with sticks and stones.
Mark Colvin: Now clearly
this represents a major betrayal of the promises by the pro-autonomy militias
that they had and would disarm. It also is presumably a major breach of
UN regulations in that they were holding a pro-autonomy march and rally
in Dili and there were armed people there. How serious an incident is this,
given that we're only a few days now from the poll itself?
Mark Bowling: Well, it's
extremely serious especially when the UN and other officials have been
saying that Dili is calm and under control, and that the areas to worry
about, the main hot-spots in East Timor, are towns along the border area
between East Timor and West Timor. They have pointed out these towns as
being Maliana and Sawai and so forth, but this afternoon we've seen that
the calm has broken in Dili itself.
It all started with a large
pro-integration, that is pro-Jakarta rally through the streets and that
ended with a large gathering in a football field and after that it's obvious
to say that the pro-Jakarta militiamen have taken to the streets, looked
at places to burn and people to shoot at.
Mark Colvin; And the obvious
question ... the other obvious question, I suppose, is where were the police?
Mark Bowling: Well, the police
did arrive at the scene that we were discussing before, the stand-off between
the two groups, but very very late. They came in and tried to get the pro-
independence youths to move away. They were met by shouts and screams and
told to get away themselves. They were unable to control that group and
therefore unable to control the situation.
Mark Colvin: Mark Bowling,
thank you very much indeed for that. Stay safe and look after your RA colleague.
Mark Bowling: Thank you,
Mark.
Militias
out in force as last rally cancelled
South China Morning Post
- August 28, 1999
Militiamen strutted the capital's
streets yesterday, a day after going on a deadly rampage, as a final rally
in the campaign for next week's vote fell victim to the violence.
Armed police were on guard,
but there was no sign of a planned joint rally by supporters and opponents
of independence on the last day of official campaigning for Monday's autonomy
ballot.
Amid international condemnation
of the Indonesian police, residents in the Kuluhun neighbourhood placed
rocks and leaves on a road to mark the spot where two independence supporters
died on Thursday.
The pair were among six killed
as pro-Indonesian militiamen, pressing for acceptance of the autonomy package
in Monday's vote, fought running battles with independence supporters.
Indonesian police for the
most part were unable to prevent Thursday's violence, and in many cases
stood by and allowed pro- Jakarta militia members, several of whom were
carrying automatic weapons, to fire on groups of independence supporters.
There were unconfirmed but
credible eyewitness reports that police killed one independence supporter
with a shot in the back after he demanded they arrest rampaging pro-Jakarta
militiamen.
At a news conference yesterday,
Indonesia's Ambassador-at-Large for East Timor, Francisco Lopes da Cruz,
accused independence supporters of starting the violence by stoning a pro-autonomy
rally.
On the streets of Dili, tension
remained high yesterday. Local staff fled the office of the UN refugee
agency, leaving only one expatriate to guard the premises. Militia fired
shots near a Unamet office, wounding two.
Several Dili-based human
rights groups told of continuing violence in the pro-independence suburbs
of Kuluhun and adjacent Becora.
Many people were fleeing
those neighbourhoods for the mountains or escaping to join family and friends
in safer parts of Dili.
One woman resident of Becora,
who asked not to be named, told human rights workers that the Aitarak militia
had threatened to steal her voter registration card and rape her if she
voted in the ballot.
Men armed with arrows and
machetes patrolled the side of the road, defending Kuluhun against any
fresh militia violence. One youth had a homemade gun. "There is an Aitarak
company behind the church with automatic weapons," a youth said.
Some shops were open and
public transport was running in central Dili as the two-week campaign came
to an end. But most streets were quiet.
East Timor's all-party Committee
for Peace and Justice met yesterday with representatives of the militias,
including Aitarak militia chief Eurico Guterres.
But no pro-independence representatives
were at the meeting, which came amid international calls for Indonesia
to do more to curb the militias.
Pessimism
grows ahead of East Timor vote
Sydney Morning Herald - August
29, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili --
Australia's senior observers have given a gloomy assessment of Monday's
historic ballot on the future of East Timor, but said there was no alternative
but to press ahead.
Labor's foreign affairs spokesman,
Mr Laurie Brereton, said a "huge question mark" hangs over the referendum
in which 450,000 registered voters will be asked to choose between autonomy
within Indonesia or independence.
"The die has been cast now
and it is very well cast," Mr Brereton said. "As each of us knows, the
[Indonesian] responsibility for security has not been met. We live in hope
it will be met in the next two days. But today it is tragedy heaped on
tragedy."
The former Deputy Prime Minister,
Mr Tim Fischer, said the United Nations-organised poll had to go ahead.
"East Timorese registered to vote against all odds, so don't write off
the process yet. What other alternative is there?"
In Dili, most shops were
closed and the streets virtually deserted as Jakarta faced mounting international
pressure over the continuing violence which left at least four people dead
last night.
In New York, the UN condemned
the violence and extended until November 30 the mandate of the UN Mission
in East Timor.
In Washington, President
Clinton warned Indonesia that its relations with the United States would
be seriously damaged if there was mass violence during the referendum process.
And in Australia, preparations
were continuing for a possible military evacuation of as many as 2000 foreigners,
including 200 Australians.
In the latest attacks in
and around the town of Maliana, Indonesian police are reported to have
stood by and watched as pro-Jakarta militias burnt houses and attacked
people. Since the militias provoked a fresh wave of violence in Dili on
Thursday, many residents of the capital and the other main towns have stayed
indoors, raising concern they will be too frightened to vote. Jakarta has
undertaken to allow independence for the former Portuguese colony after
23 years of Indonesian rule if its autonomy package is rejected.
US
threatens Indonesia over Timor violence
Dow Jones Newswires - August
29, 1999 (slightly abridged)
Washington -- US President
Bill Clinton has warned the president of Indonesia that relations with
the US will be seriously damaged -- including an implicit threat to curtail
international aid -- if there is mass violence during next week's referendum
on self- rule in East Timor, The New York Times reported Saturday, citing
senior administration officials. The US effectively has veto power over
international loans to Indonesia. Administration officials declined to
reveal the exact wording of the president's warning in a letter sent this
week, but one senior official told the New York Times the threat of curtailing
international loans and other aid through the International Monetary Fund
and the World Bank wasn't stated directly in the letter.
"But it's implicit," he said.
Another senior official said: "It's a very tough letter."
Officials told the New York
Times that Clinton's letter to President B.J. Habibie was intended to put
him on notice that he will be held responsible if the Indonesian military
fails to crack down on the anti-independence militias that have been responsible
for several recent killings in East Timor.
The Indonesian government
has been promised nearly $50 billion in loans from the IMF to deal with
the aftermath of the Asian economic crisis, which has crippled the economy
of the vast archipelago nation.
A three-member congressional
delegation that just returned from East Timor said that mass violence was
a strong possibility next week, especially given the close ties between
the well armed anti-independence militias and the Indonesian military and
police.
"My worst fears are coming
true," said Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, who led the delegation last week and
who supports the immediate use of peacekeeping troops there, possibly including
Americans. "I predicted this.
The civilian forces, the
Indonesian police, are not going to stop these thugs. They're openly associating
with them."
Harkin told The New York
Times that if there is widespread violence next week, he would push the
administration to punish Indonesia under a 1977 law requiring the US to
vote against World Bank loans for countries that systematically violate
human rights.
"It's important to underline
the fact that the Indonesian government itself has placed its credibility
on the line here," spokesman James Foley told the New York Times. "The
responsibility for maintaining law and order is East Timor is very much
the responsibility of the Indonesian authorities."
Island
of fear and faith
Sydney Morning Herald - Ausuts
28, 1999
The battle for the hearts
and minds -- and votes -- of the East Timorese people will not lose its
passion, writes Hamish McDonald from Dili, even after Monday's referendum.
Just after 6am, the camp
of palm-leaf huts is barely astir. Smoke from fires drifts in the soft
light across the looming walls of a half-built cathedral shrouded in bamboo
scaffolds. A few figures, sarongs around their shoulders, survey the bare
expanse of the churchyard to its iron-paling fence.
Yet the ramshackle old church
is already full, men on the right, women on the left. Voices soar in sweet
island harmonies. The white-clad priest intones the prayers in Tetum language,
and 300 sets of knees go down on the bare concrete floor and 300 sets of
palms are put together under 300 chins.
Father Domingos Soares begins
his sermon, and there is silence broken only by coughing. On Monday comes
a duty of voting which everyone has to accept with full responsibility,
before their own conscience, their people, and before God, to choose what
they think best for East Timor. We have suffered and waited a long time,
he says. Now is the moment for us to speak.
Later, when the sun is burning
hot, there is another gathering across the straggling township. Motorbikes
rasp through the streets, pillion passengers waving red and white Indonesian
flags, followed by dump-trucks and mini-buses crammed with young people.
In an open field where they
all stop, police are blowing whistles. A burly young man takes the mike
in front of a large speaker system and tries to lead everyone in a song
that repeats the word "Otonomi" (autonomy). But the crowd is distracted:
it mobs a truck from which a uniformed police sergeant is tossing T-shirts,
caps and lettered headbands to a sea of raised hands. Across the field,
a small crowd of housewives sit around a truck loaded with rice sacks.
These are the final days
of campaigning before Monday's vote on the territory's future, a vote to
stay with Indonesia with the promise of wider autonomy, or leave it --
to strike out as South-East Asia's newest and perhaps most bizarrely configured
nation.
The choice is quite sharply
defined in the two cultures vying for the hearts and minds of this embattled
town, Suai, in the far south-west corner of East Timor.
In the church compound are
about 2,500 people identified as supporters of independence. Mostly not
sophisticated people: men with beards and sun-darkened skin, women with
betel-nut stained mouths, people who use the "Bon Dias" of the old Portuguese
days, and raise the hand of a stranger to their lips.
They include Elisa du Redo,
22, who walked in from the outlying village of Fatuloro with her husband
and their four young children two months ago after armed men drove everyone
from their homes. Or Paulo Augustim, 36, who fled Taroman in May, after
the same group came looking for enemies and shot one in front of the entire
village.
Running that day's pro-autonomy
meeting is the same armed group, a pro-Indonesian militia called Laksaur.
It is said to be mild compared with the Mahidi, another militia largely
responsible for the deaths of the 400 or so independence sympathisers the
church estimates have been killed in the Suai-Same region since January.
The Laksaur operates from
an annexe to the local traffic police office and its rally has every facility
the government of surrounding Covalima regency can provide. Many of the
attendees are younger than 17, the voting age for the United Nations- supervised
ballot, suggesting local schoolchildren have been rounded up. The free
T-shirts and caps, the rations of rice at one-third the market price --
both are evidence of powerful backing.
By contrast, Elisa, Paulo
and their fellow "internally displaced persons" -- get nothing but harassment.
Their rations come from private charity, chiefly CARE, Caritas and Yayasan
Hak (Rights Foundation). Last week, the Laksaur prowled around one night,
shooting guns in the air and throwing rocks. The bupati (head of the regency)
turned off the water supply to the church, and only put it back on four
days later when two American senators came and complained.
A week before campaigning
was officially over, the Suai branch of the pro-independence movement,
the National Committee of Timorese Resistance, or CNRT, closed its office
in the town and moved into the church grounds, because of intimidation.
It stopped holding rallies because people seen attending were later visited
at home and threatened by militias. This week the house of an independence
sympathiser was burnt. The bupati has just stopped the rice ration of one
civil servant whose husband supports the CNRT.
Indonesian police, responsible
for security of the UN plebiscite, lounge around near the Suai market,
where pedlars lay out wizened vegetables and tiny eggs. "The police will
disperse militias," says one of Suai's group of the 1,400 foreign observers
monitoring the poll across Timor. "But they won't follow up complaints,
and they won't step on the military's toes."
Like other church leaders
and independent analysts, this observer has heard stories of special military
groups -- formed of serving or former members of the feared Kopassus or
Special Forces unit which took a leading role in the brutal conquest of
East Timor from 1974 onwards -- leading the Laksaur and Mahidi in terror
raids out of nearby West Timor.
