| Home > South-East Asia >> Indonesia | |
Prabowo called by brother as a 'defender of pluralism'
Jakarta Globe - June 7, 2014
Hashim went so far as to say that Prabowo was committed to protecting Ahmadis, who in Indonesia have long been denounced and attacked by Sunni Muslim hard-liners.
"The first task of the government is to protect its citizens," he said on Friday. "Protecting Ahmadiyah, that is a basic task of the next Indonesian government, as long as they don't pose a threat to public security and order. If they are pursuing their faith peacefully, then there's no reason why they should be bothered by the government or others."
Hashim, who spoke at a luncheon held by the Jakarta Foreign Correspondents Club at the Intercontinental Hotel, referred to his 62-year-old brother as a "big defender of pluralism."
"He has been defending Pancasila and pluralism all his life," he said, referring to his brother Prabowo, who is Muslim. Born to a Christian mother from Manado, and a Muslim father who was an acclaimed economist, Hashim spoke of diversity in his own family.
"You are aware that I am Christian, and you are aware our sister is Catholic. Prabowo has made certain promises to me and my sister," Hashim, 61, said at the event, which was attended by more than 200 people including international journalists and ambassadors.
Hashim's comments were made in light of overtures by Prabowo's running mate, Hatta Rajasa, toward the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI). Prabowo's commitment to uphold religious tolerance was seen as being severely undermined after Hatta was viewed as courting the FPI for support last week. Hashim denied that Prabowo actively sought support from the FPI.
The FPI is a hard-line Islamic organization that has repeatedly attacked minorities such as Ahmadiyah, Shiite and Christian communities. It has also raided brothels and nightclubs in a move to root out what it calls immoral behavior.
Hatta, who is the chairman of the Islamic-based National Mandate Party (PAN), last week attended a Muslim religious service in South Jakarta with prominent FPI members, where he asked attendees to give their support to Prabowo's presidential bid. Prabowo himself had earlier said his coalition would embrace all communities, "including the FPI."
Indonesians go to the polls on July 9 to vote for the next president to succeed Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, whose second five-year term ends in October. Prabowo's Great Indonesia Movement Party (Gerindra) received nearly 12 percent of the legislative vote in the April 9 ballot, far less than the 25 percent needed for the party to nominate its own presidential candidate without the need to form a coalition with other parties.
The Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P) of main challenger Joko Widodo, the Jakarta governor, took in almost 19 percent.
In response to media coverage of Prabowo, Hashim said he believed his brother had been portrayed unfairly by some Indonesian news organizations. "Prabowo was misquoted, I suspect intentionally misquoted, by a few Indonesian media. Prabowo has never courted the FPI's support," he said.
He also denied that the FPI would be a part of the current coalition that supports Prabowo. "I just want to reiterate that it is not our policy or intention to get the FPI as part of the coalition," he said.
However, analysts doubt Prabowo will really stand up for minorities in Indonesia. Arbi Sanit, a political analyst from the University of Indonesia is skeptical.
"The statement shows Prabowo's or Gerindra's inconsistency. I doubt that [the commitment] is even real," he said. "If he wants to guarantee minorities' rights, he cannot befriend radical groups such as the hard-line FPI, which is notorious for violent acts toward minorities in Indonesia."
Then there are those who wonder whether Hashim's comments truly reflect Prabowo's views. Some observers such as Yunarto Wijaya from Charta Politika aren't convinced.
"If you look closely, statements that support pluralism always come from Hashim. He is a minority himself, and he has an international background. Don't be surprised if he sides with minority groups," Yunarto said.
"Look at Prabowo's political maneuvering. Does it support Hashim's statement, or does it contradict it? As long as Prabowo does not officially say that he will guarantee minorities' rights, then Hashim's statements are as good as meaningless," he said.
'Tactical compromises'
While Gerindra has prided itself as a nationalist party – which in the Indonesian context is understood as another way of saying that the party supports pluralism as opposed to the exclusivity upheld by the Islamic parties – its decision to ally with non-pluralist Islamic parties such as the PAN, the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) and the United Development Party (PPP) has led many to wonder about its commitment to pluralism and protection of minorities in Indonesia.
