| Home > South-East Asia >> Indonesia | |
Oppenheimer reflects on implications of Oscar-nominated documentary The Look of Silence
Jakarta Post - February 9, 2016
Oppenheimer's The Look of Silence is up for Best Documentary Feature at the 88th Academy Awards set to be held in Hollywood, the US, on Feb. 28.
The film follows a man probing his brother's murder in the violence that racked the country from 1965 to 1966. The critically acclaimed documentary, released in 2014, is the companion piece to Oppenheimer's award-winning Oscar nominee documentary The Act of Killing, which was released in 2012.
The two documentaries tell stories encompassing a dark chapter in Indonesian history, namely the 1965 to 1966 communist purge, in which up to a million people with alleged links to the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI) were murdered, kidnapped or tortured.
For The Look of Silence, Oppenheimer befriended Adi Rukun, an optometrist living in North Sumatra whose brother Ramli Rukun was brutally killed in 1965.
While The Act of Killing focuses on the perpetrators boasting of how they butchered people associated with the PKI, The Look of Silence shows how Adi confronts his brother's murderers who live free, with some now grasping the reins of regional power.
The confrontation results in powerful scenes, as Adi's repressed feelings bubble up as he asks his brother's murderers why they did what they did. Oppenheimer refers to the film as an Indonesian production.
"This is the first Indonesian film ever nominated for an Oscar. The movie was made by Indonesians and for Indonesians," he told thejakartapost.com in a Skype interview from Los Angeles over the weekend.
While The Act of Killing also received an Oscar nod in 2012, it was not an Indonesian production, according to Oppenheimer, as he did not involve many Indonesians in his crew, fearing their safety might be at risk given the appearance in the film of the likes of Vice President Jusuf Kalla and the chairman of paramilitary group Pancasila Youth, Yapto Soerjosumarno. Conversely, sixty Indonesian crewmembers, who remain anonymous, worked on the making of The Look of Silence.
At one point during production, Oppenheimer and his crew, including cinematographer Lars Skree and producer Signe Byrge Sørensen, emptied all numbers on their mobile phones and bought a second car, allowing them, if need be, to make an instant switch after leaving perpetrators' houses to throw any hired goons or cops off the scent.
Despite the myriad challenges he faced, an Oscar nomination never crossed Oppenheimer's mind.
"We made these movies in order to hold up a mirror inside Indonesia and outside Indonesia so that everyone in the world can recognize the terrible consequences of what happens when human beings turned against one another, kill, frighten and torture one another and create a whole regime of fear," said the 41-year-old director.
"We try to capture what happens when a whole society is built on a story of lies, justifying crimes against humanity."
The nomination is also expected to draw people's attention to human right issues.
In his acceptance speech after winning best documentary at the 2014 BAFTA Awards, Oppenheimer accused the UK and the US of "help[ing] to engineer the genocide, and for decades enthusiastically support[ing] the military dictatorship that came to power through the genocide". This part of the speech was cut by BAFTA when it posted the acceptance video online.
Oppenheimer is currently working on a petition to force the US to acknowledge its role in the 1965 violence. At least 50,000 people, including activists from Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, have signed the petition.
The auteur will meet members of the US Senate in Washington DC this week, urging them to make available all documents relating to the US role in the genocide.
However, his actions will remain limited to overseas, as he is reluctant to return to Indonesia – a country where he spent 12 years making the two documentaries – in the face of threats. He has not returned to the country since completing the production of The Look of Silence in 2013.
The Copenhagen-based director cited "several threats" from individuals he declined to mention. "There was one threat that said 'Don't come back to Indonesia, unless you want us to use your head as a football.'"
Oppenheimer has also provided guarantees of the safety of Adi, the film's protagonist, who now lives safely with his family away from North Sumatra. A whole network of people, from human rights activists to journalists, are monitoring Adi's safety and whereabouts.
Oppenheimer and his anonymous Indonesian codirector received the prestigious Suardi Tasrif Award in September last year from the Alliance of Independent Journalists (AJI) for The Act of Killing and The Look of Silence. The judges expressed their opinion that the two documentaries had unveiled facts relating to past human rights abuses that could help spur movement toward settlements and reconciliation.
The Tasrif award was inspired by Suardi Tasrif, considered the author of the code of ethics among Indonesian journalists.
Resolving past rights abuses
The Look of Silence trains its focus on a single protagonist – Adi – but he serves as a synecdoche for untold grieving families left without justice and without answers in the wake of the government- and military-backed brutality of 1965-1966.
Through the documentary, Oppenheimer expresses hope that the government will settle past human rights abuses, hopes given impetus by President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo's promise to do just that during his 2014 presidential campaign.
Jokowi's administration announced in January that it would settle past human rights cases this year, aiming for reconciliation with victims' families.
However, the intention has been criticized by human rights activists, who disdain any reconciliation process that does not entail assigning responsibility for the crimes, and, where possible, meting out justice.
Jokowi's administration moreover gave the cold shoulder to an International People's Tribunal 1965 held in The Hague in November to shed light on the notorious yet hushed-up killings. His ministers refused to acknowledge the tribunal, citing that Indonesia had its own justice system.
The tribunal, which had no legal status to enact measures in Indonesia, stated that grave human rights abuses had taken place in 1965-1966, and called on the government to act to resolve them.
While holding out some hope in Jokowi, Oppenheimer realizes that the President is in a difficult position to keep his promise, as he "depends on power from people who have blood on their hands".
The Look of Silence was officially distributed in Indonesia through the National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), but other state bodies have called for a ban on screenings of the film.
In October, the annual Ubud Writers and Readers Festival (UWRF) was forced to cancel a series of panel discussions on the 1965-1966 violence, including screenings of The Act of Killing and The Look of Silence.
Oppenheimer believes that despite the daunting obstacles to resolving past rights abuses, new generations of young Indonesians will take on the torch of justice. "I just hope that people can come together in a non-violent way to demand justice and reconciliation, as the films have encouraged," he said. (rin)
See also:
 |