Nothing can be confirmed
but the fears are real and held by educated, informed people. And while
much has changed in West Timor, some things haven't. Kupang, a wild mixing
pot of the archipelago's ethnic groups, has luxury hotels and supermarkets,
and a newspaper, Pos Kupang, that has taken political reform to heart and
gives its readers an unrelenting diet of corruption and power-struggle
stories.
But up the long twisting
road out through the dry mountainous landscape, the island is closer to
its violent, feudal past. Many of the dwellings are still thatch-roofed
huts and people walk the roads barefooted, with machetes swinging at their
belts. It is a land of feuds, of cattle raids, of fierce wars between warriors
swinging cutlasses made of sharpened car springs. "They have high blood
pressure," says a Balinese policeman in Atambua, the main town near the
border. "Arguments shift easily to blows."
Early last week, Atambua
was full of militia leaders from across the border-tough middle-aged men
in black T-shirts, fatigue trousers, and military-style vests. They filled
the central Intan Hotel, and ate a huge meal at the town's best restaurant,
guarded by police. The deputy police chief of Nusa Tenggara Timur province
(which includes West Timor) was also in town, and the next morning the
panglima (regional military commander) arrived.
Since the Portuguese and
Dutch set up rival empires more than 300 years ago, contending powers have
never found any shortage of local recruits to fight and oppress fellow
Timorese. "There is no other source of money in these villagers," says
an observer. "If someone puts you on the payroll and gives you rice to
turn up, you do it."
On Thursday, the militias
came back to the capital, Dili. From mid-morning the town filled with hundreds
of motorcycles and dozens of seized trucks and buses and other vehicles
-- even a fire engine. Late in the sultry, clouded day, clashes happened
with watching independence supporters. Quickly the eastern sector of the
town became a battleground, weapons were produced and fired, the CNRT headquarters
wrecked. Gunshot victims trickled into the few clinics run by religious
orders. Between three and 11 people were killed. No arrests were made by
police, who themselves shot one of the victims -- a young man trying to
run away from militias.
An attempt to derail the
vote, or just another case of "high blood pressure"? Most analysts here,
including the United Nations Assistance Mission on East Timor (UNAMET),
think something like the latter. Had the militias tried to seriously disrupt
the vote, Dili would have been in flames and a lot more blood would have
been running in the streets before the Indonesian garrison turned out.
So on Monday, it appears,
the vote will go ahead. The Timorese will have to face down the ranks of
militias who will prowl the streets of towns like Suai, and put their trust
in the few UNAMET officials, unarmed foreign police and military liaison
officers, plus the volunteer observers, a courageous group staying in isolated,
uncomfortable posts for the past three weeks. Some will have to make the
risky journey back from refugee camps like the Suai church ground to the
villages where they are registered. The vote will be a battle between faith
and fear.
Faith of people like Elisa
du Rado and Paulo Augustim at Suai, who know little about the shape of
an independent East Timor but are clear about what they want. "We don't
know about these things because we are just small people," says Augustim,
when asked what kind of government he expected. "But we don't like the
Indonesians because they have their five principles [the state ideology
of Pancasila] but their attitude is completely different."
And fear of militia leaders,
like Eurico Guterres, leader of the Aitarak militia group active around
Dili and Liquica, who openly threatens to seal off East Timor from outside
contact after the vote and turn it into a "sea of flames".
It will also be a battle
of magical beliefs. On the militia side the elaborate oath ceremonies with
drinks of animal blood and liquor, and the planting of Indonesian flags
in front of almost every household.
On the independence side,
a sense of traditional lulik, or sacred duty, going back beyond the time
when Dominican friars planted Christianity at Lifau in 1556, layered by
membership of a church that has stayed with the people through all their
hard times and, under Nobel laureate Bishop Carlos Belo, has put their
rights before the world.
These mostly illiterate people
will have to mark a ballot paper asking two quite complicated questions.
But the observers have been impressed at the way 450,000 or so have registered,
turning up with the required documentation even in remote locations. They
know that the vote is the main test, but that many others will follow.
Father Hilario, the head
priest in Suai, believes that Timorese will keep faith. Even the militias,
he thinks. "They do what they are doing to save themselves," he says. "But
in their hearts it does not correspond with what they feel."
And after the vote? "We are
very afraid, and we pray to God to help us," Father Hilario says. "There
are many rumours that after the vote they [the militias] will do something,
that they will attack."
Watching a pro-autonomy rally,
an observer makes the same point. "They know who to kill," he says. "If
these people start to die, the international community will have a terrible
responsibility. We will all get on a plane after the poll and leave. The
polling staff will also leave. There will be just the UN police and military
staff. The people here are very fearful."
Indonesia
will fight if UN peace force sent
Agence France Presse - August
27, 1999 (abridged)
Lisbon -- The Indonesian
army will fight to the last soldier if a UN peacekeeping force is sent
to East Timor without Jakarta's approval, a senior Indonesian diplomat
told the Portuguese news agency Lusa on Friday.
Nughrobo Wisnumurti, head
of his country's delegation to triparite talks here between Indonesia,
Portugal and the United Nations, was quoted as saying that "we will never
submit to international pressure nor allow foreign soldiers in East Timor
as long as this territory is Indonesian."
Wisnumurti said the United
Nations "cannot send a [peacekeeping force] without an agreement" but that
if it did, "we would send troops." His country, he said, "was not Kosovo."
Wisnumurti said that, regardless
of the outcome of Monday's vote, Indonesia had sufficient resources to
guarantee public order in East Timor. If there was conflict after the vote,
Indonesia would have no need to increase its forces in the territory, he
said.
He also predicted that Monday's
outcome would be 50:50 between integrationists and independence-seekers.
Photographer
says saw police protester
Reuters - August 27, 1999
(slightly abridged)
Lisbon -- A photographer
with US magazine Time said on Friday he had witnessed Indonesian police
shoot dead a 25-year-old unarmed protester in the head during clashes in
East Timor ahead of Monday's ballot on independence.
The American photographer
told Portugal's TSF radio that he had photographed the killing in the East
Timor capital Dili on Thursday. He said the picture would be published
by Time on Monday.
"The police shot him and
turned around and walked away," said the photographer, whom TSF said had
asked that his name not be revealed for security reasons.
"The police were chasing
a presumed supporter of independence who wore an emblem in support of [East
Timor resistance leader] Xanana [Gusmao] on his hat. He [the youth] had
obviously been involved in the clashes," he added.
"They [police] ran up right
close to him, maybe within two metres, and shot him in the back of the
head. He died immediately," the photographer said.
He said the police involved
in the incident, between eight and 10, walked away immediately. The photographer
said he did not know why the police had picked out this youth.
`Dirty-tricks'
general recalled
The Age - August 28, 1999
Mark Dodd, Dili -- Under
intense diplomatic pressure, Jakarta has recalled from Dili a senior intelligence
officer alleged to be a key figure behind militia activity in East Timor.
A foreign diplomat said the
decision to recall Major-General Zacky Anwar had been made by the Indonesian
Defence Minister, General Wiranto. General Anwar, a career intelligence
officer serving as senior military liaison to the UN mission, is widely
believed to be a dirty-tricks specialist involved in the campaign against
independence. He left Dili on Monday.
In related developments,
two senior military officers in command of district posts in strife-torn
Suai and Maliana have been reassigned, the diplomat said.
General Anwar is expected
to be replaced by the head of Kopassus (Special Forces Command), a close
colleague of General Wiranto. Indonesian military sources in Dili declined
to confirm or deny the developments.
The decision was taken before
yesterday's bloody street clashes between rival supporters of the independence
and autonomy proposals that left at least five killed, more than 12 people
injured and property destroyed.
"Our thoughts are this --
Wiranto is on line to try and stop this violence. He's got all this international
pressure and he wants to be [Indonesia's] next vice-president," the diplomat
said.
In a similar surprise move
last week Special Forces Colonel Tono Suratman was replaced by Colonel
Mohamed Noer Muis as East Timor's military commander. The head of the UN
Mission in East Timor (UNAMET), Ian Martin, told a packed news conference
today that he believed there was a new willingness in Jakarta to act against
militia violence to ensure a successful referendum.
"I believe that at the highest
level of the Indonesian Government there is a wish to see the popular consultation
completed peacefully," he said. "At the same time that is not translating
into the conduct of Indonesian security forces on the ground."
Overnight the UN Secretary-General,
Kofi Annan, attacked Indonesia for its failure to prevent widespread militia
violence on the streets of Dili.
Yesterday's violence, centred
in the pro-independence suburbs of Kuluhun and Becora, was believed to
have been instigated by pro- Jakarta militia on the last day of political
campaigning for a referendum on East Timor's future political status scheduled
for Monday. "The Secretary-General is appalled at the widespread violence
in Dili. He demands the Indonesian authorities take immediate steps to
restore and maintain law and order," a statement said.
Mr Annan called on Indonesian
authorities to arrest those responsible for planning and carrying out yesterday's
mayhem and reaffirmed the determination of the UNAMET to press ahead and
hold the historic ballot.
Human rights officials in
Dili reported scores of residents fleeing Kuluhun and Becora overnight
to escape militia retribution, although calm was restored on the streets
on Friday. After receiving militia threats, the local staff of the UN refugee
agency (UNHCR) fled on Friday leaving the Dili office manned by one expatriate.
Mr Martin said today with
polling only three days away, Indonesian police had repeatedly failed to
uphold their obligation to ensure security. The small UN mission in East
Timor is unarmed and has no peace-enforcement role, relying on pressure
from the international community to force Jakarta to stick to the terms
of the agreement it signed in New York last May.
"I can only hope that Indonesia's
very keen awareness that the eyes of the world are on East Timor will finally
have that effect," Mr Martin said.
"Clearly there was not adequate
security in Dili yesterday just as there has not been adequate security
in Maliana, Viqueque and other places in recent days.
That's why these statements
make clear that the Indonesians have a responsibility to do more than is
being done to ensure security," he said.
The
trouble with trusting Indonesia
Australian Financial Review
- August 28, 1999
Brian Toohey -- Australian
policy makers have fought long and hard to get the international community
to trust Indonesia's security forces to prevent a bloodbath in East Timor.
So it is little wonder that the Defence Minister, John Moore, claimed he
was merely taking a "routine precaution" when he announced on Thursday
that Australian forces were being put on alert to evacuate people from
East Timor.
The only trouble was that
the rest of Moore's statement highlighted how Australian policy is in ruins.
Far from the security situation improving in East Timor as envisaged by
Australian policy, Moore admitted: "There is a real risk that the violence
could become more widespread in the lead-up to [Monday's] ballot and thereafter."
It is now clear that the
Indonesian security forces have deliberately destroyed the chances of a
free and fair independence ballot in East Timor on Monday. Unfortunately,
it is also clear that, thanks mainly to Australian diplomacy, it is much
too late to put any alternative policy in place if the same security forces
prove they can't be trusted to prevent a bloodbath after the ballot.
The Indonesian military has
never given any sign it wants to end its brutal occupation of East Timor,
which began with the 1975 invasion. The signs certainly did not improve
when it started organising, funding, training and arming anti-independence
militia groups last October.
Given this backdrop, it is
not surprising that the US Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian
and Pacific Affairs, Stanley Roth, has described Australia's opposition
to a UN peace-keeping force in East Timor as "defeatist".
Roth's blunt expression of
his disappointment occurred during talks in February with the head of the
Australian Foreign Affairs department, Dr Ashton Calvert. Roth had asked
Australia to help build support for a peace-keeping force to prevent bloodshed
while the East Timorese moved towards an act of self- determination.
But Calvert was adamant that
"adept diplomacy" would ensure this was unnecessary. (This was not Calvert's
first diplomatic foray involving Indonesia. As an adviser to the former
Labor Prime Minister, Paul Keating, he helped bring about the ignominious
1995 Security Treaty with the Soeharto regime.)
According to the leaked record
of the February conversation, Calvert stressed the importance of encouraging
the East Timorese to sort out their differences without resort to the UN.