In this respect, Hashim admitted that Prabowo had made compromises, but he gave assurances that Prabowo would not turn against minorities.
"We have to make tactical compromises, but we will not make any compromises on our basic thesis," Hashim said, pledging that Prabowo and Gerindra were committed to upholding pluralism in Indonesia.
Gerindra is particularly vulnerable to charges of being inconsistent due to the string of compromises that it has made.
A journalist from the Sydney Morning Herald asked Hashim during the luncheon how Prabowo could be taken seriously as an anti-corruption figure – an image that the party has been trying to promote – if there were people accused of corruption in his coalition.
Suryadharma Ali, the PPP chairman and one of Prabowo's more ardent supporters, resigned as minister of religious affairs last week after being charged in a graft scandal at his ministry. Prabowo has publicly defended him, calling Suryadharma "the best religious affairs minister" in Indonesia.
In response, Hashim reminded the audience of the presumption of innocence, saying that there shouldn't be a rush to condemn Suryadharma, who has not yet been indicted. Hashim also added that Gerindra did not have much of a choice and that it acted to be practical.
"Politics is the art of the possible. Sometimes we have to make tactical, unintended compromises. Let's be realistic – Gerindra only got 12 percent of the legislative election," he said.
He explained that with its meager share of the votes, Gerindra did not have the luxury of choice and had to be content with its current cast of coalition members to meet the 25 percent threshold requirement to name a presidential candidate.
Hashim compared Prabowo's pragmatic approach to Lee Kuan Yew, Singapore's former prime minister, who built up the city-state into the leading financial center in Southeast Asia.
"Look at Lee Kuan Yew in the 1960s. He allied himself with the Malaysian communist party, the CPM [Communist Party of Malaysia]. Take a look now... by most accounts, Singapore is considered a capitalistic paradise," Hashim said. "Sometimes you have to make tactical compromises. Lee Kuan Yew went to bed with the communist party."
'He did not kidnap people'
Hashim also addressed questions about Prabowo's poor track record on human rights. Prabowo has been criticized in Indonesia and internationally for his involvement in human rights abuses.
He is alleged to have kidnapped and tortured 13 pro-democracy activists during the turmoil that led to the resignation of the strongman Suharto, who was his father-in-law at the time. The 13 activists remain missing.
Hashim argued that Prabowo was only performing his duties as a military officer and that the abductions should not be deemed human rights violations.
"He did not kidnap people. He detained people. Those were legitimate orders from a legitimate government at the time," Hashim said. "He feels he has come out. He testified to the [House of Representatives] in 2005 and to the National Commission on Human Rights [Komnas HAM]. He feels that... the matter is closed."
Komnas HAM has asked Prabowo to come in to testify more recently, but the former Special Forces commander has balked at the request.
'Massive projects'
Regarding Prabowo's economic plans, Hashim said the candidate would remove fuel subsidies gradually. Prabowo will also raise tax revenue by cleaning up the "corrupt tax system" and by ensuring that everyone in Indonesia has a tax registration number.
Hashim said Prabowo's main economic priority was to boost infrastructure by spending about $60 billion a year on infrastructure projects. Prabowo will embark on "massive projects," Hashim said, citing a proposed 10-lane highway running the length of Sumatra.
Hashim also said that Indonesia could afford to borrow from the capital markets more to finance such projects. He said that Indonesia's private and public debt only amounted to about 28 percent to 35 percent of gross domestic product, and that it was "underleveraged."
Hashim cited as an example Malaysia, where private and public debt amount to 63 percent of its GDP. Hashim also emphasized that Prabowo was welcoming of foreign investments and foreign investors.
The public will get a chance to hear Prabowo's comments direct in the first presidential debate to be broadcast from Balai Sarbini in Jakarta on Monday.
[Additional reporting by Kennial Caroline Laia.]
Source: http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/news/prabowo-called-brother-defender-pluralism/.
See also:
 |