Given one side was being armed and incited by the Indonesian military to
kill the other side, Calvert seemed a little short of practical suggestions
on how this encouragement might be conveyed.
After all, the Australian
policy of relying on the instigators of the violence to maintain the peace
would scarcely seem a convincing way to build trust.
Calvert's performance was
further distinguished by his bizarre observation that the Indonesian Foreign
Minister, Ali Alatas, was more of a problem than the head of the military,
General Wiranto. As is now plain, the Indonesian military, under Wiranto's
command, is responsible for much of the violence that will prevent a free
and fair ballot on Monday.
Yet the Foreign Minister,
Alexander Downer, seems immensely pleased with the policy urged upon the
US by his departmental head. Downer told Parliament earlier this month
that Roth was "grateful" for the insight Calvert had given him about Indonesian
resistance to peace keepers; "only a child", he said, would continue to
push for peace keepers in these circumstances.
Downer also boasted that
Australia had taken a leading role in formulating international policy
on East Timor.
Unfortunately, Downer is
correct: US officials say privately that they were not prepared to push
for peace keepers in the teeth of such determined opposition from an ally
so close to the problem.
No-one claims that getting
UN support for a peace-keeping force would have been simple. But due largely
to Australia's opposition, the effort was not even made. As a result, Alatas
signed an agreement with the UN on May 5 which left the responsibility
for ensuring a free and fair ballot to Indonesia. Alatas specifically agreed
that it was essential that the Indonesian security forces stay "absolutely
neutral".
There is now a mountain of
evidence -- especially from Australian intelligence sources -- that this
has not occurred. Instead, Indonesian forces have masterminded a terror
campaign.
The violence has become so
bad that most outside observers, including journalists, now look like being
evacuated from East Timor within a couple of days of the ballot.
No-one knows for sure if
the bloodbath repeatedly promised by the militias will ensue. But the evacuation
of potentially damning witnesses will scarcely act as a deterrent.
The prospect of a bloodbath
prompted the head of the US military command in the Pacific, Admiral Blair,
to meet the commander of Australian Theatre forces, Air Vice Marshall Treloar,
in Honolulu in June. They discussed contingency plans to dispatch 15,000
US troops to East Timor to stop militia violence and facilitate an evacuation.
Treloar agreed to pass on
a request for US forces to transit through Darwin. In an extraordinary
display of confidence, Australian officials did not bother to pass this
on to either Moore or Downer. Instead, they rejected the request out of
hand -- thus reassuring the militia that they were in no danger of being
disarmed by a well-equipped US force.
Australian policy makers
were aghast at the proposal, which they saw as guaranteeing that the Indonesian
military would go to war with the US.
The idea is fanciful. The
US Pacific Command was not planning to fight the Indonesian military but
to take over the job the latter was failing to do on behalf of the UN in
a territory that had just voted for independence.
General Wiranto may be brutal
and untrustworthy, but he is not mad. He is well aware that the US military
could destroy his entire command and control structure if he starts a war.
Except, of course, against
the East Timorese. In that case, he knows he can rely on Australian policy
makers to stay the US hand.
Meanwhile, the Australian
military is getting ready for the next in its ongoing series of friendly
exercises with the Indonesian military, imaginatively codenamed Kakadu,
Cassowary, Rajawali Ausindo, Elang Ausindo, Albatross Ausindo, Trisetia
and New Horizon.
Jakarta
tells world to mind own business
The Age - August 28, 1999
Craig Skehan -- The Indonesian
Government has hit back at foreign critics of the upsurge in violence in
East Timor, arguing it does not need outside pressure over its handing
of Monday's ballot on self-determination in the territory.
The Foreign Minister, Mr
Ali Alatas, expressed regret over yesterday's violence, but he rejected
calls for international peacekeepers to be sent to the territory.
And a Foreign Ministry spokesman
said the fighting in Dili was "not major" and that Jakarta did not need
foreign advice on how to maintain security in East Timor before the ballot.
The spokesman was commenting
on a statement by the Australian Prime Minister, Mr John Howard, that the
world was watching events in East Timor and that Indonesia's reputation
depended on the outcome of the vote. Mr Howard said he would be contacting
the Indonesian President, Dr B.J. Habibie, over the weekend to press Australia's
concerns.
But a senior Indonesian Foreign
Ministry spokesman, Mr Sulaiman Abdulmanan, told The Age: "We don't need
international pressure. We have already decided ourselves to solve this
problem."
He said Indonesian authorities
were working resolutely to implement the terms of an agreement with the
United Nations for conducting the ballot.
Mr Sulaiman rejected a call
by the imprisoned pro-independence leader Jose "Xanana" Gusmao for the
dispatch of armed UN peacekeepers to East Timor as a result of yesterday's
clashes.
"Nothing has changed and
I think our position has already been made very clear on a peacekeeping
force," Mr Sulaiman said. "There were some clashes yesterday, but in the
history of East Timor they were not major. Do you think there could be
a peacekeeping force brought in now? Do you think there is time? I don't
think so. The situation is not as bad as many other part of the world."
Mr Sulaiman called for greater
balance in media reporting on East Timor and for journalists not to exaggerate
the level of violence. "It is not only the integration side [causing problems],
it is the pro-independence groups as well making provocations," he said.
Mr Alatas said he was confident
that order would be restored in Dili. "We regret the incidents of yesterday,"
he told Reuters. Mr Alatas said that Mr Gusmao's planned release on 15
September was contingent on the result of Monday's ballot being known several
days earlier.
Indonesia
slammed over militia violence
Agence France Presse - August
28, 1999 (slightly abridged)
Dili -- The United Nations
on Friday led international condemnation of Indonesia's handling of militia
violence in East Timor as an exiled separatist leader called for a UN peacekeeping
force.
The United Nations demanded
that Indonesia crack down on armed anti-independence militias trying to
disrupt Monday's vote on East Timor's future.
And the head of the UN Mission
in East Timor (UNAMET), Ian Martin, slammed Indonesian police handling
of the militia rampage Thursday which left five dead.
The violence forced the cancelation
of a joint rally by opponents and supporters of independence on the final
day of the vote campaign on Friday.
"All that was witnessed by
UNAMET suggests that it was the militias carrying guns, weapons and that
once again heavily armed police failed to intervene when that militia violence
was carried out in front of them," Martin told foreign journalists.
Australian Foreign Minister
Alexander Downer urged Indonesia to take action to maintain security in
the lead-up to the ballot, in which East Timorese will vote on an offer
of broad autonomy.
"The behaviour of a bunch
of thugs on the streets of Dili or in other towns of East Timor should
not stop the people of East Timor being able to exercise democratically
their own wishes and to determine their own future," he said.
Exiled independence campaigner
Jose Ramos-Horta urged Australia and the United States to take tougher
action against Indonesia and said the deployment of an international peacekeeping
force was imperative.
"At this stage the conditions
require a peacekeeping force because it is the only way to save the whole
process and to save lives," the Nobel Peace Prize winner told AFP in Sydney.
Indonesia would only act
if it received serious warnings from Australia and the United States that
they were prepared to intervene militarily, he said.
The United States welcomed
a pledge Thursday by Jakarta to release jailed separatist leader Xanana
Gusmao in mid-September, but called on Indonesia to do more.
"Indonesia must create an
environment free of intimidation in which to hold the vote and, furthermore,
reassure all parties that it will accept and uphold the decision of the
people of East Timor," State Department spokesman James Foley said.
Martin said the head of UNAMET's
civilian police contingent, Alan Mills, had spoken with East Timor police
chief Colonel Timbul Silaen about the "deplorable" violence. Silaen denied
accusations that police had done nothing. "It is not like that," he told
the private SCTV television channel, claiming a deployment of four companies
across Dili had prevented worse loss of life.
But Martin added: "Clearly
there was not adequate security in Dili yesterday just as there has not
been adequate security in Maliana and Viqueque and other places in recent
days."
Indonesian police, who are
in charge of security for the historic vote, had occasionally taken action
but "almost never by arresting those responsible or seizing their weapons,"
he said.
Independence
supporters take to streets
Associated Press - August
25, 1999
Convinced they will win a
historic UN-supervised referendum by a landslide next week, up to 10,000
jubilant supporters of independence for East Timor defied threats by rivals
and choked the streets of Dili on Wednesday.
It was the most impressive
display of the separatist movement's popular strength to date and far outmatched
earlier and more subdued rallies by anti-independence campaigners.
"We are sure 90 percent of
East Timor's people will vote for independence," said Manuel Carrascalao,
a longtime pro- independence politician.
Wednesday's crowd turned
out despite what activists say is a campaign of violence and intimidation
against civilians and UN staff by militia groups accused of trying to derail
the ballot so they can stay part of Indonesia.
Riot police broke up a brief
clash between pro and anti- independence groups after both sides threw
rocks. One man was injured before officers closed off a street adjacent
to a militia building.
Overall, however, the rally
was peaceful. Hundreds of people rode on trucks, buses and motorcycles
in a noisy and smokey parade along Dili's coconut palm-lined and ramshackle
streets.
"Today is a golden day for
us, ahead is freedom and independence," said Zoana Victor, a 38-year-old
resistance supporter who was jailed by Indonesia in the 1970s.
Many waved the blue, green,
and white independence flags that were banned until recently. Others carried
portraits of jailed rebel leader "Xanana" Gusmao.
The celebration was marred
by a traffic accident in which three people died. Three others were injured
in the collision between a truck and a car in the motorcade.
Members of Indonesia's armed
forces, accused for decades of human rights abuses in their quest to crush
separatist guerillas, watched passively as the raucous procession moved
slowly by their barracks. A police helicopter hovered overhead.
Earlier, thousands rallied
outside the seafront headquarters of the Council for Timorese National
Resistance. They sang and danced, and chanted "Long live East Timor", and
"Long live Xanana".
Xanana
outlines East Timor program
Jakarta Post - August 26,
1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- Jailed East Timor
resistance leader Jose Alexandre "Xanana" Gusmao promised on Wednesday
to offer amnesty to his political opponents if East Timorese voted for
independence on the August 30 ballot.
"This act of generosity transcends
our emotions, heals wounds and elevates the soul of our people. I wholeheartedly
appeal for an immediate end to violence," he said in a press conference
at his detention house in Central Jakarta.
The press conference was
conducted in three languages in succession: Portuguese, English and Indonesian.
More than 50 local and foreign journalists attended.
In his first comprehensive
program proposal for an independent East Timor to be renamed Timor Lorosae,
Xanana said he would immediately hold negotiations with the Indonesian
government to define the status of East Timorese civil servants, maintain
the rupiah currency and protect the rights of Indonesians who decided to
live and work in East Timor.
Xanana said if the vote favored
proindependence, a transitional government would set up a five-year development
plan starting from the year 2000.
Xanana shied away from the
issue of disarmament despite the continuing violence that rocked the former
Portuguese colony.
Five days before the ballot
only a few symbolic gestures of arms surrender have been carried out by
the prointegration militia. The proindependence militia, Falintil, has
said it would not give up its arms to the Indonesian Military.
In his eight-page statement
covering at least 15 points, Xanana called for the East Timorese to reconcile
their differences and uphold national unity. He declared a fight against
illiteracy and promised empowerment of the society as well as a self-sufficient
economy based on a market economy with selective intervention from the
state. He declared that solidarity with the Portuguese people is unbreakable.
Meanwhile, Reuters reported
from Vatican City that Pope John Paul on Wednesday called for reconciliation
in East Timor and for an end to recent violence in Ambon, Maluku.
Speaking at his weekly general
audience, the pontiff said he hoped the people of East Timor would be moved
by "a sincere desire to work for reconciliation and contribute to healing
the painful wounds of the past".
Jakarta
officials set to reject poll
The Age - August 26, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili --
Indonesia's top officials in East Timor are preparing to reject the outcome
of Monday's ballot on the territory's future, claiming the way the United
Nations will count the votes is flawed.
Mr F.Lopes Da Cruz, Jakarta's
ambassador-at-large for East Timor, said today the UN's plans to transport
the votes to a central location in the capital, Dili, were not democratic
or transparent.
"There is definitely a possibility
to reject the ballot," said Mr Da Cruz, a long-term campaigner against
East Timor separating from Indonesia.
As UN officials, diplomats
and independent analysts predict a win for independence supporters, Mr
Da Cruz stepped up the pressure on the UN to agree to count the votes at
200 polling centres across the territory.
"If you try to bring the
ballot boxes to Dili, by road or helicopter, anything could happen to them
on the way," he said. "It is not fair. If they are counted at the polling
booth there will be many people who will be able to see what is happening."
Mr Da Cruz is the second
senior Indonesian official to criticise the counting system, despite the
UN's blunt rejection of any review.
After Mr Dino Patti Djalal,
the spokesman for Indonesia's taskforce in Dili, last week demanded the
UN provide a breakdown of how various districts voted, the UN's spokesman,
Mr David Wimhurst, insisted: "There will be no change." The stand was confirmed
today by another UN spokesman in Dili, Mr Hiro Ueki.
UN officials said UN civilian
police would escort the votes to Dili. They said the priority was to ensure
voters could be satisfied that no reprisals would be taken against them,
whichever way they voted. "The vote must be secret," a UN official said.
"There will be no compromise on this point."
But Mr Da Cruz said the security
of the vote was more important than possible reprisals afterwards. "The
Indonesian police are responsible for protecting people from reprisals,"
he said.
The controversy over the
count comes amid renewed criticism of Indonesia for its refusal or inability
to stop the intimidation of voters ahead of the ballot that gives 450,000
East Timorese a choice between autonomy and independence.
In New York the UN Security
Council issued a statement voicing "strong concern at the continuing campaign
of intimidation and violence in East Timor". It deplored "recent acts of
violence and intimidation against UN staff".
Pro-Jakarta militias have
been responsible for most of the intimidation and violence leading up to
the vote, according to human rights groups.
The biggest group of independent
observers in East Timor today joined a growing number of countries and
groups calling for international troops, preferably armed, to be sent to
the territory to maintain security after the ballot.
The International Federation
for East Timor -- Observer Project, in a letter to the UN Secretary-General,
Mr Kofi Annan, accused the Indonesian military of undermining the ballot
to such an extent that it threw into question the legitimacy of the vote.
It called on the Indonesian police to disarm and disband all militia and
paramilitary groups.
UN
bars Indonesian groups as observers
Asian Wall Street Journal
- August 24, 1999
Jeremy Wagstaff, Dili --
The United Nations mission in East Timor has refused applications by 24
Indonesian government-linked youth groups to send observers to this month's
referendum on the future of East Timor, in a move likely to deepen a rift
between the UN team and Jakarta.
The UN East Timor mission,
UNAMET, is concerned that the youth groups -- some of them regarded by
many Indonesians as either creations of the government or linked to the
criminal underworld -- will disrupt the August 30 ballot. The groups deny
links to organized crime.
"Their intentions in coming
to East Timor at this time are at best unclear and, in the light of their
political track record, it seems likely that their presence could prove
disruptive," a UN official said.
Functional proxies' for
Jakarta
UNAMET's chief electoral
officer, Jeff Fischer, refused the request Saturday in a meeting with the
head of the Indonesian delegation, Djamaris Suleman, saying that the groups
were "functional proxies" for Indonesia. An appeal to the UN electoral
commission by Mr. Suleman was turned down later the same day. The move
comes in the final week of campaigning by East Timorese for and against
an offer of greater autonomy under the territory's existing ruler, Indonesia.
If voters reject the offer, East Timor would effectively be declaring independence.
Despite noisy and sometimes aggressive cam paigning by pro-Indonesian supporters,
many observers expect East Timorese to opt for an end to Jakarta's 24-year
old rule.
Fears that the groups aren't
merely independent observers may have some justification. Members of the
youth groups themselves say officials of the Ministry of Youth and Sports,
which oversees all official youth social organizations, encouraged them
to send observers.
"The main purpose of the
team is to monitor the process and to give support to those people who
are pro-autonomy," said Hoedaifah, the cultural chief of one group, Pemuda
Pancasila, or Pancasila Youth. An assistant to the minister of youth and
sports confirmed that ministry officials planned to accompany the youths.
Links denied officially
Indonesia denied any links
to the move. "They are paying for themselves and are coming here on their
initiative," said Dino Djalal, spokesman for the Indonesian delegation
overseeing the referendum.
It wasn't clear whether the
youths were East Timorese and how many were already in East Timor. Most
of them are likely to arrive on a cruise ship due to dock in Dili on Tuesday,
said Robby Rawis, chief of the local chapter of another of the groups,
Pemuda Panca Marga, or the youth wing of army veterans. He said some 38
groups would send as many as 10 representatives each. Other people aware
of the plan said the observers would number no more than 100.
It wouldn't be the first
time such groups have been used by the Indonesian government as an unofficial
tool. Several of the groups that have applied to send observers have been
accused by local and international human-rights groups of intimidating
government opponents, including political parties, nongovernment groups
and the media. Since the fall of President Suharto in May 1998, however,
most such groups have either lain dormant or sought more respectable roles.
Some Pemuda Pancasila leaders, for example, abandoned their longstanding
support for the former ruling Golkar party at national elections held in
June. Combustible mix
The overt presence of such
groups would add to an already combustible mix. Indonesian officials and
pro-autonomy leaders accuse UNAMET of favoring the pro-independence movement.
In the past few days, a UNAMET vehicle was torched and another stoned,
and a UN building attacked. UN officials accuse Jakarta of organizing,
arming or encouraging pro-Indonesian militias and have twice delayed the
ballot because of security concerns.
Indonesian officials said
the presence of Indonesian observers would help balance out what they said
was a bias in favor of pro-independence observers allowed to register.
"There's a perception that there are too many foreign observers," Mr. Djalal
said. "This is a free game."
The rejection of accreditation
is the first since UNAMET began work several months ago. The youths would
be barred from polling sites, from the official counting and won't be allowed
to file official procedural complaints.
[Special correspondent
Rin Hindryati in Jakarta contributed to this article.]
America
rules out troops for Timor ballot
The Age - August 25, 1999
Gay Alcorn, Washington --
The Clinton administration said today that, on a practical level, it was
too late for an armed United Nations peacekeeping force to enter East Timor
before Monday's historic ballot, but said nothing about the possibility
of a force immediately after the vote.
The administration is under
pressure from influential members of Congress with strong interests in
human rights in East Timor to push for a peacekeeping force, rather than
rely on Indonesian authorities to maintain the peace. There are UN civilian
police and military liaison officers in the territory, but not an armed
multinational force.
A State Department spokesman,
Mr James Foley, said: "We don't believe that the dispatch of armed UN peacekeepers
before 30August is possible at this point."
Mr Foley was responding to
calls from a senior Democrat Senator, Mr Tom Harkin, who last week led
a Congressional delegation to East Timor, for President Clinton to recommend
to the UN "that they get some peacekeeping forces down here in a hurry".
Mr Foley said that the administration
had been concerned very much about the security situation in East Timor
in past months. "We want the vote to be a free and fair vote, an honest
reflection of the will of the people of East Timor," he said.
"In a more fundamental sense,
we believe this is the responsibility of the Government of Indonesia, and
we don't want to take that responsibility away from them," he added.
Senator Harkin was a co-sponsor
of an amendment passed in the US Senate in June which is expected to become
law next month. The amendment raised the prospect of withholding aid money
to Indonesia if it fails to control pro-Government militia groups responsible
for widespread violence in East Timor.
Although the UN is developing
plans for a force, it would not be in place until at least four months
after the ballot, which many observers believe will be too late to avoid
violence.
The assistant secretary of
State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs, Mr Stanley Roth, is due in Australia
this week. As the administration's most senior policy adviser on Asia,
Mr Roth is considered influential with President Clinton and committed
to a smooth transition in East Timor.
Earlier this year, Mr Roth
met the head of Australia's Foreign Affairs Department, Dr Ashton Calvert,
when, according to a record of the meeting, Mr Roth said Australia's aversion
to a peacekeeping force was defeatist. Both governments have denied any
policy rift over East Timor.
Jakarta
loyalists warn of new Timor war
Reuters - August 25, 1999
(slightly abridged)
Tim Johnston, Dili -- A leading
opponent of East Timorese independence said on Tuesday that a narrow loss
in next Monday's ballot on the future status of the troubled territory
would lead to a renewed guerrilla war.
The warning came as Indonesia's
military warned that militants on both sides were out to provoke violence
in the troubled territory.
Tito Baptista, chairman of
the United Front for East Timor Autonomy, said opponents of independence
would be prepared to wage a guerrilla war if 40 percent of voters chose
autonomy and 60 percent chose independence.
"If we lose 40 percent it
is enough to fight a hundred years more. We will live as guerrillas in
the mountains," said Baptista. UNIF is an umbrella organisation that groups
all the main parties opposed to East Timor's secession from Indonesia.
In Jakarta, the military's
new chief spokesman said there were provocateurs on both sides trying to
stir up trouble. "We don't want it and want to discourage such violence,"
Brigadier-General Sudrajat said.
Baptista, speaking on the
fringes of a pro-Jakarta rally of some 3,000 people, said that mistakes
had been made in the past, but promised that they would be rectified under
autonomy.
"During the 20 years of integration
we have a lot of mistakes: corruption, nepotism, violation of human rights,
we know it. But under autonomy we will amend everything that was bad over
the last 23 years," he said.
He accused the United Nations
Mission in East Timor (UNAMET), which is organising the $53 million vote,
of partiality towards independence.
"We know that UNAMET is not
impartial, but first of all we will see the result," he said. The United
Nations has blamed armed pro-Indonesia militias for most of the violence
that has killed dozens of people and displaced tens of thousands in the
past eight months.
A local human rights group
criticised the United Nations on Tuesday for doing too little to stop the
violence.
"UNAMET obviously recognises
the problem of the violence but has not done anything to respond to it,
much less prevent it from occurring," human rights group Yayasan HAK said
in a statement.
Yayasan HAK said the Indonesian
police, who are responsible for security, had failed to fulfil their duty.
"It appears to us that there is no reason to continue the ballot in this
kind of situation," Yayasan HAK said.
A leader of the pro-independence
National Council for Timorese Resistance (CNRT) said that the insecure
environment in East Timor had severely limited their ability to campaign.
"It has had a tremendous
impact on our campaign in some areas," said David Ximenes. In some areas
most CNRT activists were in hiding, he added. But he said that he did not
want the vote, which has already been delayed twice, to be further postponed.
Militias
trying to scare Timorese from voting
Reuters - August 23, 1999
The recent surge of violence
in East Timor is part of a deliberate pattern to scare voters away from
participating in the August 30 referendum on the territory's future status,
the United Nations said on Monday.
"The pattern is to try and
intimidate people away from voting either by direct threats of physical
violence now or by threatening dire consequences after the vote," UN spokesman
David Wimhurst said in Dili.
Over the past two weeks there
had been an increase in attacks on supporters of independence by armed
militias seeking to maintain East Timor's status as part of Indonesia,
he said.
The violence was limiting
the ability of the pro-independence National Council for Timorese Resistance
(CNRT) to campaign for the vote, Mr Wimhurst said.
"The level playing field
in terms of campaigning has not been successfully established in the sense
that the CNRT are in many areas not able to campaign openly, so that is
a matter of concern."
He said that the United Nations
was also concerned that people were being driven away from the places where
they had registered to vote.
The United Nations is organising
the ballot, but Indonesia is responsible forensuring security. The vote
has already been delayed twice because of unrest and logistical problems.
"It seems that there is an
effort being made to intimidate local people ... to move refugees out,
and the concern of all these people who have been intimidated is how they
are going to vote if they have been forced away from their homes," he said.
Several incidents over the
weekend involved threats and violence against staff of the UN Mission in
East Timor.
An Australian civilian police
adviser needed six stitches on Saturday after he was hit on the head by
a rock thrown into a restaurant in the militia stronghold of Suai, 95 kilometres
south of Dili, Mr Wimhurst said. In the town of Same, 50 km south of Dili,
several of the UN's electoral officers had to be evacuated to the police
station after their house was attacked on Saturday.
Australia
warns Alatas over security
Sydney Morning Herald - August
24, 1999
Peter Cole-Adams -- The Foreign
Affairs Minister, Mr Downer, telephoned his Indonesian counterpart, Mr
Ali Alatas, last night to repeat Australia's concern over security breakdowns
in East Timor.
Mr Downer said he emphasised
the importance of next week's independence-or-autonomy ballot being free
and fair. If it was a debacle, which he did not expect, it would cause
international problems for Indonesia.
Mr Downer told ABC television
he believed the Indonesian police and military had the ability to provide
security for the ballot. "Whether they do remains to be seen," he said.
"But there is no excuse for them not being able to secure the situation
in East Timor after the ballot. Indonesia must understand the eyes of the
world are on it, and [on] the behaviour of the police, military and militias."
He said security had improved
in some parts of East Timor but there were still problems in the west of
the territory and a potential for trouble in other parts. Mr Downer will
meet the US Assistant Secretary of State for East Asia and Pacific Affairs,
Mr Stanley Roth, in Canberra for talks centred on East Timor tomorrow.
Mr Roth will address the National Press Club on Thursday.
The Australian Government
will hope and expect that Mr Roth will put to rest suggestions that differences
remain between Washington and Canberra over East Timor. Mr Downer was embarrassed
earlier this month by the leak of a record of a conversation between Mr
Roth and the Secretary of the Foreign Affairs and Trade Department, Dr
Ashton Calvert, last February.
In it, Mr Roth was quoted
as saying he believed a full-scale peacekeeping operation would be necessary
in the territory. The US and Australia have since emphasised there are
no policy disagreements, but the question of sending in armed UN peacekeepers
was raised again last weekend by US Senator Tom Harkin during a visit to
the territory.
Scent
of a normal life so close
Sydney Morning Herald - August
23, 1999
Mark Dodd -- After 24 years
of fighting for independence, a senior commander of one of the world's
most enduring guerilla groups says he is considering what once seemed unthinkable
-- a return to a normal life cut short when Indonesian troops stormed ashore
in East Timor in 1975.
On the 24th anniversary of
Falintil's independence struggle, Taur Matan Ruak, 43, the movement's deputy
commander, believes peace in East Timor is a real possibility.
"What I miss most is peace,"
he said. "I hope it returns quickly so I can return to my family and friends.
I'm dreaming of that day -- we're all hoping it will be a reality."
Asked what he would do, the
former Dili lorry driver said: "I'd abandon military life and work for
the people affected by war -- the widows, orphans and maimed." At the weekend,
Falintil invited a select group of journalists and supporters to their
camp in a remote corner of East Timor's south-west to celebrate the anniversary.
Security was tight, and the identity of Timorese visitors thoroughly checked.
The security was needed.
Yesterday, 30 suspected pro-autonomy infiltrators had been apprehended,
several were badly beaten and only the intervention of senior Falintil
officers prevented what could have been a lynching. They remain in custody.
Festivities started on Thursday
and the campsite, complete with concert stage, communal kitchens and thatch-roof
barracks, looked more like a 1970s Sunbury rock concert than a military
camp. However, the presence of hundreds of armed guerillas among the estimated
7,000 civilians could not be ignored.
In the 10 years following
the invasion, although vastly outnumbered in terms of personnel and equipment,
Falintil carried the armed struggle against the Indonesian armed forces,
quickly earning a reputation for aggressive tactics resulting in early
victories. Under the leadership of Mr Xanana Gusmao, the independence movement
has focused more on diplomacy than confrontation, but it continued small-scale
operations against isolated army outposts, individuals and Indonesian officials.
Recalling the years of struggle,
Mr Ruak dismissed the threat posed by pro-Jakarta militias. He branded
them cowards, and as puppets of Indonesia who only attacked helpless, unarmed
civilians. Asked if the recent change of Indonesian military commanders
in East Timor signalled a more conciliatory approach by the military to
the political crisis, he quoted a Portuguese saying: "The s--- changes
but the flies are all the same."
All but a handful of Falintil
have registered to vote and, unsurprisingly, Mr Ruak reckons on a convincing
independence victory at the ballot. "So the Indonesian Government does
not feel embarrassed, I will give them 30 per cent and 70 per cent for
us," he said with a smile.
On Friday, about 400 fighters
wearing an assortment of coloured berets and dressed in a mish-mash of
uniforms, either bought locally or captured from the Indonesian military,
assembled on parade to mark the 24th anniversary.
The highlight of the ceremony
was a message broadcast via a satellite telephone link from Mr Gusmao,
Falintil's supreme commander, under house arrest in Jakarta, where he is
serving a 20-year prison sentence for inciting rebellion.
A hush fell over the crowd
of 5,000 as the 20-minute speech was broadcast over a battery of loudspeakers
on the hot and dusty river-flat parade ground.
"Today we are going to prepare
for the popular consultation [referendum] on August 30," he said. "The
crowing of the rooster has been heard and that is a sign of our independence."
The crowd erupted into applause. "Viva Timor Leste -- Viva Xanana -- Viva
Falintil," they roared.
Pro-Indonesia
group urges on-the-spot vote
Agence France Presse - August
22, 1999 (slightly abridged)
Jakarta -- A pro-Indonesia
group has called on the United Nations to count the votes at next week's
self-determination ballot at the stations where they are cast, the state
Antara news agency said Sunday.
"People will not have a chance
to see the counting process transparently if the vote counting is centered
in Dili," Antara quoted a spokesman for the Forum of Unity, Democracy and
Justice (FPDK) as saying.
The UN Mission in East Timor
(UNAMET) has repeatedly announced that the August 30 ballot will be secret,
to avert possible reprisals, and that for the same reason the votes will
be counted centrally.
Basilio Araujo, the spokesman
for the FPDK, which groups several pro-Indonesia fronts including the army-backed
militia, argued the centralized system was "undemocratic."
Araujo also warned the central
count by UNAMET could become "a reason for either or both of the two conflicting
groups in East Timor to reject the outcome of the ballot."
Australian
army primes for Timor
The Age - August 23, 1999
Jill Jolliffe, Darwin --
Almost exactly 24 years ago, Darwin was put to the test when thousands
of traumatised East Timorese refugees fleeing civil war landed from every
imaginable type of vessel, only eight months after Cyclone Tracy had almost
wiped the city from the face of the earth.
This time city officials
are taking no chances -- a week before the United Nations-sponsored poll
in East Timor, the Northern Territory Chief Minister, Mr Denis Burke, is
following the situation closely. A few kilometres out of town the army's
2800- strong First Brigade, the vanguard of Australia's rapid deployment
force, is engaged in constant exercises to enhance its intervention readiness
-- it has been on 28-day alert since June. The navy's HMAS Jervis Bay,
a high-speed catamaran that can move 500 soldiers at a time, lies at wait
in Darwin harbor. It can reach Dili in about 14 hours and has two crews
so it can run a continuous troop shuttle if necessary.
"With this wave slicer we
could deploy all of the First Brigade and its equipment there within three
days," Mr Burke observed, although like most politicians and military personnel
here his official line is that there will be no need for that. They are
tight-lipped about possible Australian intervention if things go wrong
in East Timor, especially after the controversy this month over an alleged
rift between United States and Australian policy makers.
The reality, however, belies
the claim that all is well. In the bush outside Darwin, the First Brigade
is engaged in Operation Predator's Chariot, which involves an imaginary
island called Legais somewhere north of Papua New Guinea. It has been invaded
by its traditional enemies, the Musorians and the Kamarians, and the brigade
has intervened with American forces to restore its sovereignty.
As M113 armored personnel
carriers speed through the bush behind him towards some imaginary enemy
target, the brigade's media man, Captain John Liston, described the context
of the unit's activities. It first began moving its forces from Sydney
to the Top End in 1992, after a debate in defence circles in the late 1980s
about the vulnerability of Australia's north coast. There are now 2100
First Brigade personnel here of the total complement of 2800, and by March
2000 the entire force will be concentrated around Darwin.
Today's army is very different
from that of 1975 -- it is a high-tech army, and the First Brigade is on
the cutting edge of change. The fight for Legais is largely conducted with
computers. The current exercise is in command-post procedures, on the principle
that the the commanders' battle-readiness must be tested as well as that
of the soldiers. In various encampments under camouflage netting, men and
women are hunched over laptop computers, giving orders that are then distributed
through the radio system. This mock battle is described as a "mid-intensity
conventional conflict", whereas a previous exercise was in peace-keeping.
Captain Liston said that
even in an army as sophisticated as this, soldiers only obey politicians.
If they were sent to East Timor, it would be without debate, he said, but
like everybody else in authority in Darwin, he denied this was on the cards.
"Sure, guys read the papers, they know what's going on in the region, but
as far as any specific scenario, we're not preparing anything." On the
Jervis Bay, there is a similar state of preparation. Its two captains say
the catamaran can be ready for sea on four to 24 hours' notice.
One other military institution
that is ready and active is the Defence Signals installation at nearby
Shoal Bay, remembered as the interception centre that overheard the Indonesian
battle orders given when five Australian-based journalists were killed
in the East Timorese town of Balibo on 16 October 1975. "It can pick up
the conversations in the Timor Governor's office," one Darwin insider commented.
Mr Burke does not fear a
worst-case scenario in East Timor. "I think that, if anything, the situation
is improving," he said. "There was a lot of fear and concern. It seems
the vote will definitely be for independence and you might get a large-scale
emigration of integration supporters into West Timor." But otherwise, he
says, "things look pretty good", especially after last week's handover
of weapons by pro-Indonesian militias.
The East Timorese in Darwin
are not so sure. For Mr Alfredo Borges Ferreira, of the National Council
of Timorese Resistance, East Timor's ruling resistance body, the tumult
of Darwin 1975 is still a vivid memory. His life is more settled and prosperous
now and he hopes he will be able to serve an independent East Timor in
the coming period, but he is pessimistic.
"I don't trust the Indonesians,"
he said. "I think they are preparing something for [election] day or the
day before. I believe we will have an around 75 per cent majority ... I
don't think they will allow the results to go ahead -- they're the same
pack of wolves."
His colleague, Mr Roberto
de Araujo, regional secretary of the UDT party, shares his view, believing
that the Indonesian army will intervene rather than allow independence
to go ahead. Darwin's military preparedness is all very well, these two
men consider, but if a crisis erupts, by the time the Jervis Bay reaches
Timor many lives may have been lost and the situation may have broken down
irretrievably, as it did in '75.
Timor
militias massing for war, US told
Sydney Morning Herald - August
23, 1999
Lindsay Murdoch, Dili Armed
militias massing in East Timor near the western border plan to go to war
to stop the territory they hold becoming independent, United Nations officials
have warned.
The officials told visiting
US politicians in the town of Maliana at the weekend that the ballot to
decide East Timor's future, scheduled for next Monday, should be called
off in the militia- dominated district because "too many people will die".
After the confidential briefing,
Senator Tom Harkin told reporters in the capital, Dili, that he would make
an urgent call to President Clinton asking him to support the sending of
armed UN peacekeeping troops to the former Portuguese territory.
"As one of the UN officials
said, this could be a bloodbath down here," Senator Harkin said before
flying to Jakarta to meet President Habibie.
The call for peacekeepers
comes ahead of a visit to Canberra this week by the US Assistant Secretary
of State for East Asia and Pacific Affairs, Mr Stanley Roth.
In February, Mr Roth told
the head of Australia's Foreign Affairs Department, Dr Ashton Calvert,
that he believed a full-scale peacekeeping operation would be necessary
in East Timor.
Senator Harkin said there
was strong evidence that Indonesia's military had worked with militia groups
to sabotage the vote. "I am going to recommend to the President [Clinton]
that he recommends to the Security Council that they get some peacekeeping
forces down here in a hurry."
Meanwhile, UN sources said
senior Indonesian military officers in Dili were making secret contingency
plans to evacuate 50,000 civilians from areas near the border with West
Timor.
The plans indicate that Indonesia's
police and army will allow the militias they have armed and trained to
seize control of large areas of the militias' heartland either before or
after the ballot.
The delegation of three MPs
led by Senator Harkin was shocked to hear how the militias were terrorising
independence supporters and taking away voter registration cards.
Led by Mr Joao Tavares, a
68-year-old warlord with close links to Indonesia's armed forces, the militias
had access to sophisticated weapons, they were told. Mr Tavares told the
Herald last week that "if I want war, there will be war".
UN officials told the senators
that civilians were being kidnapped from their homes and not seen again.
One of the latest victims had had his head and arms chopped off.
The officials outlined to
the senators preparations by the militias to go to war, including moving
their relatives across the border to the town of Atambua. They said hundreds
of independence supporters expecting violence were fleeing to forests and
the mountains.
One Australian assigned to
the UN contingent in Maliana said the situation was a "powderkeg". He and
other UN officials in Maliana were ready to leave in a convoy for West
Timor.
In Suai, a port on Timor's
south coast, the US delegation saw 2,500 mostly pro-independence supporters
being held as virtual hostages in a church compound.
Senator Harkin told the people:
"We're going to be asking our Government and the United Nations to be providing
some peacekeeping forces here. From what we've seen it's necessary to have
somebody here to stop the intimidation."
The Indonesian Government
has refused to consider allowing armed international peacekeepers to be
sent to East Timor for the ballot, in which 450,000 people will get a choice
between broad autonomy within Indonesia or independence.
Political/economic
crisis |
Up
to 12 dead in fresh clashes in Ambon
Agence France Presse - August
24, 1999
Jakarta -- Fresh Moslem-Christian
clashes in Indonesia's spice Moluccas islands have left up to 12 people
dead, scores injured and several churches torched, sources and reports
said Tuesday.
A member of the Church Advocacy
team in Maluku's provincial capital of Ambon said about people nine died
when Moslem mobs attacked nine churches in Seram island, in Central Maluku
on Wednesday last week.
Other reports said up to
12 people were killed in religious violence over the weekend. "Moslem mobs
attacked six Christian hamlets simultaneously on Wednesday," Simon Noya
of the Church Advocacy team told AFP by phone.
Churches were torched in
the six hamlets, including five Protestant churches, two Roman Catholic
and one Advent, he said.
Central Maluku district police
chief Lieutenant Colonel Benny Vonbulow said as many as 12 people were
killed and 40 injured during clashes in West Seram over the weekend, the
Kompas daily reported.
News of the violence in the
island province of Maluku only reached Ambon late on Monday as the area
where it had occured is not covered by telephone network.
Vonbulow said police dispatched
two companies of the elite police mobile brigade from Ambon to overcome
the situation in West Seram.
Ambon and other islands in
Maluku, known as the Spice Islands, were hit by months of Moslem-Christian
violence at the start of the year which left more than 300 dead, drove
tens of thousands to other provinces and caused widespread destruction.
Noya said the violence in
West Seram was most intense Wednesday although it continued sporadically
until Sunday. He said the attack took place some 100 kilometers north of
Ambon in the hamlets of Kawa, Loki, Wailisa, Seaputty, Olas and in the
main town of Piru.
Moslems attacked and torched
all homes and churches in the Christian hamlets, killing seven people in
Wailisa on Wednesday and injuring five people in Loki.
The mob attacked another
Ariate Christian hamlet on two separate days, Thursday and Sunday, leaving
one person dead and 13 others injured.
Police failed to reach Ariate
on Thursday after mobs set up roadblocks and fired shots at the reinformcements
sent in from Salahutu sub-district town of Masohi, Noya said.
"It's not clear whether the
ones who shot at the police were some of the villagers or other security
officers who had been partial in their defense," he added.
Following the attack some
of the refugees who had been hiding in Ariate left for Piru. "We don't
know exactly how many had fled and stayed," he added.
On Sunday some of the Christian
residents in Ariate retaliated and attacked the Laala Moslem hamlet and
torched some homes. The number of casualties and damage could not be immediately
ascertained.
Meanwhile, troubles flared
anew on Saturday when Moslem mobs torched shops in the city's Mardika area,
Noya said, adding that security had shot four rioters.
A separate clash between
residents and security members broke out late on Monday in the city's Air
Salobar area of Pohon Mangga leaving two marine troops injured, Kompas
said.
Maluku military information
office's chief Lieutenant Colonel Iwa Kusuma confirmed the clash on Monday
but could not elaborate on the number of casualties.
Police reports showed that
the death toll in the Moslem-Christian violence in Maluku from July 24
to August 16 stood at 105, with the number of injured at over 400.
One soldier was among those
killed and 35 others were among the injured. "The number [of casualties]
could grow bigger with the recent clashes. We're still waiting for updates,"
Iwa said.
Moslems
rally over violence in Ambon, Aceh
Agence France Presse - August
22, 1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- Some 2,000 Indonesian
Moslems held a mass prayer here Sunday calling for an end to mounting violence
in two of the country's major trouble spots -- Ambon and the western province
of Aceh.
Separately, thousands more
Moslem youths from the Front for the Defence of Islam roared through the
city's main thoroughfares on motorcycles, calling for unity among the country's
Moslem majority, witnesses said.
Another group of motorcyclists,
the Ka'aba Youth, also took to the streets of the capital in support of
President B.J. Habibie.
The crowd at the Jakarta
Al-Azhar Mosque chanted "God is Great" and waved placards reading "Stop
the Violence" and "Beware of Foreign Interference in Aceh."
The Indonesian Association
of Islamic Boarding Schools (BKSPP), the organizer of the mosque rally,
demanded that security forces protect Moslems in Ambon, the scene of months
of Moslem-Christian violence.
"Violence against Moslems
in Ambon is motivated by the spirit of the Crusade and is a result of a
conspiracy," the group said in the statement. It said fighting against
"evil conspiracies" constituted a holy war or "jihad." The group also attributed
the continuing violence in Ambon and Aceh to the government's inability
to protect the people.
BKSPP also urged the military
and separatist rebels who have been fighting for an independent Islamic
state in Aceh since the 1970's to stop the violence and hold a dialogue.
Indonesian
ministers visit troubled Aceh
Agence France Presse - August
28, 1999 (abridged)
Jakarta -- Protests greeted
a visit Saturday to the restive Aceh province by a delegation of Indonesian
ministers and senior officials bringing aid for refugees fleeing violence
between troops and Moslem rebels.
In the latest attack, four
gunmen shot dead a soldier in Pidie district on Friday.
The seven ministers were
scheduled to hand over finance for several development projects in Aceh
as well as aid for the province's growing number of refugees, said an Aceh
government spokesman, Wid.
"They will also hold dialogue
with public and religious leaders and district and provincial officials
at the governor's office" in the local capital Banda Aceh, Wid added.
He said the team was discussing
how to improve the central government's efforts to boost security and living
standards in Aceh, an Islamic stronghold where harsh anti-rebel operations
by the military have caused deep resentment.
The delegation was headed
by Coordinating Minister for People's Welfare Haryono Suyono and included
16 senior officials, Wid said. But the aid pledge failed to impress some
300 protestors, mostly students, who demonstrated at the parliament building
more than a kilometre from the governor's office.
They demanded that the military
face justice for innocent victims of the anti-separatist campaign. Many
of the protestors wore headbands carrying the word "Referendum" as they
demanded self- determination in line with that being offered to East Timor,
television pictures showed.
Activist Shalahuddin Alfata
said the ministers' visit would have little impact since they were not
meeting any members of the banned GAM.
"The GAM is not being involved
in the dialogue. Even though we do not recognize them as an organisation,
in reality they are there," said Alfata, chairman of the Aceh People's
Forum for Struggle and Justice.
He told the SCTV television
station the government needed to talk to the GAM to halt the violence before
moving onto other issues, and called for outside mediation.
"If the government of Indonesia
is serious in trying to resolve the problems in Aceh openly and transparently,
then invite the United States as a mediator," he said. The US should be
involved because it had sizeable investments in gas-rich Aceh, he added.
This is the second visit
by a group of ministers to Aceh since President B.J. Habibie came to Banda
Aceh for a day in May and pledged to investigate military abuses and improve
social conditions. Amran Zamzani, who heads the independent investigation
promised by Habibie, said Friday nobody should interfere in its probe into
military violence against Acehnese.
"We do not want to be like
other teams. If we're not going to be of any use, then it would be better
if we just disbanded ourselves," Amran said.
Students
demand UK account for operation
Agence France Presse - August
27, 1999
Jakarta -- Scores of students
in the easternmost Indonesian province of Irian Jaya have protested over
the alleged involvement of British elite troops in a violent hostage-rescue
operation in 1996, a report said Friday.
Some 150 students rallied
outside the parliament building in the provincial capital Jayapura on Thursday
to demand Britain account for its role in allegedly sending Special Air
Service troops to rescue 11 hostages who were being held by Free Papua
Movement (OPM) rebels, the Jakarta Post said.
They also demanded an explanation
from Pretoria over the role of Executive Outcomes, a group of South African
mercenaries which has a base in England, the newspaper said.
"The two countries should
be held responsible for killing Indonesians in the operation," student
leader Aplin Yarangga was quoted as saying.
A team of soldiers from the
SAS and Executive Outcomes led the raid to free foreign and Indonesian
scientists who had been held captive for months by OPM guerrillas in the
jungles of central Irian Jaya.
The captives, part of a team
conducting a biological study of the 2.2 million hectare Lorentz reserve
in the mountainous region, included four Britons, a German and a Dutchman.
They were all freed unharmed, but rebels killed two Indonesian scientists
during the operation. Witnesses said 16 foreign troops led the successful
rescue bid but left at least 12 villagers dead.
Human-rights and church activists
said an anti-rebel crackdown by Indonesian troops ensued "in which many
Irianese were massacred, raped, tortured and dispossessed," the Jakarta
Post reported.
The students also demanded
the International Court of Justice investigate the role of former president
Suharto and former military chief general Feisal Tanjung, who is now coordinating
minister for political and security affairs.
They also cited Prabowo Subianto,
a former lieutenant general in the Indonesian army's elite Kopassus unit
and a son-in-law of Suharto, who was in charge of the operation.
The OPM has been fighting
for an independent Melanesian state in the former Dutch territory of Western
New Guinea since it became the Indonesian province of Irian Jaya in 1964.
Australia's
role in Irian Jaya exposed
The Age - August 26, 1999
Antony Balmain -- As East
Timor prepares to vote in a United Nations ballot to decide its future,
documents show Australia played an active and secret role to ensure Irian
Jaya became a part of Indonesia in another UN-supervised vote -- the so-called
Act of Free Choice in 1969.
The secret government files
show Australia colluded with Dutch, United States and UN officials to rubber-stamp
the Indonesian takeover of Irian Jaya, or West Papua, the western half
of New Guinea island.
The documents show an uncanny
similarity between Australia's response to events in West Papua and our
later reaction to the Indonesian takeover of East Timor in 1975. While
Australian diplomats were well-aware of Indonesian repression in the territory,
they advocated that Australia stand back and say little.
They also show that Australia
obstructed efforts by West Papua leaders to travel to New York to put the
case for independence to the UN.
The diplomatic cables, intelligence
documents and government reports are contained in 13 Department of Territories
files due for release in January 2000. They were released early by the
Department of Foreign Affairs to SBS television's Dateline program.
One secret US Government
document given to Australia before the self-determination process started
in July 1969 shows UN officials believed almost all West Papuans supported
independence.
The document, prepared by
the US embassy in Jakarta, said: "Personal political views of the UN team
are ... 95 percent of Irianese support the independence movement and that
the Act of Free Choice is a mockery."
In the act, 1025 West Papuans,
selected by Indonesia, voted on behalf of the entire population of some
800,000. The vote took place over three weeks, ending on 4 August 1969.
The process fulfilled a 1962
agreement initiated by the US to avert war between Indonesia and the Netherlands,
Indonesia's former colonial ruler. The rest of what had been the Dutch
East Indies became independent in 1949, but the Netherlands had originally
wanted West Papua to become a separate Melanesian nation.
A clear indication that the
Netherlands and Australia knew there would not be a fair vote is contained
in one top-secret report, written by a Dutch intelligence officer and distributed
to Australia and Indonesia.
Dated 27 June 1969, the document
said: "The Act of Free Choice cannot be carried out honestly according
to Western ideas. The `electors' will also be appointed by the Indonesians.
But finding enough Papuans willing to act as `electors' for the Indonesians
may turn out to be quite a problem. So there will be no free choice by
the people."
The documents show Australia,
at the request of Indonesia, arrested and prevented two pro-independence
West Papuan leaders from travelling to the UN, just weeks before the vote.
Willem Zonggonao, 26, and
Clemens Runawery, 27, were detained when they crossed into then-Australian
administered New Guinea, carrying testimonies from West Papuan leaders
calling for independence and for the UN to abandon the Act of Free Choice.
"Because we refused to sign
the paperwork, they put us in jail," Mr Zonggonao, previously a member
of the Indonesian West Irian Assembly, said in a recent interview from
Port Moresby.
"Then ASIO (the Australian
Security Intelligence Organisation) interviewed us and we were ... flown
to Manus Island." Scores of West Papuan refugees were sent to Manus Island,
300 kilometres north-east of New Guinea, to ensure they did not engage
in political activity.
Mr Zonggonao said the West
Papuans chosen to participate were "indoctrinated by military officers
and told if they didn't vote for Indonesia they would have their tongues
cut out".
The Australian ambassador
to Indonesia at the time, Mr Gordon Jockel, witnessed the Act of Free Choice
in Irian Jaya and in one cable wrote: "In the two or three days we had
in Biak and Djajapura, it was easy to see the mass of the Papuans there
are sullen and discontented."
In a cable to Canberra on
22 July 1969, Mr Jockel acknowledged the Act of Free Choice had "had many
bad effects". Jakarta was engaged in indoctrination and, "with their traumatic
fear of separatism, it has led them into repression which has in turn increased
the spread of anti-Indonesian sentiment".
The documents show Australia
maintained a secret military and intelligence relationship with Indonesia,
aimed at eliminating armed pro-independence dissent.
The documents show Australian
military officers collected evidence of Indonesian atrocities, including
rapes, beatings, lootings and torching of villages.
One report, dated 29 August
1969, stated: "Our previous information on rapes committed by Indonesian
soldiers has been confirmed in a number of cases. The Bobol and Tamus people
are quite definite on this score and ... in particular one girl from Bobol
... was raped by a number of soldiers when she was 11, several years later
again, and again when she was 16 and then married."
Despite these abuses, the
files showed Australia played a leading role in a campaign to ensure the
Act of Free Choice was accepted without debate at the UN General Assembly
in November 1969.
Indonesia, backed by Australia
and the Netherlands, lobbied countries including Malta and several West
African nations to not question the legitimacy of the self-determination
process. A September cable from Sir Patrick Shaw, the Australian ambassador
to the UN, shows Dutch and UN officials hoped there would be no debate
in the General Assembly about the vote.
While many West Papuan leaders
were calling for a new act of self-determination, the UN Secretary General,
Mr U Thant, ultimately ratified the wish of the Irian Jayans "to remain
with Indonesia".Antony Balmain is an SBS journalist based in Melbourne.
Police,
rebels blame each other for killing
Indonesian Observer - August
23, 1999
Jakarta -- Police yesterday
beefed up security at the US$2.5 billion Arun LNG refinery following reports
of arson over the weekend, and have blamed rebels for a new round of killings
in the restive Aceh province.
A policemen was kidnapped
and six civilians were killed in three separate incidents in North Aceh.
Meanwhile, the body of Corp. [Police] Ali Rahman Siregar was found Saturday
on a roadside in Nisam district, AP reported Aceh police chief Col. Bachrumsyah
Kasman as saying from the provincial capital of Banda Aceh. Siregar was
abducted on Friday as he rode a motorcycle home from work.
Kasman said four civilians
were found dead in a pit near Beuream. All had their necks slashed. Another
two people were shot to death by unidentified gunmen in Batee Geulungkuh.
Kasman blamed the pro-independence Free Aceh Movement for the seven deaths.
Hundreds of people have been
killed this year in fighting between troops and rebels who want to set
up an independent Islamic state in the oil and gas-rich region, about 2,000
kilometers northwest of Jakarta. Security forces and rebels have accused
one another of causing the deaths of civilians.
Meanwhile, Reuters quoted
witnesses as saying anti-riot soldiers were continuing to patrol the area
despite an earlier pledge by Indonesian Military [TNI] Commander General
Wiranto that they would be withdrawn from villages.
"They were still patrolling
the villages, entering houses and kitchens belonging to the public. And
they were even searching the forests," one witness said, adding the situation
was tense. Aceh was under an often savage military rule for nine years
in which at least 2,000 people -- mostly civilians -- were killed.
In a related development,
Mandiri Online reported that fire broke out on Friday in Arun, the world's
largest LNG refinery located in Aceh's industrial city of Lhokseumawe.
Security forces blamed the
separatist Free Aceh Movement (GAM) for the arson, while GAM blamed the
military, saying it needed to justify its heavy presence in the territory.
Violence
in Aceh claims 11 lives
Agence France Presse - August
20, 1999
Jakarta -- Continued violence
between separatists and the military has claimed 11 lives in the past two
days in the troubled Indonesian province of Aceh, sources and reports said
Saturday.
Residents of North Aceh's
Jeumpa district town of Bireun found the bodies of four unidentified people
on Saturday outside a government district office, Iskandar Muda Legal Aid
director Yacob Hamzah told AFP by telephone from Lhokseumawe.
"All four died of slash wounds
that almost severed their heads. Their identities are unknown," he said.
Another man died early Friday
when members of Free Aceh separatist movement (GAM) attacked a group of
around 30 government troops as they travelled to the city of Lhokseumawe
in northern Aceh, a rights worker said.
"A GAM member was killed
and two troops were injured," Hamzah said.
He added that 10 armed GAM
members in four cars had blocked the troops' path at Bayin village and
started shooting. The dead man was identified as Nurdin, 22.
The troops were returning
to their barracks on orders from Indonesian armed forces chief General
Wiranto (eds: one name), who has promised to pull 1,200 crack riot troops
-- widely blamed for fuelling unrest in Aceh -- back to their bases.
Meanwhile, another volunteer
at Iskandar Muda said a resident of North Aceh's Samalanga district, Abdullah
bin Ahmad, 30, was found dead on Friday two days after being taken in by
the military.
"Abullah had been taken in
during a military sweep. He was shot dead after he had been tortured,"
the volunteer said, requesting anonymity.
North Aceh residents had
also found the bodies of three other civilians who were kidnapped by an
unidentified group, Hamzah said.
"They were found, also with
their heads nearly severed on Friday. Only one of them could be identified,"
he said.
Separately a police officer,
from the North Aceh district of Dewantara, was found murdered on Friday
night, a security member there said.
"A police officer was found
dead last night in the Nisam district at 21:00. He had been stabbed to
death," a security officer who prefered anonymity in Dewantara's main town
of Krueng Geukeuh said.
Meanwhile an unidentified
marksman in South Aceh district village of Ujung Padang Rasian killed an
innocent passerby with two shots in the chest.
"The marksman is unknown
and the victim was a farmer identified as Alim, 24," a duty officer at
the main Tapak Tuan town, who identified himself only as Sudiro, said.
Hamzah said tens of thousands
of refugees were heading home from makeshift camps after Wiranto's pledge.
He estimated that around
50,000 in the district of Pidie were returning home, but added those in
Samalanga sub-district had remained in their camps "because there are still
a lot of military in the woods".
Since May, some 140,000 people
have fled their villages fearing violence from soldiers and separatist
rebels, packing mosques and refugee centers in several Acehnese towns.
Crack Indonesian riot troops
have been blamed for fuelling the violence that spiralled in Aceh after
the military shot dead 41 civilians during a protest in Lhokseumawe on
May 3. Separatist clash kills one, residents find four kidnap victims in
Aceh
Emergency
rule threat
South China Morning Post
- August 21, 1999
Vaudine England, Jakarta
-- While international attention is focused on the forthcoming ballot in
East Timor, the Indonesian armed forces chief has threatened to impose
emergency rule in Aceh. At the same time, President Bacharuddin Habibie's
promise of an independent commission to investigate military abuses in
Aceh was proving as hollow as his earlier pledge that no more blood would
be shed, said a prospective member of the commission.
The source said Mr Habibie's
offer of a true accounting of recent military massacres was not serious,
as he was personally approached to fund the commission out of his private
savings and commission meetings were taking weeks to arrange.
Thousands of refugees were
returning to their homes yesterday after armed forces chief General Wiranto
promised to withdraw riot troops, state sources said.
The general, after a fleeting
visit to Aceh this week, has demonstrated the iron hand in a velvet glove
approach.
He first said 1,200 joint
military and riot police troops would be withdrawn -- at least from residential
areas -- then said if security conditions did not improve he would impose
emergency rule.
Yesterday he offered separatist
rebels a general amnesty if they disarmed and ended guerilla activities.
He promised "to train those eligible fighters to become members of the
local military".
In the latest clash, one
suspected rebel died when 20 separatists attacked soldiers in North Aceh
yesterday.
More than 200 people have
been killed in Aceh since May, helping to transform what was a minority
separatist movement into a popular cause. "[Jakarta's] approach shows they
have learned nothing from their failure in East Timor," said another member
of the investigatory commission.
Recent visitors to the separatist
fighters in Aceh said the Free Aceh Movement intended to step up rebel
actions. Caught between the military and the separatists, many Acehnese
civilians have fled and now more than 100,000 are in growing camps of internally
displaced people.
General Wiranto has said
the separatists must stop attacking government buildings and civilians,
stop kidnapping and killing troops and disrupting economic activities and
public transport, and they must surrender their weapons and stop flying
the separatist flag. If not, the army would implement emergency rule, General
Wiranto said.
World
Bank threatens Indonesia
Associated Press - August
24, 1999
Jakarta -- The World Bank
is threatening to halt funding for Indonesia if it doesn't swiftly conclude
an investigation into a banking scandal involving the ruling Golkar Party.
"If this case is not resolved
early and satisfactorily, it is difficult for us to provide budget support
to the government of Indonesia," Mark Baird, the World Bank's director
for Indonesia, said Tuesday. Last year, the World Bank provided about $1.6
billion to Indonesia.
The scandal broke last month
after an audit into Bank Bali found its directors had used government bailout
money to pay a $80 million fee to a debt collection company controlled
by a senior official of the Golkar Party.
The disclosure has sparked
an uproar in Indonesia, unsettled financial markets and threatened its
economic recovery. It has also led to calls for senior officials -- including
the finance minister and central bank governor -- to resign.
The money, which has since
been returned, was disbursed by the central bank as part of a government
guarantee program. It was supposed to compensate Bank Bali for funds owed
it by a bank that closed. But the funds were then transferred from Bank
Bali to a firm controlled by Golkar's deputy treasurer.
Opponents of Golkar allege
the money was to be used to bankroll President B.J. Habibie's campaign
to retain the presidency.
Habibie's main rival in the
presidential race is Megawati Sukarnoputri, whose party won the largest
share of seats in parliamentary election in June, Indonesia's first free
ballot in 44 years.
Last week, the International
Monetary Fund called for an audit of the central bank. The IMF is leading
a $43 billion program to bail out Indonesia's moribund economy.
On Tuesday, central bank
deputy governor Achjar Iljas confirmed that an international firm will
be allowed to audit Bank Indonesia.
The World Bank's vice president
for East Asia, Jean-Michel Severino, also urged the government to swiftly
look into the affair.
"It is clear that the Bank
Bali case has major macroeconomic and microeconomic implications," Severino
said in Jakarta. "I imagine that the World Bank can't carry on its activities
unchanged if the issue isn't satisfactorily resolved." The World Bank says
Indonesia needs to fully disclose the findings of its investigation and
punish any wrongdoers.
Who
watches the watchers
Time Magazine - August 23-30,
1999
Eric Ellis, Singapore --
Every time Christovita Wiloto sits down at his computer, the 30-year-old
banker is reminded of how tough his job is. His screensaver depicts hungry
sharks circling their prey -- a wry metaphor for the Indonesian Bank Restructuring
Agency.
Until recently, IBRA was
a rare fish in Indonesia, an institution seemingly free of corruption and
symbolic of a new, more professional Indonesian way of doing business.
Its team of savvy young lawyers
and bankers was re-shaping the country's shattered economy with a patriotic
probity that won admiration at home and abroad. "We pride ourselves on
our integrity," Wiloto says. "If we don't have integrity and the confidence
of the people, then what do we have?"
That question took on a poignant
significance last week following embarrassing revelations of a backroom
deal that smacked of the crony culture IBRA aims to cleanse. IBRA deputy
chairman Pande Lubis was suspended from duties after being accused of helping
siphon funds from an institution under his care, PT Bank Bali. The money
-- some $77 million -- ended up at PT Era Giat Prima, a company controlled
by a senior official in the ruling Golkar party. The 59-year-old Lubis,
an associate of senior Golkar officials, including President B.J. Habibie,
allegedly arranged a cash transfer from Bank Bali, a bank under IBRA's
care, to another stricken bank via "intermediaries."
That middlemen should even
be present in an everyday interbank transaction was strange enough. But
when a Jakarta banking analyst, Pradjoto, revealed that a huge "commission"
for the transfer was paid to a company linked to Setya Novanto, Golkar's
deputy treasurer, the implication was clear -- IBRA funds may have financed
Golkar's recent parliamentary election campaign. The party insists it is
innocent. "It was a pure business deal which Golkar has nothing to do with,"
says party chairman Akbar Tanjung. "We are ready to be investigated." The
disclosures unsettled international investors, who had hoped that IBRA
would lead Indonesia's economic renaissance. The rupiah lost 12% of its
value last week, the Jakarta stock market half that.
Meanwhile, work inside IBRA
has been paralyzed by a series of investigations into the affair. IBRA's
apparent stumble gives ammunition to unscrupulous businessmen whose cosy
cartels were threatened by the agency's previous work. It's also a sad
reminder for Indonesians of how hard it is to rid corruption from their
country's rotten corporate culture.
This isn't how things were
meant to be. After it was set up in early 1998 as a condition of a $42
billion International Monetary Fund bailout, IBRA earned the respect of
many skeptics as proof that real change was underway. The IMF was pleased,
too, calling IBRA's job -- to get bankrupt Indonesian banks back on their
feet -- a "life and death matter" for the economy.
If it were a company, IBRA
would easily be Indonesia's biggest. It controls $85 billion in assets
-- 20% of the country's GDP -- and not just banks, but also holdings pledged
for bad loans: major stakes in businesses like Indofood, the world's largest
noodle manufacturer, carmakers, hotels and property -- even Suharto friend
Bob Hasan's private plane. And it's all for sale, with the pressure to
raise funds intensifying as Indonesia's next budget draws nearer.
IBRA has an Indonesians-first
divestment policy though few buyers at home, which would make it a happy
hunting ground for foreigners -- if they could trust the system. But not
many foreign deals have been concluded -- one of the biggest so far is
Standard Chartered Bank's conditional purchase of a stake in Bank Bali
in April. Foreign investors complain IBRA doesn't move fast enough, while
some Indonesians accuse the agency of selling national treasures.
Still, the agency seemed
to be getting some good work done. On August 2, IBRA's 18 months of hard
work paid off with the national debut of Bank Mandiri, a superbank of 530
branches hewn from four failures. Mandiri's snazzy outlets might look like
Scandinavian furniture stores, but its real achievement is less visible:
only one director of the four original banks sits on Mandiri's board.
Ironically, it was a new
transparency in the system that unearthed the scandal. Standard Chartered's
auditors were poring over Bank Bali's books when they discovered the $77
million hole. IBRA deputy chairman Arwin Rasyid admits the agency faces
"huge pressure from influential politicians. With the wealth and assets
we're holding, no wonder many parties try eagerly to take advantage." The
sharks on Christovita Wiloto's screensaver are real. Arwin says the Bank
Bali affair "is an acid test of IBRA's professionalism." But in an Indonesia
desperate for change, there's a lot more at stake than reputations.
Former
President Suharto leaves hospital
Indonesian Observer - August
20, 1999
Jakarta -- Former President
Soeharto left hospital yesterday after five days of treatment for intestinal
bleeding as his lawyer brushed aside rumors his client is seeking treatment
abroad.
"What I can see is that Pak
Harto is fit, medically fit, you can ask the doctors. I have heard Pak
Harto has no plans to go to Singapore or Japan for treatment," lawyer Juan
Felix Tampubolon told reporters.
Indonesia's former strongman
was rushed to Pertamina Hospital last Saturday after being diagnosed with
intestinal bleeding. Last month he was treated at the same hospital for
10 days after suffering a mild stroke. His doctors said the bleeding has
nothing to do with the stroke.
"Medically speaking, he can
go home anytime, and [in fact] doctors have permitted him to return home,"
Dr Ibrahim Ginting, head of the the former president's medical team, told
reporters.
Looking pale and worn out,
the 78 year-old Soeharto managed a smile and a wave at the hordes of curious
journalists as he stood up from a wheelchair to get into a waiting car
driven by his second son Bambang Trihatmodjo. Eldest daughter Siti "Tutut"
Hardiyanti Rukmana was also in the car.
When asked about overseas
treatment for the ex-president, Ginting said: "The [Soeharto] family did
not mention the possibility of taking him abroad."
Ginting said Pak Harto needs
to be disciplined about his diet. A doctor and several nurses will take
care of the former leader at a private clinic situated in his Menteng,
Central Jakarta home.
Indonesia's second president,
Soeharto, was forced down in May last year after 32 years in power, and
is currently facing a corruption investigation.
The government, meanwhile,
has offered a political settlement to resolve his case and is set to review
the probe next week on health reasons.
The Attorney-General's Office,
which has so far failed to find indication of corruption, early this week
presented a "legal display" of progress of the probe to Coordinating Minister
of Development Supervision and State Administrative Reform Hartarto Suryosunario
and State Secretary/Justice Minister Muladi.
Muladi said President BJ
Habibie will decide on the status of the probe when he receives a report
on the probe next week.
In its May edition, TIME
magazine claimed that the former president and his family have assets totaling
US$15 billion and that he transferred cash amounting to US$9 billion from
a Swiss account to an Austrian bank moments after his downfall. The former
strongman, meanwhile, has denied any wrongdoing.
Tampubolon said "psychological
torture," a consequence of the extremely slow moving legal process has
contributed to his client's condition. Uncertainties over Soeharto's legal
status are proof of a violatin of human rights, the lawyer added.
New
fires destroy huge swathe of forest
Agence France Presse - August
28, 1999
Jakarta -- Fires which have
resumed in Indonesia's Sumatra and Kalimantan regions have ravaged at least
5,561 hectares of forest and scrub in the past month, a report said Saturday.
The National Environmental
Impact Management Agency said fires in Sumatra's Riau province alone had
caused losses of 8.9 billion rupiah (1.2 million dollars) since July, the
Antara news agency reported.
The widespread burning, blamed
on smallholding farmers and plantation owners, has revived fears of haze
blanketing neighbouring countries in a repetition of a regional environmental
disaster two years ago.
The agency defined the cost
estimate from the Riau fires in terms of lost income from the forestry
sector and the need for funds to replace trees.
It excluded in its estimate
economic losses caused by poor visibility sparked by the haze and increased
costs for the resulting health care.
It said that smoke from the
fires had caused a rise in the incidence of respiratory illnesses and disruption
of school education.
Riau authorities last month
called for the closure of schools especially at nursery and primary levels,
saying that youngsters were most vulnerable to the effects of the smog.
They have also called on schools to refrain from conducting outdoor activities
for their older pupils.
Forest fires have reappeared
in the lower half of Sumatra island and several parts of Kalimantan, the
Indonesian part of Borneo island, since June.
But occasional rain has stopped
the haze from reaching the levels it hit in 1997, when huge forest and
ground fires during a prolonged drought destroyed more than 10 million
hectares of Indonesian forest.
The meteorology office here
said that in the past week visibility in Riau and other southern Sumatran
provinces had been good owing to heavy rainfall.
In 1997 and early 1998, the
smoke haze covered a wide swathe of skies over Indonesia and neighbouring
countries, causing massive economic losses along with serious health problems
and visibility hazards to ships and planes.
On Thursday a meeting in
Singapore of environment ministers from the Association of Southeast Asian
Nations pressed Indonesia to take urgent action to prevent a renewal of
the 1997 crisis. The meeting was brought forward from October because of
the urgency of the potential problem.
The ministers urged Indonesia
to quickly implement the necessary by-laws and regulations to enforce the
"zero-burning" policy imposed by the government of President B.J. Habibie
earlier this year. Indonesian officials have cited a lack of funds and
personnel for their failure to enforce the policy.
Illegal
logging devastating 'protected' parks
Deutsche Presse-Agentur -
August 25, 1999
Jakarta -- Logging and forest
fires are destroying rainforests and the wildlife they support, government
authorities and environmentalists warned yesterday.
Uncontrolled forest fires
-- mostly lit illegally to clear logged forest areas for palm oil plantations
-- are again raging through Borneo and Sumatra, while a blanket of smoke
is covering villages and towns on the islands. The fires were mostly lit
by plantation companies taking advantage of a three-month drought, the
state- run Antara news agency said.
Local authorities feared
a repeat of the huge rainforest fires of recent years, in which "millions
of hectares of tropical forest were destroyed" on Borneo and Sumatra, Antara
said.
Environmental groups warned
in Jakarta that large-scale illegal logging in two Indonesian national
parks seriously threatened the survival of orang-utans, one of the world's
most endangered species.
The Environmental Investigation
Agency, based in London and Washington, and Telapak Indonesia said illegal
logging was rampant in the Gunung Leuser National Park in North Sumatra
and the Tanjung Puting National Park in central Kalimantan.
"I have witnessed scenes
of appalling devastation in both of these so-called protected parks. The
logging is totally out of control," said agency director Dave Currey. "The
Government of Indonesia must act against the timber barons directing this
destruction before these vital areas and their wildlife are lost."
The Gunung Leuser National
Park in northern Sumatra covers 2.5 million hectares, from the Indian Ocean
to the hills along the Straits of Malacca, and has mountains 3,000 metres
high.
Unlike orang-utans elsewhere,
the ginger-haired primates in the park's Suaq Balimbing region live in
structured social groups and make and use tools, the agency said. Yet activists
had "witnessed loggers with chainsaws operating in the Suaq Balimbing research
area".
The Tanjung Puting National
Park on Borneo -- where an orang-utan research programme was set up in
the early 1970s -- was also under great threat from illegal logging. "We
are calling for the Indonesian Government to clamp down immediately on
the illegal logging," the groups said.
"We are also calling for
the international community to use their power within Indonesia to try
to get the Government to act.
"If we don't see this happening
soon, both Tanjung Puting National Park and Gunung Leuser National Park
will no longer be worth protecting and some of these species, especially
orang- utans, may be lost forever."